Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Women basically doing everything on family trip

158 replies

oha · 12/08/2022 08:38

We are on a family holiday at the moment. Several families with children, babies and toddlers.

The men are pretty much sat outside drinking beer, whilst the women do everything. Cooking, clearing up and tending to the children.

The dynamic has always been like this in my family and I'm so resentful.

Do anyone else's trips end up like that ?

OP posts:
TeenyQueen · 12/08/2022 14:42

I'm definitely the organiser, but that's because I supposedly have more time to get admin stuff done, although DH will pack his own stuff.

I insist on an all-inclusive hotel so no cooking, washing up or laundry for me please! I wouldn't do a self catering holiday with young children.

Fink · 12/08/2022 14:33

We have a mixture when all the family go away together. One dad is useless (although not at the level of telling the mum about a shoe falling off!) and also always brings his laptop and works most days. Does nothing except when specifically asked, but does at least do what's been asked. Another dad is brilliant, does everything (is a bit too house proud for my standards so we grate on one another a bit, but can't fault him for his involvement with kids and housework). Another one is in the middle, a bit lazy but does some of the work, not as much as his wife and isn't great with kids (doesn't watch them properly). Parents have a 'traditional' dynamic for their age: dad has his own jobs which he does reliably, but doesn't notice when anything different needs doing. And I'm divorced so no more useless husband to get under my feet.

MotherofPearl · 12/08/2022 14:16

Boybandfacedfannyfart · 12/08/2022 09:01

Fuck. Self-catering.

you only need to browse through the thousands of “air bnb /SC” threads here to note it’s NEVER “my husband’s been up since 5am scrubbing the apartment and we got charged extra cleaning”.

single mum here and I’ve tried to raise fully-functioning humans. My ex’s family think I’m lazy and a poor excuse for a woman - but then my ex-MIL raised two boys who couldn’t use a washing machine until aged 35.

book the fucking hotel, order a cocktail and open your kindle.

I love you.

I love hotels for exactly this reason.

girlmom21 · 12/08/2022 14:08

Pretty difficult to change the dynamic that easily if you've grown up that way and it's always been that way.

Does your husband pull his weight at home?

VickerishAllsort · 12/08/2022 14:07

None of this nonsense on family group holidays - everyone takes full adult responsibility for the kids, housework, shopping etc etc.
BUT DH and I used to go on group holidays with 3 other couples where all the men sat around drinking and chatting while the women indulged in competitive catering in the kitchen.
I didn't say anything (didn't want to disrupt the dynamic if everyone else was happy with it.
I was taking things easy with the men though - I figured if that's the way they wanted to play it I'd just please myself and not get involved.

Shinyandnew1 · 12/08/2022 14:06

oha · 12/08/2022 13:56

It's just like this, same at Christmas, Easter etc. anytime family gets together- the women are slaving around after the kids and serving everyone and the men sit on their arses.

Pretty difficult to change the dynamic that easily if you've grown up that way and it's always been that way.

Same in DH family. There was once a relative who didn't do that much and they called her a lazy cow.

But what about when it’s just you/DH/kids?

fantasmasgoria1 · 12/08/2022 14:01

I remember being around 13 and we went on holiday to somewhere different to the usual so my dad booked a self catering apartment. At the end of the two weeks my dad said I'll just nip next door and book for next year. My mum said no you will not. I'm not coming on holiday again to have to do what I do at home. It's no holiday for me. So next year was a lovely hotel. I think my mum enjoyed her dinners when we stayed in the hotel!

oha · 12/08/2022 13:56

It's just like this, same at Christmas, Easter etc. anytime family gets together- the women are slaving around after the kids and serving everyone and the men sit on their arses.

Pretty difficult to change the dynamic that easily if you've grown up that way and it's always been that way.

Same in DH family. There was once a relative who didn't do that much and they called her a lazy cow.

OP posts:
GlitteryGreen · 12/08/2022 13:56

Yeah I agree this is a common dynamic....I think a lot women have to ignore things for such a long time - longer than is comfortable for them - before a lot of men will take it upon themselves to deal with it, especially when it comes to children.

Had this with my DP recently after coming home from a holiday with SCs - it was all "Can we put their dirty clothes in the washing tomorrow so they can take it home clean?" I did a load but not the full lot...did the rest of it get done?? Of course not.

TheSoapyFrog · 12/08/2022 13:55

The OH is disappointed that I've not done any cooking so far. I saved up enough money to make sure I didn't have to and we could eat out and buy convenience and picnic foods. Now he's trying to be frugal and eat in the caravan and I'm having none of it. If he wants a full English in the morning, he cooks it.

easylisten · 12/08/2022 13:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Shinyandnew1 · 12/08/2022 13:54

Do anyone else's trips end up like that?

No! And there wouldn’t be a repeat trip of it did. If you just went away with your own household, what would happen?

Hlglu56 · 12/08/2022 13:52

We go camping with my husband’s family and the men are useless. They will go off and do their own thing like fishing or surfing whilst the women look after the dogs and children. Apart from taking the children to the pool for a bit they do hardly anything whilst the women cook, clean get everything for the beach etc. I really don’t know why my MIL and SIL bother going, it’s harder work than being at home.

Fortunately my husband is much better and shares the chores. He rarely leaves me alone with the children.

Eeksteek · 12/08/2022 13:46

We all muck in. When my late -DH came with us, and just sat around treating it like an all inclusive with us all waiting on him (including me fielding DD as a toddler) I was SO embarrassed, I flatly refused to take him again. I’ve never been sure whether he really was being that much of a dick about it, or if he just couldn’t get his head around the idea of communal labour (he had grown up with all inclusive, and always refused to let anyone visiting us help at all. But he expected not to do anything when we visited other people, which I thought was shit. I always offer to lend a hand, even when I had a baby on my hip)

Goldbar · 12/08/2022 13:41

CatsAreCrackers · 12/08/2022 13:32

I have to disagree a bit with this. "Society" is made up of 50% women so I would say that if 50% of society say enough is enough, don't put up with crap from the very first date, then the other 50% of "society" would soon fall into line.

I see so often on here women saying "Oh, he's always been like this...". So why did they marry him? And then go onto have children with him? And if he was good until the first child was born, why did they go on to have more?! Or why didn't they put their foot down the first time thy refused to get up for a night feed or change a nappy?

And I'm not talking about men that turn out to be mentally or physically abusive once the woman has children, that's a different thread. I'm talking about your average lazy-assed bloke who sits on the sofa because his wife never says "Oi, get your bum off the sofa and be a fully functioning adult!"

I flatly refuse to accept the excuse that sometimes it's quicker to do it yourself. It's like allowing children to get their own way when they are tiny because it's easier than dealing with the tantrums. You are making a rod for your own back.

It makes me sad / mad that women treat themselves as second class citizens. If we said "I'm worth better than this" and walked away much earlier then society WOULD improve as a whole.

The work in a relationship often doesn't really ramp up until you have children. It can be hard to spot the duffers beforehand, especially as expectations on women often ramp up on maternity leave and expectations on men are lowered. How often have you seen women on maternity leave being told that, since they're at home, they should do the majority of the childcare and night wakings, cook dinner and do most of the housework? Despite men managing to cook, clean and fend for themselves pre-DC. Once these patterns are established, they often persist even when women are back at work. I agree with you on the having more children though... the ultimate goal should be to ditch the duffer not procreate again with them!

I take issue with your "making a rod for your own back" comment. Men are not small children and it is not women's job to train them.

whatwouldAnnaDelveydo · 12/08/2022 13:41

All the women saying you wouldn't tolerate it are being extremely native.

Lots of men, when asked to do something, will "forget", "do it wrongly", "make a mess". It's called weaponised incompetence. I was married to one of these. It took me many years to understand that with some people there is no talking, asking or anything.

They don't want to do. It's as simple as that.

You either put up with it or you get as far as possible.

CatsAreCrackers · 12/08/2022 13:32

Goldbar · 12/08/2022 12:37

It depresses me to hear people saying that women "shouldn't put up with it", need to "speak up" and are equally to blame or "doormats" for allowing it.

With the sort of men who behave like this and genuinely can't see or don't care about the fact that they're not sharing the load equally, pointing this out to them is unlikely to have an effect. Or if it does, they'll tend to change for a little while and then revert to type. Yes, you can speak up every time, but you may not get the result you want and will probably have to deal with an aggrieved, aggressive partner who feels put apon and accuses you of "nagging".

And it's an extra thing to add to the chore list, isn't it? Get kids up, make breakfast for kids, do dishwasher, verbally batter OH into submission until he agrees to sort lunch or take the kids out to play. At some point, it does become easier just to do it yourself if you're in this situation.

The issue isn't so much with women's expectations of men, it's with society's expectations of men (and consequently men's expectations of themselves).

I have to disagree a bit with this. "Society" is made up of 50% women so I would say that if 50% of society say enough is enough, don't put up with crap from the very first date, then the other 50% of "society" would soon fall into line.

I see so often on here women saying "Oh, he's always been like this...". So why did they marry him? And then go onto have children with him? And if he was good until the first child was born, why did they go on to have more?! Or why didn't they put their foot down the first time thy refused to get up for a night feed or change a nappy?

And I'm not talking about men that turn out to be mentally or physically abusive once the woman has children, that's a different thread. I'm talking about your average lazy-assed bloke who sits on the sofa because his wife never says "Oi, get your bum off the sofa and be a fully functioning adult!"

I flatly refuse to accept the excuse that sometimes it's quicker to do it yourself. It's like allowing children to get their own way when they are tiny because it's easier than dealing with the tantrums. You are making a rod for your own back.

It makes me sad / mad that women treat themselves as second class citizens. If we said "I'm worth better than this" and walked away much earlier then society WOULD improve as a whole.

girlmom21 · 12/08/2022 13:18

Getoff · 12/08/2022 12:54

I have been a man on a family trip a lot like this. The women collectively delegated cooking a meal to the men. I was slightly pissed off, because it should not have been my job, under my own family arrangements. I was already being vastly short-changed in terms of the benefits and costs of being in that relationship, and I did not appreciate one of the tiny compensations for the shitness of being in that marriage being taken away from me. I couldn't say anything without looking like an arse, because of assumptions and prejudices like those displayed by most posters in this thread .

I guess group preferences are always going to be a problem on group holidays, the only solution is to never go on holiday with a group.

Let me guess, you earned loads of money so shouldn't have to cook or clean or take care of the kids?

You sound like an entitled tit. I hope you're out of your miserable relationship and manage to wipe your kids snotty noses all by yourself.

G5000 · 12/08/2022 13:10

You might say 'make your dh do it then' but this will genuinely result in the kids being dehydrated, hungry and burnt

Can you imagine a mother 'forgetting' to feed and water her children? But men poor darlings, can't be expected to..

watchoutApple · 12/08/2022 13:10

Well my MIL would think that’s ‘as it should be’

I got told recently that I’m ‘weak’ and how appalled she is that her son has to help with school drop-off and pick up, meetings and medical appts. Let alone day to day stuff!
she is positively proud that her she has always done nothing and told me that I’m her family they are all ‘strong women’ and none of them understand me …..
She also lost her temper when she wasn’t available to her to give her a lift when she demands and she told me her heart is broken that he could put us first and congratulations to me as I’ve now taken him and got my family unit 🤦‍♀️

She signed off with letting me know how she knows plenty of families with SEN kids whose dads don’t have to do anything and that I’m basically using it as an excuse !!!

If she saw these families on holiday that you describe OP she would be ecstatic 😂

Whataplanker · 12/08/2022 13:09

We always do AI and DH has always stepped up more with child entertainment. He is more willing to be in the pool, snorkeling, playing board games etc than me.

I do all the researching, planning, booking, insurance, airport parking arrangements prior to going though.

Goldbar · 12/08/2022 13:05

Getoff · 12/08/2022 12:54

I have been a man on a family trip a lot like this. The women collectively delegated cooking a meal to the men. I was slightly pissed off, because it should not have been my job, under my own family arrangements. I was already being vastly short-changed in terms of the benefits and costs of being in that relationship, and I did not appreciate one of the tiny compensations for the shitness of being in that marriage being taken away from me. I couldn't say anything without looking like an arse, because of assumptions and prejudices like those displayed by most posters in this thread .

I guess group preferences are always going to be a problem on group holidays, the only solution is to never go on holiday with a group.

Why did the women feel the need to 'delegate' cooking a meal to the men at all?

Surely in a group of adults, all adults should realise that they need to contribute equally to the catering arrangements or agree some other fair split of responsibility. Why were the women "default" when it came to feeding people?

user1477391263 · 12/08/2022 13:03

It depresses me to hear people saying that women "shouldn't put up with it", need to "speak up" and are equally to blame or "doormats" for allowing it.
With the sort of men who behave like this and genuinely can't see or don't care about the fact that they're not sharing the load equally, pointing this out to them is unlikely to have an effect. Or if it does, they'll tend to change for a little while and then revert to type. Yes, you can speak up every time, but you may not get the result you want and will probably have to deal with an aggrieved, aggressive partner who feels put apon and accuses you of "nagging".
And it's an extra thing to add to the chore list, isn't it? Get kids up, make breakfast for kids, do dishwasher, verbally batter OH into submission until he agrees to sort lunch or take the kids out to play. At some point, it does become easier just to do it yourself if you're in this situation.
The issue isn't so much with women's expectations of men, it's with society's expectations of men (and consequently men's expectations of themselves).

So much this. No, women are not "equally to blame." Society and men conspire to make us feel like nags, bores and fun-sponges when we try to insist that the guys step up and do their share.

I don't mean women shouldn't be speaking out; I mean, just please have a bit of compassion and understanding for the difficulties that women face when they try to do this.

Getoff · 12/08/2022 12:54

I have been a man on a family trip a lot like this. The women collectively delegated cooking a meal to the men. I was slightly pissed off, because it should not have been my job, under my own family arrangements. I was already being vastly short-changed in terms of the benefits and costs of being in that relationship, and I did not appreciate one of the tiny compensations for the shitness of being in that marriage being taken away from me. I couldn't say anything without looking like an arse, because of assumptions and prejudices like those displayed by most posters in this thread .

I guess group preferences are always going to be a problem on group holidays, the only solution is to never go on holiday with a group.

Yeezytiger · 12/08/2022 12:43

Dont do it, pour yourself a glass of wine and relax