Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people should chill with the hysterical doomsday threads

138 replies

elzober · 12/08/2022 17:11

Before the pile on about minimising the difficulties people are having, I'm not saying there aren't serious challenges going on at the moment from climate to the cost of living. There's no denying any of that and I hope this crappy government will redeem themselves and take steps to help people.

But talk of apocalypse and the collapse of society is pretty OTT and I keep seeing the tin hat brigade commenting about their various conspiracy theories too.

It's a bit hysterical when you think there are people from from developing countries with hyperinflation, war on their doorstep and armed militias who had to flee to places like the UK for safety.

OP posts:
Discovereads · 13/08/2022 01:22

ImWell · 13/08/2022 01:15

That is a discussion of plausible solutions in general relativity, with no suggestion that they will be valid.

As to the idea that you “just” need a nuclear reactor; gravity is 10^40 times smaller than electromagnetism, you’d need an energy source of a billion suns to try to manipulate it at the scale of a human construction.

A pair of black holes colliding make a ripple far smaller than the width of a human hair; every reactor on earth doesn’t get within a factor of a million of that sort of power output.

I don’t think you read the paper as Dr Lentz states in it that a fission reactor would be more than enough energy to power a soliton “warp bubble”

I think you’ve done a 180 degree about face from:

None of it accords with the known laws of physics.

to

That is a discussion of plausible solutions in general relativity,

because you’ve seen it’s an actual published and peer reviewed theoretical physics paper by a prestigious physicist at a top world university.

which brings me to
How do people of limited intelligence and education come to believe that they know more than all of the worlds experts. Yes, I do wonder the same thing…

ImWell · 13/08/2022 01:16

Discovereads · 13/08/2022 01:14

Yes, exactly, solitons have already been observed. Which is more than we can say for when black holes were theorised in 1915 by Einstein to exist- 50yrs before we actually discovered/observed one in 1964. And 2019 was first time we have imaged a black hole.

Yes, we can make one in a swimming pool if we want, or a fish tank. It’s a relatively trivial solution of the standard wave equations in a dispersive media.

Hawkins001 · 13/08/2022 01:15

@ImWell
all I know is i know nothing, but mere speculation and guesses, sometimes my analyses and perspectives could accurate, sometimes I could be wildly off the mark. Bottom line, I know very little about many things.

ImWell · 13/08/2022 01:15

Discovereads · 13/08/2022 01:09

And here is the paper
Breaking the warp barrier: hyper-fast solitons in Einstein–Maxwell-plasma theory. by Dr. Erik W Lentz
Published 9 March 2021 • © 2021 IOP Publishing Ltd
Classical and Quantum Gravity, Volume 38, Number 7
Citation Erik W Lentz 2021 Class. Quantum Grav. 38 075015
iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1361-6382/abe692

That is a discussion of plausible solutions in general relativity, with no suggestion that they will be valid.

As to the idea that you “just” need a nuclear reactor; gravity is 10^40 times smaller than electromagnetism, you’d need an energy source of a billion suns to try to manipulate it at the scale of a human construction.

A pair of black holes colliding make a ripple far smaller than the width of a human hair; every reactor on earth doesn’t get within a factor of a million of that sort of power output.

Discovereads · 13/08/2022 01:14

ImWell · 13/08/2022 01:09

The Wikipedia article gives a decent enough explanation of what solitons are. The wave that people surf on up the River Severn is an example of one.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soliton#:~:text=In%20mathematics%20and%20physics%2C%20a,dispersive%20effects%20in%20the%20medium.

Yes, exactly, solitons have already been observed. Which is more than we can say for when black holes were theorised in 1915 by Einstein to exist- 50yrs before we actually discovered/observed one in 1964. And 2019 was first time we have imaged a black hole.

Hawkins001 · 13/08/2022 01:13

ImWell · 13/08/2022 01:02

No, quantum mechanics is the most accurate part of our whole knowledge of the universe. Look at how well our calculation of the fine structure constant matches measurement. It’s an amazingly precise area of human knowledge.

Your suggestion breaches fundamental aspects that underpin all physics. Energy conservation, relativity, momentum conservation, even the very basics of what a wave function is.

It’s not like positing that Bigfoot exists, it’s like suggesting that the earth really does rest on the back of a turtle and that aliens have replaced our parents with robots.

On the history point, you are equally wrong. Archaeologists, geologists, sociologists, linguists, historians, and more, would all need to be in on the conspiracy. All of them, from all over the world. That’s just not possible. The idea that not a single one would speak up.

How can you even suggest that all governments; Russia, France, Peru, The UK, that they all have agreed to fake world history?

And why?

This is always the problem with conspiracy theorists, you can’t or won’t try to understand what else would need to be true for your ideas to be possible.

The only interesting part of it is the psychology. How do people of limited intelligence and education come to believe that they know more than all of the worlds experts, in so many unrelated fields.

That bit, I find absolutely fascinating.

Archaeology,

dating of the sphinx, based on water erosion ect, Graham Hancock,

AuntTwacky · 13/08/2022 01:10

Where are all these hysterical threads

ImWell · 13/08/2022 01:09

Discovereads · 13/08/2022 01:00

Have you heard of solitons? Bubbles that fold space in front of the space ship to go faster than light? All we need is for the space ship to have its own nuclear fission reactor or similar level energy source.

The Wikipedia article gives a decent enough explanation of what solitons are. The wave that people surf on up the River Severn is an example of one.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soliton#:~:text=In%20mathematics%20and%20physics%2C%20a,dispersive%20effects%20in%20the%20medium.

Discovereads · 13/08/2022 01:09

And here is the paper
Breaking the warp barrier: hyper-fast solitons in Einstein–Maxwell-plasma theory. by Dr. Erik W Lentz
Published 9 March 2021 • © 2021 IOP Publishing Ltd
Classical and Quantum Gravity, Volume 38, Number 7
Citation Erik W Lentz 2021 Class. Quantum Grav. 38 075015
iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1361-6382/abe692

Discovereads · 13/08/2022 01:07

ImWell · 13/08/2022 01:03

None of what you wrote there is correct. None of it accords with the known laws of physics.

Where on Earth did you read it?

Apparently it obeys Einsteins theories of physics.
Press release: Breaking the warp barrier for faster-than-light travel No. 32 - 09.03.2021. Astrophysicist at Göttingen University discovers new theoretical hyper-fast soliton solutions
www.uni-goettingen.de/en/3240.html?id=6192

ImWell · 13/08/2022 01:03

Discovereads · 13/08/2022 01:00

Have you heard of solitons? Bubbles that fold space in front of the space ship to go faster than light? All we need is for the space ship to have its own nuclear fission reactor or similar level energy source.

None of what you wrote there is correct. None of it accords with the known laws of physics.

Where on Earth did you read it?

ImWell · 13/08/2022 01:02

Hawkins001 · 13/08/2022 00:52

And what if the stargate would operate at the quantum mechanics, level, as my basic knowledge is, our laws of physics breaks down at that point

No, quantum mechanics is the most accurate part of our whole knowledge of the universe. Look at how well our calculation of the fine structure constant matches measurement. It’s an amazingly precise area of human knowledge.

Your suggestion breaches fundamental aspects that underpin all physics. Energy conservation, relativity, momentum conservation, even the very basics of what a wave function is.

It’s not like positing that Bigfoot exists, it’s like suggesting that the earth really does rest on the back of a turtle and that aliens have replaced our parents with robots.

On the history point, you are equally wrong. Archaeologists, geologists, sociologists, linguists, historians, and more, would all need to be in on the conspiracy. All of them, from all over the world. That’s just not possible. The idea that not a single one would speak up.

How can you even suggest that all governments; Russia, France, Peru, The UK, that they all have agreed to fake world history?

And why?

This is always the problem with conspiracy theorists, you can’t or won’t try to understand what else would need to be true for your ideas to be possible.

The only interesting part of it is the psychology. How do people of limited intelligence and education come to believe that they know more than all of the worlds experts, in so many unrelated fields.

That bit, I find absolutely fascinating.

Hawkins001 · 13/08/2022 01:01

Discovereads · 13/08/2022 01:00

Have you heard of solitons? Bubbles that fold space in front of the space ship to go faster than light? All we need is for the space ship to have its own nuclear fission reactor or similar level energy source.

Not a wisper, although I'll do a bit of research, much appreciated.

Discovereads · 13/08/2022 01:00

Hawkins001 · 13/08/2022 00:52

And what if the stargate would operate at the quantum mechanics, level, as my basic knowledge is, our laws of physics breaks down at that point

Have you heard of solitons? Bubbles that fold space in front of the space ship to go faster than light? All we need is for the space ship to have its own nuclear fission reactor or similar level energy source.

Hawkins001 · 13/08/2022 00:58

@ImWell

This is from Google,

"How is quantum physics violating every rule known to man but regular physics isn't?
Regular physics is based on what natural philosophers, later known as scientists, observed around them. They put rigor to what we could see and therefore what corresponded to our common sense.

But there were “issues.” Certain things, pushed to the limit, didn’t make sense. Thus we get general relativity and quantum mechanics. GR and QM describe everything that we can test. Even in our macro world. But in their limiting cases they simplify to classical physics. We only experience this simpler limiting case. The full GR and/or QM explanation of things has no intuitive, instinctive equivalence. They don’t violate “every rule known to man,” but they do vastly complicate the rules we have from real-world experience.

As has been said many times, just get over it and do the math. It works. And yes, there are real world macro cases, where you have to apply GR or QM to get the right answer"

Hawkins001 · 13/08/2022 00:52

And what if the stargate would operate at the quantum mechanics, level, as my basic knowledge is, our laws of physics breaks down at that point

Hawkins001 · 13/08/2022 00:50

ImWell · 13/08/2022 00:40

Er, what? You think that there could be government projects beaming people across the galaxy, or that there is some sort of hidden human history that the government knows that is kept from us?

That’s even more ridiculous than flat Earth theories. How could you possibly believe that either of these is true? The former goes against the laws of physics, the latter would require a conspiracy so large that it would fall apart in hours.

They were more generalisations as examples,

But laws of physics, who's to say we are fully correct in all areas of our knowledge ?
As for the large number of people, please, all you need is a strict military controls, a chain of command, then it broken down into teams of units, why do people presume large numbers equals someone will talk, even if they would, im.sure control measures would be in place to squash the information or discredit the information. don't forget the vast number of people when developing atomic weapons ? How would that be any different vast project, numerous groups, ect

ImWell · 13/08/2022 00:40

Hawkins001 · 13/08/2022 00:35

So it's better to not look up ? Better to presume the gov't is completely honest, better to presume there is not more to human history than we are told, to presume their are no projects similar to the stargate ?

Er, what? You think that there could be government projects beaming people across the galaxy, or that there is some sort of hidden human history that the government knows that is kept from us?

That’s even more ridiculous than flat Earth theories. How could you possibly believe that either of these is true? The former goes against the laws of physics, the latter would require a conspiracy so large that it would fall apart in hours.

Hawkins001 · 13/08/2022 00:39

abcdefghijklmnopxxx · 13/08/2022 00:32

Sorry I've posted on the wrong thread!

I'm guessing that's the infected ear thread ?

Hawkins001 · 13/08/2022 00:35

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 13/08/2022 00:31

@Hawkins001
If you can't disseminate this thread then I can't help you.

So it's better to not look up ? Better to presume the gov't is completely honest, better to presume there is not more to human history than we are told, to presume their are no projects similar to the stargate ?

Discovereads · 13/08/2022 00:35

Hawkins001 · 13/08/2022 00:29

I think what they mean by weaponising energy is basically using energy as a bargaining chip, at the casino tablet so to speak.

It still hyperbole. Refusing to buy from or sell to a country because of something their government is doing is an economic sanction. We’ve dished them out many times and now it’s our turn to be on the receiving end.

abcdefghijklmnopxxx · 13/08/2022 00:32

Sorry I've posted on the wrong thread!

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 13/08/2022 00:31

@Hawkins001
If you can't disseminate this thread then I can't help you.

abcdefghijklmnopxxx · 13/08/2022 00:30

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Hawkins001 · 13/08/2022 00:29

Discovereads · 13/08/2022 00:25

@cakeorwine
We are at war now. Putin is weaponising energy. This is real.

Thats the thing we are always involved in a war somewhere.
Putin is not weaponising energy, unless you’re referring to laser weapons which are in development both there and here. Mostly for zapping drones out of the sky (so they say) but if you can zap a drone, you can zap a manned aircraft or ground vehicle too.
Any hoo, refusing to sell gas to Europe isn’t weaponising energy, it is a type of economic sanction…so think about that…it’s really rare for us to be on the receiving end of an economic sanction. Usually we’re doing it to other countries and we sort of ignore the suffering of the civilian population that always is the result of economic sanctions. You do know their purpose is to try and make the populace so desperate that they riot, start a civil war, overthrow their government?

I think what they mean by weaponising energy is basically using energy as a bargaining chip, at the casino tablet so to speak.