Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked to discover

364 replies

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 00:02

Apparently, it is NOT illegal for a stranger to take photographs or video clips of people, including their children in a public place. 😵

I, like many of my friends are astonished if this is true.

I wonder how many people are aware of this?

OP posts:
Bernardo1 · 13/08/2022 18:24

No, entirely normal. The minute you step out your door, you're public, with no image rights. Of course, if somebody touched or adjusted the childs clothing, that would come under other legislation.

Zwellers · 13/08/2022 18:17

So op are you seriously saying you have never in your life taken a photo in public that has random other people of all ages in?.

DaughterofDawn · 13/08/2022 18:10

it’s not illegal in the US or Canada either. Teenagers get annoyed on the bus because I cover my daughters face when they’re snapping selfies but I don’t really care. Even if she’s just accidentally behind your seat I don’t want her face all over a strangers instagram.

SmudgeButt · 13/08/2022 18:10

What about all those Ring doorbell cameras? Taking pictures of innocent posties without their permission??

SortOfAdmireQuagmire · 13/08/2022 18:07

Knackeredbutnot · 13/08/2022 10:03

I was pleased that he intervened to be honest. I understand that we were in a public place, but I think close up pictures of only your child being taken by a complete stranger is off. I’m sure I’m not the only person who would feel uncomfortable about that - whatever the reason. I think, as a courtesy, asking the parent and explaining the images use should be a minimum when photographing a minor.

If this had happened (it didn’t) the policeman should expect to be disciplined for breaking the law and abusing his authority.

AnnieSnap · 13/08/2022 17:58

Of course it’s not illegal. If people are in a public place where anyone around can see each other and CCTV is everywhere, wouldn’t you be acting accordingly and not displaying behaviour you wouldn’t want a stranger to see. One of my hobbies is photography. I enjoy various genres, including street photography. If I want to photograph someone who will notice, I ask if they are happy for me to do so. The only people who have ever declined were in the Middle East. Elsewhere everyone I have asked have been pleased. A couple of times when they were doing something special, I have taken their email address and emailed some shots to them (e.g. a woman who was just learning to use her skateboard). In addition though, I often take street photos where people are just going about their business and have no idea. These shots document life within a time and a culture. Those who have taken such shots over the ages have given us so much pleasure and information.

So yes, you are being unreasonable unless you come from a culture where you believe the camera can ‘steal the soul’!

Tessabelle74 · 13/08/2022 17:48

Duh! How else can you take photos in public place such as a castle? Wait until there's no strangers in shot? What about filming your kids at the park?

Popcorncovered · 13/08/2022 10:58

Knackeredbutnot · 13/08/2022 10:03

I was pleased that he intervened to be honest. I understand that we were in a public place, but I think close up pictures of only your child being taken by a complete stranger is off. I’m sure I’m not the only person who would feel uncomfortable about that - whatever the reason. I think, as a courtesy, asking the parent and explaining the images use should be a minimum when photographing a minor.

I agree.

Popcorncovered · 13/08/2022 10:57

How do you think things like cctv and speed cameras or ring doorbells etc are allowed to operate?

There are rules about those. You can't just let your cctv or ring door bell film people without their knowledge and you are not meant to film past your own boundary.

SerendipityJane · 13/08/2022 10:50

CCTV is not singling my child out and is for the purposes of crime prevention.

  1. How do you know ?
  2. are you sure ?

There are cases of CCTV operators being found spying on women. And these are the ones we know of ....

Also, I'd be curious as to how much crime CCTV ever prevents no one I know has ever seen an arrest from CCTV they supplied ... and the fact they are able to supply it tells you it was after a crime

Knackeredbutnot · 13/08/2022 10:03

Shade17 · 13/08/2022 09:36

WTAF!? The only person acting illegally there was the police officer. I do hope the photographer made a complaint and put in a civil claim against the police force in question.

I was pleased that he intervened to be honest. I understand that we were in a public place, but I think close up pictures of only your child being taken by a complete stranger is off. I’m sure I’m not the only person who would feel uncomfortable about that - whatever the reason. I think, as a courtesy, asking the parent and explaining the images use should be a minimum when photographing a minor.

latetothefisting · 13/08/2022 09:48

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 00:30

CCTV is not singling my child out and is for the purposes of crime prevention.
That's a legitimate reason to capture images of many people going about their business.
CCTV dont post children onto SM, and it is my child I am most concerned about, not myself.

If I discovered someone had deliberately targeted my child in a photograph, I would demand they delete the image there and then.
What possible reason could they have for wanting to take pictures of my child unless it was nefarious?

How would you discover this though? Anyone could claim they were photographing their own child/general park scene for a number of reasons, they have absolutely no obligation to show you their phone/camera and if you tried to grab it off them you'd be the only one committing a crime.

latetothefisting · 13/08/2022 09:44

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 00:09

No one in my circle of friends were aware of this.
Surely you must ask permission of the parent before snapping pictures or video clips of their children especially?
Paparazzi have no interest in taking random pictures of strangers or their children though, and surely they have to get permission first, either from a parent if they wish to capture images of a child, or an adult themselves if they wish to capture images of an adult?

No they dont!! Haven't you ever seen the videos of celebs being swarmed by paparazzi? You don't see a queue of them waiting to one by one ask "please Ms Jolie can I take your picture?"
What about all the ones clearly taken when the celeb was unaware e.g. celeb in unflattering pose on beach "x "proudly bares" her stretch marks"

There are specific vids because they take photos of celebs kids and get right up in their faces and upset them. There was a whole thing about this in the media last week because Kim kardashians kid was telling the paps to go away.

As pps have said, I don't know why you logically didn't work this out, presumably every time you've taken a photo of your kid at the beach or with their friends you didn't go and ask all their parents and everyone on the vicinity that it was OK?

How do you think things like cctv and speed cameras or ring doorbells etc are allowed to operate?

Shade17 · 13/08/2022 09:36

Knackeredbutnot · 13/08/2022 06:44

I had this situation where a random man was very obviously snapping pictures of my (then) 2yr DD. I did ask him to stop, to delete the picture and questioned why he was photographing her. It was at an event and a police officer was there so I reported what happened and he took the camera, went through the images and deleted the ones of DD. Was all very odd.

WTAF!? The only person acting illegally there was the police officer. I do hope the photographer made a complaint and put in a civil claim against the police force in question.

lljkk · 13/08/2022 08:32

My mother (1980s) used to take lots of pictures of people, including unobserved. She loved people. She loved to capture the atmosphere & ordinary people in a place. Little old men in berets & black outfits in a dusty French town playing boules. Or formidable Babushkas in exUSSR. Plump mamas hanging out their washing in Italy. Laughing children in fountains. I suppose you don't get it if you aren't interested in people.

Knackeredbutnot · 13/08/2022 06:44

I had this situation where a random man was very obviously snapping pictures of my (then) 2yr DD. I did ask him to stop, to delete the picture and questioned why he was photographing her. It was at an event and a police officer was there so I reported what happened and he took the camera, went through the images and deleted the ones of DD. Was all very odd.

onelittlefrog · 13/08/2022 04:58

why do people want pictures of non consenting strangers?

Not allowing any photography of non-consenting strangers would be utterly bonkers. How on earth would you enforce it?

Someone takes a picture of their friend/ family member/ child. landmark etc., and another family happen to be in the background. So they have now committed a crime and you want the police to come out and fine them? Ridiculous. Do you know how often that happens? It is absolutely unrealistic - the police are stretched and have a million more pressing things to be worrying about.

Laws around harrassment and paedophilia already cover everything that people are worried about on this thread.

onelittlefrog · 13/08/2022 04:51

If someone is shooting pictures of another person and making them uncomfortable then that is covered by harrassment.

You can't make it illegal to take a picture of someone you don't know - as PP's have said, there would be hardly any photos if this were the case.

1stWorldProblems · 13/08/2022 00:10

UK law is based on the idea that anything that isn't specified as illegal in law is legal.

jcyclops · 12/08/2022 17:04

Home Office & ACPO (Association of Chief Police Officers) guidance - confirmed by NPCC (National Police Chiefs Council - the replacement for ACPO):

Police may not prevent someone from taking photographs in public places unless they justifiably suspect criminal intent. It is not an offence to take photographs in public places. This includes photographs of children, police officers or PCSOs. You do not need someone's permission to take their photograph, but you may need their permission to publish it commercially. There is no licence for photography. Once an image has been recorded, police have no powers to delete or confiscate it without a court order.
^^

SlickShady · 12/08/2022 16:55

burnoutbabe · 12/08/2022 16:20

the indecent pictures comments relate to things like cartoons or CGI images (of child related sexual abuse).

its still illegal even if clearly there was no child ever used in the creation of those images.

That's probably a hangover from Puritanical laws. Something like outraging public decency or whatever (which used to be the reason it was illegal for same sex couples to kiss in public). I just can't get worked up by a drawing someone made, no matter how disgusting and abhorrent it is to me personally. That shouldn't be an issue for the state.

Aposterhasnoname · 12/08/2022 16:35

XenoBitch · 12/08/2022 00:19

Wait until you hear about CCTV.

This

srey · 12/08/2022 16:22

But we are talking about people taking pictures of kids in public? Not manufactured indecent images?

burnoutbabe · 12/08/2022 16:20

the indecent pictures comments relate to things like cartoons or CGI images (of child related sexual abuse).

its still illegal even if clearly there was no child ever used in the creation of those images.

Goldencarp · 12/08/2022 15:38

I thought it was common knowledge too.