Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I the only one who thinks scrimping and saving can go and get fucked for bare essentials

335 replies

Freedomfromunfairbills · 11/08/2022 17:45

All the advice about cost of living seems to be ways you can scrimp and save to possible cobble together enough money to stay alive on bare necessities such as food, water, etc. Am I the only one thinking fuck this we just should not accept this when many of the companies jacking up their prices are making record profits. Even if it’s technically possible why on earth should I give up new clothes, gadgets, TV, holidays abroad, ect all to fund the obscene riches of the one percent. Instead of this advice on how to possibly meet these we actually need to say on mass no we are not surfs under the feudal system and we refuse to become a peasant class enough is enough. We should demand the government steps on and nationalises these companies and demand immediate taxes on the ultra rich to fund it all. I’ve always been fairly right wing and conservative but surely this is simply some kind of feudalism that will reduce many of us to little more than peasants and ruin the quality of life for many. Aibu?

OP posts:
Fifteentoes · 11/08/2022 23:45

Macaroni1924 · 11/08/2022 21:25

I will probably get flamed for this but why are so many people on here against rich people? I am not well off by any means and am concerned about the rise in costs, watching pennies and cutting back. Do I grudge people who have money, absolutely not. If I could find some way of selling something that people want and make a mint then I sure as hell would and I certainly don’t think I should be penalised because I came up with something to make me rich. They already pay higher taxes and IF they make their money honestly then what harm does that have? Bloody good for them, I wish I could join them. I’ve been in positions when I’ve needed help financially and because our income is above a certain threshold there was nothing for us at all. We both work full time, pay our bills but it counts for nothing. I personally have more issue with those who drain the system when there are people out there in real need who don’t receive enough.
Id rather spend my life appreciating what we do have and have achieved whilst hoping our child achieves more than being bitter about the guy down the road in his mansion.

Just on a point of accuracy: the rich don't pay higher taxes, as a percentage of their income.

Fifteentoes · 11/08/2022 23:36

MushMonster · 11/08/2022 18:23

For good.
Voting is the main power we hold.
We can all collect signatures to request early elections. If we get enough signatures in they do have to discuss the matter in parlament. We can do this each month, till they get the idea.
We are not powerless.
And exercising our power does not need to be illegal, violent, detrimenting to the economy or to others in any way.

No, voting is no power at all.

The Tories and their allies are busy manipulating the system to ensure they can't lose. And just in case they do, they've also ensured the destruction of any left wing power within Labour and the positioning of an establishment stooge as leader who will change nothing of substance.

It's over, pretty much. The combination of the failing capitalist system since 2008 and the reality of climate change, means that either the ruling class who can afford it are going to have to give up a lot of wealth, or a substantial number of workers who can't are going to have to starve. But the ruling class saw it coming, got their ducks in a row and made sure the mechanism to choose the first option is no longer there. And people resisted it, or failed to see its urgency, long enough to let them.

Jumpstark · 11/08/2022 23:35

Friars23 · 11/08/2022 18:19

Because those with great wealth and assets have only massively increased their wealth whilst the majority have seen wages in real terms flat lining since the 2008 crash.

Even if we could grab and share all their extra wealth we'd only have £7k each. It wouldn't last very long.

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 11/08/2022 23:29

Tory neoliberalcapitalism has been leading up to this point for 30 years. People voted for it time and again despite the warnings from those who were branded "loony left" by the right wing media. None of this should be a surprise. It's just the inevitable end game of too many people being "fairly right wing and conservative".
Maybe more people will educate themselves and make different choices at the next election after this winter.

Jki · 11/08/2022 23:27

About 2,750 billionaires control 3.5% of the world’s wealth, the Paris-based Global Inequality Lab said in a report Tuesday. That’s up from 1% in 1995, with the fastest gains coming since the pandemic hit, the group said. The poorest half of the planet’s population owns about 2% of its riches.

Jki · 11/08/2022 23:22

rnsaslkih · 11/08/2022 23:12

It’s ridiculous to think the “super rich” will fund everything. They’ll just emigrate. And because they are super rich, they’ll have people to arrange that instantaneously and will probably already own a lovely mansion abroad.

Raising the top rate of taxation fails to bring in a larger amount of tax overall. Remember when GPs cut their working hours to avoid going into that top rate?

I do agree we have major problems. But thinking that the super rich are the solution is fantasy.

Plus when you consider the likes of Kate Middleton’s family, who worked their way from poor to rich, why should people like them pay for you? If the rich are going to pay for us all, why would anyone work? Was anyone forced to buy their party supplies? Did they shit on people on their way up? No. They live in a nice house. Good for them. They probably give plenty to charity.

Quick search shows the Middleton’s net worth at £50 million, that is made and lost in a day for UHNW individuals.

People with millions aren’t the ones who are rich anymore, they have a paltry net worth compared to the ones who are billionaires.

rnsaslkih · 11/08/2022 23:12

It’s ridiculous to think the “super rich” will fund everything. They’ll just emigrate. And because they are super rich, they’ll have people to arrange that instantaneously and will probably already own a lovely mansion abroad.

Raising the top rate of taxation fails to bring in a larger amount of tax overall. Remember when GPs cut their working hours to avoid going into that top rate?

I do agree we have major problems. But thinking that the super rich are the solution is fantasy.

Plus when you consider the likes of Kate Middleton’s family, who worked their way from poor to rich, why should people like them pay for you? If the rich are going to pay for us all, why would anyone work? Was anyone forced to buy their party supplies? Did they shit on people on their way up? No. They live in a nice house. Good for them. They probably give plenty to charity.

BitOutOfPractice · 11/08/2022 23:08

@DustinsHat yes. This. I am so sick of the “at least Tories know what a woman is” posts on here. Yes they know what a woman is so they can screw us over! They couldn’t give a toss for women’s rights! The erosion of women’s rights in the 12 years has been horrifying. Yet still this “at least…” whataboutery gets spouted here unchallenged

DustinsHat · 11/08/2022 23:01

theworldhas · 11/08/2022 22:12

@OlympicProcrastinator
Neither do the politics of greed. There is a balance to be had. These conversations always seem to be a tale of extremes between hardline socialists and capitalists. I think the parties in parliament are reflective of this polarisation.

Thankfully we have a centrist government in waiting, led by Keir Starmer. The alternative is another five years of the right wing free market extremists that are running the country into the ground - they spent the first decade decimating public services while blathering about Brexit, and now the cost of living crisis is here as well. They’ve achieved nothing.

Exactly. Forums like these are full of Tory shills who post things like 'I'm a lifelong Labour voter and I could never vote for Starmer!' And people believe that and start to think well I could never vote for Starmer either! It's the oldest trick in the book and people are falling for it!

You may also think that the Tories will protect your sex based rights, but they're no friend of women. It is women who are left looking after the kids when men up and leave relationships, WE are the ones who have to try to protect them from all of this. They've fucked us all right over.

Notlosinganyweight · 11/08/2022 22:58

LaurieFairyCake · 11/08/2022 17:51

I think people are too stupid to realise that the rich have everyone else's money Hmm

They didn't make it - they just sold you something at a price you were (mostly forced) to buy...

They kind of did 'make' it - they printed a fuck tonne of it.

It's sad that a lot of people seem defeated on this thread. We do sort of have to show our strength or we will just be walked over. There is more of us than them and I fear at this rate the resolution will literally come down to that.

BitOutOfPractice · 11/08/2022 22:58

So @Cyclebabble if we “all” have to cut back, what should the top 10% cut back on while the poorest cut back on feeding their kids?

I think that’s what the op is saying. That the pain should be equally distributed. Or if not equally, then at least a bit more equally than it is now.

BitOutOfPractice · 11/08/2022 22:53

@NSA2103 have you really come here to correct SPAG? Have you any idea what a an utter knob that makes your look?

Cyclebabble · 11/08/2022 22:47

Auntieobem · 11/08/2022 18:17

That's not what OP means. I get it. Why should the majority cut back to the bare necessities to pay into the coffers of energy companies and line the pockets of the rich?

For a while I am afraid we all need to cut back. Foreign holidays are not an essential. There is a good case for a further windfall tax, but we are all going to face increased costs even then. There is a war on and we cannot get all of the gas and electricity we need without buying it on an open market. For the very poorest I would support a social tarriff, but we have no rights to foreign holidays when times get tough. Sorry.

BitOutOfPractice · 11/08/2022 22:46

You expect a Tory government to nationalise essential services? Or even give a shiny shit for ordinary people? Of you do I’ll have whatever you are smoking

NSA2103 · 11/08/2022 22:42

"En masse", not "on mass".

Doobydoo · 11/08/2022 22:39

I agree with@BattenburgDonkey .

birdfeeders · 11/08/2022 22:39

And I have a very low income and have hardly been abroad

birdfeeders · 11/08/2022 22:38

But gadgets and holidays abroad are entirely optional luxuries. Don't see why you would demand them as a basic human right. How much of a nanny state are you wanting, exactly?

Getoff · 11/08/2022 22:37

I think people are too stupid to realise that the rich have everyone else's money

This isn't true. The majority of the non-rich population's money has not be been stolen or borrowed by the rich. The rich may have money that used to belong to everyone else, which everyone else used to by goods and services from the rich, or pay rent to the rich, or pay interest to the rich. But that money now belongs to the rich, it stopped belong to everyone else when they spent it.

Winederlust · 11/08/2022 22:35

latetothefisting · 11/08/2022 21:52

How much do you think the 1% earn that not paying them would make any difference to the cost of living?

I don't necessarily morally agree with the ridiculous bonuses they get, but say the CEO of EDF got a million pound bonus this year and it gets cancelled. Divide that between 10 million customers and that's....10p off my estimated energy bill of, whatever it's currently been estimated at, say £3500. Well that will make all the difference. Get rid of bonuses for the CEOs of tescos and vodafone too and pass those savings onto the customers and I'm laughing, I'll be able to go on holiday with that saved 30p.

Lots of things are a bit shit and unfair in Britain at the moment, and its not unreasonable to discuss what we could do to improve them, but yabu to just rant without making any sense, and to suggest that a year or two not having a holiday or the latest iphone makes life not worth living.

You know that the likes of BP are posting profits of $billions per quarter?
we're not talking about director bonuses here, we're talking about the actual profits of the business, most of which go straight in the shareholders' pockets.

Jki · 11/08/2022 22:33

OP you lost me at ect.

Me as well.

That’s is a shocking thing to write, isn’t it?

ladygindiva · 11/08/2022 22:33

Macaroni1924 · 11/08/2022 21:29

No, I wouldn’t because I have been there. Did u grudge people who made smarter choices than me in life no.

That comment reveals so much. And none of it good.

InChocolateWeTrust · 11/08/2022 22:30

I’ve always been fairly right wing and conservative

Well you pretty much got what you voted for then!

There are alternatives you know. You don't have to vote for Liz Thatcher Truss.

InChocolateWeTrust · 11/08/2022 22:28

I'm not sure there has ever been a time when mankind has had such excess/surplus as a society (beyond what we need to live) where it's been distributed fairly. As long as there has been societal wealth it has pretty much always been hogged by a lucky few.

That said, the UK are worse than other countries. We seem to be modelling ourselves on the most unequal economies (...the US) rather than the more equal like the nordics.

HMSSophia · 11/08/2022 22:27

PlanetNormal · 11/08/2022 18:21

Well, OP, if you have “always been fairly right wing and conservative”, then congratulations. You have got the capitalist, privatised, free-market economic system you voted for, and it’s a bit late to start whinging about it now. You are the Turkey who rather stupidly voted for Christmas. So suck it up.

What she said. In bold italics.

Swipe left for the next trending thread