Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does your children's high school give demit points...

140 replies

senneeds · 11/08/2022 18:36

Our local high schools give demerit points to kids who are late, have lost or forgotten things, have not handed in homework etc; if a child gets a certain number of points they get dentition.

I was wondering if other people's high school's do the same?

I ask because I was diagnosed with ADHD in my 50s... and I don't remember my high school giving out demerit points for these behaviours; it bothers me a lot that this happens in our local schools because a child being late, losing and forgetting things and not handing in homework are all ADHD traits.

A child can not get diagnosed as having ADHD unless they have evidence of these behaviours - so does that mean our schools are effectively punishing kids for their disabilities?

And while some schools might make allowances for the kids with ADHD and other SENs which have known executive function deficits...how about the kids who have not been diagnosed yet? It can't be great for their self esteem to be getting the message that how their brain works is so undesirable that they need to be punished or threatened with punishment.

I found a survey by ADHD UK who surveyed 800 teachers and found that 74% of these teachers did not recognise difficulty with organisation to be a symptom of ADHD and 78% did not recognise difficulty interacting socially to be a symptom of ADHD. adhduk.co.uk/teachers-and-adhd/

I also found this article about ADHD in the classroom thought provoking:
www.fintanoregan.com/fairness-isnt-giving-everybody-the-same-its-giving-everybody-what-they-need/

YANBU - yes my local high school gives demerit points to kids who are late, have lost or forgotten things, have not handed in homework etc.

YABU - no my local high school does not give demerit points to kids who are late, have lost or forgotten things, have not handed in homework etc.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
senneeds · 13/08/2022 18:52

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 18:29

@senneeds I’ve linked to Glasgow’s document on promoting positive behaviour here Promoting Positive Behaviour.

The wider approach to education is reflected across their learning strategy but also through Health, Social Care, Housing and Police so hard to centre in one document. If you google Glasgow nurture and schools there’s loads of stuff that outlines the approach taken to really try and centre children within the education system. Glasgow have seen a 75% reduction in exclusions following this approach and using restorative approaches to behaviour management.

Things are by no means perfect, and Glasgow as a city has its challenges but I do think their less punitive approach is worth consideration.

thanks very much Jellycatspyjamas

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 18:41

JustLyra · 13/08/2022 16:42

Your aim since you started on the thread has been clear.

You’re full of the bollocks whataboutery that always happens on these threads.

its always the same few tranches that is blatant ableism, later dressed up as faux concern that adjustments actually just prevent students with SEN from seeing their potential.

Its bollocks. And clear.

Actually what's clear is that you don't have the faintest fucking idea about me, or my motivations for posting, and have decided to leap straight to assumptions and abuse rather than, I dunno, asking what my experience is that is leading to me objecting to children with those SEN having such negative generalisations made about them.

No fucking clue at all. Perhaps you should consider that before posting such pompous self-righteous tripe in future.

Newrumpus · 13/08/2022 18:39

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 18:33

I disagree with this. Reasonable judgment doesn’t mean the rules don’t apply. It means that there is support available to help the pupil comply with those rules.

It may also mean the rules are set aside. My DD hasn’t done homework throughout her primary years. She has a specialist tutor (privately funded) who works with her particular learning style, class based homework was increasingly stressful given how overwhelmed she was in coping with the school day - she does undertake learning activities at home but no formal homework. We’ll start working with her on more structured homework this year, which is her final year at primary.

You missed the part of the quote where I said ‘in most cases’. I would argue that your child is doing homework. She is just doing different homework which is also possible at secondary although the system I have described above works in most cases.

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 18:33

I disagree with this. Reasonable judgment doesn’t mean the rules don’t apply. It means that there is support available to help the pupil comply with those rules.

It may also mean the rules are set aside. My DD hasn’t done homework throughout her primary years. She has a specialist tutor (privately funded) who works with her particular learning style, class based homework was increasingly stressful given how overwhelmed she was in coping with the school day - she does undertake learning activities at home but no formal homework. We’ll start working with her on more structured homework this year, which is her final year at primary.

Newrumpus · 13/08/2022 18:32

Sirzy · 13/08/2022 18:25

If Ds isn’t allowed to eat what he wants and where he wants he wouldn’t eat and he would have massive meltdowns. He is at the end of year 7 and has never set foot in the dining room because he can’t cope with it at all. He eats in a safe place for him, he eats the same every day (an apple and a packet of crisps) to force anything else would be counterproductive. He is mainly tube fed and that is done at break time in school so he doesn’t go with his peers then either.

A reasonable adjustment here would be the same place and time each day. Loads of pupils have similar adjustments. They learn that they can comply with rules even though the rules might be different from those followed by others. If your son is allowed to eat at any time this causes problems with supervision - schools work to timetables so having individuals choosing when they eat each day would be difficult to manage. However, if this a particular need for your son, I would imagine it is written into his plan as this goes beyond being an adjustment that most schools could make and therefore he is likely to need enhanced support.

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 18:29

@senneeds I’ve linked to Glasgow’s document on promoting positive behaviour here Promoting Positive Behaviour.

The wider approach to education is reflected across their learning strategy but also through Health, Social Care, Housing and Police so hard to centre in one document. If you google Glasgow nurture and schools there’s loads of stuff that outlines the approach taken to really try and centre children within the education system. Glasgow have seen a 75% reduction in exclusions following this approach and using restorative approaches to behaviour management.

Things are by no means perfect, and Glasgow as a city has its challenges but I do think their less punitive approach is worth consideration.

Sirzy · 13/08/2022 18:25

If Ds isn’t allowed to eat what he wants and where he wants he wouldn’t eat and he would have massive meltdowns. He is at the end of year 7 and has never set foot in the dining room because he can’t cope with it at all. He eats in a safe place for him, he eats the same every day (an apple and a packet of crisps) to force anything else would be counterproductive. He is mainly tube fed and that is done at break time in school so he doesn’t go with his peers then either.

Newrumpus · 13/08/2022 18:20

PrixChoc · 13/08/2022 18:15

It can mean rules don't apply.

For example where there is a stict uniform policy, exceptions may be made if a child can't wear the uniform due to their disability or other protected characteristic.
Or where there are rules around lunches, but the school make an exception for children on special diets.

Obviously if appropriate support can be given to help to child meet the rule then this is preferable. But if the support isn't available then there should be no negative consequences for the child.

In my opinion the uniform should not be scrapped altogether nor should the lunch routines be entirely disregarded. Instead an adjustment would be a variation in the uniform which could be bespoke and alternative lunch time arrangements that mirror as closely as possible the routines followed by others.
This is different from allowing pupils to wear entirely what they choose or free choice about when, where and what they eat.
The rules still apply and this is an important principle. As an adjustment, pupils are supported to comply.

PrixChoc · 13/08/2022 18:15

Newrumpus · 13/08/2022 18:02

I disagree with this. Reasonable judgment doesn’t mean the rules don’t apply. It means that there is support available to help the pupil comply with those rules. If a pupil struggles to complete homework on time then they could complete homework at school under the supervision of staff, they can be reminded to attend this homework session and even brought to it by an staff or a senior pupils. But they should still have to complete homework and hand it in on time in most cases.

It can mean rules don't apply.

For example where there is a stict uniform policy, exceptions may be made if a child can't wear the uniform due to their disability or other protected characteristic.
Or where there are rules around lunches, but the school make an exception for children on special diets.

Obviously if appropriate support can be given to help to child meet the rule then this is preferable. But if the support isn't available then there should be no negative consequences for the child.

Newrumpus · 13/08/2022 18:15

Sirzy · 13/08/2022 18:05

All students can access it if needed.

im not saying the teachers don’t do a lot and a fantastic job of it but the TA support is there where needed to the help beyond what can be done in a classroom setting without

I understand what you are saying. What I am saying is that most of the SEN support is delivered in a way that is probably invisible to the pupils and parents. It is subtle and routine. It is the bread and butter of teaching.

Sirzy · 13/08/2022 18:05

Newrumpus · 13/08/2022 18:03

But this department will only be dealing with a minority of the SEN support required. If it is a normal state mainstream.

All students can access it if needed.

im not saying the teachers don’t do a lot and a fantastic job of it but the TA support is there where needed to the help beyond what can be done in a classroom setting without

Newrumpus · 13/08/2022 18:03

Sirzy · 13/08/2022 17:58

That will vary from school to school. Ds school has a fantastic learning support department that is mainly staffed by teaching assistants who also work throughout the school. It is the main reason I picked the school for ds because of the effort they had put into that set up

But this department will only be dealing with a minority of the SEN support required. If it is a normal state mainstream.

Newrumpus · 13/08/2022 18:02

The · 13/08/2022 13:47

You CAN have one rule for some children and another rule for others 🙄This is called a reasonable adjustment, and these are enshrined in the Equality act. Failure to make reasonable adjustments leave schools wide open for a disability discrimination claim.

I can't tell if you are just ignorant @Hungryharriet or an ableist troll. I certainly don't believe you're a teacher in a UK mainstream, because I'm pretty sure the majority are aware of the many reasonable adjustments made for disabled children 🙄

I disagree with this. Reasonable judgment doesn’t mean the rules don’t apply. It means that there is support available to help the pupil comply with those rules. If a pupil struggles to complete homework on time then they could complete homework at school under the supervision of staff, they can be reminded to attend this homework session and even brought to it by an staff or a senior pupils. But they should still have to complete homework and hand it in on time in most cases.

Sirzy · 13/08/2022 17:58

Newrumpus · 13/08/2022 17:54

No it isn’t. There are very few TAs in schools. The vast vast majority of SEN support is provided delivered by teachers.

That will vary from school to school. Ds school has a fantastic learning support department that is mainly staffed by teaching assistants who also work throughout the school. It is the main reason I picked the school for ds because of the effort they had put into that set up

Newrumpus · 13/08/2022 17:54

The · 13/08/2022 11:36

SEN support is usually delivered by TAs not teachers.

No it isn’t. There are very few TAs in schools. The vast vast majority of SEN support is provided delivered by teachers.

PrixChoc · 13/08/2022 17:54

Sirzy · 13/08/2022 17:26

This all seems to be focused on diagnosis and reasonable adjustment for the diagnosis. What is needed is reasonable adjustment for the individual if they are struggling with an area then the key thing is to find out why and what can be done to change it and not only for those who have a diagnosed problem.

I have no issue with a sensible demerit system but as well as being used for punishment when needed it also needs to be used to look for patterns and what can be done to stop the behaviour in the first place otherwise it’s pointless.

This is so true, and SEN support is supposed to be needs led, not diagnosis led.

However, for those people who think this is all unnecessary pandering, the only thing they CAN'T argue with is the law (although
@Hungryharriet will even try and argue against that 😂) and this only offers protection to those with a diagnosed disability .

Also as I said earlier for this to happen as is should, there should be the time, staff, funding and support services available to do this, and as we all know there just Isn’t.

So while we have strict rules, especially pointless ones about what colour hair bobble you wear, or whether you track the teacher with your eyes at all times, or whatever other nonsense they dream up AND YES I KNOW THIS IS ONLY SOME SCHOOLS but its gradually trickling down especially under Torys they love this shit), a punitive behaviour management system, plus lack of support for SEND and possible SEND we have a perfect storm where children who wouldn't have struggled in mainstream a several years ago now can't cope. But no wants to talk about this apart from people directly affected, it's all figures in ears lalalala.

senneeds · 13/08/2022 17:48

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 15:57

While you think most kids with SEN might be able to meet those expectations, that usually comes at a cost to the child which shows up in other areas of their lives. Demerit systems are deficit based, reinforcing what the child hasn’t don’t with no differentiation between unwilling or unable. Support for those with diagnosed SEN is nigh on impossible to obtain, those with undiagnosed needs have no chance.

I’d rather we looked towards models where nurture and a trauma informed approach were universally applied, such as the Glasgow model, than continually reinforce a deficit based approach.

Jellycatspypyjamas - thank you for your post - do you have any more information please or a link to the Glasgow model you refer to? I google it but I don't think I found it. thanks very much

OP posts:
Littlefish · 13/08/2022 17:46

@Hungryharriet before diagnosis at age 15, my dd was given endless detentions, demerits etc for being disorganised, handing work in late, being distracted in lessons, losing books, not finishing work in class. Her difficulties were handled appallingly by her school. They simply did not know enough about autistic and ADHD girls to recognise what was going on. My dd was bullied on a daily basis in an insidious, low level way.

Until she was formally diagnosed, no reasonable adjustments were put in place in spite of seemingly endless requests by me. I offered my full support at home, if only they would keep me informed about deadlines, expectations, difficulties etc. all of which they refused to do, saying 'at year 9/10/11 we expect students to be able to manage these things themselves'

Once her diagnosis was received, the school quickly realised they had got things very wrong. Medication helped to improve my dd's focus and concentration in lessons, and her grades soared.

Her school is still pretty shit at supporting her emotional needs, and the daily meltdowns and shutdowns at home bear witness to this.

ADHD and autism can be completely intertwined. There is no way of separating them in my dd.

Just because your dgs is able to get himself to lessons on time has absolutely no bearing on whether autistic children in general can do this. SOME autistic children would be able to. SOME children with ADHD would be able to.

It is absolutely impossible to generalise, and this is why a rigid approach to anything, including demerits, will never work in schools without potentially damaging and disadvantaging children with additional needs.

Sirzy · 13/08/2022 17:33

When you have met one person with Autism you have met one person with autism. (Point is the same for every other disability too)

josephjohnson · 13/08/2022 17:31

@Hungryharriet

"I have an undiagnosed autistic grandson, younger than your daughter appears to be, given that you are talking about A levels. To me his autism is very obvious, although I can't go into details on the internet. He attends a prestigious, extremely academic London private school. As far as I know (and I only know what his mum tells me), he has never been given my kind of sanction for being late to class or forgetting equipment. On the contrary, he he manages to organize himself very well.

Which serves to underline my point about autistic children (although the OP was talking about ADHD children), as long as they are not severely impaired, being capable of turning up to lessons on time, properly equipped. "
*
The fact that your grandson can turn up to lessons fully equipped and on time means absolutely nothing.* Every child is different and autism is not the same as ADHD which is not the same as dyspraxia etc. "Well he can do it so why can't you?" is just another stick used to beat those who are disabled or not NT. And you are such a classic example of someone who sees hidden disabilities as made up disabilities. I'm really glad you're no longer teaching.

Sirzy · 13/08/2022 17:26

This all seems to be focused on diagnosis and reasonable adjustment for the diagnosis. What is needed is reasonable adjustment for the individual if they are struggling with an area then the key thing is to find out why and what can be done to change it and not only for those who have a diagnosed problem.

I have no issue with a sensible demerit system but as well as being used for punishment when needed it also needs to be used to look for patterns and what can be done to stop the behaviour in the first place otherwise it’s pointless.

Hungryharriet · 13/08/2022 17:22

Littlefish · 13/08/2022 16:40

@Hungryharriet

My dd is a very high achieving student at a selective, mainstream private school.

If supported correctly at school she will achieve 3 A levels at A or A* grade.

She has been recommended to follow an academically rigorous university course.

She excels at both music and sport.

If school get their approach wrong, eg a teacher uses a critical, punitive, approach, she falls apart. Self harm, panic attacks, complete shutdown etc. She is approximately 30% less mature than her peers. She struggles massively to maintain (but not make) friendships. She requires additional support to help her negotiate a myriad of small social situations.

Will she always need this level of support? Hopefully not. She should reach full emotional maturity at approximately 26-28.

Does she need extra support at the moment? Absolutely.

I hope that she will register her difficulties when/if she goes to university and will receive reasonable adjustments and support.

I also hope that she will declare her disabilities when applying for jobs to ensure that she gets the right support.

Why shouldn't she receive support? She is an intelligent, talented young woman with a huge range of skills and attributes who would be an asset to any university or job.

Would you suggest not supporting someone with mental health issues, or someone who finds maths a challenge?

@Littlefish

Thank you for explaining how the disability impacts your daughter. Is this autism or ADHD? I am assuming that she gets to lessons on time and with the right equipment (based on her predicted grades).

I have an undiagnosed autistic grandson, younger than your daughter appears to be, given that you are talking about A levels. To me his autism is very obvious, although I can't go into details on the internet. He attends a prestigious, extremely academic London private school. As far as I know (and I only know what his mum tells me), he has never been given my kind of sanction for being late to class or forgetting equipment. On the contrary, he he manages to organize himself very well.

Which serves to underline my point about autistic children (although the OP was talking about ADHD children), as long as they are not severely impaired, being capable of turning up to lessons on time, properly equipped.

The OP was objecting to children with invisible disabilities receiving demerits. In my opinion, as long as they are reasonably capable, they should be given demerits if they can't turn up to class like other children. Why should the education of the majority of the class suffer because a teacher has to waste time going over what has been missed by latecomers ?

Would you suggest not supporting someone with mental health issues, or someone who finds maths a challenge

Of course not, but your question is too sweeping and generalized. It would depend on the level and type of mental illness, or the difficulties with maths. Some children are good at maths, others not.

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 16:56

If school get their approach wrong, eg a teacher uses a critical, punitive, approach, she falls apart. Self harm, panic attacks, complete shutdown etc. She is approximately 30% less mature than her peers. She struggles massively to maintain (but not make) friendships. She requires additional support to help her negotiate a myriad of small social situations.

You could be describing my daughter though she is younger. The right approach means she is happy, engaged and able to learn. The wrong one results in high levels of anxiety, school refusal and no learning. The right approach doesn’t actually cost anything in terms of additional resources but requires flexibility from the school and a positive approach from her class teacher.

Jellycatspyjamas · 13/08/2022 16:52

I don't think you can say that that is because they are expected to bring a pen or get to lessons on time.

Thats a pretty reductive way of looking at it. The student with autism may have struggled with a noisy PE lesson, struggled with noisy corridors, struggled with the bell telling them to change class, raising general stress levels. The knowledge that they need to have a pen or get a demerit may make them repeatedly check they have a pen (in the right colour) and overthink what might happen if the pen gets lost. They then need to negotiate social stuff at break time etc while knowing they need to comply with what the school requires.

These stresses are cumulative, with a myriad of situations to negotiate which on their own aren’t a big deal but combined across the course of the day start to add up.

And that’s assuming a diagnosis and some staff understanding of their particular, individual challenges. No diagnosis, or staff who take the “I just want them to bring a pen” approach and the school day quickly becomes very challenging.

JustLyra · 13/08/2022 16:42

noblegiraffe · 13/08/2022 16:16

I’m not interested in a discussion with someone who’s aim is blatantly clear

You seemed to be suggesting that my aim was for no reasonable adjustments to be made for anyone, ever, so I'm not sure you do know.

Your aim since you started on the thread has been clear.

You’re full of the bollocks whataboutery that always happens on these threads.

its always the same few tranches that is blatant ableism, later dressed up as faux concern that adjustments actually just prevent students with SEN from seeing their potential.

Its bollocks. And clear.