Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cheeky couples on Location Location Location

137 replies

Arbesque · 12/08/2022 09:35

Just watched another episode where Bob and Lisa have been trying, for 2 years, to find a house within their 350k budget that meets all of their criteria.
Kirsty finds them one that has the 3 bedrooms, tick, big garden, tick, off street parking, tick and is in one of their preferred areas. It's on at 350k
Bob and Lisa love it and are beyond amazed that the perfect house in the perfect area, within budget, exists because in their 2 years of searching they have never one.

They decide to go in with a 'cheeky' (insulting) offer of 325. They are a bit miffed when this is turned down and up their offer to 330. Again, to their amazement this is turned down and the Estate Agent patiently explains that the vendors feel the asking price is fair.

Bob and Lisa very reluctantly up their offer to 340 and are shocked and hurt this is also rejected. They decide to 'walk away' and 3 months later are 'still looking' for their dream house.

No wonder, with that attitude.

If the house is worth it and you have the money just PAY THE ASKING PRICE and stop mucking everyone around.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
qpmz · 12/08/2022 21:31

Pemba · 12/08/2022 20:38

qpmz I guessed it must be London or the South East. The house sounds beautiful, I hope you'll be happy.

Thank you Flowers

gatehouseoffleet · 12/08/2022 21:12

SleeplessInEngland · 12/08/2022 10:28

I imagine the producers are good at finding slightly difficult couples otherwise there wouldn't be much of a show. "looks good, we'll take it" isn't very dramatic.

That is true. Sometimes we watch it and don't like any of the houses, but other times we'd buy any of them and wonder why they are so picky. And then we think "well we'd make crap TV". Admittedly you only see what they show you, so you don't know there's a power station down the road or similar. But then they don't mention that, they decide the bathroom is the wrong colour or some such excuse.

Pemba · 12/08/2022 20:38

qpmz I guessed it must be London or the South East. The house sounds beautiful, I hope you'll be happy.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 12/08/2022 19:51

I can’t say I sympathise with all this ‘The poor seller!! They might not get the price they want!!! 🙁’ business. People negotiated house prices long before LLL. If you want £250k for your house and won’t take a penny less, that’s your prerogative - but it’s not unreasonable or ‘cheeeeeeky’ of potential buyers to make a lower offer. You can always say no!

I do agree that lots of LLL participants are deluded. But if you’ve got £300k to spend, know what you can get in the area you like for that and are happy to work in and around that budget, why would you need help? Aside from the fact that it’s an entertainment show, so they probably deliberately pick contrary/clueless people, the format naturally attracts those people.

When you think about it, LLL has managed over 20 years on telly with minor variations on a few dilemmas:

Deluded couple want a two-bed flat near Chiswick with independent shops and restaurants nearby for £300k. Kirstie has to tell them they can just about run to that property in part of South London with no tube if they push themselves to the absolute limit by buying lunch from Greggs instead of the one cutesy bakery nearby.

Equally deluded couple think that by flogging their one-bed in Zone 3, they can afford four beds in the Home Counties within 15 minutes of a direct train to Waterloo.

Couple want to live in the countryside and make milk-souring faces at the slightest hint of car noise, but won’t consider a property more than 10 minutes from a motorway junction.

Family have £800k to spend on a five-bed house, but all the ones they want are actually worth over a million.

Token nice artsy person is actually realistic on location… if there’s space for the workshop/artist's studio/wood fired kiln they absolutely need to run their business.

qpmz · 12/08/2022 19:37

Pemba · 12/08/2022 13:06

Whereabouts are you qpmz, out of interest?

We've just bought near Caterham in Surrey. The house is beautifully renovated so we don't need to lift a finger once we've moved in! We were told 11 people bid initially and then we went to 2nd and final offers.

Pemba · 12/08/2022 18:51

Well exactly Larkspur, they are more interested in how the programme looks than finding the right property for the buyers. How often does the show end in the buyers going through with any of the houses they are shown? Plus of course some 'buyers' are not serious, they just want to be on TV. Or with the shows featuring houses in France, or Mediterranean countries, or Australia, they just want a free holiday!

Jedsnewstar · 12/08/2022 18:51

‘This is Dave and his wife Susan. Dave is a retired postman and Susan volunteered on the school PTA. Their budget is £500k

WTF did Dave deliver, Cristal Meth?

LarkspurLane · 12/08/2022 18:45

I watched an episode set in my home town. Buyers had particular needs - near a particular school, walking distance of town and a great budget. The houses they were shown did not match these at all. Near town, near the school, not both. One was miles out in the countryside "to see if they fancied something a bit different". They didn't buy and maybe to the general public looked a bit stupid for that but they were presumably not allowed to say "why did you show me this house five miles from town, nowhere near the school we asked for?"
The town looked great though and might have piqued the interest of viewers.

LadyEloise1 · 12/08/2022 18:21

SpidersAreShitheads · 12/08/2022 11:43

The ones that get to me are the house buyers who walk away over a couple of grand, despite being able to afford it.

Buyer: My budget is £250k but I'll go up to £300k for the perfect house.

LLL: Here is your perfect house, and even better it's bang on your budget of £250k. It was originally up for sale for £280k but the last buyer dropped out so they've reduced the price for a quick sale. It's a real bargain.

Buyer: I love it and must have it!!! Offer them £240k.

LLL: The estate agent says if you up your offer to £245k you've got a deal.

Buyer: I'll increase to £242,500 but that's my final offer.

LLL: The seller says they can't afford to drop below £245k because they need the money for their onward purchase.

Buyer: I'll leave it then.

End Voiceover: "Twatty buyer is still looking for their dream house but feels confident that they'll find something very soon."

It's literally a couple of grand, and you can afford it. It's a tiny gnat piss drop in the ocean of the overall cost. Just pay it and stop being so bloody minded about "driving a hard bargain".

And breathe..... 😂

My sentiments exactly.

Not good for the blood pressure when you've just sat down to watch for a bit of escapism.

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 15:26

Also, some desirable houses are deliberately priced low to get lots of interest. Then people get keen and then there's lots of competition in a bidding war or full and final.

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 12/08/2022 14:39

This really confuses me and I need to get a handle on it. We bought our house 28+ years ago when in fact yes, if you could afford say £100k, you actually looked at houses up to £120k and would offer accordingly. Now all these years later we need to sell up due to divorce and I hate to think I'll be at the estate agents mercy to know what to do, whereas previously years ago I was very confident on how far to push/pull things.

House is in OK condition but not the showroom glossy grey you see on most listings (and I know that's expected as when people who can't sell post on here they are criticised for leaving a couple of toys out!) - so am I to market at the price its worth and what I want from it, or still stick it on slightly higher so as to let buyers feel they've got a bargain when they knock me down £10K?! And I assume the price I see is at least the price I'll pay on any potential new house listings? Even in not so desirable areas? Hmm

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 14:34

This always makes my mind boggle on LLL, they've been looking for years/have seen 7000 houses and are desperate, Kirsty and Phil find them the perfect house and they won't get it unless the can do a deal and knock £5k off

And this is what makes me think that, while they truly might not realise it, they don't actually want their dream house for a fair price. They want a house for less than they think it's actually worth.

cecilthehungryspider · 12/08/2022 14:31

Arbesque · 12/08/2022 10:03

I agree there's no harm starting with a lower, although realistic, price. But booking 2nd and 3rd viewings and stubbornly refusing to offer the asking price on a house you can afford, really love and have seen nothing to match it in 2 years seems silly, and must annoy the he'll out of Phil and Kiesty.

I agree they have shot themselves in the foot there. Haggling is normal but if you really like a house and it is budget you need to be prepared that you may have to pay full price for it.

cecilthehungryspider · 12/08/2022 14:29

Minecraftatemychild · 12/08/2022 09:53

Yes. It’s dumb.

I’ve never sold or bought at below asking price, I think it’s a myth. I’ve occasionally tried to haggle but people thought I was mad.

Different if you’re on a tv show 🙄

I have never paid the full asking price on a property. I have bought and sold multiple houses and some haggling is completely expected and normal. The only exception to this rule is when a house has been priced to sell quickly so is already on at a low price.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 12/08/2022 14:25

There was a time when you could put in an offer on a house before you had sold yours. Around here you can't get a viewing unless you are immediately proceedable.

”Proceedable” drives me crackers. Just the lack of flexibility and the failure to acknowledge that the property buying process in this country is multi-stage and hugely prone to collapse. I’m not sure it helps any party.

Fluffyboo · 12/08/2022 14:23

If the house is worth it and you have the money just PAY THE ASKING PRICE and stop mucking everyone around.

This always makes my mind boggle on LLL, they've been looking for years/have seen 7000 houses and are desperate, Kirsty and Phil find them the perfect house and they won't get it unless the can do a deal and knock £5k off

Ffs, that £5k difference will be pissed up the wall in rent in a few months, not to mention the risk of house prices increasing by that much by the time the next unicorn house that meets their giant list of requirements comes about! Honestly I have no idea how P&K keep their cool

Pleiades2020 · 12/08/2022 14:22

To be fair on Kirstles and Phil their advice is mostly sound, and they've usually pretty good with what to offer. They do say pay the asking price when it's appropriate, or even a bit over. Agree the buyers are their own worst enemies at times - if you're not a millionaire you have to compromise on something, and a home is what you make it.

I've always offered less than asking for a house, but also have accepted less than asking when selling. But things are a little bit different this year so achieving asking prices is more common than it was.

Chillow · 12/08/2022 14:13

We got £40k off a property listed for £600k and I think we overpaid.

We compared it against a similar property at time of purchase, but didn’t realise that that property was converted into 3 flats, and therefore had a higher selling fee.

cupofdecaf · 12/08/2022 14:07

I appreciate that this just fluke but I've bought 2 houses, one 15k under asking and another 56k under 'guide price' (code I think for we don't have a clue what it's worth so we'll stick a CF high number on and see what happens).

I've sold one house and it went for 28k over asking (though only just over the highest of the valuations we got, went with the middle valuation estate agent).

Depends on local practices and different agents. Some areas you expect a bidding war and others the asking prices are a joke.

Is it better to go low and get people through the door then have a bidding war or put a high price on, less people view and the buyer feels they got a bargain? I wonder which works better?

WireSkills · 12/08/2022 14:04

That does sound frustrating.

I haven't bought or sold a house for over 10 years but whenever I'd sold before the estate agent has always said, for example, "We'd expect this to sell for £220,000, so I'd suggest putting it on for £240,000".

I think over time, however, people started getting disappointed with £225k when the asking price was £240k, even though they'd been told to expect £220k in the first place.

Either way, pricing it high to negotiate, or pricing it low to start a bidding war is just very annoying practice either way! How about advertising a house for what it's worth and what you want for it??

We got mucked around by someone who had a house listed for £525k. Our budget was £500k. EA told us to go and look at it because "I'd never show you something you can't afford" - i.e. it's not worth £500k.

We offered £490k I think but it was rejected and the vendor refused to accept anything below list price, so we walked away. Two weeks later we found a nicer house that was listed at £445k and we got it for £430k. A couple of months later, the original house we offered on was removed from the market unsold and has never gone back on since. What a waste of everyone's time that was!

ThePollutedShadesOfPemberley · 12/08/2022 13:50

Whether they are cheeky or not depends on how old the program is.

Time was you could behave like this and get what you want.

There was a time when you could put in an offer on a house before you had sold yours. Around here you can't get a viewing unless you are immediately proceedable.

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 13:39

Whitehorsegirl · 12/08/2022 13:34

I think there can be valid reasons to offer below asking price if:

  • the property has been on the market for some time and it is obvious it is overpriced compared to similar properties in the area
  • a survey reveals that there is a lot of structural work to be done that wasn't immediately obvious when viewing the property so you review your offer
  • you are not in a chain/are a cash buyer and the seller is really keen to move out fast so you offer a slightly lower offer.
In this case if sounded like these people were just being silly...

I personally won't entertain the principle of ''bidding wars'' either. I stick to my budget and no more.

Yes, these are all sensible. But there are actual reasons going on there.

Bidding wars get dangerous. Again, sales psychology. You get caught up in the need to "win" and nor miss out rather than make a sensible purchase.

If someone came in with an offer I thought was unfairly low, I wouldn't necessarily refuse a fairer offer if they came back with one. But coming back with one grand more each time would piss me right off and make me sell elsewhere. I don't know why.

Wombat27A · 12/08/2022 13:39

Things are very different now, you can absolutely do your own valuations as the information that the valuers use is openly available.

At the end of the day, some people will value decor highly (met people when showing houses who wouldn't buy a house where the paint colours weren't to their taste, no chance they would be opening a can) and others who can happily visualise it with an entirely different layout. It's an art and a bit of a science.

Wombat27A · 12/08/2022 13:34

JinglingHellsBells · 12/08/2022 12:27

I don't think people understand the valuation is for the property in the condition it is currently in.

Oh come on! @Wombat27A

Estate agents have only one aim - to sell a house. They are sharks.

They often price low if they need to reach their monthly sales targets, or high if they want a higher percentage of the sale and are willing to try it on and see if someone pays over the odds.

They sometimes bow down to the vanity of sellers who usually think their houses are worth more than they are. And of course they are quids in if the house sells for more than it is worth.

Bathrooms and kitchens are subjective. They can be functional, but still need ripping out if dated or tatty.

I said the valuation. Some estate agents are fab, some are shite, the market determines the value...

Trust me, I sat through the lectures on how one can be sued if the comparables don't back up the asking price. That is clearly happening just now as valuations aren't reflecting the situations where people are bidding over.

Note I did go on to say if the property was overpriced relative to the market by all means offer but don't be rubbish and expect a seller to discount just so you can change the decor.

Whitehorsegirl · 12/08/2022 13:34

I think there can be valid reasons to offer below asking price if:

  • the property has been on the market for some time and it is obvious it is overpriced compared to similar properties in the area
  • a survey reveals that there is a lot of structural work to be done that wasn't immediately obvious when viewing the property so you review your offer
  • you are not in a chain/are a cash buyer and the seller is really keen to move out fast so you offer a slightly lower offer.
In this case if sounded like these people were just being silly...

I personally won't entertain the principle of ''bidding wars'' either. I stick to my budget and no more.