Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked to discover

364 replies

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 00:02

Apparently, it is NOT illegal for a stranger to take photographs or video clips of people, including their children in a public place. 😵

I, like many of my friends are astonished if this is true.

I wonder how many people are aware of this?

OP posts:
CandyLeBonBon · 14/08/2022 22:48

bobster31 · 14/08/2022 16:08

@CandyLeBonBon @Jumpking - that was my argument with them! It wasn't a public place, it's privately owned property but the police just refused to do anything. They knew exactly who he was, knew his address and was well known to the security staff for similar behaviour. The PC I dealt with told me that as no crime had been committed, his boss wouldn't let him go to speak to the man in question. I couldn't quite believe it! I think it was just a case of not enough police to deal with something they didn't seem serious.

Well in my experience the police are often happy not to pursue things they don't feel are worthwhile, even if crimes have been committed which sounds probable in your scenario. I'm sorry that happened. Clearly there was a problem that no one wanted to own. Flowers

rwalker · 14/08/2022 20:49

I’m more astonished you didn’t know

IsTheOffDutyDoneYet · 14/08/2022 20:41

I was aware of this.

My best friend has an ex who used to make him ask people to delete their photos if she thought she was in it. Basically someone would take a photo, she may have been in the background. She used to get him to go up to these people and ask them to delete the photos. And he used to do it too! Absolutely batshit. I’ve never met her as it was before I knew him, but they managed to last at least 8 years, no children involved either. Crazy.

SoupDragon · 14/08/2022 20:41

must be breaking some law regarding privacy?

What privacy do you think you have in a public space?

Billieaskin · 14/08/2022 20:34

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 01:01

Exactly!
Inadvertently capturing someone in a photo you are taking of someone you know is not quite the same as deliberately taking a picture or worse, a video clip of someone you dont know, without permission, must be breaking some law regarding privacy?

OP what’s so hard to understand here? You’re still shouting about privacy rights.

I really hope you never post your child’s photos to social media (even if you’re on private)

ClareBlue · 14/08/2022 20:19

GDPR is exempt for personal or household activities. A photo taken in public is not personal information and you can hold it legally without consent.

ClareBlue · 14/08/2022 20:08

Oiduntbelieveit · 12/08/2022 07:10

ipo.blog.gov.uk/2019/06/11/copyright-and-gdpr-for-photographers/

In GDPR law, no one is allowed to keep an image of you without your consent. A photo of you is categorised as personal data under GDPR. Check out the link above from the Intellectual Property Office UK.

That's not what that links say at all. There are specific contractual instances where you formed a contract for an image, but not all images taken in public. How do you get consent to keep a picture of 1000 people on a beach.

Popcorncovered · 14/08/2022 19:51

FunnyBeaux · 14/08/2022 17:45

What's the worst that could happen? I mean even if they had the most nefarious intentions (love this phrase), what actual harm do you think could come to your child?

The worst? Well they could be found by someone that shouldn't be able to find them if you put the photos on the internet/ newspaper.

Popcorncovered · 14/08/2022 19:48

AngelsWithSilverWings · 14/08/2022 10:11

I see so often on local Facebook groups where someone's posts a photo of kids up to no good and then posters line up to tell her she has broken the law by publishing the photo. It's such a widely believed myth.

I'm a hobby photographer and am always out and about taking landscape shots and bird photography on our local beach.

One evening I was on the beach with my young daughter and was wandering around with my camera taking photos of her and of the landscape as the sun was setting.

A local scout group was on the beach playing football on the wet sand where the tide had gone out ( it's a thing here - they call it mud football)

Scout leader saw me with my camera and very rudely demanded I put my camera away. I refused and she demanded to see what I had taken. I explained politely that I was just with my young daughter getting some nice sunset photos of her and the landscape and had every right to take photos on the beach. She then asked me where I was going to publish them and that if any of the scouts were in them I'd have to get permission from their parents. She also said I was breaking the law taking photos of the scouts. I put her right on the law but she was so angry and rude to me. I had no plan to publish anything but I think my professional looking camera made her assume I would.

If she had come up to me politely and asked if I could try to avoid getting any of the scouts in my shots I would have gladly tried to. In the end I told her that if she didn't want to risk her scouts being captured in the background of people's photos she should probably not bring them ,at sunset,to a beach that is a very popular spot for sunset photography.

You should not have taken photos of a group of scouts. You know they're not there with their parents and in that situation the scout leader was responsible for keeping them safe.There might have been children in the group that mustn't be on SM/the internet in order to keep them safe. If you are a photographer you should be aware of this and be considerate.

Scepticalwotsits · 14/08/2022 19:19

FunnyBeaux · 14/08/2022 17:45

What's the worst that could happen? I mean even if they had the most nefarious intentions (love this phrase), what actual harm do you think could come to your child?

if its privately owned property a breach of the rules is a civil issue not a criminal one, therefor police would not get involved

FunnyBeaux · 14/08/2022 17:45

bobster31 · 14/08/2022 16:08

@CandyLeBonBon @Jumpking - that was my argument with them! It wasn't a public place, it's privately owned property but the police just refused to do anything. They knew exactly who he was, knew his address and was well known to the security staff for similar behaviour. The PC I dealt with told me that as no crime had been committed, his boss wouldn't let him go to speak to the man in question. I couldn't quite believe it! I think it was just a case of not enough police to deal with something they didn't seem serious.

What's the worst that could happen? I mean even if they had the most nefarious intentions (love this phrase), what actual harm do you think could come to your child?

Snaketime · 14/08/2022 17:42

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 01:01

Exactly!
Inadvertently capturing someone in a photo you are taking of someone you know is not quite the same as deliberately taking a picture or worse, a video clip of someone you dont know, without permission, must be breaking some law regarding privacy?

In this situation you can't so anything about them taking pictures of your child, but you can go to the police and say there was a strange person taking pictures of my child, I asked them to stop, they wouldn't, I asked them to delete, they refused and this is what the look like. That situation would infer they were either a paedophile or trafficker.
A stranger taking pictures in itself isn't illegal, it is what they do with them that can be illegal.
Again if someone posts photos of you or your child on SM, you can ask them to take it down, if they refuse you can report them to the SM platform, after that I believe you can take them to court for using your image without your permission.

If they made it illegal it would have a knock on effect with cctv, ring door bells, dashcams etc also as it stands, if you feel you are in a dangerous position you can record the other person for your safety, there are lots of examples of this online when people record to save themselves.

bobster31 · 14/08/2022 16:08

@CandyLeBonBon @Jumpking - that was my argument with them! It wasn't a public place, it's privately owned property but the police just refused to do anything. They knew exactly who he was, knew his address and was well known to the security staff for similar behaviour. The PC I dealt with told me that as no crime had been committed, his boss wouldn't let him go to speak to the man in question. I couldn't quite believe it! I think it was just a case of not enough police to deal with something they didn't seem serious.

Kidsfortea · 14/08/2022 14:37

XenoBitch · 12/08/2022 00:19

Wait until you hear about CCTV.

Grin
CandyLeBonBon · 14/08/2022 11:07

I think they're wrong here. A shopping centre is private property, therefore they get to dictate the rules inside it in regard photos.

I'm surprised if he was causing damage and overturning tables that the police weren't called for breach of the peace? There's plenty of laws he broke there that could've allowed the police to arrest him - especially if he was known to them.

Jumpking · 14/08/2022 11:05

My XH is a crappy amateur photographer, so I've been aware of this for years, as he was asked several times to stop taking photos. It surprises me how many people don't know about it.

My daughter was about 7, being snapped in Hong Kong by a guy. I stood in front of her to block his line of shot. I know how Photoshop works, sadly.

SD1978 · 14/08/2022 11:02

Yup, that's why there are so many videos on the internet of people losing their shit, either rightly or wrongly. Did you think any of them consented?

Jumpking · 14/08/2022 10:59

bobster31 · 13/08/2022 22:08

A few years ago I was in my local Waterstones with my son who was about 10 at the time. A man, who was a complete stranger, came up to him whilst he was browsing the children's books and took a picture of him with his mobile. My son felt very uncomfortable about it and came straight over to tell me. I asked the man if he had taken a photo and he said yes he had. I asked him why he would think that would be ok to do without my permission - he told me "taking photos of nice boys makes me happy"!!!! I tried to get him to delete it but he turned really abusive, upturning a table of books over me then ran out of the shop. When we contacted the shopping centre security and then the police, they knew exactly who he was and that he'd done it before but couldn't do anything because taking photos of children in public is not illegal. Might not be but it still seemed incredibly dodgy to me and you would have thought his actions plus his words would have been a big red possible paedophile flag!!

I think they're wrong here. A shopping centre is private property, therefore they get to dictate the rules inside it in regard photos.

ProfessorSlocombe · 14/08/2022 10:56

AmberMcAmber · 14/08/2022 10:15

If you spot someone taking pictures of your child you can politely ask them what their business is there, if one of the kids is theirs etc and ask them
to delete the offending pic(s) being in the public is being in the public
if you are concerned by the behaviour of someone, you can take a pic/video of them, note as much info as you can (direction from where they came/left, accent, distinguishing features, etc etc) and report to police
most genuine photographers would delete a pic if the parent/child was distressed about it

There are are almost an infinite number of things you can do. However not all of them are supported by the framework of the law, and this is one of them.

You can ask - of course you can. I can ask you for a million pounds and your Clubcard number. But - as with someone taking photographs in public - you don't have any reason to comply.

Shame I'm old. This looks like developing into a new freeman of the land myth. But I suspect a few colleagues pensions are being boosted ....

AmberMcAmber · 14/08/2022 10:15

If you spot someone taking pictures of your child you can politely ask them what their business is there, if one of the kids is theirs etc and ask them
to delete the offending pic(s) being in the public is being in the public
if you are concerned by the behaviour of someone, you can take a pic/video of them, note as much info as you can (direction from where they came/left, accent, distinguishing features, etc etc) and report to police
most genuine photographers would delete a pic if the parent/child was distressed about it

AngelsWithSilverWings · 14/08/2022 10:11

I see so often on local Facebook groups where someone's posts a photo of kids up to no good and then posters line up to tell her she has broken the law by publishing the photo. It's such a widely believed myth.

I'm a hobby photographer and am always out and about taking landscape shots and bird photography on our local beach.

One evening I was on the beach with my young daughter and was wandering around with my camera taking photos of her and of the landscape as the sun was setting.

A local scout group was on the beach playing football on the wet sand where the tide had gone out ( it's a thing here - they call it mud football)

Scout leader saw me with my camera and very rudely demanded I put my camera away. I refused and she demanded to see what I had taken. I explained politely that I was just with my young daughter getting some nice sunset photos of her and the landscape and had every right to take photos on the beach. She then asked me where I was going to publish them and that if any of the scouts were in them I'd have to get permission from their parents. She also said I was breaking the law taking photos of the scouts. I put her right on the law but she was so angry and rude to me. I had no plan to publish anything but I think my professional looking camera made her assume I would.

If she had come up to me politely and asked if I could try to avoid getting any of the scouts in my shots I would have gladly tried to. In the end I told her that if she didn't want to risk her scouts being captured in the background of people's photos she should probably not bring them ,at sunset,to a beach that is a very popular spot for sunset photography.

TrulyFubar · 14/08/2022 09:26

There is no expectation of privacy in public and nobody needs your permission to capture your image. That's it.

Gardenglove · 14/08/2022 09:13

twoandcooplease · 12/08/2022 00:57

The more you write though I'm starting to think I also maybe didn't know it was legal either

I knew media coverage like I exampled in my pp is legal but you're talking about someone intentionally taking a picture of your child. Not by accident and not in the background but going over and taking a photo - I don't think I knew that was allowed
It's really not ok and if I phoned the police to report someone doing this to my ds would they just laugh at me and say they can't help? Not come to take a statement or anything??

I think this kind of behaviour would be viewed as rather strange and disturbing.
Photography aside, If a person was targeting an individual child like this maybe it would be seen as harassment/stalking. The police might look to see if the person doing it was on the sex offenders list, or ask why they were doing it at least?! I think this would perhaps be viewed a bit differently to just taking pictures of your kids and catching others in the background etc, which is of course entirely legal...

RachaelN · 14/08/2022 08:54

I'm aware this isn't illagal. However we went out last weekend to a busy tourist spot in Aberdeen shire and a man deliberately kneeled down in front of my kids with a big camera and started to take pictures. My kids are 7 and 9. No permission seeked and as you can imagine I was seething. Yes I caused a scene, and he walked away very embarrassed. He was not a member of staff, just an Italian tourist. I know this because I heard him speaking to his friend as they walked away.

Tomasinabombadil · 14/08/2022 08:32

I follow a few friends on FB who have young children. They often post photos of their family & children at various events & outings. If other random children are in the photo then that child’s identity is disguised by pasting a smiley face🙂over their image, before uploading to FB.