Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked to discover

364 replies

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 00:02

Apparently, it is NOT illegal for a stranger to take photographs or video clips of people, including their children in a public place. 😵

I, like many of my friends are astonished if this is true.

I wonder how many people are aware of this?

OP posts:
FunnyBeaux · 12/08/2022 06:05

Maybe somebody took a photograph of one of my sons when they were younger. Maybe somebody is lusting over it right now. And you know what, I don't know and I don't care and neither would they.

This. I've always found it bizarre the paranoia some have about a person doing nefarious things to their kid's photo. That's the definition of a victimless crime. After all the nobody is hurt whatsoever.

srey · 12/08/2022 05:46

I'm surprised you didn't know this tbh.

IceStationZebra · 12/08/2022 05:39

OP is being ridiculous but tbh I would possibly be a bit weirded out if someone was deliberately photographing my child in a public place, and would seek to remove my child and myself from the situation. Depends on the vibe really.

Having said that, I did once photograph a man in a park who had one of those huge bubble wands and had a constant stream of children running about to catch and pop them. The photos were lovely.

FormerlySpeckledyHen · 12/08/2022 05:38

Why do you think celebrities sometimes punch photographers in the street ?

If it was illegal Diana would still be alive .

FrenchFancie · 12/08/2022 04:44

theres no expectation of privacy in a public place - I enjoy photography and rely on this to take street photography, zooming in on people with interesting faces etc. (Although I do try to be subtle about it).

as a previous poster said, sadly pervs aren’t taking pictures of children in the street.

OP I’m sorry but you and your circle of friends needs to get over yourselves a bit….

Clymene · 12/08/2022 04:13

Most people don't want pictures of your kids so I'm not sure why you're getting all riled up about

@MulletsBeGone you know some weird people

Jenny70 · 12/08/2022 04:11

There are lots of things people do that are distasteful & socially unacceptable, but not illegal. I wouldn't be pleased to sit next to someone picking their nose, squeezing a zit or taking their shoes off with smelly feet. But because these acts are only rude, I simply have to move away, ask them to stop or put up with it.

And yes if someone obviously photographed my child without my/their consent, I would be annoyed and probably suspicious as to their motives. But I realise than in a public space, I have no legal right to stop them. And if they put it on social media, yes again cross, but not ready to call the police.

It is definitely bad manners and socially unacceptable to film someone else's child, particularly if it isn't a background/crowd scenario. But I never expected it to be illegal, or a crime.

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 03:56

Paparazzi have no interest in taking random pictures of strangers or their children

You've never seem pap shots of slebs out with their kids? Or shots of public streets on the news?

Public places are public.

sashh · 12/08/2022 02:31

Don't be ridiculous OP

I watched an event at the commonwealth games, I was on TV, as was the entire crowd, including children.

There were even some close ups of children waving flags.

And these may well have been shown internationally.

My local paper published a picture of a local paddling pool, lots of children in very little clothing.

www.expressandstar.com/news/local-hubs/wolverhampton/2022/08/11/bumper-crowds-enjoy-tettenhall-pool-but-people-warned-to-take-care/

Not only that but anyone can order a copy.

OP

You do know about CCTV don't you?

clary · 12/08/2022 02:01

Op think about it. How could it possibly be illegal? How could you police it? If it were illegal, no one would be allowed to take a picture in any crowd- at the Olympics, at Alton Towers, at a football match. You wouldn't be able to film your child winning a race or scoring a goal. Have you never seen a crowd shot on the news or a film clip showing shoppers or people at a gig?

You say you make sure not to take pix with others' children in them - really? So no pic of your kids' football team or your child in the school play?

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 12/08/2022 01:57

POTC · 12/08/2022 01:50

They wouldn't laugh because they're too professional and sadly too used to getting ridiculous calls. No they wouldn't come out or take a statement because nothing illegal would have taken place and they're too busy dealing with things that are actually illegal!

If someone you didn’t know was actually taking a specific inappropriate interest in your child, you would probably be able to get the police interested in that, TBF. Just not for some made up offence of “photographing without permission”.

JasmineVioletRose · 12/08/2022 01:55

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 00:24

So a random stranger, let's say an adult on their own, can walk into a playground and take pictures or videos specifically of my child, which then belong to the random stranger, and then post them on their own instagram page? 🤨
Without my permission?
With no consent from anyone?
Can I force them to delete the images if I catch them snapping away?
Does my child or myself have any rights to images taken by a complete stranger?
Surely it is a flagrant breach of our privacy?

But you are not in a private place. What's complicated?

POTC · 12/08/2022 01:50

twoandcooplease · 12/08/2022 00:57

The more you write though I'm starting to think I also maybe didn't know it was legal either

I knew media coverage like I exampled in my pp is legal but you're talking about someone intentionally taking a picture of your child. Not by accident and not in the background but going over and taking a photo - I don't think I knew that was allowed
It's really not ok and if I phoned the police to report someone doing this to my ds would they just laugh at me and say they can't help? Not come to take a statement or anything??

They wouldn't laugh because they're too professional and sadly too used to getting ridiculous calls. No they wouldn't come out or take a statement because nothing illegal would have taken place and they're too busy dealing with things that are actually illegal!

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 12/08/2022 01:43

Paparazzi have no interest in taking random pictures of strangers or their children though, and surely they have to get permission first, either from a parent if they wish to capture images of a child, or an adult themselves if they wish to capture images of an adult?

You are not really expecting us to believe that you thought that all paparazzi work by consent?!

scarletisjustred · 12/08/2022 01:41

Most people's children are not so attractive or distinctive or so undressed that random paedophiles are going to be snapping their pictures at the park. Even identifying small children can be difficult because they change so much and so many of them have the same facial proportions - like proportionally bigger eyes and little noses and so on. My youngest son looked liked like a blue eyed Anglo Saxon with straight light brown hair. I had trouble picking him up in the playground at after school care because the place was full of small boys most of whom looked a lot like him and were dressed a lot like him. My dark eyed dark haired son who stood out in that group but would look like any other number of children in other groups.

Maybe somebody took a photograph of one of my sons when they were younger. Maybe somebody is lusting over it right now. And you know what, I don't know and I don't care and neither would they.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 01:40

Scareofeasttown · 12/08/2022 01:37

That’s actually not quite true as bizarre as it sounds. For instance, you can breastfeed in a public place and expect a degree of privacy. You’ll never find it detailed specifically in law, some of that’s governed by the human rights act and it’s the test cases that direct us.

We had someone who had their photo taken on a train argue their human rights had been violated, and they won!

Do you have a case reference for that? It’s a very unusual,result, and I suspect there was something more to it than just being in a photograph.

It’s right that there are protections around things like breastfeeding, and people taking pictures up someone’s skirt, but a picture with a person in who’s just sitting around in public is generally fine,

Scareofeasttown · 12/08/2022 01:37

ImWell · 12/08/2022 01:31

Privacy? You are in public, you have no right to, or expectation of, privacy when you are out in public.

That’s actually not quite true as bizarre as it sounds. For instance, you can breastfeed in a public place and expect a degree of privacy. You’ll never find it detailed specifically in law, some of that’s governed by the human rights act and it’s the test cases that direct us.

We had someone who had their photo taken on a train argue their human rights had been violated, and they won!

MulletsBeGone · 12/08/2022 01:35

It's one thing being in the background of someone's landscape photo to having a stranger specifically decide they're recording or taking your photos with the intent of uploading you to social media for people to comment on whatever the person with the camera wants you to. I've seen people have some stranger shove a camera in their face as they're getting on the night bus home and they're live streamed to thousands of people. Or someone is minding their own business trying to work out at a gym and you've got someone recording them and uploading to their followers to mock someone who might be on the larger side or who dares walk in front of a camera..

I've an extended family member (who I don't see it have contact with) who live streams every night out, zooming in on people she thinks looks pissed and can't stand up, or slags off the clothes other women wear and if anyone asks her to stop recording them she gets very aggressive and says it's a free country and they're "choosing" to be out of their home.

Dds college used to have someone who made videos of girls eating their lunch in the park outside, he'd sit on the college wall, wait for a girl to sit on the grass and he'd zoom in and comment and what's in her lunchbox, what order he'll think she'd eat it, make rude comments if it was something like a banana and guess if she's straight or not, laugh at her clothing if he didn't like it. He'd also zoom in to see what they where browsing on their phone screens sometimes. I know dd and her friends avoided eating their lunch in certain places because they didn't want to end up on tik tok with strangers guessing her sexuality and they never found out who it was because everyone was on their phones. He just stopped, not sure why because nothing was done in the months people were complaining about it.

I don't think that type of stuff should be ok and there's some people who use the "it's a public place" to just record people they know would say no if they walked up and asked, like if they said "I'm just gonna record you sitting there eating your lunch so my followers can guess if you're straight" They know they'd be told no.

It's very different to someone taking a photo of a landmark or of their own family going down a slide and catching someone else's child in the background, because the stranger isn't the feature of the photo in those contexts.

Starlitexpress · 12/08/2022 01:34

I hope you haven't seen the pictures of Bournemouth beach in the press then. Thousands of adults and children having their picture taken expressly to print online.

MissyCooperismyShero · 12/08/2022 01:33

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 00:24

So a random stranger, let's say an adult on their own, can walk into a playground and take pictures or videos specifically of my child, which then belong to the random stranger, and then post them on their own instagram page? 🤨
Without my permission?
With no consent from anyone?
Can I force them to delete the images if I catch them snapping away?
Does my child or myself have any rights to images taken by a complete stranger?
Surely it is a flagrant breach of our privacy?

You and your child have no rights whatsoever in this regard. And of course you have no right to privacy in a public playground!

ImWell · 12/08/2022 01:31

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 00:24

So a random stranger, let's say an adult on their own, can walk into a playground and take pictures or videos specifically of my child, which then belong to the random stranger, and then post them on their own instagram page? 🤨
Without my permission?
With no consent from anyone?
Can I force them to delete the images if I catch them snapping away?
Does my child or myself have any rights to images taken by a complete stranger?
Surely it is a flagrant breach of our privacy?

Privacy? You are in public, you have no right to, or expectation of, privacy when you are out in public.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 01:29

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 00:09

No one in my circle of friends were aware of this.
Surely you must ask permission of the parent before snapping pictures or video clips of their children especially?
Paparazzi have no interest in taking random pictures of strangers or their children though, and surely they have to get permission first, either from a parent if they wish to capture images of a child, or an adult themselves if they wish to capture images of an adult?

Well no, and how could that possibly work? No pictures of your family if there’s anyone in the background? No selfies at a festival, no crowd shots in a stadium?

I’m really surprised that anyone thought that there was a law against taking pictures outdoors.

On your paparazzi point, did you just assume that the law said that it’s fine if the person has been in Hollyoaks, but not otherwise?

Scareofeasttown · 12/08/2022 01:21

Also photos are not automatically personal data just because you are in it, there’s a basic test that data protection officers use and it’s along the lines of - can I use this photo to learn something about you and in what context

Scareofeasttown · 12/08/2022 01:19

Junipercrumble · 12/08/2022 01:01

Exactly!
Inadvertently capturing someone in a photo you are taking of someone you know is not quite the same as deliberately taking a picture or worse, a video clip of someone you dont know, without permission, must be breaking some law regarding privacy?

you know you can go read law if you want. It’s published online

but in short: data protection laws govern the commercial/corporate/organised use of personal data meaning not domestic use. Paparazzi are governed by GDPR because they sell identifiable personal data. It sometimes comes down to expectation of privacy and the age of someone photographed which is why children are often blurred out in paparazzi photos.

GDPR does not cover domestic use, but if a photo is taken for commercial gain you have some rights.there’s also the human rights act to take into consideration which does talk about right to privacy

noirchatsdeux · 12/08/2022 01:19

Responding to the questions in your 2nd post, OP:

Nope

and

Nope

Hope that helps.

Swipe left for the next trending thread