Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked to discover

364 replies

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 00:02

Apparently, it is NOT illegal for a stranger to take photographs or video clips of people, including their children in a public place. 😵

I, like many of my friends are astonished if this is true.

I wonder how many people are aware of this?

OP posts:
RuthBrenner · 12/08/2022 08:50

Have you genuinely never heard of or seen street photograhphy? Ever heard of photographers like Henri Bresson or Vivian Maier?

Topseyt123 · 12/08/2022 08:49

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 00:09

No one in my circle of friends were aware of this.
Surely you must ask permission of the parent before snapping pictures or video clips of their children especially?
Paparazzi have no interest in taking random pictures of strangers or their children though, and surely they have to get permission first, either from a parent if they wish to capture images of a child, or an adult themselves if they wish to capture images of an adult?

Come on! Did you really think that the paparazzi who chase the royals and other celebrities around snapping photos for newspapers would get consent first!!??

Taking photographs in public which include members of the public and children is not illegal. Never has been and nor should it be.

If you mean a complete stranger approaching and taking taking specific pictures of your child then that is creepy. It might not be illegal in itself, but I would consider reporting it to the police due to worries over paedophile activity.

In general though, you have no expectation of privacy if you are out in a public area. If you went to a touristy area in London then you could expect to end up in the photos taken by other tourists. They don't have to get the consent of everyone around them, whether you are in them or not is purely incidental.

If you want total privacy then stay at home at all times. On no account ever go out anywhere.

AppleKatie · 12/08/2022 08:47

There is such a huge difference between say legitimate street photography for an art exhibition and a dirty old man in a raincoat taking a picture of a kid in the park.

The law is such a blunt instrument though- ban one and you would ban the other.

So instead we have culture. It is culturally unacceptable for lone adults to walk into parks and take inappropriate pictures of children, someone doing it would get called out by the community (inc online).

this is enough to prevent it becoming common practice. Someone persisting is likely to be breaking other existing laws about harassment or intimidation.

therefore, there is no need for a change in the law to stop legitimate photography.

Also, all that is before you get into how impossible it would be to police a ban on photography in all public spaces ever.

Newmumatlast · 12/08/2022 08:45

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 00:09

No one in my circle of friends were aware of this.
Surely you must ask permission of the parent before snapping pictures or video clips of their children especially?
Paparazzi have no interest in taking random pictures of strangers or their children though, and surely they have to get permission first, either from a parent if they wish to capture images of a child, or an adult themselves if they wish to capture images of an adult?

No. Anyone can take photos of your kids when you're out. It only becomes potentially unlawful or illegal if the behaviour amounts to harassment or if the person takes an indecent image of your child but you'd have to be able to have good reason to think they have for the police to likely ask to check their camera based on reasonable suspicion I.e. your child changing on the beach and you see someone purposefully taking pictures of them naked (I wish this wasn't something parents did but amazingly I've seen them do this in public putting their kids at risk).

Whitehorsegirl · 12/08/2022 08:43

I would say it is common knowledge...

Neverendingdust · 12/08/2022 08:43

Bless you OP. I wish I could follow your MN account if you’ve been so shocked by that ‘revelation’, I bet it’ll have some corkers soon once you making more discoveries. 😂

SoupDragon · 12/08/2022 08:42

Popcorncovered · 12/08/2022 08:39

I agree, it is a breach of privacy

What privacy do you think you have in a public space?

lljkk · 12/08/2022 08:40

Should not be illegal.

How do you think footage of crimes happening or police brutality get collected if it's illegal to take pictures of strangers. Can't know when filming starts how the events will evolve & if there will could be some presupposed legal justification. How does one get pictures of celebs, or public events. Did everyone at Glastonbury sign a waiver. I don't know what people are thinking with these weird ideas.

ProfessorSlocombe · 12/08/2022 08:40

because if, in a park, a person were taking photos of children playing on play equipment, and a parent challenged them and made a fuss, I think that a community police officer or park warden, would, indeed ask them to stop doing it.

And if they say no ? Outwith any by laws and absent any behaviour that might be considered harassment or threatening a request to desist a legal activity has no force.

Popcorncovered · 12/08/2022 08:39

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 00:24

So a random stranger, let's say an adult on their own, can walk into a playground and take pictures or videos specifically of my child, which then belong to the random stranger, and then post them on their own instagram page? 🤨
Without my permission?
With no consent from anyone?
Can I force them to delete the images if I catch them snapping away?
Does my child or myself have any rights to images taken by a complete stranger?
Surely it is a flagrant breach of our privacy?

I agree, it is a breach of privacy

Quia · 12/08/2022 08:39

Oiduntbelieveit · 12/08/2022 08:35

Under the Protection from Harassment Act, you can be protected in law, if someone taking your picture is causing you distress or intimidation.

No, that is not the criterion for establishing harassment under that Act. It's an objective test.

gogohmm · 12/08/2022 08:38

There's a huge difference between someone taking a photo of your child and someone taking a picture of their child and your is slightly blurred in the background

srey · 12/08/2022 08:37

gogohmm · 12/08/2022 08:37

Background images are completely legal. If you want to take a close up it's polite to ask, you only need permission if it's for public/commercial use. If it's from behind no permission is needed even for commercial gain

This is wrong.

Even for commercial use you do not need permission.

gogohmm · 12/08/2022 08:37

Background images are completely legal. If you want to take a close up it's polite to ask, you only need permission if it's for public/commercial use. If it's from behind no permission is needed even for commercial gain

45hopperbunny · 12/08/2022 08:37

Tbh I’d never even considered whether this was legal or not until it happened to me and I posted on here about it.

A couple months ago I had got on the bus with DD (she would have been 11 months), placed the pushchair in the pushchair area and sat down in the seats right next to it. As soon as I sat down the woman next to me picked up her phone and seemed like she was taking a picture of DD. I looked at her phone as she could have been taking a selfie or looking at the front camera and using it as a mirror. She wasn’t. My child was on her screen and she was taking a picture of her.

Without hesitation I said, ‘er why you taking a picture of my child, you need to delete that.’ She goes, ‘she’s just so cute I had to take a picture.’ I was so shocked and said ‘you can’t just take pictures of people’s kids without asking. Delete it.’ She then said ‘sorry you’re right’ and deleted it. I asked to delete it from her deleted folder but she didn’t know how to do that and asked if I’d help her. Deleted the pic of her phone and the whole time I just sat next to her in silence. Her dad was standing next to the pushchair and couldn’t believe it.

When I posted on MN there was a mix of ‘this situation isn’t funny at all and very serious, I would have went crazy/her phone would have went out the window’ and then there was the ‘well it’s not illegal to take pictures of your child/you were rude to tell her to delete it’ and all those sort of comments.

Whether it’s illegal or not. Anytime I see someone take a picture of my child I’ll confront them everytime. One time I was in Cafe Nero and I realised a boy about 17 was taking a video of DD and I who would have been around 4 months old. Straight away I said ‘what do you think you’re doing,’ all of a sudden it was ‘oh sorry sorry’ and he ended up dropping his phone because he was so flustered as I don’t think he expected me to realise/say something.

CCTV is also a different matter because it’s not about your child being captured on something alongside many other people. It’s the fact that an individual is going out of their way to take a picture of YOUR child for 1) absolutely no reason and 2) they don’t have consent. Why would you want a picture of a random baby/child on your phone? Fuck that

StreetwiseHercules · 12/08/2022 08:36

Of course it’s not illegal. How do you think CCTV exists?

People don’t have the right to privacy in public. How could they?

Oiduntbelieveit · 12/08/2022 08:35

Under the Protection from Harassment Act, you can be protected in law, if someone taking your picture is causing you distress or intimidation.

hapinthewood · 12/08/2022 08:34

What are views on inside a sports stadium? Someone who works there takes a photo of a teenager misbehaving, not surreptitiously.

CJsGoldfish · 12/08/2022 08:33

Deliberately captures video clips of your child? You'd be comfortable with this?
I assume anyone doing that isn't going to be brazen doing so I doubt I'd even know. Same with pics so not going to spend my time worrying about it 🤷‍♀️

CounsellorTroi · 12/08/2022 08:31

A group of birdwatchers was questioned by police when they were seen camped outside a school with cameras and lenses.

www.walesonline.co.uk/news/wales-news/birdwatchers-questioned-police-after-trying-15730450

orbitalcrisis · 12/08/2022 08:25

Whatever they are photographing or filming you do in public was openly viewed by others, where was your expectation of privacy? Yes, somebody might take a photo of your child as they're a pervert, but you cannot police people's thoughts, if they don't take a photo they are still having those thoughts. Most paedophiles do not act on their feelings and your children are far more likely to be abused by somebody you know.

Teach your children not to talk to strangers, not to keep secrets and which body parts others should not touch and chill out, there are NOT perverts around every corner.

BooksAndHooks · 12/08/2022 08:14

In public area you don’t have a right to privacy. Anyone can be watching or looking at anyone in public. You can photograph anything or anyone in a non restricted public area.

Quia · 12/08/2022 08:13

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 00:35

If they refused, at this point they would know I was extremely unhappy about them having the image, but what could I do?
Call 101?
Rip the camera from their hands and smash it?
I dont know. What could I do if they refused?

If you called 101, you would simply give some call handler a bit of a laugh. If you took the camera and smashed it, you would get yourself arrested and a bill for replacing the camera. Incidentally, you would also not succeed in destroying the photo that way as the memory card would almost certainly survive.

Figgygal · 12/08/2022 08:12

Of course it isnt illegal but poor etiquette absolutely

TeenDivided · 12/08/2022 08:08

MassiveSalad22 · 12/08/2022 07:53

What about school photos? I have paid money for photos of ‘random kids’ in my kids’ class photo and my son’s photo is in many random people’s houses as they have done the same. Are schools public or private? Also fairly certain we’re in many theme park photos and baby class photos and so on. And then of course all the public places like fairs, playgrounds etc.

Schools ask for photo permission from parents when they join the school.
My DC are adopted, so we said no to social media / online / papers but said yes to class photos. Baby classes should do likewise.

Interestingly we had a 'near miss' on that. Another parent came up to me saying she thought she knew by DCs birth grandparents, as they lived next door to her mum, had talked about them and she recognised the pairing of the names. Sensibly didn't say anything. If mine had been in the same class and they had given a class photo to her mum, who had had it displayed in her home when neighbours visited...

Theme parks etc are less of an issue as people come from all over so a child might be recognised but couldn't be traced.