Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does your children's high school give demit points...

140 replies

senneeds · 11/08/2022 18:36

Our local high schools give demerit points to kids who are late, have lost or forgotten things, have not handed in homework etc; if a child gets a certain number of points they get dentition.

I was wondering if other people's high school's do the same?

I ask because I was diagnosed with ADHD in my 50s... and I don't remember my high school giving out demerit points for these behaviours; it bothers me a lot that this happens in our local schools because a child being late, losing and forgetting things and not handing in homework are all ADHD traits.

A child can not get diagnosed as having ADHD unless they have evidence of these behaviours - so does that mean our schools are effectively punishing kids for their disabilities?

And while some schools might make allowances for the kids with ADHD and other SENs which have known executive function deficits...how about the kids who have not been diagnosed yet? It can't be great for their self esteem to be getting the message that how their brain works is so undesirable that they need to be punished or threatened with punishment.

I found a survey by ADHD UK who surveyed 800 teachers and found that 74% of these teachers did not recognise difficulty with organisation to be a symptom of ADHD and 78% did not recognise difficulty interacting socially to be a symptom of ADHD. adhduk.co.uk/teachers-and-adhd/

I also found this article about ADHD in the classroom thought provoking:
www.fintanoregan.com/fairness-isnt-giving-everybody-the-same-its-giving-everybody-what-they-need/

YANBU - yes my local high school gives demerit points to kids who are late, have lost or forgotten things, have not handed in homework etc.

YABU - no my local high school does not give demerit points to kids who are late, have lost or forgotten things, have not handed in homework etc.

OP posts:
ImWell · 11/08/2022 20:17

If your child has ADHD then you may have to work harder at getting them to school on time, and making sure that they have done their homework, but I don’t think it unreasonable that the school still expects that you do.

Doing your work and being on time are crucial skills for survival in the adult world as an employee; children are being done no favour by being allowed to let those slip.

Rosehugger · 11/08/2022 20:08

Every secondary school teacher and those running schools desperately need training in how to deal with kids with autism and ADD, as they are failing so many children. Also most schools are just too massive for any child to do well. Too anonymous, too many for teachers to deal with, classes too big, noisy and chaotic in corridors. Secondary school is an unpleasant and stressful experience. I don't understand why we shove kids into these massive silos, it's crazy.

Meem321 · 11/08/2022 19:59

Keyansier · 11/08/2022 18:40

What does ADHD got to give with getting demerit points?

If your children are often late, and repeatedly do not hand in homework on time, I'd expect them to get demerit points. What exactly is your problem here?

ADHD, Autism and Dyslexia can all 'cause' organisational issues despite the child's best efforts or intentions. Therefore these children are being discriminated against because of their special needs and the school's 'one size fits all' approach to discipline. That is, I think, the point the OP was trying to make. And it's the reason I left secondary mainstream education and went into special education where each child is treated as the individual they are, and ordanisational skills are taught and lack of those skills is accepted, not punished.

Sirzy · 11/08/2022 19:57

PrixChoc · 11/08/2022 19:44

My child attended a secondary school that gave demerits and detentions for things like this.

My child is disabled and has an EHCP, and struggles massively with organisational skills and time keeping. She was still given demerits every time, and despite speaking to the SENCO repeatedly about this and asking for more support it didnt change. The staff didn't make allowances due to her disability, and didn't work out that it was glaringly obvious that she needed more support.

This was one for many things that happened which lead to DD developing appalling school induced anxiety and emotionally based school non attendance. She now attends a special school, which was probably not really necessary as she has no learning disabilities.

I have since heard of another disabled child leaving the school for similar reasons, so the school hasn't learnt, and apparently doesn't care enough to change their policy. It's almost like it's a planned strategy to get rid of those undesirable disbaled children 🤔

Sadly bad schools will always find a way to push out. It’s so wrong.

I am lucky Ds has an ehcp with full 1-1 and his school adapt things to him we have had some issues but they have been quickly resolved

PrixChoc · 11/08/2022 19:44

Sirzy · 11/08/2022 18:45

If a child is regularly getting demerit points for the same thing then it is surely obvious to the parents and the school that that is an area they need more support it? If anything it can be a postive for having evidence of need.

My child attended a secondary school that gave demerits and detentions for things like this.

My child is disabled and has an EHCP, and struggles massively with organisational skills and time keeping. She was still given demerits every time, and despite speaking to the SENCO repeatedly about this and asking for more support it didnt change. The staff didn't make allowances due to her disability, and didn't work out that it was glaringly obvious that she needed more support.

This was one for many things that happened which lead to DD developing appalling school induced anxiety and emotionally based school non attendance. She now attends a special school, which was probably not really necessary as she has no learning disabilities.

I have since heard of another disabled child leaving the school for similar reasons, so the school hasn't learnt, and apparently doesn't care enough to change their policy. It's almost like it's a planned strategy to get rid of those undesirable disbaled children 🤔

Bessica1970 · 11/08/2022 19:39

To add - my son has ASD and has had one detention in three years despite needing help with organisation.

Bessica1970 · 11/08/2022 19:38

I haven’t voted because your choice of words is not neutral.
My school gives detentions for lateness and homework but it’s not unreasonable.
Students with diagnosed SEN receive support with homework and timekeeping. Undiagnosed SEN is recognised earlier by having a system which captures data and repeat transgressors are worked with to work out why they are not able to comply.

ricestardust · 11/08/2022 19:30

My kids' high school issues demerit points... and my child who gets demerits has ADHD. They rarely get demerits (so I'm hopeful the school makes some SEND allowances) but when they do it's been for not concentrating in class and, once, for forgetting equipment. (I know demerit points can be issued for late arrival but I drop my kids off so they're never late. I also try my best to stay on top of homework so it gets completed on time.)

Whatkindoflifeisthis · 11/08/2022 19:20

I used to get demerit points for being late/not doing homework/talking in class.

Should kids not be punished for poor behaviour because it might be ADHD?

HappyBinosaur · 11/08/2022 19:01

My son’s school gives ‘demerit’ points out (although they are called something different) and they proved useful both in identifying aspects of his adhd and also as evidence for his diagnosis.
He still gets them occasionally and I don’t think he should be exempt because he has adhd.

walsprj · 11/08/2022 18:52

We have similar. Appropriate allowances are made for students with SEND for a whole range of things in school, including this. Also as others have said a recorded pattern of a particular type of behaviour can be helpful evidence.

MargaretThursday · 11/08/2022 18:51

Ds has ADHD and ASD and when he doesn't give in homework he gets a "behaviour point". Thoroughly deserved because it's normally because he couldn't be bothered, and will freely admit that.

Sirzy · 11/08/2022 18:45

If a child is regularly getting demerit points for the same thing then it is surely obvious to the parents and the school that that is an area they need more support it? If anything it can be a postive for having evidence of need.

AppleKatie · 11/08/2022 18:43

The demerits can act as the evidence such children need to help with a diagnosis.

Keyansier · 11/08/2022 18:40

What does ADHD got to give with getting demerit points?

If your children are often late, and repeatedly do not hand in homework on time, I'd expect them to get demerit points. What exactly is your problem here?