Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does your children's high school give demit points...

140 replies

senneeds · 11/08/2022 18:36

Our local high schools give demerit points to kids who are late, have lost or forgotten things, have not handed in homework etc; if a child gets a certain number of points they get dentition.

I was wondering if other people's high school's do the same?

I ask because I was diagnosed with ADHD in my 50s... and I don't remember my high school giving out demerit points for these behaviours; it bothers me a lot that this happens in our local schools because a child being late, losing and forgetting things and not handing in homework are all ADHD traits.

A child can not get diagnosed as having ADHD unless they have evidence of these behaviours - so does that mean our schools are effectively punishing kids for their disabilities?

And while some schools might make allowances for the kids with ADHD and other SENs which have known executive function deficits...how about the kids who have not been diagnosed yet? It can't be great for their self esteem to be getting the message that how their brain works is so undesirable that they need to be punished or threatened with punishment.

I found a survey by ADHD UK who surveyed 800 teachers and found that 74% of these teachers did not recognise difficulty with organisation to be a symptom of ADHD and 78% did not recognise difficulty interacting socially to be a symptom of ADHD. adhduk.co.uk/teachers-and-adhd/

I also found this article about ADHD in the classroom thought provoking:
www.fintanoregan.com/fairness-isnt-giving-everybody-the-same-its-giving-everybody-what-they-need/

YANBU - yes my local high school gives demerit points to kids who are late, have lost or forgotten things, have not handed in homework etc.

YABU - no my local high school does not give demerit points to kids who are late, have lost or forgotten things, have not handed in homework etc.

OP posts:
Littlefish · 13/08/2022 16:40

@Hungryharriet

My dd is a very high achieving student at a selective, mainstream private school.

If supported correctly at school she will achieve 3 A levels at A or A* grade.

She has been recommended to follow an academically rigorous university course.

She excels at both music and sport.

If school get their approach wrong, eg a teacher uses a critical, punitive, approach, she falls apart. Self harm, panic attacks, complete shutdown etc. She is approximately 30% less mature than her peers. She struggles massively to maintain (but not make) friendships. She requires additional support to help her negotiate a myriad of small social situations.

Will she always need this level of support? Hopefully not. She should reach full emotional maturity at approximately 26-28.

Does she need extra support at the moment? Absolutely.

I hope that she will register her difficulties when/if she goes to university and will receive reasonable adjustments and support.

I also hope that she will declare her disabilities when applying for jobs to ensure that she gets the right support.

Why shouldn't she receive support? She is an intelligent, talented young woman with a huge range of skills and attributes who would be an asset to any university or job.

Would you suggest not supporting someone with mental health issues, or someone who finds maths a challenge?

josephjohnson · 13/08/2022 16:39

@Hungryharriet you talk about students struggling later in life. Well yes of course they do. They don't suddenly become NT when then turn 18 or 21. School can support by helping the child work out what strategies they need to manage basic expectations of everyday life.
The education system is exceptionally rigid. As someone said, managing the bring in time 6 times a day in different rooms that change over two weeks plus homework given in many different formats along with the actual learning that is expected is really complex, and without reasonable adjustments some kids cannot manage this.
Once out of the education system, you have the opportunity to forge a career that plays to your strengths, if you're lucky, and / or have a workplace that follows the EA and puts reasonable adjustments in place. A RA, for example, would not behaving a rigid start / finish time. Entirely possible in many workplaces / professions.

But if the child spends their whole school life as a round peg constantly trying and failing to fit into a square hole, then this will have a profound impact on them. Is that what we really want?

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 16:34

Don't pretend that you're doing these kids a favour by dressing up "denying reasonable adjustments in line with their disability" as "high expections" because that is also bollocks.

I don't think you'll be able to find a post where I said children should be denied reasonable adjustments in line with their disability, because that would be bollocks.

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 16:33

I don't think you can say that that is because they are expected to bring a pen or get to lessons on time.

A student with dyspraxia, for example, may find PE very stressful, therefore have a higher level of stress and anxiety based around that, but not about punctuality. A student with autism may struggle with the social interaction, noise, or lights, but be fine about having a pen.

These are individuals.

PrixChoc · 13/08/2022 16:30

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 16:14

And this comment While you think most kids with SEN might be able to meet those expectations, that usually comes at a cost to the child which shows up in other areas of their lives. is the sort of thing I'm referring to when I'm saying how depressing it is that kids with SEN are being referred to in this general negative way. Starting with the assumption of deficit and damage....awful.

Don't pretend that you're doing these kids a favour by dressing up "denying reasonable adjustments in line with their disability" as "high expections" because that is also bollocks.

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 16:27

But I feel you are extrapolating your experiences with your children to other people's children when you say things like 'While you think most kids with SEN might be able to meet those expectations, that usually comes at a cost to the child which shows up in other areas of their lives'

Im actually drawing on research which shows higher levels of anxiety and stress across a range of children with additional support needs as a result of their school experiences.

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 16:26

A demerit is generally a logging of a behaviour rather than a sanction.

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 16:25

I’ve not said there should never be sanctions but there’s a difference between sanctions being a option of last resort and them being the first thing you reach for.

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 16:22

Both my kids have complex additional support needs, I certainly don’t start with an assumption of deficit and damage.

I am sure that is very challenging.

But I feel you are extrapolating your experiences with your children to other people's children when you say things like 'While you think most kids with SEN might be able to meet those expectations, that usually comes at a cost to the child which shows up in other areas of their lives'

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 16:19

Do you really think a punitive approach to behaviour management is the best, or indeed only, way to work?

I've seen where a system of no sanctions for poor behaviour ends up, so I'm generally in favour of a behaviour management system that includes them.

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 16:17

Both my kids have complex additional support needs, I certainly don’t start with an assumption of deficit and damage. A demerit based, punitive approach to behaviour management does start from a place of deficit for all kids, making no differentiation between unwilling or unable.

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 16:16

I’m not interested in a discussion with someone who’s aim is blatantly clear

You seemed to be suggesting that my aim was for no reasonable adjustments to be made for anyone, ever, so I'm not sure you do know.

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 16:14

And this comment While you think most kids with SEN might be able to meet those expectations, that usually comes at a cost to the child which shows up in other areas of their lives. is the sort of thing I'm referring to when I'm saying how depressing it is that kids with SEN are being referred to in this general negative way. Starting with the assumption of deficit and damage....awful.

JustLyra · 13/08/2022 16:14

Littlefish · 13/08/2022 15:24

@Hungryharriet I'm sure you had a lovely teaching career, and I'm sure that you still hear from some of your former pupils.

However, I'm also sure that your teaching practices, attitude and knowledge are now completely outdated and would be damaging to pupils with either diagnosed or undiagnosed SEND.

You clearly have absolutely no idea about the state of SEND support in school and from outside agencies, the difficulty and time involved in getting a diagnosis, and then even more difficulty and time involved in trying to get an EHCP for a child.

Your comment that children with higher needs should be, or are in special schools is simply laughable. Do you have any idea of the shortage of special school places?

I have been a teacher for the last 22 years, a SENDCo and senior school leader. I also have a child with ADHD and Autism.

Your comments on this thread are unhelpful, patronising and completely ableist.

👌

JustLyra · 13/08/2022 16:13

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 16:09

So you do think that there is a problem with demerit systems for basic expectations?

I’m not interested in a discussion with someone who’s aim is blatantly clear 👍🏻

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 16:12

How does this get kids to lessons on time? I mean, we're talking about schools with, say, 1500 kids. Do you really think it's unreasonable to start with the expectation that kids can get to lessons on time?

Do you really think a punitive approach to behaviour management is the best, or indeed only, way to work?

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 16:09

So you do think that there is a problem with demerit systems for basic expectations?

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 16:09

Most jobs want people who can be on time, be organized and be equipped with whatever they need to do their job. If children can't learn this while they're young, they will struggle later in life.

Thats ridiculous - children’s capacity for learning changes across their life course, therapeutic support and intervention can help as cognitive capacity changes, the ability to understand and put strategies in place to mitigate the impact of additional needs changes across time. Very often kids need time and space to learn - their capacity at 16 looks very different to their capacity at 12 and again at 19/20. We scaffold them until they have the ability to stand - for kids with disabilities that process takes longer and is more complex but it’s not impossible.

My DD is on average about 2 years behind her chronological age pretty much across the board. She is and will continue to catch up but expecting chronological age appropriate expectations of her simply sets her up to fail, she will get there but it will take much longer for her than for most other kids. In the meantime she won’t have a choice of a school setting that would give her the time she needs, so in the absence of specialist provision any mainstream setting will need to accommodate her.

MerryMarigold · 13/08/2022 16:08

My son has ADHD. He manages to be on time for classes. He hates getting into trouble so it's a good motivation for him to try to be on time, not forget homework etc. He prioritises it. His brother on the other hand does not have ADHD and gets way more points because he doesn't really care about the teacher's opinion of him. But a missed break or detention is not welcome.

JustLyra · 13/08/2022 16:07

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 15:57

We agree that reasonable adjustments should be made.

That they are not in some schools is not a problem with the demerit system, but a problem with SEN support.

Thats your opinion.

people are allowed different ones.

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 16:01

I’d rather we looked towards models where nurture and a trauma informed approach were universally applied

How does this get kids to lessons on time? I mean, we're talking about schools with, say, 1500 kids. Do you really think it's unreasonable to start with the expectation that kids can get to lessons on time?

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 15:58

Littlefish · 13/08/2022 15:24

@Hungryharriet I'm sure you had a lovely teaching career, and I'm sure that you still hear from some of your former pupils.

However, I'm also sure that your teaching practices, attitude and knowledge are now completely outdated and would be damaging to pupils with either diagnosed or undiagnosed SEND.

You clearly have absolutely no idea about the state of SEND support in school and from outside agencies, the difficulty and time involved in getting a diagnosis, and then even more difficulty and time involved in trying to get an EHCP for a child.

Your comment that children with higher needs should be, or are in special schools is simply laughable. Do you have any idea of the shortage of special school places?

I have been a teacher for the last 22 years, a SENDCo and senior school leader. I also have a child with ADHD and Autism.

Your comments on this thread are unhelpful, patronising and completely ableist.

@Littlefish
Yes, teaching methods change, but children don't. Today's approach of expecting all children with invisible disabilities to be somehow treated as extra special, with their every need catered for and adjustments made for them, does nothing at all to prepare them for adult life.

It's all very well during their school career to teach them that everyone else has to allow for their needs, but that doesn't translate into working life.

Most jobs want people who can be on time, be organized and be equipped with whatever they need to do their job. If children can't learn this while they're young, they will struggle later in life.

My comments reflect my opinions and are not designed to be patronizing, just truthful as I see it.

I also have a child with ADHD and Autism

How do these traits manifest themselves, and are they in mainstream education? If so, how does the school cater for them? Do you believe that they will be able to function in the world of work?

These are genuine questions because I am interested.

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 15:57

While you think most kids with SEN might be able to meet those expectations, that usually comes at a cost to the child which shows up in other areas of their lives. Demerit systems are deficit based, reinforcing what the child hasn’t don’t with no differentiation between unwilling or unable. Support for those with diagnosed SEN is nigh on impossible to obtain, those with undiagnosed needs have no chance.

I’d rather we looked towards models where nurture and a trauma informed approach were universally applied, such as the Glasgow model, than continually reinforce a deficit based approach.

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 15:57

We agree that reasonable adjustments should be made.

That they are not in some schools is not a problem with the demerit system, but a problem with SEN support.

JustLyra · 13/08/2022 15:54

The point - that is being deliberately missed - is that the reasonable adjustments are not being made

But do continue with your waffling attempts at derailing from the actual point of the thread 👍🏻