Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these kids need to develop some resilience

203 replies

PollysKettleIsOn · 11/08/2022 22:08

Not my DC but a family members, we usually get together once a fortnight or so but have been seeing each other more frequently during the summer holidays.

They are 5.5 and almost 10 (I have three of my own who are 4.5years, 3years and a baby)

I feel terrible saying this but I'm starting to dread these meet ups / play dates. You could bet your house on the fact that usually both, but atleast one of them will break into exasperated screaming multiple times for total non events.

The younger ones were messing around with a flask earlier on (her 5 year old DD and my 3 year old DD) and my DD got whacked on the arm with it. She was fine but i heard her say ouch. I asked, nicely, what had happened. Cue the 5yo starting to scream and cry uncontrollably for the next 10 minutes. I actually thought she was the one who got hit with it the way she was carrying on.

When she finally stopped her mum asked why she was so upset, her response was that she thought she was going to get into trouble. My 3yo DD, the one who actually got hit, just stood there looking miffed.

Later on she slid off the end of the slide and got a Teeny Tiny graze on her knee, off she was again for the next half an hour.

The older one is exactly the same if not worse. You only have to so much as ask him not to do something and off he goes, crying and wailing to the point he looks like he is hyperventilating. The children have never been hit or frightened by their parents or anybody else. There's absolutely need to act that way.

My DC on the other hand are alot more resilient. I'm not sure I can credit myself for that it's just who they are. If they need to be told off then they are, in a calm but firm manner. I don't have to bite my tongue in fear they're going to stand there shaking. I have on occasion had to raise my voice the same as everyone else and they don't respond with anywhere near that level of dramatics - and my eldest has special needs.

AIBU to think (perhaps even say) that the children need to develop some resilience because life will be very bloody hard for them if they don't. The eldest will be going to secondary school in no time and will end up (wrongly, obviously) becoming a target.

OP posts:
basilmint · 12/08/2022 08:04

To be fair what people are slagging off is a lot of parents' complete inability to stop their sensitive child impinging on everyone else's fun. A couple of minutes of tantrum is one thing, 30 minutes of it? sure i will be judging you. Very harshly. And actually after 15 minutes I'd be asking you to make it stop (ND children notwithstanding, that's a whole different story)

Your experience of tantrums is different to mine. Younger DC used to have tantrums for an hour or more as a toddler. It was often over something completely trivial, not as many seem to suggest on here because I had said no to her. There was no being able to stop her just because some adult in the park told me she should. She completely lost control of her emotions - believe me if there'd been a fast way to stop her I would but speaking firmly, giving consequences etc had no effect whatsoever. The only thing that worked would be to find somewhere quiet and sit bwside her while it burned itself out. She was always incredibly ashamed afterwards!

It wouldn't have bothered other kids in the park though because I would have taken her away knowing what she is like. This child is still incredibly sensitive today. Older sibling rarely tantrumed as a young child and deals with things differently now to younger DC. They have different personalities. I have looked into ASD because I was so concerned about the outbursts but she doesn't seem to fit most of the criteria.

lollipoprainbow · 12/08/2022 08:01

@SpidersAreShitheads agree totally

iRun2eatCake · 12/08/2022 07:55

PollysKettleIsOn · 11/08/2022 23:17

I don't care whether its a result of parenting, nurture, nature or anything else.. it is spoiling days out for my DC and can be incredibly distracting and annoying.

I'm on the fence as to whether or not to have a conversation with her and if so how to broach it with minimal fallout.

I don't need to piss on somebodies bonfire to make mine burn brighter either. I'm far from a perfect parent and would never pretend otherwise, I don't think there is any such thing as a parent parent anyway.

But yes my children are less challenging, even the 9mo baby going through sleep regression and my eldest who starts a special needs school in September as he is severely autistic, the latter of which many on mumsnet would assume to display the most difficult behaviour. Even he is getting sick of it.

That might be the "excuse" to use... your autistic child is getting distressed by the screaming etc so you'll have to cut down on the meet ups until he/she is less "noise sensitive"...

Take the blame from her DC but makes the point that their behaviour is causing a child with genuine needs distress

autienotnaughty · 12/08/2022 07:52

@ASimpleLampoon completely relate. I raised two fairly easy daughters with little critique. I now have an asd son who's needs are more complex and suddenly everyone has an opinion 🙄

carefullycourageous · 12/08/2022 07:52

SpidersAreShitheads · 12/08/2022 07:35

Oh.

Here we go again.

I don't know what the fuck is going on with MN right now but there's an absolute deluge of posts on here recently slagging off sensitive kids. Cue the piling on of comments pointing out that kids need to be disciplined and toughen up blah blah. Usually served up with a side snark of "wait for the comments suggesting SEN".

Be glad when this trend passes.

I wonder if it is in some way linked to the fact we have had a very bad couple of years and are facing a very difficult/uncertain future - it drives some people to think they need to toughen their kids up.

You get the same thing around 'hard work' when economic times are tough.

Everyone, the tough nuts and the wets, are just fucked up crazy humans trying their best to do the right thing for their kids. There has always been a range, and most people wind up OK.

Brefugee · 12/08/2022 07:48

I can create a social story later to teach him how to react but telling him to get a grip in the moment is not an option.

I get that, but what do you do in the moment when every other kid in the playpark is having their enjoyment of the park disturbed by a kid shrieking because they have to take their turn on the slide? My DCs were (still are) very different in terms of reactions to things, but my tantrummer would be immediately removed to a corner of the playpark and told that they have to wait their turn like everyone else, and that they are not to shriek like that. Shriekers have to sit quietly for 10 minutes before they are allowed back on the equipment. And if it persisted? We went home. There were and are still no rewards for tantrums or bad behaviour in our hose (and the other DCs got to play games at home, while the tantrummer had to sit quietly with me and show they could play nicely.

Which is why it always irked me when i encountered a "but x is so sensitive can't you let them go first?" - that leads to people pleasers in some kids and entitlement in others.

I don't know what the fuck is going on with MN right now but there's an absolute deluge of posts on here recently slagging off sensitive kids

To be fair what people are slagging off is a lot of parents' complete inability to stop their sensitive child impinging on everyone else's fun. A couple of minutes of tantrum is one thing, 30 minutes of it? sure i will be judging you. Very harshly. And actually after 15 minutes I'd be asking you to make it stop (ND children notwithstanding, that's a whole different story)

autienotnaughty · 12/08/2022 07:46

@carefullycourageous well put
Also repressing emotion for fear of rebuke

autienotnaughty · 12/08/2022 07:44

SpidersAreShitheads · 12/08/2022 07:35

Oh.

Here we go again.

I don't know what the fuck is going on with MN right now but there's an absolute deluge of posts on here recently slagging off sensitive kids. Cue the piling on of comments pointing out that kids need to be disciplined and toughen up blah blah. Usually served up with a side snark of "wait for the comments suggesting SEN".

Be glad when this trend passes.

Completely agree 👏👏👏👏

Dibbydoos · 12/08/2022 07:42

You wonder why kids behave like this. It's obviously environmental ie someone has taught the eldest and the youngest has either followed or been taught the same.

Stop having play dates. Talk to their parents. Can't understand why parents accept these types of damaging behaviours....but like I said thry are learned and reinforced by something/someone at home...

SpidersAreShitheads · 12/08/2022 07:35

Oh.

Here we go again.

I don't know what the fuck is going on with MN right now but there's an absolute deluge of posts on here recently slagging off sensitive kids. Cue the piling on of comments pointing out that kids need to be disciplined and toughen up blah blah. Usually served up with a side snark of "wait for the comments suggesting SEN".

Be glad when this trend passes.

acorntotree · 12/08/2022 07:34

I think some children are a lot more sensitive than others. There is always one in my dc's classes who seems to be crying at every pick up. They usually grow out of it or just grow up to be a sensitive soul. It would annoy me being around them a lot though, maybe try and plan things apart from them.

carefullycourageous · 12/08/2022 07:34

Kanaloa · 12/08/2022 07:18

Well I suppose what’s being discussed with regards to resilience here is the massively disproportionate reaction to everyday things. A hugely out of whack reaction (crying and screaming at age 10 so you don’t get told off) doesn’t suggest a very resilient child.

The word 'resilient' was misused by the OP and the thread has carried on misusing it.

Whether one cries loudly as a child or expresses anger/frustration loudly is nothing to do with resilience, the word is being trivialised to mean 'not expressing emotions in a noisy way'.

I think parents who have children who do not notice when they are hurt/upset or who brush everything off should be wary of feeling they have won the parenting trophy - brushing things off can mean we remain in negative situations much longer than the people who notice they are unhappy and complain, for example.

Brefugee · 12/08/2022 07:33

Think whatever you like bit it's not on you to say anything about it, they're not your DC so it's not your business. If they irk you so much then stop spending time with them.

Meh. They are family members? I'd definitely say things like "why are you making such a fuss over a tiny scratch" etc. And i would definitely tell the parents that if it doesn't stop i won' be spending time with them because it is exhausting and sets a bad example for your own DCs.

Bubbafly · 12/08/2022 07:30

I am with you OP, that nonsense would drive me nuts.

Kanaloa · 12/08/2022 07:18

carefullycourageous · 12/08/2022 06:58

Being able to deal with adversity and overcome it is part of being an adult This is true, but there is actually no real link between being a weeper and being good at picking yourself up afterwards. There is evidence that those who can't express their emotions openly are less resilient as they do not get over negative feelings as quickly as those who let them out.

The word 'resilient' is being used now to mean something more like 'doesn't exhibit they are upset' but actually the old British way of bottling it up was not working in the modern, changeable world.

Well I suppose what’s being discussed with regards to resilience here is the massively disproportionate reaction to everyday things. A hugely out of whack reaction (crying and screaming at age 10 so you don’t get told off) doesn’t suggest a very resilient child.

Kanaloa · 12/08/2022 07:17

carefullycourageous · 12/08/2022 06:39

There is no 'never' in any situation but one of the things we were taught to look out for specifically was under reacting.

Another thing you look out for is violence in play/violence to peers as it indicates a reenactment of violent to themselves. That’s why there’s no point saying ‘abused children are/do x.’ Like anyone else, they exist on a scale and any information should be taken in context. Not ‘oh he shouts a lot? Then he’s obviously not abused because if he was he’d be quiet and timid.’

ASimpleLampoon · 12/08/2022 07:13

For those "waiting for suggestion of SEN" . Having been through it, I guess some of us just jump straight to "This child\ parent is having difficulties they don't yet have skills to cope with. Rather than " terrible child, shit parent .

Giraffesandbottoms · 12/08/2022 07:11

YANBU I stopped being friends with someone whose child was an absolute wet lettuce - she was older than DS and when they played near each other if he jostled her arm or something reaching for an item she would cry.

she had no qualms about pulling his hair and kicking him/snatching and the mother never did anything beyond bullshit “gentle parenting” chats so I gave up. That, and her mother let her shit in a travel potty in a food court.

wellineverdidit · 12/08/2022 07:02

Carrieonmywaywardsun · 11/08/2022 22:14

Children are never to blame for behaviour. Clearly they aren't disciplined or comforted correctly

Absolute nonsense!

carefullycourageous · 12/08/2022 06:58

Being able to deal with adversity and overcome it is part of being an adult This is true, but there is actually no real link between being a weeper and being good at picking yourself up afterwards. There is evidence that those who can't express their emotions openly are less resilient as they do not get over negative feelings as quickly as those who let them out.

The word 'resilient' is being used now to mean something more like 'doesn't exhibit they are upset' but actually the old British way of bottling it up was not working in the modern, changeable world.

ASimpleLampoon · 12/08/2022 06:56

Spinasaurus · 11/08/2022 22:22

I wouldn't pat yourself too hard on the back about your amazing parenting. Kids are just different personalities. If my youngest gets hurt, he gives a performance like a diving premiership footballer. Eldest picks himself up and shrugs it off. Same eldest has a screaming meltdown if I take the trolley back in the supermarket without him. I could probably leave my youngest home alone for a fortnight before he noticed.

This! I have two children. Polar opposites. One highly senSitive mainLy due to his disabilities. The other couldn't ask for a better behaved More mature chikd. Both are loved and disciplined in the way appropriate for them. My parenting of the child with complex needs is at times c
criticized in spite of being much much harder and I doubt the critics would do any better if they had to deal with what I deal with every day. Not a word about what I do with my daughter. Even though its easy.

Spanielsarepainless · 12/08/2022 06:52

If all three are like this it's the parents overdramatising every little setback. There's lot of it about.

Florenz · 12/08/2022 06:44

I think a lot of parents fail to realise that their job is to raise adults, not children. Being able to deal with adversity and overcome it is part of being an adult

carefullycourageous · 12/08/2022 06:39

Kanaloa · 12/08/2022 02:43

I will say no ‘abused children don’t do xyz.’ Some children who have suffered abuse can behave badly in order to get attention. Some will echo/imitate the violence they see in their homes in order to act out their trauma/because they have learned that is how to deal with conflict. Some will be quiet and timid to avoid drawing attention
on themselves.

Not that I think these kids are abused, I think they’re just a bit spoiled and indulged. But I’m not keen on this silly ‘no abuse victims would never act like x, they only do Y.’

There is no 'never' in any situation but one of the things we were taught to look out for specifically was under reacting.

Porcupineintherough · 12/08/2022 05:57

Spinasaurus · 11/08/2022 22:22

I wouldn't pat yourself too hard on the back about your amazing parenting. Kids are just different personalities. If my youngest gets hurt, he gives a performance like a diving premiership footballer. Eldest picks himself up and shrugs it off. Same eldest has a screaming meltdown if I take the trolley back in the supermarket without him. I could probably leave my youngest home alone for a fortnight before he noticed.

Honestly, this^^

Swipe left for the next trending thread