Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD's controlling friend & safeguarding

81 replies

Obeythedancecommander · 12/08/2022 08:56

Should I be speaking to the school about this friendship/child?

My DD is going into y2 and is confident and outgoing. We moved schools beginning of the year and a girl who was initially mean to my DD is now her friend.

My daughter mentioned casually a few times how her friend has to decide what games they play in the playground and gets cross with her or cries if she doesn't agree or if she plays with other kids. I encouraged DD to play with other children too and occasionally she would say they played in a group.

A few weeks ago DD asked me if I'd heard of "huggy wuggy and kissy missy" and explained they were scary characters. I dug a bit and she told me her friend plays these scary games at home and also watches "pennywise the scary clown" too and at school DD is forced to play whatever a playground recreation of these things is and she doesn't want to. Huggy wuggy is part of a horror game called "Poppy Playtime" and is 100% not suitable for any 6 year old. Obviously the same with pennywise.

I invited this child over to our house to play a few days ago (DD has been desperate for playdates) and I thought it would be a good opportunity to observe the friendship.

She remarked on all my daughters toys, I asked her what toys she had at home. She said she only had an ipad and barbies. I asked her what did she like to do on her ipad and she said she liked to play roblox and watch scary things like Poppy Playtime and watch Killer Clowns called pennywise. This led to me gently asking leading questions on this and basically she is allowed free range of the ipad and to watch things I would personally deem inappropriate.

The day initially started well but soon became apparent this child had to make every decision on what they were doing and how they did it and DD was not allowed input. I initially encouraged my daughter to let her friend have dibs on certain things as the guest (this child didn't bring a swimming costume, and wanted the one my daughter was wearing instead of the spare costume I offered her. Neither would agree but eventually my daughter relented). This continued on, the child demanding x y z and my daughter trying to negotiate and compromise but this child not willing to meet halfway.

It came to a head later on in the day with my daughter refusing to give up something (they were roleplaying) and my daughter saying "hang on, gave you that, I gave you this when we did x, I gave you y when we did that... why can't I have anything?" I was watching them from the stairwell and began trying to mediate which was pointless. The girl squeezed my daughters wrists really hard refusing refusing let her move and said "if you don't let me have it I'm not going to be your friend and I'll never be your friend again at school". It led to both girls crying and me trying to mediate again and comfort the other child as well my own.

The girl threatened the not being friends thing at school a lot. Not sure how we got there but she started reiterating what my daughter had said about her not letting her play with other kids and saying she only ever wanted to play with my DD and my DD isn't allowed to play with others at school. I said it's nice to play with lots of different people or in a big group and she said again, if DD plays with others when they go back to school she would not be friends with her.

For the last hour of the playdate they got on ok but I am wondering how to approach this. I am concerned about how controlling this child is and I don't want DD to not be able to have other friends at school.

I questioned my daughter gently but in depth and she says this girl will just cry and scream at school if she tries to play with other kids or doesn't play her games by her rules. I explained about give and take and how it's not a true friendship if you being forced to do things all the time.

AIBU to bring this up with the school? Has anyone been in a similar situation and was the school able to do anything? It's obviously the summer holidays but I don't think an email is enough.

Also, if the school did agree to meet with me AIBU mentioning the inappropriate media she is accessing? Or is it just my opinion its inappropriate?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hopeandlove · 12/08/2022 17:51

And don’t invite bloody Elsie back and teach Beth her own boundaries. Elsie says she doesn’t want to be Beth’s friends. Beth goes ok and goes to other group. Model boundaries explain bullying and what to do etc explain why this girls to do but it doesn’t mean you put up with it

Hopeandlove · 12/08/2022 17:49

billy1966 · 12/08/2022 09:10

OP,

What you have written is dreadful.

Get onto the school and ask them to keep the children apart.
Not sitting near each other.
Separated in the school yard.

List out the behaviours, threats, the physically restraining and hurting.

I actually can't believe you allowed it to go on all afternoon.

I would have suggested that it was time to go home as she clearly wasn't happy at your home.

Nip tjis very firmly in the bud with the school or you could have huge problems ahead of you next year.

This. We talk about guest rules at that age. Everything in their bedroom is theirs and if they choose to play with something it comes in the lounge.
we play together and alternate - jump in and say no Elsie as the guest you have had first go and now it’s Beth’s turn. We play fair here.

any nasty comments nip in the bud - if she says she hates you Daughter or whatever ask her ‘Elsie can you repeat what you just said’ - if she says it again say ‘Elsie that sounds really mean can you explain why you are saying that?’ If she can’t - or isn’t remorseful take her home.

she hurt your DD protect her ‘Elsie have you just hurt Beth’s wrist ?’ Are you ok Beth - let’s get you an ice pack. Elsie why did you just grab Beth’s wrist?’ We don’t hurt people or animals - house rule. Etc

your house your rules

Lmf685 · 12/08/2022 17:40

❤️ Is this book available on Amazon ? I could do with this. My daughter is at an age where she is noticing different types of friends and expressing her feelings

Lmf685 · 12/08/2022 17:36

I had almost the exact issue with my daughter and two of her friends at school. I have time and time again encouraged her to play with other friends because reports I get back are if my daughter tries to play with anyone else she gets screamed at and they tell others to purposely not to play with my DD. And they run away from her and refuse to include her so she plays alone most days. It’s horrible and so upsetting to hear .

I have complained twice to the school and second time was in person but they mainly brushed it of. My DD got so frustrated and angry one day at this happening she pinched another child. The school then took the bullying as I feel it is , more seriously. That was dealt with and we had a chat and she’s learnt how to express her anger and frustration verbally now to her teachers and me. One of the said children in particular came round once and I could hear the falling out and bickering and extreme bossiness of this other child I had to end the play date.

Another good chat with DD and we are now branching out to other children to bond with. I am hoping the friendship with this one child fizzles out or atleast becomes less dependent as my DD is seeing a true side to this child now. They worship these friends and it’s so sad when it isn’t always reciprocated the same way. However I know my DD is not perfect and most likely can give as good as she gets so it’s not always one side.

Defo speak to the school . You do not want it effecting your child long term and getting bad habits from this other child.

cansu · 12/08/2022 16:51

It is utterly ridiculous to email the school that you have a safeguarding concern in the summer when the school is closed. If you have a safeguarding concern you phone social services.

forinborin · 12/08/2022 16:33

My 6 year old knows about huggy wuggy and I can guarantee that not from watching violent videos at home. I had similarly scary stories going round when I was that age (don't remember about what, but remember being terrified), and most of us did not even have TVs, never mind youtube. That's just what the kids do, experimenting with the fight or flight response in a safe environment, and learning to control it. Don't overreact.

nokidshere · 12/08/2022 16:31

I've emailed the school and mentioned there's a safeguarding issue too so will meet them as soon as they can

It's school holidays. If you feel there's a safeguarding issue you need to report it now, not wait till the new term starts. Report to your local children's safeguarding team.

cansu · 12/08/2022 16:30

Tbh I think the person you needed to speak to about the playdate is the other parent not the school!

If you want the school to perhaps keep an eye on the friendship in school then speak to school about that. You can ask them to be kept apart in the class in that they don't need to sit with each other but in terms of the playground your dd will choose herself.

MassiveSalad22 · 12/08/2022 16:16

And yes tell the school.

MassiveSalad22 · 12/08/2022 16:13

My son has just finished year 2, if a kid told him in front of me that he wasn’t allowed to play with anyone else I would say ‘he absolutely is allowed to play with other children and hopefully he will do if you keep hurting him’. Then call parent to come and collect! It would be good for your daughter to hear you stand up for her like that, and good for the other kid to hear that.

Motherofalittledragon · 12/08/2022 16:07

My dd had a friend like this at primary school, this girl wouldn't even allow her to play or talk to her siblings at school, my god it caused nothing but trouble. I was relieved when they finally went to separate secondary schools.

GreenManalishi · 12/08/2022 13:59

I'd be in touch with the school via email now and ask for a meeting when the new term starts. Focus on helping your daughter understand what a friend looks like, and does not look like, what behaviour is appropriate to tolerate from others, what boundaries are and how to set and enforce them. This might be the first difficult character she's encountered but it wont' be the last. Back her up by helping her choose some different friends and inviting them over to play etc, explaining that you wont' be inviting this child over again and why.

2bazookas · 12/08/2022 13:34

definitely raise it at school.

This is coercive control and bullying of a female. (your DD). Make it stop. You do NOT want DD to grow up accepting that as "normal relations from my chosen pal"

DD'd new friend is possibly mirroring her home circumstances, but school or SS are best equipped to deal with why she's like that. and help her.

thebeesknees123 · 12/08/2022 13:29

We stopped doing the I'm the Guest thing as I found the other child tended to exploit it and expect to get first dibs on everything and monopolise play so I spent half my life sorting out fights. I just had a rule that, in this house, we share and take turns.

As for how to handle it in the school, mention the inappropriate stuff, ask the girls to be separated and get them to keep an eye. The rest is down to you. Equip your daughter with the tools to recognise and leave bad friendships. I would say to my daughter that the girl breaking friends would be the best thing she could do, not the worst possible outcome

justmaybenot · 12/08/2022 13:15

Obeythedancecommander · 12/08/2022 13:07

Because I was always encouraged to share my things when I had friends over as a child, and when my daughter has been to playdates the host has always been encouraged to share their things with my daughter.

I wouldn't ask my daughter to share her own personal things with a child she didn't know at the park. But on a playdate I wouldn't like the guest not get to play with something they picked up or wanted because my child wanted that same specific thing too on every occasion. It's give and take; taking turns and learning to share and compromise. When the compromising and sharing wasn't happening both ways I stepped in.

OP it sounds like you did what you could, I wouldn't worry about your own handling of it.

Obeythedancecommander · 12/08/2022 13:07

catandcoffee · 12/08/2022 12:56

OP ,why on earth did you allow,and encourage, your daughter to give up her favourite swimming costume.

This is not being kind this is putting others needs before your own.

Build your daughters confidence and less of the 'being kind '.

Because I was always encouraged to share my things when I had friends over as a child, and when my daughter has been to playdates the host has always been encouraged to share their things with my daughter.

I wouldn't ask my daughter to share her own personal things with a child she didn't know at the park. But on a playdate I wouldn't like the guest not get to play with something they picked up or wanted because my child wanted that same specific thing too on every occasion. It's give and take; taking turns and learning to share and compromise. When the compromising and sharing wasn't happening both ways I stepped in.

OP posts:
Pinkishpurple · 12/08/2022 13:06

Op i had this exact situation 4/5years ago! In fact it was so bad i became sick with worry. School were no help as the child was compliant and quiet in class! And to be quite frank the school was terrible at addressing any problem. This child would literally hug squeeze my daughter until she cried and refuse to let go, she dominated all play decisions and would not let my child play with any other kids, she'd also love bomb my daughter, she was the most manipulative child i have ever met. In the end i started to read my daughter a book called 'my secret bully' although the situation in the book was slightly different my daughter recognised that people who were supposed to be your friend could also bully you and she realised that her friend was her bully. We also did alot of talking about what makes a good friend and what behaviours are not those of a friend. In the end to fully kill off the friendship i did have to be more blunt. I also did loads of playdates with other children. Eventually my daughter just decided one day to not be friends with her, this was helped along as they had a massive argument when my daughter finally found her voice. Six months later my daughter changed schools which further helped. I know from others that her behaviour has not changed as she got older and in fact has only intensified (just think if school had got involved they could have worked with her on healthy relationships). I fully expect that whoever she ends up with she will abuse.
Speak to the school. Set up playdates with other children. And help your daughter to work out what a good friend is. And if all else fails tell her you ban their friendship.

justmaybenot · 12/08/2022 13:03

Hungryharriet · 12/08/2022 13:00

@justmaybenot In my extensive experience of over twenty years of teaching in both state and private schools, I can tell you that you are wrong. Yes, some schools have more than one teacher on duty, depending on the size of the school, but they won't necessarily be acquainted with all the different friendship dynamics.

I've seen controlling and difficult friendships be handled with skill both in the classroom and at break times

How have you seen this if you're not in the school?

As I said, I've worked in literacy support in classrooms. And have experience of teachers on duty being asked to keep an eye out for particularly toxic friendships. My experience is not wrong. I only have this experience in two schools and maybe I can't extrapolate from that, but don't imagine they were completely unique.

Hungryharriet · 12/08/2022 13:00

justmaybenot · 12/08/2022 12:34

In my (extensive) experience as a parent, as school literacy support and on school boards, telling the teacher is certainly not 'fairly useless.' I've seen controlling and difficult friendships be handled with skill both in the classroom and at break times. Many schools have more than one teacher on duty that will keep an eye out if they know there's a particular issue.

@justmaybenot In my extensive experience of over twenty years of teaching in both state and private schools, I can tell you that you are wrong. Yes, some schools have more than one teacher on duty, depending on the size of the school, but they won't necessarily be acquainted with all the different friendship dynamics.

I've seen controlling and difficult friendships be handled with skill both in the classroom and at break times

How have you seen this if you're not in the school?

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/08/2022 12:57

Honestly, I think it's a bit strangeto come onto MN and complain about a 6 year because they are a bit mean and watch YouTube and then get offending by people commenting on the behaviours of your child and you. Ask the school to look out for bullying, stop inviting the girl over for playdates, and encourage other friendships.
They generally grow out of a lot of this in the next couple of years. And then new problems start!

catandcoffee · 12/08/2022 12:56

OP ,why on earth did you allow,and encourage, your daughter to give up her favourite swimming costume.

This is not being kind this is putting others needs before your own.

Build your daughters confidence and less of the 'being kind '.

Obeythedancecommander · 12/08/2022 12:54

@ChagSameachDoreen

She can and does stand up for herself, hence the fact she didn't just relent to her friend. She is not a pushover, please don't try to analyse a child's behaviour by a single post on mumsnet, you do not know her or me.

She is standing up for herself at school and at the playdate at home. She is being manipulated by someone who is threatening to remove all friendship if she doesn't agree and my daughter isn't perhaps experienced enough to know a good friendship from a bad one just yet.

OP posts:
eish · 12/08/2022 12:46

Sorry the above was for @DrShepsBall

eish · 12/08/2022 12:45

Roblox can be toxic for the following reasons (that it am aware of), they can all be redressed by parents if they put on restrictions (as long as the children don't turn them off again!)

The chat facility - the culture of chat in the game. There are lots of older people (teens / adults) on it who talk horribly to younger children, they goad them and argue /troll/bully. This gives children an example of bullying and aggression and poor online behaviours and they can mimic them/think this is acceptable.

The number of bullying reports we have had from parents amongst friends at our primary on this game. Children are often not mature enough (please note this isnt all children at all).

Both of the above can be fixed by disabling chat so it is fixable.

Games can be created within roblox, some of these actually have an 18 age rating so not appropriate for younger children. I'm not sure how you fix this one as my children aren't interested in roblox.

I am by no means anti gaming, there are normally ways to play safer but unfortunately some parents don't always know about them so whilst your child can be well protected they can still be exposed to it secondhand (eg in the playground etc). Annoyingly many games put the onus on the parents to find out and switch on restrictions rather than making as safe as possible and the turning those restrictions off for older children. Also children are super smart and know how to get around restrictions!

Obeythedancecommander · 12/08/2022 12:44

ChagSameachDoreen · 12/08/2022 12:36

I can't believe you stood back and let this girl treat your daughter like that in her own home. No wonder she can't stand up for herself.

I didn't stand back and let her treat her like anything, I intervened as was necessary. Initially all I said was it would be nice to let her friend wear the swimming costume she wanted and asked her to let her which she did. She didn't let DD chose games or what they did without a battle and was making threats. I haven't written absolutely everything that happened that day, just enough to give an idea, but I didn't stand by and let my DD get walked all over. I wanted opinions on approaching the school, not how I handled a playdate.

OP posts: