Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does your children's high school give demit points...

140 replies

senneeds · 11/08/2022 18:36

Our local high schools give demerit points to kids who are late, have lost or forgotten things, have not handed in homework etc; if a child gets a certain number of points they get dentition.

I was wondering if other people's high school's do the same?

I ask because I was diagnosed with ADHD in my 50s... and I don't remember my high school giving out demerit points for these behaviours; it bothers me a lot that this happens in our local schools because a child being late, losing and forgetting things and not handing in homework are all ADHD traits.

A child can not get diagnosed as having ADHD unless they have evidence of these behaviours - so does that mean our schools are effectively punishing kids for their disabilities?

And while some schools might make allowances for the kids with ADHD and other SENs which have known executive function deficits...how about the kids who have not been diagnosed yet? It can't be great for their self esteem to be getting the message that how their brain works is so undesirable that they need to be punished or threatened with punishment.

I found a survey by ADHD UK who surveyed 800 teachers and found that 74% of these teachers did not recognise difficulty with organisation to be a symptom of ADHD and 78% did not recognise difficulty interacting socially to be a symptom of ADHD. adhduk.co.uk/teachers-and-adhd/

I also found this article about ADHD in the classroom thought provoking:
www.fintanoregan.com/fairness-isnt-giving-everybody-the-same-its-giving-everybody-what-they-need/

YANBU - yes my local high school gives demerit points to kids who are late, have lost or forgotten things, have not handed in homework etc.

YABU - no my local high school does not give demerit points to kids who are late, have lost or forgotten things, have not handed in homework etc.

OP posts:
JustLyra · 13/08/2022 14:06

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 13:06

This has gone from a thread about giving demerits, to one about support for children with disabilities.

Those with disabilities which entitle them to an ECHP obviously need support and get it in the form of 1 to 1 with a TA.

The OP was suggesting that children with disabilities such as ADHD, autism or dyslexia should not be given demerits.

You can't have one rule for some children and another rule for others. If a child is so severely impacted by their ADHD, autism or dyslexia that they can't get to lessons on time with the correct equipment, they probably shouldn't be in mainstream education.

Those with disabilities which should entitle them to an ECHP obviously need support and should get it in the form of 1 to 1 with a TA.

The OP was suggesting that children with disabilities such as ADHD, autism or dyslexia should not be given demerits for things that are purely down to their disabilities. It’s called reasonable adjustments.

This is also fucking hilarious “If a child is so severely impacted by their ADHD, autism or dyslexia that they can't get to lessons on time with the correct equipment, they probably shouldn't be in mainstream education.“ considering the fight people have whose children need specialist provision. My youngest is profoundly disabled. Can’t (and won’t) be able to read or write, can’t communicate, needs 1-1 care 24/7 and I still had to fight for her not to be allocated our local school with zero provision.

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 14:01

The · 13/08/2022 13:47

You CAN have one rule for some children and another rule for others 🙄This is called a reasonable adjustment, and these are enshrined in the Equality act. Failure to make reasonable adjustments leave schools wide open for a disability discrimination claim.

I can't tell if you are just ignorant @Hungryharriet or an ableist troll. I certainly don't believe you're a teacher in a UK mainstream, because I'm pretty sure the majority are aware of the many reasonable adjustments made for disabled children 🙄

How do you suggest teachers know which children have an invisible disability?

You appear to be assuming a lot about me, without actually knowing me.

Your very rude assumption that I am ignorant or a troll is entirely mistaken. I am a retired teacher, who taught in many mainstream private and state schools for over 20 years.

During my time in teaching, I never came across so many children who nowadays appear to have a disability. I can think of two, out of the many hundreds of children I taught, who might today be diagnosed with ADHD, and none whom I would have considered autistic.

(And you needn't bother coming back to say you're glad I don't teach currently - I've heard it before, and I was actually an excellent teacher, still in touch with many of my former pupils and their parents).

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 14:00

You can't have one rule for some children and another rule for others. If a child is so severely impacted by their ADHD, autism or dyslexia that they can't get to lessons on time with the correct equipment, they probably shouldn't be in mainstream education.

That would be wonderful if there were sufficient places for kids with additional support needs. Kids who really need the additional framework a specialist placement would give them can’t get a place, provision for mild to moderate learning needs is appalling - so they are placed in a mainstream setting and expected to get on with it. My DD has complex additional needs and it’s known that a mainstream setting will be wholly unsuitable for her - but she could still find herself in a mainstream setting if there is no specialist place available.

Thats unfair to her, and unfair to the staff who will be teaching her because the school environment isn’t set up to meet her needs. Punishing her for things outside of her control (she struggles with executive functioning on all levels) isn’t fair to her.

While additional needs provision is so poor, schools need to be run to meet the needs of all pupils, as education is a universal service. Kids can’t opt out of school, and for some kids mainstream school is a pretty hostile environment. Giving demerits is indeed lazy teaching and impacts kids who have no choice but to attend an unsuitable placement with minimal support.

The · 13/08/2022 13:47

You CAN have one rule for some children and another rule for others 🙄This is called a reasonable adjustment, and these are enshrined in the Equality act. Failure to make reasonable adjustments leave schools wide open for a disability discrimination claim.

I can't tell if you are just ignorant @Hungryharriet or an ableist troll. I certainly don't believe you're a teacher in a UK mainstream, because I'm pretty sure the majority are aware of the many reasonable adjustments made for disabled children 🙄

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 13:06

josephjohnson · 13/08/2022 12:03

We are working on strategies and working with the school to support them, that's the key thing. My point earlier wasn't specifically me saying my child is struggling, though, it was more about how there's an assumption that kids will have learned these skills by 11.
Child A has cerebral palsy and walks with a frame, they take more time to get around, collect things etc because of their physical disability.
Child B has ADHD (or dyslexia, is not NT), they take more time to get around as they are distractible, tend to leave books / bags behind so need to go and collect them.

Both children have a disability that impacts the way they manage the school day. But i don't think anyone would be saying child A just needs to walk more quickly and be more coordinated as they "aren't a toddler", would they?

This has gone from a thread about giving demerits, to one about support for children with disabilities.

Those with disabilities which entitle them to an ECHP obviously need support and get it in the form of 1 to 1 with a TA.

The OP was suggesting that children with disabilities such as ADHD, autism or dyslexia should not be given demerits.

You can't have one rule for some children and another rule for others. If a child is so severely impacted by their ADHD, autism or dyslexia that they can't get to lessons on time with the correct equipment, they probably shouldn't be in mainstream education.

Sirzy · 13/08/2022 12:17

It can be a big demand for some children especially if they are new to secondary school so haven’t learnt the ways yet.

a good school will have things in place to help all pupils at transition points to help things keep moving smoothly. Even using older students to help monitor the corridors and keep things moving.

it really shouldn’t be a big ask for a school to have support in place at such a basic level.

ds has an ehcp which includes in it how transitions between lessons will work but there will be plenty of other children who don’t have an ehcp which will still need the extra support

The · 13/08/2022 12:09

Both children have a disability that impacts the way they manage the school day. But i don't think anyone would be saying child A just needs to walk more quickly and be more coordinated as they "aren't a toddler", would they?

@Hungryharriet would

josephjohnson · 13/08/2022 12:03

Blahahahah · 13/08/2022 11:53

@josephjohnson what techniques are you developing for them to manage their time outside school? Can these not be applied inside school, eg alarm reminders?

We are working on strategies and working with the school to support them, that's the key thing. My point earlier wasn't specifically me saying my child is struggling, though, it was more about how there's an assumption that kids will have learned these skills by 11.
Child A has cerebral palsy and walks with a frame, they take more time to get around, collect things etc because of their physical disability.
Child B has ADHD (or dyslexia, is not NT), they take more time to get around as they are distractible, tend to leave books / bags behind so need to go and collect them.

Both children have a disability that impacts the way they manage the school day. But i don't think anyone would be saying child A just needs to walk more quickly and be more coordinated as they "aren't a toddler", would they?

Blahahahah · 13/08/2022 11:53

@josephjohnson what techniques are you developing for them to manage their time outside school? Can these not be applied inside school, eg alarm reminders?

josephjohnson · 13/08/2022 11:43

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 11:37

@josephjohnson Are you able to suggest just what kind of support these children need, and who should give it? Teachers will be in their classroom waiting for the class to arrive. At secondary school age, it's not too big a demand that children can get themselves to class. It doesn't take much effort.

As for 'not doing it on purpose,' I suppose you think that children never stop to chat with their mates when they are getting their things from a locker. If they are late to lessons I very much doubt that they 'can't help it.'

It's fairly easy to see you have not been a teacher.

No I'm not a teacher but I am a parent of a child with ADHD who also has ADHD herself.
If you're a teacher, what do you suggest? Because just telling my child to organise themselves better, not get distracted and to cure themselves of time blindness really isn't going to cut it I'm afraid.

Tallulasdancingshoes · 13/08/2022 11:40

My school uses class charts and we can award positive and negative points for loads of things. It’s really helpful because parents get more communication from school about day to day issues and it’s helps to give a clearer picture of what’s going on.

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 11:37

@josephjohnson Are you able to suggest just what kind of support these children need, and who should give it? Teachers will be in their classroom waiting for the class to arrive. At secondary school age, it's not too big a demand that children can get themselves to class. It doesn't take much effort.

As for 'not doing it on purpose,' I suppose you think that children never stop to chat with their mates when they are getting their things from a locker. If they are late to lessons I very much doubt that they 'can't help it.'

It's fairly easy to see you have not been a teacher.

The · 13/08/2022 11:36

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 11:02

@PrixChoc

Likewise, a parent can ensure a child arrives in school in time, but cannot ensure a child arrives to each lesson on time. So if they're regularly faffing around with their stuff at their locker and then arrive to class late, support needs to be provided by school, and if this isn't available then it is unfair to issue a demerit

What support are you thinking of? Teachers are there to teach. They're not there to waste their time standing by a locker to see if little Jimmy is capable of getting his books out on his own. These are secondary age children, not toddlers.

SEN support is usually delivered by TAs not teachers.

JustLyra · 13/08/2022 11:31

A good school will ensure that extra needs are catered for in their points system

Sadly a lot of schools are very poor when it comes to SEN. Which leads to children being punished for things outwith their control.

josephjohnson · 13/08/2022 11:21

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 11:02

@PrixChoc

Likewise, a parent can ensure a child arrives in school in time, but cannot ensure a child arrives to each lesson on time. So if they're regularly faffing around with their stuff at their locker and then arrive to class late, support needs to be provided by school, and if this isn't available then it is unfair to issue a demerit

What support are you thinking of? Teachers are there to teach. They're not there to waste their time standing by a locker to see if little Jimmy is capable of getting his books out on his own. These are secondary age children, not toddlers.

Are you not able to understand that some kids struggle with timekeeping and organisation even though they aren't toddlers? For some they will need support / strategies with this. They aren't doing it on purpose FFS.

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 11:03

@senneeds
Thank you for the link, it's very interesting. It doesn't change my opinion on the issue of demerits though.

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 11:02

@PrixChoc

Likewise, a parent can ensure a child arrives in school in time, but cannot ensure a child arrives to each lesson on time. So if they're regularly faffing around with their stuff at their locker and then arrive to class late, support needs to be provided by school, and if this isn't available then it is unfair to issue a demerit

What support are you thinking of? Teachers are there to teach. They're not there to waste their time standing by a locker to see if little Jimmy is capable of getting his books out on his own. These are secondary age children, not toddlers.

josephjohnson · 13/08/2022 10:15

PrixChoc · 11/08/2022 22:14

With regards to children with executive disfunction difficulties-

It is easier to remember your pencil case, as that is something you need every day. And easy for parents to support this.

PE kits, various aprons and food/equipment for technology less so. Especially when requests are made in class to bring in kit for a one off event, for e.g. food when cooking, PE kit for a drama session when they're covering dance. If you have a child like mine theyre unlikely to remember a request made in class, even if they do write it somewhere, and a parent has no clue the request has been made.

Likewise, a parent can ensure a child arrives in school in time, but cannot ensure a child arrives to each lesson on time. So if they're regularly faffing around with their stuff at their locker and then arrive to class late, support needs to be provided by school, and if this isn't available then it is unfair to issue a demerit.

With homework, it is easy to for parent to support when homework added to an app and clear instructions given. Less so if not added to the app or the instructions don't make sense to the parent who wasn't in class, or the child who has since forgotten.

I found it very difficult to support my child with their organisational skills for these reasons. My child never forgot their pencil case or stuff I thought it would be obvious they would need based on the timetable and what I recall from my school days 30 years ago. But there was still so much missed because it was communicated to the students and usually instanstly forgotten by my DC.

This is a HUGE frustration of mine. Our school is totally inconsistent as to where information is shared. Some teachers use teams for everything, some use Teams sometimes but not always. Some get kids to write in their planner, some tell the kids verbally but don't expressly ask them to write it down (yes it's obvious to you and me but not to a child that is both very literal and very distractible.
So I, as a parent with ADHD myself, find it really stressful trying to help my DC keep on top of things and also find it difficult to help them learn strategies because there are too many different options to consider.

bellac11 · 13/08/2022 10:11

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 07:13

The number of children in a secondary school who have ADHD Is small. The school can't be run as if all its students have a disability, it has to be run to fit the majority. There are plenty of NT children who are disorganized and forgetful too, and how are teachers meant to know, if a child might have a condition? To try to run a school on the lines the OP is suggesting would lead to chaos.

I think Im also uncomfortable with the constant labelling of behaviour

Children are children first, who may have any number of disorders

And as they are children and still learning, and going through puberty and other developmental stages, sometimes they will behave badly, sometimes they might forget something, sometimes they cant be bothered, sometimes they just dont want to do something if they dont enjoy it, sometimes they push boundaries

That is the same for all children, disorder or no disorder

Sometimes there is too much focus on 'that behaviour is because they have x disorder' which means that them just being a child is overlooked. Sometimes kids are just kids

There will be countless examples of an child who has an ND disorder being given a punishment unfairly because their behaviour was caused by their disorder. There will also be countless examples of a child who has an ND disorder being given a punishment because they were just being a kid and misbehaving.

senneeds · 13/08/2022 09:59

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 09:02

@senneeds

I don't think I missed the point of your post. Even including all children with a disability such as ADHD, autism or dyslexia, they still, hopefully, make up a small proportion of a school.

Where did you get the idea that children's brains develop from the back of their heads to the front? Children's brains are developing throughout their childhood and into early adulthood.

"I would understand if these 'demerit' points in schools were called something like 'recognition points' (ie points recognising repeat behaviours) and accruing points would lead the child to sit down with their form teacher to discuss why these behaviours keep happening and what they can do to change them

Changing the name of a demerit wouldn't change anything at all. In most cases, when children do accrue a lot of demerits this often does lead to a discussion, usually with the head of year. Giving a demerit or a detention has the effect of signalling to the child that their behaviour is unacceptable and needs changing. It's a clearer signal than a cosy little chat.

As I said previously, schools can't be run on the kind of lines you are suggesting. How are teachers meant to know that X, who forgets his pencil case, just might have a condition? The probability is that X is a neurotypical child who needs to get himself/ herself organized.

Children grow up and get jobs. It's doing them no favours if they are not taught to be organized when they are young.

Hungryharriet if you google developing teen brains it says all over the internet children’s brains develop from the back to the front. Their decision making process is one of the last areas to fully develop at the age of 25 which is why car insurance companies lower their premiums at this age.
but here is a link if it’s helpful to you
raisingchildren.net.au/pre-teens/development/understanding-your-pre-teen/brain-development-teens

OP posts:
PeekAtYou · 13/08/2022 09:54

I have a child with ADHD but he's learned to deal with school because I've supported him at home.

His school is 2000 students and make adjustments for kids with SEN. Eg his friend with autism was allowed to leave class a few minutes early when he was in the younger years because the busy corridors would be overwhelming and make him late for his next class.

I know that it is luck that my son has support at home and has persevered with learning skills that others find easy but it is what it is. He has behaviour points for forgetting stuff/being late but he's not bothered by them and says that teachers don't treat it as a big deal as he's apologetic and the reality is the kids are all sharing equipment anyway.

senneeds · 13/08/2022 09:50

Threelittlelambs · 13/08/2022 08:59

See I can't imagine any schools using demerit points leading to detention as a strategy to improve a dyslexic child's spelling - but it seems to be OK to do this to kids whose disability is struggling with disorganization.

Well o was with you until I read this!

Dyslexics also struggle with time keeping, organization and memory problem and spelling, reading, grammar. Individually to different degrees.

And those saying ‘I drop my kid off’ good for you, but the late marks are for each class not the minute they walk into school.

And yes teachers need to understand disabilities, they get little training.

DS - Dyslexic has been punished for all of these things, being late, forgetting homework, not being focused, put on report etc and it destroys their self esteem, which meant we spend longer working of this then dealing with strategies to help with the deficits.

Then!! School decided to have a dress down down for those without May behaviour points, he’d already been punished with detentions and now had to suffer a further punishment.

I was proud when his sisters refused to dress down and when asked by teachers ‘what they had down wrong’ clearly told them how they felt about the new policy on double punishments.

Sorry ThreeLittleLambs I was not taking a pop at dyslexics so sorry if you thought this - it is well known that ADHD, autism and dyslexia all have executive function deficits so elsewhere in my posts you will see I am suggesting this change for all kids to avoid exactly what you are saying unfortunately happens to you son. I was also wondering if you have thought of getting your son assessed for ADHD? if you look at the crested website which list schools who have specialist dyslexia training crested has recognised its quite common for dyslexia to also have another SEN like adhd, austim etc.

OP posts:
Threelittlelambs · 13/08/2022 09:49

Try working in poorer schools, the SEN ratio is very different.

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 09:31

@Threelittlelambs Nonsense. This is from a local government site:

Neurodiversity refers to the different ways the brain can work and interpret

information. It highlights that people naturally think about things differently. We

have different interests and motivations, and are naturally better at some things

and poorer at others.
Most people are neurotypical, meaning that the brain functions and processes

information in the way society expects.
However it is estimated that around 1 in 7 people (more than 15% of people in

the UK) are neurodivergent, meaning that the brain functions, learns and

processes information differently.

So, 15%. Schools can't be run as if most children are neurodivergent.

Threelittlelambs · 13/08/2022 09:10

I don't think I missed the point of your post. Even including all children with a disability such as ADHD, autism or dyslexia, they still, hopefully, make up a small proportion of a school

Get real a lot of classes have 50% SEN

High School not so much as most of them are thrown on lower ability classes or ‘extra’ support classes so you know the others are disturbed.