Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cheeky couples on Location Location Location

137 replies

Arbesque · 12/08/2022 09:35

Just watched another episode where Bob and Lisa have been trying, for 2 years, to find a house within their 350k budget that meets all of their criteria.
Kirsty finds them one that has the 3 bedrooms, tick, big garden, tick, off street parking, tick and is in one of their preferred areas. It's on at 350k
Bob and Lisa love it and are beyond amazed that the perfect house in the perfect area, within budget, exists because in their 2 years of searching they have never one.

They decide to go in with a 'cheeky' (insulting) offer of 325. They are a bit miffed when this is turned down and up their offer to 330. Again, to their amazement this is turned down and the Estate Agent patiently explains that the vendors feel the asking price is fair.

Bob and Lisa very reluctantly up their offer to 340 and are shocked and hurt this is also rejected. They decide to 'walk away' and 3 months later are 'still looking' for their dream house.

No wonder, with that attitude.

If the house is worth it and you have the money just PAY THE ASKING PRICE and stop mucking everyone around.

OP posts:
BellePeppa · 12/08/2022 13:31

DillonPanthersTexas · 12/08/2022 09:52

I always wonder where some of the couples get their enormous budgets from when they come across as being utterly thick unemployable fuckwits.

And aged about thirty and have a near million pound budget. It’s really mystifying sometimes.

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 13:31

JinglingHellsBells · 12/08/2022 13:19

Yes, so if you've done your checks (which I assume you do before making such a massive purchase) and it's fairly priced etc etc, why not offer asking?

Because everyone knows that people always try to sell houses and cars above the value and expect some negotiation.

Houses that hang around are often the ones where the sellers will not take even £100 less than they think it's worth.

And the 'value' is a guide. You can see 'sold' prices but you can't always see what the asking price was.

I've had someone I know sell a house recently. They had 3 valuations. These aren't the real figures, but for example, the valuations ranged hugely.
eg. £350K, £400K, £435K

They chose an agent who had suggested the mid figure as that was closer to their own appraisal of the market in their area. It sold for the asking price, as the buyers were desperate for a house having lost out on one.

Yes, but assuming the house hasn't hung around etc etc.

We've bought two houses and didn't "know" anything about the prices without doing a bit of research on recent comparative sales etc. How would you "know" that without researching?

When we sold our last house, we got three valuations and they were all very similar. No offers under, sold for quite a lot over. As many houses have done recently (may be cooling now, I don't know). Bidding wars aren't uncommon.

Anyone who "knew" we were trying to bump the price up to negotiate down and offered under would have had no chance. There are no constants. You have to judge things individually.

Of course values depend on certain things and change depending on the circumstances. My point is, if you've got a budget, you've done your research, the price is fair and you've been looking for two years (so I have to assume what you want doesn't come up that much)...why not just offer asking? If you do actually want the house?

There might be a reason why these people searched without success for two years and then failed to get it even when they found it.

Sales psychology is interesting, I suppose. Some people seem to want what they think is a bargain, not their dream house at the expected price. But the whole point of a bargain is that you pay less than it's worth, otherwise it's just a fair price.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 12/08/2022 13:30

Sometimes we watch 'A Place In the Sun' (to jeer at it) & some of their buyers do the same thing. There was one property which had already been massively reduced several times & so was just in the buyer's price range, & they were told that was the absolute lowest acceptable price... you'd think they'd snap it up but they went in with a much lower offer. So funny to see the presenter swallow hard but phone in the offer, which was naturally turned down. Other times the presenter will say, "That's a cheeky offer." I wish they'd broadcast both sides of the subsequent phone calls to the estate agents.

JinglingHellsBells · 12/08/2022 13:19

Yes, so if you've done your checks (which I assume you do before making such a massive purchase) and it's fairly priced etc etc, why not offer asking?

Because everyone knows that people always try to sell houses and cars above the value and expect some negotiation.

Houses that hang around are often the ones where the sellers will not take even £100 less than they think it's worth.

And the 'value' is a guide. You can see 'sold' prices but you can't always see what the asking price was.

I've had someone I know sell a house recently. They had 3 valuations. These aren't the real figures, but for example, the valuations ranged hugely.
eg. £350K, £400K, £435K

They chose an agent who had suggested the mid figure as that was closer to their own appraisal of the market in their area. It sold for the asking price, as the buyers were desperate for a house having lost out on one.

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 13:12

Pemba · 12/08/2022 13:05

Yes but that was all an act. I am sure Kirsty didn't really care. She is in the business of making an entertaining TV show, and that comes far above getting the buyers sorted with a property. Everything is not as it seems.

Doesn't it make the show look better if it can succeed in finding what the buyers failed to find in two years of searching?

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 13:11

SpeckledlyHen · 12/08/2022 12:59

I had exactly the same. The house was on offer for £900k. Within hours we had multiple viewings and he offered at £880. Of course this was at the weekend so we did get all the offers in until the Monday. We turned down his offer and he increased by 1k, then again for another 1k. Apparently really disappointed and annoyed with us. The offer we accepted in the end was for £935k.. IF he had just offered the asking price in such a buoyant market (i think in fact it was slightly undervalued if anything judging by the response we got) he may have got a bargain. Twat.

Something about the raising by a grand each time would piss me off so much. I don't know why but it would.

balalake · 12/08/2022 13:10

Scottish law is better for house purchase, even though not perfect.

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 13:09

JinglingHellsBells · 12/08/2022 12:40

If it was your dream house, fairly priced, under your budget and wouldn't have made much difference to the monthly payments, why did you initially go in at £10k under? Why not offer the asking price straight away?

Fairly priced is subjective.

Everyone knows that houses and 2nd hand cars are priced over their true value with the expectation of offers.

It's easy to see true values by using RM House Sales and comparing with other houses in the same road/area and adding on inflation or deflation, and demand.

Yes, so if you've done your checks (which I assume you do before making such a massive purchase) and it's fairly priced etc etc, why not offer asking?

Pipsquiggle · 12/08/2022 13:07

You realise all of this is about psychology - everyone in these buying / selling scenarios want to feel like they have a good deal and value for money.

Unless you are in the hottest of property markets, I would never offer the asking price on the first bid.

I remember the first house we bought, the asking price was £10k over the stamp duty threshold. It was never, ever, going to sell at the asking price as the fees to the buyer went exponentially up. As we were chain free, first time buyers we were not the highest bid but the most flexible which is why they sold to us.

If the house has been on the market for a few months with no proceedable offer, why would offer the asking price?

Pemba · 12/08/2022 13:06

Whereabouts are you qpmz, out of interest?

Pemba · 12/08/2022 13:05

Yes but that was all an act. I am sure Kirsty didn't really care. She is in the business of making an entertaining TV show, and that comes far above getting the buyers sorted with a property. Everything is not as it seems.

qpmz · 12/08/2022 13:04

Oh god, we've just paid £46k over the asking price! Wouldn't have stood a chance if we went under!

Arbesque · 12/08/2022 13:04

Pemba · 12/08/2022 13:01

Maybe the house wasn't worth £350,000 to them. In comparison to others they'd seen, or maybe there were alterations they wanted to do, so that needed to come out of their budget? Maybe they realised that they were pushing themselves too far to pay the top of their stated budget?

They declared the house as being absolutely perfect, we could just move in etc. And Kirsty did seem genuinely frustrated.

OP posts:
DanteThunderstone · 12/08/2022 13:01

My favourite episode of LLL was a Scotland one. A couple wanted a very specific house - can't remember the details but it was akin to 'three bedrooms exactly, mature garden, a walk from central Edinburgh, must be Victorian or older and have high ceilings and buckets of charm. Budget 375k'. Phil and Kirstie found them contenders but they found miniscule fault with all of them and were being completely inflexible on their criteria. Anyway it ended up with them out of nowhere announcing that they'd bought a 5 bed newbuild in Bonnyrigg for 450 thousand and Kirstie was just hilariously pissed off with them for wasting her time.

Pemba · 12/08/2022 13:01

Maybe the house wasn't worth £350,000 to them. In comparison to others they'd seen, or maybe there were alterations they wanted to do, so that needed to come out of their budget? Maybe they realised that they were pushing themselves too far to pay the top of their stated budget?

SpeckledlyHen · 12/08/2022 12:59

PyjamaFan · 12/08/2022 09:38

I agree.

I had a buyer make a very low offer and then when I refused repeatedly raised it by £1k at a time.

It annoyed me so much that I wouldn't have sold to him even if he had ever reached a fair price.

Twat.

I had exactly the same. The house was on offer for £900k. Within hours we had multiple viewings and he offered at £880. Of course this was at the weekend so we did get all the offers in until the Monday. We turned down his offer and he increased by 1k, then again for another 1k. Apparently really disappointed and annoyed with us. The offer we accepted in the end was for £935k.. IF he had just offered the asking price in such a buoyant market (i think in fact it was slightly undervalued if anything judging by the response we got) he may have got a bargain. Twat.

Arbesque · 12/08/2022 12:56

Zeus44 · 12/08/2022 12:22

They are right to walk away. Asking prices have no real measure against an index, it’s inflated by the agent as commission based and the greed of the seller.

You are looking at it very opaquely if you believe they should’ve bought as they may not have been able to afford the repayments if interest rates had risen etc. Lots of factors.

Then why say your budget is 350k, if actually you are only prepared to spend 335k?

OP posts:
JinglingHellsBells · 12/08/2022 12:40

If it was your dream house, fairly priced, under your budget and wouldn't have made much difference to the monthly payments, why did you initially go in at £10k under? Why not offer the asking price straight away?

Fairly priced is subjective.

Everyone knows that houses and 2nd hand cars are priced over their true value with the expectation of offers.

It's easy to see true values by using RM House Sales and comparing with other houses in the same road/area and adding on inflation or deflation, and demand.

Blossomtoes · 12/08/2022 12:38

We bought our house 23 years ago in a red hot market and paid asking price. I bought my previous house three years earlier and got it for £5k under asking because the market then was a lot slower. The days of offers under are returning I suspect as the market cools.

JinglingHellsBells · 12/08/2022 12:37

Kirsty thought it was a bargain and you could see she was frustrated the couple were stubbornly refusing to go up to the asking price.

So Kirsty is an expert, not someone being paid to make a programme where they create tension and drama?

Quia · 12/08/2022 12:34

Candleabra · 12/08/2022 10:07

It can be a bit annoying with the fussy buyers but LLL is generally the only property show where people actually end up buying something.

The worst ones are the “Escape to….” genre. I don’t think I’ve ever seen anyone buy a house on that show. It’s very frustrating for the viewer.

To be fair, they do sometimes. I like "I Escaped to the Country" where they revisit to see what the buyers did with the house they bought, or where they ended up if they didn't buy any of the houses they saw on the programme.

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 12:32

SilverGlassHare · 12/08/2022 10:49

YANBU. Totally agree it’s just being greedy and shortsighted when they have the budget. We found our dream house 5 years ago, offered £10k under. Vendors said no so we immediately offered full asking price (this was me, DH wanted to go up by £5k but I was desperate for this house), they accepted, we all lived happily ever after. We’ve both said since how glad we are that we did offer full asking price - it was still under our budget and didn’t make much difference to our monthly repayments. We didn’t get round to cancelling our Rightmove alerts for ages afterwards and never saw anything we liked as much for the price.

If it was your dream house, fairly priced, under your budget and wouldn't have made much difference to the monthly payments, why did you initially go in at £10k under? Why not offer the asking price straight away?

JudgeJ · 12/08/2022 12:32

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 12/08/2022 11:57

This in spades! Every time I watch house programmes, I am amazed at the number of entitled, rather thick people who seem to be rolling in it.

I also get amazed at how many people go on Wanted Down Under, they live in a normal 3 bedroom semi in Smalltown UK and wonder why they can't get the Aussie dream in Sydney for the same money, with walk-in wardrobes and a pool, obviously.

Twins3007 · 12/08/2022 12:30

I find it strange with all these types of programmes , house in the sun, places in the sun etc etc that they all go in with a budget find the perfect property and then walk away because the vendor wont go down 30 to 50K why say you have this amount to spend when clearly you haven't ?

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 12:28

OnlyEverAutumn · 12/08/2022 09:57

I’ve bought and sold houses for 25 years and have ALWAYS gone in with an offer below asking - and had same from buyers. Totally standard behaviour. (And worked in an estate agency when I was younger and it was accepted then too). Nothing new or unusual about it. House prices are very ballpark figures dreamt up by estate agents, they’re not science 😄.

£25k under, when the valuation is fair, it's in your budget and you've been searching for two years?

Swipe left for the next trending thread