Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Partner threw a step stool

87 replies

crackedearth · 12/08/2022 06:33

Just looking for some responses here as I have experienced domestic violence before so I am particularly attuned to red flags and wondering if I'm prone to overreacting.

My parter had both kids all days, which he finds difficult (it is).

By the end of the day I was doing bath time and he was tidying downstairs. He eventually came up to help and by that time I was a little cross about a few things, which I explained to him and then said I was taking a 10 min time out to calm down. He asked me not to and I said I needed to and walked off and shut the door. Seconds later the kick stool hit the bedroom door that I'd shut. I opened the door and asked him if he'd really just thrown the stool at me and he looked at me like I was being ridiculous and said absolutely not. He was just throwing it out of our tiny bathroom as it was in the way.

I believe that he didn't throw it at me but I was shocked so stayed in bedroom while he continued bedtime and he seemed to go into ultra great capable Dad mode, whistling cheerfully in the face of screaming children.

I came out to put one kid to bed and he immediately repeated that he didn't throw it at me. We agreed to speak later.

Queue 2 hours later due to difficult bedtime, we finally chatted. He said he threw the stool in anger but not at me. I told him that wasn't acceptable because it is a first step on the way to a more violent act. He got really angry at this point, saying it was one mistake and why should he be painted as an abuser and why can't I support him etc. Essentially turning himself into a victim because I haven't supported him. He has form for this kind of response

He also pointed out that I have thrown stuff in rage and he has always responded with kindness - to me, this isn't the same thing.

So...

YABU - everyone has moments and you are seeing this through the lens of past trauma

YANBU - he is male and the most physically strong in the household and more likely to escalate

OP posts:
crackedearth · 12/08/2022 08:40

As one pp stated, they would have answered differently if I hadn't mentioned I'd in the past thrown something. That strikes me as wrong...but then again, that's why I'm here to get advice because I suspect I'm confused and wrong!

OP posts:
crackedearth · 12/08/2022 08:37

PrinnyPree · 12/08/2022 08:36

"Just giving this some further thought, I don't want to separate the incidents to justify my behaviour but because I don't want my partner to use it as an excuse to justify his."

But it does in a way justify his because you've set a precedent in the relationship for throwing things when you're frustrated.

If its not counted as abusive when you do it you can't count it as abusive when he does it. Either that or you admit you were the abuser before the incident today, past trauma does not give you a free pass in being abusive in your present relationship.

I couldn't agree more. Throwing something is always abusive and having been someone to throw something makes me an abuser. But I am accountable for my actions and he is accountable for his.

OP posts:
PrinnyPree · 12/08/2022 08:36

"Just giving this some further thought, I don't want to separate the incidents to justify my behaviour but because I don't want my partner to use it as an excuse to justify his."

But it does in a way justify his because you've set a precedent in the relationship for throwing things when you're frustrated.

If its not counted as abusive when you do it you can't count it as abusive when he does it. Either that or you admit you were the abuser before the incident today, past trauma does not give you a free pass in being abusive in your present relationship.

crackedearth · 12/08/2022 08:26

Just giving this some further thought, I don't want to separate the incidents to justify my behaviour but because I don't want my partner to use it as an excuse to justify his.

I.e. when I have thrown something in the past, such as a book to the floor, I am fully accountable for that action. Nothing he did prior to that moment is a cause. When my partner threw the stool, he should be fully accountable for his action too, and for consequences. Anything I have done, past or present, shouldn't be a reason to justify the action or the DARVO that followed.

Hope that makes sense.

Again, all comments useful.

OP posts:
Quartz2208 · 12/08/2022 08:16

Your past doesnt mean you can hold others to higher standards than yourself though OP. You have no idea what he feels when you throw things and excusing it as not being abusive simply because he is bigger and stronger than you.

But you also seem to have double standards about him being with the children - how much he cant cope and needs your help yet you get angry because 5 minutes into you having 2 you cant cope.

YOu get angry and when he wants to leave - say you need 10 minutes (to make sure you dont throw something) and again he asks and your view takes precedent.

Then he loses it - and throws something and you think it isnt the same because he is bigger than you.

To your children it is the same both parents are now throwing things. Both are bigger than them

You need some help

LittleBearPad · 12/08/2022 08:14

jsvacation · 12/08/2022 08:12

Have you gotten help over your past abuse OP?

I’d suggest not!

TabithaTittlemouse · 12/08/2022 08:13

All of this happened in front of your children?

jsvacation · 12/08/2022 08:12

Have you gotten help over your past abuse OP?

DashboardConfessional · 12/08/2022 08:11

Whiskeypowers · 12/08/2022 07:58

the example you give is not gaslighting

Shall I say it's "manipulation" instead? Any time in a relationship where one justifies bad behaviour because they are a man or woman (or because they are the one who works outside the home, earns most of the money, have the kids all day) is trying to make the other person doubt themselves over whether it's actually wrong.

AnImaginaryCat · 12/08/2022 08:08

You said:
"And no I don't think it is acceptable for me to throw things. However, my partner throwing something triggered a huge fear response in me due to my past"

Then went on to explain (excuse) why you can throw things. Yet why doesn't your violent behaviour make you fear you are that person in your past? Your children asorbe your violent behaviour. If you take away the justification that they were male and you aren't. To your children that doesn't matter - you are bigger and stronger than them.

From what you've written this is the first time he's ever thrown something in anger. Yet you have done it more than once.

LittleBearPad · 12/08/2022 08:00

crackedearth · 12/08/2022 07:58

The best explanation I have as to the difference is that his action left me formulating a plan as to how I'm going to escape with the kids in the face of an escalation. Or even wondering if that was enough for me to leave.

When I've thrown something, this wouldn't even cross his mind.

As explained, past trauma and knowledge of systemic male domestic violence has left me on high alert. Hence the need for perspective.

I think you’re being very selective in how you think about this.

Why can’t you bath your children alone and why did he have ti do all of bedtime having had the kids all day?

Brefugee · 12/08/2022 07:59

I think you both need to re-evaluate how you do things. Perhaps bath-time should be one child at a time with the other partner doing some tidying with the other (it is never too early to learn)

It is worrying that you throw things but immediately get the hump when he does. Nobody should throw things and i would, in his shoes, expect an apology from you in that respect. No throwing should apply to everyone in the house.

If he can't handle the one day of childcare, you both need to look at your arrangement and work out how you can have a set-up that works for both of you. It's not easy to look after 2 young children, and there are times you need to step away -but you both need to have clear roles and expectations. There are times when "can you come and help" just means you're a bit overwhelmed, and other times when it means "COME NOW, ACCIDENT!" and you probably need to arrange a sliding scale of help requests? so they know.

And if someone does turn up to help, immediately launching into a whinge is not helpful.

Agree with pp that couples therapy might be the best way to go here.

crackedearth · 12/08/2022 07:59

user1471462428 · 12/08/2022 07:53

I think your house sounds chaotic and miserable. Both of you sound like you’re handing the kids over rather than tackling the behaviour. Have you both considered parenting classes? You’re kids don’t deserve this environment?
Ive had parenting classes (found them online) and it has helped dealing with my kids behaviour and the everyone is calmer and happier.

Yes there is an element of constantly handing the kids over and it feels relentless. We do try to tackle the behaviour too though. I've not heard of parenting classes so I'll look into them. Thanks.

OP posts:
beastlyslumber · 12/08/2022 07:59
  1. Throwing things absolutely is abusive. It's violent and completely unacceptable.
  2. This applies to both of you.
  3. You urgently need help to unpick all of this. Find some counselling or support asap.
Whiskeypowers · 12/08/2022 07:58

DashboardConfessional · 12/08/2022 07:26

If a man was having a go at you for throwing something and said he wanted to treat it as separate from his own temper tantrums because it's "different" when he does it, that would be gaslighting.

the example you give is not gaslighting

crackedearth · 12/08/2022 07:58

miowpow · 12/08/2022 07:52

@crackedearth

'He also pointed out that I have thrown stuff in rage and he has always responded with kindness - to me, this isn't the same thing.'
*

Why?

The best explanation I have as to the difference is that his action left me formulating a plan as to how I'm going to escape with the kids in the face of an escalation. Or even wondering if that was enough for me to leave.

When I've thrown something, this wouldn't even cross his mind.

As explained, past trauma and knowledge of systemic male domestic violence has left me on high alert. Hence the need for perspective.

OP posts:
SandieCollins · 12/08/2022 07:57

crackedearth · 12/08/2022 07:51

I would absolutely love this but between managing two little kids and the cost of living it's not a realistic option right now. Something for the bear future I hope.

If you live in the UK the waiting lists are huge but you can get it free in the NHS and there are lots of charities which offer therapy. Although the type I think will be helpful based on this brief thread is DBT and that’s pretty hard to find.

AnImaginaryCat · 12/08/2022 07:56

You have all the excuses don't you?

Consider your behaviour towards him, without attaching a reason for it. If there's any DARVO occurring it reads like likes coming frim you.

user1471462428 · 12/08/2022 07:53

I think your house sounds chaotic and miserable. Both of you sound like you’re handing the kids over rather than tackling the behaviour. Have you both considered parenting classes? You’re kids don’t deserve this environment?
Ive had parenting classes (found them online) and it has helped dealing with my kids behaviour and the everyone is calmer and happier.

miowpow · 12/08/2022 07:52

@crackedearth

'He also pointed out that I have thrown stuff in rage and he has always responded with kindness - to me, this isn't the same thing.'
*

Why?

crackedearth · 12/08/2022 07:52

SapphosRock · 12/08/2022 07:50

Oh so it is a reverse?

Your DH regularly throws things and you respond with kindness. Yesterday you'd had the kids all day. The kids were being annoying. He took 10 minutes out and you threw a stool at a closed door.

Now he's calling you an abuser?

Just trying to get the story straight.

You both sound like you could do with some anger management therapy.

Not a reverse. Even trying to understand this telling makes me confused! All is as I said.

OP posts:
crackedearth · 12/08/2022 07:51

SandieCollins · 12/08/2022 07:40

I know this is often trotted out on here but this comment is coming from an informed and well intentioned place. Have you ever had therapy or mental health support? It sounds like you might find it helpful to have some support around trauma and emotional regulation. The only drawback of this is that a therapist will only hear your version of events so you would need to be very honest and willing to be self reflective.

I would absolutely love this but between managing two little kids and the cost of living it's not a realistic option right now. Something for the bear future I hope.

OP posts:
Nautica · 12/08/2022 07:51

That wouldn’t be gas lighting p, gaslighting would be trying to convince the other person it didn’t happen, or that they were being over sensitive to it, and being melodramatic, making it a them issue

Isn't that what PP just said? Gaslighting is essentially lying, manipulating, false narratives. Like saying x is different after doing the same so they're the sole aggressor.

By the way, good on you @crackedearth for taking people's comments on board.

SapphosRock · 12/08/2022 07:50

Oh so it is a reverse?

Your DH regularly throws things and you respond with kindness. Yesterday you'd had the kids all day. The kids were being annoying. He took 10 minutes out and you threw a stool at a closed door.

Now he's calling you an abuser?

Just trying to get the story straight.

You both sound like you could do with some anger management therapy.

Thepossibility · 12/08/2022 07:42

Bwix · 12/08/2022 06:51

Is this a reverse? You regularly throw things in anger but your DH does it once and it's domestic violence on the basis he's male? Your DH has dealt with kids all day (and in this weather) and you need to check out for 10 mins after dealing with them for a short time, then you're criticising him for cheerfully putting them to bed? OP this doesn't pass my you in a great light tbh.

Agree. If you had never thrown anything in frustration yourself I would think differently.