Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does your children's high school give demit points...

140 replies

senneeds · 11/08/2022 18:36

Our local high schools give demerit points to kids who are late, have lost or forgotten things, have not handed in homework etc; if a child gets a certain number of points they get dentition.

I was wondering if other people's high school's do the same?

I ask because I was diagnosed with ADHD in my 50s... and I don't remember my high school giving out demerit points for these behaviours; it bothers me a lot that this happens in our local schools because a child being late, losing and forgetting things and not handing in homework are all ADHD traits.

A child can not get diagnosed as having ADHD unless they have evidence of these behaviours - so does that mean our schools are effectively punishing kids for their disabilities?

And while some schools might make allowances for the kids with ADHD and other SENs which have known executive function deficits...how about the kids who have not been diagnosed yet? It can't be great for their self esteem to be getting the message that how their brain works is so undesirable that they need to be punished or threatened with punishment.

I found a survey by ADHD UK who surveyed 800 teachers and found that 74% of these teachers did not recognise difficulty with organisation to be a symptom of ADHD and 78% did not recognise difficulty interacting socially to be a symptom of ADHD. adhduk.co.uk/teachers-and-adhd/

I also found this article about ADHD in the classroom thought provoking:
www.fintanoregan.com/fairness-isnt-giving-everybody-the-same-its-giving-everybody-what-they-need/

YANBU - yes my local high school gives demerit points to kids who are late, have lost or forgotten things, have not handed in homework etc.

YABU - no my local high school does not give demerit points to kids who are late, have lost or forgotten things, have not handed in homework etc.

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 15:49

I was talking to JustLyra but feel free to actually say what it is you disagree with.

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 15:47

No, I don’t think we do agree.

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 15:43

Right, so we agree that a system of demerits for not meeting basic expectations in school is fine. We agree that reasonable adjustments should be made for pupils with SEN who struggle to meet those basic expectations, along with support in order to enable them to meet those expectations rather than just exempting them from them. We also agree that most children with SEN will be able to meet those expectations.

Feetache · 13/08/2022 15:43

My DD has ADHD. We copes with the timetable and time with the help of her friends. She marked down on reports for getting distracted, being off topic etc I don't worry about it too much as that's something she tries her best to overcome

JustLyra · 13/08/2022 15:40

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 15:36

Not a single person has said that every single pupil should be exempt.

But, as per OP, if we do not exempt every pupil, then we will be applying the system to those who do not have a diagnosis, yet do have those SEN. The logical conclusion is that to avoid this, no pupil should be expected to arrive at lessons on time.

That’s just bollocks.

Its the same kind of bollocks that’s used repeatedly to have no SEN adjustments in schools and workplaces.

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 15:36

Not a single person has said that every single pupil should be exempt.

But, as per OP, if we do not exempt every pupil, then we will be applying the system to those who do not have a diagnosis, yet do have those SEN. The logical conclusion is that to avoid this, no pupil should be expected to arrive at lessons on time.

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 15:35

Making out that kids with SEN are basically incapable of things like getting to lessons on time and so they should be exempt from those expectations as a starting point of discussion is doing them a disservice.

My DS has additional support needs. He doesn’t need particular adjustments in school, he’s academic and very compliant and the structured school day suits him well. However, his class teacher in primary 2 had a very old school approach to class discipline which included a traffic light system - he couldn’t understand why his name was on the “amber” light, he did something perfectly acceptable to his primary 1 teacher and didn’t understand that different teachers expected different things from him. He didn’t know how to get back on “green” and after several weeks of trying to figure it out had a complete meltdown getting ready for school one morning. I had a 7 year old self harming at the thought of turning up to class.

The class teacher said she had explained the rules, but not in a way he could understand (“I don’t have time to go over every detail of what’s required with every child who might be hard of understanding”). After discussion with the head teacher, the traffic light system in the class was changed - and my DS was able to cope better because he wasn’t sat with a public, constant reminder that he wasn’t as good as his peer group.

Children may not need particular adjustments but fairly minor - in the schools eyes - ways of managing behaviour can cause huge levels of anxiety for kids who already have more demands made on them coping with the busyness of the school day. They’re already expected to do what everyone else is, to fit in, and get on with it which immediately places them under additional pressure even if they manage to comply with school expectations - that comes at a cost to them. I don’t think it’s too much to consider how the day to day school environment might be made more manageable for kids who have no choice but to be there.

LaMadameCholet · 13/08/2022 15:29

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 07:13

The number of children in a secondary school who have ADHD Is small. The school can't be run as if all its students have a disability, it has to be run to fit the majority. There are plenty of NT children who are disorganized and forgetful too, and how are teachers meant to know, if a child might have a condition? To try to run a school on the lines the OP is suggesting would lead to chaos.

As a secondary school teacher at an outstanding school, I completely disagree with this. If we make reasonable adjustments for the (larger than you think, I suspect!) students who have needs, absolutely everybody prospers.

Littlefish · 13/08/2022 15:24

@Hungryharriet I'm sure you had a lovely teaching career, and I'm sure that you still hear from some of your former pupils.

However, I'm also sure that your teaching practices, attitude and knowledge are now completely outdated and would be damaging to pupils with either diagnosed or undiagnosed SEND.

You clearly have absolutely no idea about the state of SEND support in school and from outside agencies, the difficulty and time involved in getting a diagnosis, and then even more difficulty and time involved in trying to get an EHCP for a child.

Your comment that children with higher needs should be, or are in special schools is simply laughable. Do you have any idea of the shortage of special school places?

I have been a teacher for the last 22 years, a SENDCo and senior school leader. I also have a child with ADHD and Autism.

Your comments on this thread are unhelpful, patronising and completely ableist.

KittenKong · 13/08/2022 15:21

DSs school used to give demerits/referrals. A specific number per term and - something happened (parents called or punishment).

JustLyra · 13/08/2022 15:16

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 15:10

The point being made is that in many schools reasonable adjustments are not being made.

In a lot of cases of pupils with those SEN, reasonable adjustments aren't needed. I don't see this point being made and it needs to be. Making out that kids with SEN are basically incapable of things like getting to lessons on time and so they should be exempt from those expectations as a starting point of discussion is doing them a disservice.

That’s just whataboutery that comes up every time SEN comes up.

The OP is talking about children who are effectively being punished for their needs.

Not a single person has said that every single pupil should be exempt. The discussion was about pupils who are being discriminated against by these set things, but as always it’s been turned about into a discussion about pupils who are not in need.

Which is what always happens and allows schools (and workplaces) to continue ignoring the needs of those who are negatively impacted.

PrixChoc · 13/08/2022 15:16

The biggest disservice is to the children who do need the adjustments but aren't getting them. The ones who develop emotional or mental health problems or can no longer attend school because they aren't getting the adjustments and support they need, and the school can only operate a punitive approach.

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 15:10

The point being made is that in many schools reasonable adjustments are not being made.

In a lot of cases of pupils with those SEN, reasonable adjustments aren't needed. I don't see this point being made and it needs to be. Making out that kids with SEN are basically incapable of things like getting to lessons on time and so they should be exempt from those expectations as a starting point of discussion is doing them a disservice.

JustLyra · 13/08/2022 15:07

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 15:03

Not one single person has said that no kids with those SEN can manage it.

And yet the vibe on this thread is that having it as a basic expectation in schools is unreasonable, because of children with those SEN.

No, it’s not. The Op is stating that it’s unreasonable to expect it of pupils with SEN whilst making no adjustments for said SEN.

The vibe on this thread is actually that kids with SEN just have to suck it up for the greater good. Which is how threads like this always go on here.

im just waiting for the bingo card comment of how SEN kids actually damage the education of all the other kids

JustLyra · 13/08/2022 15:05

The point being made is that in many schools reasonable adjustments are not being made.

Some schools simply don’t deal well with their pupils with SEN.

My elder DDs are 22. I had to have a properly robust chat with their school when DD2’s attendance (all days missed were for broken bones or hospital appointments) meant her class missed out on a cinema trip and she got ten tonnes of shit from it from her classmates. Our neighbours had the same problem, with the same school, last year after their child required a three week hospital stay.
They’ve learned nothing and kids are still losing out because of their refusal to learn

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 15:03

Not one single person has said that no kids with those SEN can manage it.

And yet the vibe on this thread is that having it as a basic expectation in schools is unreasonable, because of children with those SEN.

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 15:01

Well my DC was one such child, and I know of one other from the same school.

Right, so let's not extrapolate from two DC and one school to all DC and all schools.

And even if a small minority of children that are struggling, it still needs to be addressed.

Yes, of course children who are struggling with organisation or punctuality should be flagged and supported. The easiest way to flag this, by the way, is by logging that behaviour across lessons and spotting patterns.

Kids who are pissing around in the corridors with their mates instead of going to lessons need some sort of system where this can be logged and then sanctioned.

Kids who can't be arsed to bring basic equipment need this logging and then sanctioning.

Kids who can't be arsed to do homework, not because they struggle with organisation but because they spend all evening on FIFA or whatever, need this logging and then sanctioning.

JustLyra · 13/08/2022 15:00

The idea that no kids with autism, dyspraxia, ADHD or other SEN can manage to achieve these basic expectations (some with more parental support than others) just isn't borne out by my daily experience. Yes, some have more severe SEN and need more in-school support or reasonable adjustments.

Not one single person has said that no kids with those SEN can manage it. Not one.

PrixChoc · 13/08/2022 14:51

You'd think, from this thread, that secondary schools are filled with kids miserably accruing demerits because they are late to every lesson and never have a pen because this is too much for them to manage and also that no one has ever talked to them about this or supported them with strategies. That's just not true

Well my DC was one such child, and I know of one other from the same school. Of course she wasn't late to EVERY lesson, and never forgot a pen, let's not talk extremes just to make your point 🙄 But even if she was late to one lesson a day, the points soon added up.

And even if a small minority of children that are struggling, it still needs to be addressed. Because I don't believe ANY child should develop mental health problems due to their experience at school. AND I'm not saying it was demerits or detentions gave my DD the problems. It was a death of a thousand cuts, this was just one thing out of many that added to school becoming too unmanageable for her. Some of these things couldn't been helped, but many could.

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 14:27

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 14:25

I have to say, the vast, vast majority of students in secondary school manage to get to lessons on time, if this is the expectation. The ones who don't are generally pissing about in the toilets with their mates. The vast majority have their equipment, or the ability to borrow from a mate. The idea that no kids with autism, dyspraxia, ADHD or other SEN can manage to achieve these basic expectations (some with more parental support than others) just isn't borne out by my daily experience. Yes, some have more severe SEN and need more in-school support or reasonable adjustments.

You'd think, from this thread, that secondary schools are filled with kids miserably accruing demerits because they are late to every lesson and never have a pen because this is too much for them to manage and also that no one has ever talked to them about this or supported them with strategies. That's just not true.

Thank you. I'm so glad I 'm not the only one who thinks this.

Sirzy · 13/08/2022 14:25

Good schools certainly make the time to help and support their pupils beyond just the academics. It is very much in teachers best interests to help with these small things in order to keep the classroom a calmer place.

a one size fits all approach doesn’t work.

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 14:25

I have to say, the vast, vast majority of students in secondary school manage to get to lessons on time, if this is the expectation. The ones who don't are generally pissing about in the toilets with their mates. The vast majority have their equipment, or the ability to borrow from a mate. The idea that no kids with autism, dyspraxia, ADHD or other SEN can manage to achieve these basic expectations (some with more parental support than others) just isn't borne out by my daily experience. Yes, some have more severe SEN and need more in-school support or reasonable adjustments.

You'd think, from this thread, that secondary schools are filled with kids miserably accruing demerits because they are late to every lesson and never have a pen because this is too much for them to manage and also that no one has ever talked to them about this or supported them with strategies. That's just not true.

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 14:19

Hungryharriet I very clearly said after I wrote my OP I was influenced by people's responses to recognise the importance of keeping some sort of record of these behaviours - isn't this the point of posting - to get the view of others to develop evolve an opinion?

What I do believe though is these kids should not be punished for showing the traits of their disabilities - what I don't get though is why you would think giving them detention is a better option over discussing with their teacher a way forward to help them improve these behaviours.

In fact I don't think any kids should be punished for executive function behaviours because all kids develop their brains at different times - records should be taken of behaviours and they should be having discussions with the parents and school how these can be improved.

Yes, I understand what you are saying. My point is that schools exist primarily to teach children. In order to do that effectively, children need to be in class, with the correct equipment. It's incredibly disruptive to have children walking in five minutes after a lesson has started, and unless teachers are strict about giving demerits or détentions, lateness would get out of control, with a resulting decline in education, which benefits no-one.

Teachers are extremely busy people as I'm sure you are aware. In an ideal world, they would have time to sit and talk to every student who is late for a lesson, record all these events and talk them over with the parents. In practice, this is not possible and children need to learn to be organized - all children, not just those who find it easy.

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 14:13

These are secondary age children, not toddlers.

Oddly enough children don’t grow out of things like autism, ADHD and dyslexia, or indeed trauma related processing difficulties. They need more time to develop strategies that will see them cope in adulthood - they can’t learn them at the same pace as children not so affected, and can’t learn them in the same way.

The idea that if a 12 year old can’t cope with multiple class changes, multiple changes in teachers, multiple changes in homework expectations and equipment needs (while also actively learning the curriculum) means they won’t cope with working life as an adult is ridiculous.

I can’t think of a time in my working life where every 50 minutes the task I’m doing, the place I’m doing it, the equipment I need, the language I’m speaking and the person leading the activity changes across the day 5 days per week. The strategies needed to cope in mainstream high school are very different to those needed to cope with adult working life - there are no comparisons really with how most adults live their lives.

senneeds · 13/08/2022 14:06

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 13:06

This has gone from a thread about giving demerits, to one about support for children with disabilities.

Those with disabilities which entitle them to an ECHP obviously need support and get it in the form of 1 to 1 with a TA.

The OP was suggesting that children with disabilities such as ADHD, autism or dyslexia should not be given demerits.

You can't have one rule for some children and another rule for others. If a child is so severely impacted by their ADHD, autism or dyslexia that they can't get to lessons on time with the correct equipment, they probably shouldn't be in mainstream education.

Hungryharriet I very clearly said after I wrote my OP I was influenced by people's responses to recognise the importance of keeping some sort of record of these behaviours - isn't this the point of posting - to get the view of others to develop evolve an opinion?

What I do believe though is these kids should not be punished for showing the traits of their disabilities - what I don't get though is why you would think giving them detention is a better option over discussing with their teacher a way forward to help them improve these behaviours.

In fact I don't think any kids should be punished for executive function behaviours because all kids develop their brains at different times - records should be taken of behaviours and they should be having discussions with the parents and school how these can be improved.

OP posts: