Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked to discover

364 replies

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 00:02

Apparently, it is NOT illegal for a stranger to take photographs or video clips of people, including their children in a public place. 😵

I, like many of my friends are astonished if this is true.

I wonder how many people are aware of this?

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 14/08/2022 01:55

I’m surprise you didn’t know that OP.

How do you think photographers and news crews would do their job otherwise?

Julz1969 · 14/08/2022 01:39

There is no expectation of privacy in public. every where you go there is camera's etc: Tesco, post office, banks, dash cams the are every place.

BooneyBeautiful · 13/08/2022 23:54

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 00:17

If this is true, I literally have no words.

There was a local primary school prom a few weeks ago and one of my FB friends posted some photos of their daughter taken from outside the school. In one of them I spotted one of my neighbours in the background (his daughter also went to that school). So yes, it was posted on social media along with lots of other people in the background.

iliketartan · 13/08/2022 23:08

Fanning myself out of shock after your shocking insight OP

DaughterofDawn · 13/08/2022 23:05

SortOfAdmireQuagmire · 13/08/2022 22:54

None of those seem like a good reason to me, more the ravings of a paranoid mentalist.

If someone sticks one of my little children’s faces onto a porn star and has a bit of a fiddle, what of it?

I’ll never know, they’ll never know, so why the paranoia?

And let’s be honest, that’s not happening. You are coming up with ludicrous “what if” situations. That’s a “you” problem that you should probably speak to someone about.

This actually did happen to someone close to me and they did find out about it and they tried to kill themselves over it. I don’t know what your age is but people 20 and younger deal with this a lot more than we realize. They were photoshopped with a dick in their mouth because they had a shocked expression on their face and kids at school passed out around and it circulated for a few months and people kept reuploading it. So no lol. It’s really not that paranoid or delusional. And you might not care but your kid might.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/08/2022 23:01

I’m also surprised that others don’t know this!

Daisybuttercup12345 · 13/08/2022 23:00

You are very naive not to know this.

SortOfAdmireQuagmire · 13/08/2022 22:54

DaughterofDawn · 13/08/2022 22:12

People start to care when it’s revenge porn our child pornography. A child’s face can easily be photoshopped into a naked body. So yeah it is yours. I don’t want a creep posting my child’s face online for nefarious purposes. Also look up stories of people who became viral memes overnight. I know a story of a woman who worked at a bank and her picture was used for sexual memes. She lost her job over it even though she did not make the meme and she was dressed appropriately. While these are wild and unlikely I still would like to keep my child’s online foot print very small. I’m not saying it should be illegal. I don’t think that can happen without infringing on other rights but… What I am saying is that people care for a very good reason.

None of those seem like a good reason to me, more the ravings of a paranoid mentalist.

If someone sticks one of my little children’s faces onto a porn star and has a bit of a fiddle, what of it?

I’ll never know, they’ll never know, so why the paranoia?

And let’s be honest, that’s not happening. You are coming up with ludicrous “what if” situations. That’s a “you” problem that you should probably speak to someone about.

DaughterofDawn · 13/08/2022 22:46

ReneBumsWombats · 13/08/2022 22:17

People start to care when it’s revenge porn our child pornography. A child’s face can easily be photoshopped into a naked body.

None of that is candid, true photography in a public space. We've got laws to cover that. They might do with some improvement but it's a separate aspect of law.

Yes but once it’s online you’re going to have to jump through hoops to remove it from the internet. So I would rather not get into that situation in the first place. Also I realize revenge porn and child pornography are illegal. I was simply explaining that they are not just pixels on a piece of paper. The image is a person. And photo’s taken for manipulation can and does happen in a public space.

jcyclops · 13/08/2022 22:21

Skodacool · 13/08/2022 20:59

Some of the situations on here could be remedied under Section 4A Public Order Act where:

‘Your actions have caused another person to feel harassed, alarmed, or distressed’

Incorrect. A section 4A offence requires that

  1. You have used threatening, abusive, or insulting words or behaviour or disorderly behaviour, towards another person; AND
  2. intended to cause them harassment, alarm or distress; AND
  3. that you have caused that other person harassment, alarm or distress.

If ONLY 3) was required, you could be arrested and prosecuted for going to Macdonalds because you are causing a passing vegan alarm and distress, or a Liverpool player could be arrested after scoring for causing Man City fans alarm and distress.

Incidently, the ACPO advice I quoted higher up the thread was originally aimed at Police Officers, because there were too many reports of them breaking the law through ignorance and demanding to see and/or delete photographs taken by law abiding members of the public.

Thatswhyimacat · 13/08/2022 22:18

I think the idea is that paedophiles who stalk, photograph and keep images of young children are covered by other and better laws than 'taking a picture of someone in public'.

The idea is that nefarious misuse of images IS a crime, but for the myriad of reasons outlined on this thread, capturing them is not.

ReneBumsWombats · 13/08/2022 22:17

People start to care when it’s revenge porn our child pornography. A child’s face can easily be photoshopped into a naked body.

None of that is candid, true photography in a public space. We've got laws to cover that. They might do with some improvement but it's a separate aspect of law.

DaughterofDawn · 13/08/2022 22:12

SortOfAdmireQuagmire · 13/08/2022 21:47

Not particularly, though. My little ones have the most piercing blue eyes despite Mediterranean skin tones, I’d not be surprised at all of someone photographing them, nor bothered about it.

I don’t really even understand why others care. It just seems so precious and ludicrous. The photons that went into the camer weren’t ours, the reconstructed image of their face isn’t ours. It verges on a mental condition to me that someone would be upset about it.

People start to care when it’s revenge porn our child pornography. A child’s face can easily be photoshopped into a naked body. So yeah it is yours. I don’t want a creep posting my child’s face online for nefarious purposes. Also look up stories of people who became viral memes overnight. I know a story of a woman who worked at a bank and her picture was used for sexual memes. She lost her job over it even though she did not make the meme and she was dressed appropriately. While these are wild and unlikely I still would like to keep my child’s online foot print very small. I’m not saying it should be illegal. I don’t think that can happen without infringing on other rights but… What I am saying is that people care for a very good reason.

bobster31 · 13/08/2022 22:08

A few years ago I was in my local Waterstones with my son who was about 10 at the time. A man, who was a complete stranger, came up to him whilst he was browsing the children's books and took a picture of him with his mobile. My son felt very uncomfortable about it and came straight over to tell me. I asked the man if he had taken a photo and he said yes he had. I asked him why he would think that would be ok to do without my permission - he told me "taking photos of nice boys makes me happy"!!!! I tried to get him to delete it but he turned really abusive, upturning a table of books over me then ran out of the shop. When we contacted the shopping centre security and then the police, they knew exactly who he was and that he'd done it before but couldn't do anything because taking photos of children in public is not illegal. Might not be but it still seemed incredibly dodgy to me and you would have thought his actions plus his words would have been a big red possible paedophile flag!!

marktayloruk · 13/08/2022 21:59

Is it mere coincidence that parent and paranoid begin with the same three letters?

NerrSnerr · 13/08/2022 21:57

kittenkipping · 12/08/2022 00:36

Without being rude or wanting to trigger anyone, really op- pervs don't want photos of fully dressed kids in parks. They have the internet and its many and varied horrors. The only time I have seen people taking photos of kids has been to document bad behaviour to show to local schools- the mums kicked off then , braying about no right to take photos off their kids etc .

Has this actually happened op? Someone has taken photos of your child? Or a friends child? For no reason at all? Other than mystery nefarious reasons that you me imagines could be far better found upon the dark web?

I agree with this. There was an outcry in our village a few months back because the parish council put CCTV in the park and they thought pervert counsellors would he viewing it.

If people are wanting pictures/ videos for a sexual nature that's not how they go about getting them.

CHML1976 · 13/08/2022 21:55

I manage to take photos of my LG in public places without capturing other children. It can be done no matter how busy it is. My daughter is adopted, so safeguarding is a priority. I can’t have her picture plastered all over social media. I’ve seen patents take pictures and videos knowing that my daughter is in them and I’ve asked them politely to either delete or blur her out. They have always been understanding. Places where I take my daughter, swimming, sports, after school activities, birthday parties, they have a policy that photos are not taken unless permission is given. It’s not illegal but there are so many children that need safeguarding so hoping more parents reading this will just think twice about snapping away with other peoples kids.

Tee20x · 13/08/2022 21:54

Like others have said - no right to privacy in a public place. So by being in public, yes whoever can take pictures of whatever they want.

That doesn't mean it's normal or ok & if I saw someone taking photos of my kid they'd certainly get a mouthful from me, though like you have come to realise it's not a crime & I wouldn't be ringing the police expecting them to do anything.

SortOfAdmireQuagmire · 13/08/2022 21:47

Knackeredbutnot · 13/08/2022 21:26

@SortOfAdmireQuagmire I love how some people on mumsnet assume they know everything (they don’t). It was a small village type fete and the policeman was insistent that he was shown the images and the ones of DD were deleted. The photographer maybe deleted them himself, perhaps that’s why the policeman wasn’t acting outside of the law.
Genuine question - would other people not have been concerned that their child (and only their child was in the picture) was being photographed?

Not particularly, though. My little ones have the most piercing blue eyes despite Mediterranean skin tones, I’d not be surprised at all of someone photographing them, nor bothered about it.

I don’t really even understand why others care. It just seems so precious and ludicrous. The photons that went into the camer weren’t ours, the reconstructed image of their face isn’t ours. It verges on a mental condition to me that someone would be upset about it.

csigeek · 13/08/2022 21:42

You have no expectation of privacy in public spaces so of course it’s not illegal.
It’s not right, but it’s not illegal.

Knackeredbutnot · 13/08/2022 21:26

SortOfAdmireQuagmire · 13/08/2022 18:07

If this had happened (it didn’t) the policeman should expect to be disciplined for breaking the law and abusing his authority.

@SortOfAdmireQuagmire I love how some people on mumsnet assume they know everything (they don’t). It was a small village type fete and the policeman was insistent that he was shown the images and the ones of DD were deleted. The photographer maybe deleted them himself, perhaps that’s why the policeman wasn’t acting outside of the law.
Genuine question - would other people not have been concerned that their child (and only their child was in the picture) was being photographed?

Bangolads · 13/08/2022 21:14

Obviously- how would tabloids work otherwise

Skodacool · 13/08/2022 20:59

Some of the situations on here could be remedied under Section 4A Public Order Act where:

‘Your actions have caused another person to feel harassed, alarmed, or distressed’

Babysitter12 · 13/08/2022 19:34

More to this ?, recently covered on youtube
Black belt barrister

LovelyIssues · 13/08/2022 18:57

I always assumed that was the case and aren't shocked. If you're in a public place with your children 😕