Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I the only one who thinks scrimping and saving can go and get fucked for bare essentials

335 replies

Freedomfromunfairbills · 11/08/2022 17:45

All the advice about cost of living seems to be ways you can scrimp and save to possible cobble together enough money to stay alive on bare necessities such as food, water, etc. Am I the only one thinking fuck this we just should not accept this when many of the companies jacking up their prices are making record profits. Even if it’s technically possible why on earth should I give up new clothes, gadgets, TV, holidays abroad, ect all to fund the obscene riches of the one percent. Instead of this advice on how to possibly meet these we actually need to say on mass no we are not surfs under the feudal system and we refuse to become a peasant class enough is enough. We should demand the government steps on and nationalises these companies and demand immediate taxes on the ultra rich to fund it all. I’ve always been fairly right wing and conservative but surely this is simply some kind of feudalism that will reduce many of us to little more than peasants and ruin the quality of life for many. Aibu?

OP posts:
User135644 · 12/08/2022 18:02

Proudboomer · 11/08/2022 18:56

If you want new clothes, gadgets, TV, holidays abroad, ect then you like capitalism but you think the rich should fund it for you?

New clothes/shoes need to be bought at some point (if you've got growing children they're essentials). Smart phones are basically essentials now for day-to-day life with apps and a paperless society. Holidays abroad are a luxury that people will need to give up but going on holiday, in itself, is hardly 'capitalism'

Tv also becomes more of a need if you're stuck at home all the time because you can't afford to go anywhere.

Capitalism creates all these so called luxuries that often become essentials and cost a lot of money. Having clothes on your back and shoes on your feet is not a luxury.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 17:58

User135644 · 12/08/2022 17:52

We get the leaders we deserve, we really do.

40 years of privatisation/neoliberal madness and Corbyn and Milliband who at least offered an alternative were demonised like fuck, all so the Tories could continue to fuck over the non-rich.

Yes, they really do have it in for the low-paid, with those inflation-busting minimum wage rises, big increases in the tax-free allowance and the pensions triple lock, paid for by (checks notes) oh yes, higher taxes on top earners and the loss of their tax allowances.

Still, let’s not let facts get in the way of good old-fashioned ignorance and prejudice, eh?

Do you also blame the government for your waistline and general feeling of lethargy?

MsPincher · 12/08/2022 17:55

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 04:23

Are you sure?

I’m not a bit and I’m a gc feminist.

User135644 · 12/08/2022 17:53

ImWell · 12/08/2022 17:52

Do you think that the bookmakers have this one wrong then?

I reckon that they are about right, with Conservatives being slight favourites. I think they are perhaps slightly underestimating the effect of the tories getting their act together and the likely Labour civil war that will inevitably be in full-swing as the election campaign gets under way.

The next 2 years will be that shit that even the Teflon Tories will be kicked out. Starmer is a fence sitting centrist. An unradical version of Blair. Not what is needed given the mess the country is going to be.

User135644 · 12/08/2022 17:52

Despairingof · 11/08/2022 18:55

So you voted for this government to treat the poor like they’ve always treated the poor and only care now it impacts you? 😂🤣 True Tory there

We get the leaders we deserve, we really do.

40 years of privatisation/neoliberal madness and Corbyn and Milliband who at least offered an alternative were demonised like fuck, all so the Tories could continue to fuck over the non-rich.

MsPincher · 12/08/2022 17:52

Jki · 12/08/2022 15:56

Thank you - my phone had distorted the
article, now I see it.

This is interesting but it doesn’t take into account net worth?

what about Assets and employment benefits that aren’t taxed as income? for example, I used to work in an office where many staff had drivers and company cars, if the Director wasn’t using the car/driver we could be utilise those resources without them being taxed to us as a benefit. Bad example in the scheme of monetary gain but all I can think of. Company would also buy cars for cash, list them as an asset, take the depreciation, and staff would get a new BMW without benefit taxation.

It’s fairly easy once your net worth reaches a certain level to legally avoid taxation in the U.K. so this seems to paint an odd picture.

I don’t know if I am making a lucid point or not but when I don’t have a migraine I will read these stats more thoroughly.

I was a tax advisor for years. Any provision of a company car should be reported as a benefit in kind. Passing ownership of a car for under value is also a benefit in kind. Both are fully taxable if you are using them for personal use. What your ex employer was doing sounds like tax evasion (or perhaps you just misunderstood what they were paying in tax).

it’s actually not at all easy to legitimately avoid tax at all (lots of weird myths on mn but irl it really isn’t). Of course there are schemes set up by the government to avoid tax but promote other behavior (like pensions) but beyond that it’s pretty tough these days.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 17:52

User135644 · 12/08/2022 17:49

Two more years of abject misery and then we can get 5 years of Keir Starmer offering little alternative. What's the point?

Do you think that the bookmakers have this one wrong then?

I reckon that they are about right, with Conservatives being slight favourites. I think they are perhaps slightly underestimating the effect of the tories getting their act together and the likely Labour civil war that will inevitably be in full-swing as the election campaign gets under way.

User135644 · 12/08/2022 17:49

MushMonster · 11/08/2022 18:18

I do agree with the need of demanding them to do something to sort it.
That is not by rioting, striking or demonstrating.
It is by flipping wiping them from parliament.

Two more years of abject misery and then we can get 5 years of Keir Starmer offering little alternative. What's the point?

MsPincher · 12/08/2022 17:45

Winederlust · 11/08/2022 22:35

You know that the likes of BP are posting profits of $billions per quarter?
we're not talking about director bonuses here, we're talking about the actual profits of the business, most of which go straight in the shareholders' pockets.

The shareholders of large listed companies like bp are insurance companies and pension funds. Basically the dividends are funding pensions and life insurance. They are very large companies and actually the market is competitive so they don’t tend to make excessive profits over time. But it’s not owned by some “rich guy” rather by teachers pension funds, etc.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 17:44

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 17:40

Wealth distribution does matter, but it doesn’t always follow the distribution that you would expect, and throws up some confounding data. On the first point, egalitarian Sweden has higher wealth inequality than the UK

Wealth yes but on income, the UK is one of the worst in Europe.

It’s been falling in the UK in recent years, with GINI now 34%, about the same level as Germany.

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 17:43

ImWell · 12/08/2022 17:39

But in the UK, under this government, we tax the rich more than we tax lower earners, and more than Labour taxed them. What then is your evidence for your claim?

AS i told you, Cons have run the economy v badly, so lowest 5th have seen incomes fall, top 5th have seen them increase.

You can't tax people more who earn just a few '000 above the Threshold.

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 17:40

Wealth distribution does matter, but it doesn’t always follow the distribution that you would expect, and throws up some confounding data. On the first point, egalitarian Sweden has higher wealth inequality than the UK

Wealth yes but on income, the UK is one of the worst in Europe.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 17:39

BaileySharp · 12/08/2022 17:35

Taxing the rich is more of a left wing idea. The reason conservatives are reluctant to do much is preventing companies from getting profits and taxing the rich is completely against their ideals. Perhaps you aren't as right wing as you thought!

But in the UK, under this government, we tax the rich more than we tax lower earners, and more than Labour taxed them. What then is your evidence for your claim?

anniegun · 12/08/2022 17:39

Democratically we voted to keep things as they are and let the wealthy take most of the money. I have no idea why

MsPincher · 12/08/2022 17:36

BaileySharp · 12/08/2022 17:35

Taxing the rich is more of a left wing idea. The reason conservatives are reluctant to do much is preventing companies from getting profits and taxing the rich is completely against their ideals. Perhaps you aren't as right wing as you thought!

the government does tax companies profits.

MsPincher · 12/08/2022 17:36

ImWell · 12/08/2022 17:30

But the last time we checked there were more people who voted for the Conservatives than voted for any other party, so of course they get to form the government.

If you want a different party to govern you need to convince people to vote for that.

Labour supporters never seem to want to do this, though, preferring to insult and sneer at Conservative voters instead.

One day maybe this will change, and when it does, if your arguments are persuasive you may get the government that you want.

This. I’m not a Tory voter but I accept democracy and all this sneering and demonizing of Tory voters doesn’t help.

BaileySharp · 12/08/2022 17:35

Taxing the rich is more of a left wing idea. The reason conservatives are reluctant to do much is preventing companies from getting profits and taxing the rich is completely against their ideals. Perhaps you aren't as right wing as you thought!

MsPincher · 12/08/2022 17:34

Auntieobem · 11/08/2022 18:17

That's not what OP means. I get it. Why should the majority cut back to the bare necessities to pay into the coffers of energy companies and line the pockets of the rich?

The prices of energy has gone up due to a shortage of supply. You don’t have to pay for it but if you want to that’s the price. Actually because of the cap it’s being sold at a loss. The energy suppliers aren’t making any profits although the energy producers are.

so why should you pay for it? Well if you want it you need yo pay the price. That’s life I’m afraid

ImWell · 12/08/2022 17:30

MushMonster · 12/08/2022 17:24

This I totally agree with! All your questions and no answers.
Some people seem to be just resigned to keep accepting this.
I cannot comprehend it.
I just want the whole of the current goverment gone for good.

But the last time we checked there were more people who voted for the Conservatives than voted for any other party, so of course they get to form the government.

If you want a different party to govern you need to convince people to vote for that.

Labour supporters never seem to want to do this, though, preferring to insult and sneer at Conservative voters instead.

One day maybe this will change, and when it does, if your arguments are persuasive you may get the government that you want.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 17:28

Jki · 12/08/2022 17:00

You’ talking about extreme wealth which is often hidden away. That is not what they were highlighting.

Yes, I think this is where my problem lies, the accumulation and acquisition of wealth among UHNW people isn’t fairly taxed and they represent what, some insane % of global wealth. To me, that % of people are far more relevant to global economics (and British) than people who earn over £100k in the U.K. .

Two different populations.

As above, though, wealth isn’t taxed at all in the UK, so we definitely can’t claim that the super rich are avoiding or evading it.

It’s also worth bearing in mind what the very richest people’s wealth is in. Elon Musk is inconceivably wealthy, but it’s not in cash, it’s in the value of his companies. His money is building electric cars, sending rockets into space, pretending to build a fast underground railway and so on. It’s being productive, providing services and goods that people want, jobs for tens of thousands of people and so on.

It may well be better for society if it was shared among a load of pension funds, but nearly all of the value in his companies is additive to the total amount of wealth in the world, it’s not taken from others.

MushMonster · 12/08/2022 17:24

Mistlewoeandwhine · 12/08/2022 16:58

The government should step in and protect us - that’s literally their job. They are meant to represent our interests. This unholy mishmash of Brexit and rampant unchecked capitalism cannot be blamed on Covid and Putin otherwise other countries would be suffering equally. This is literally the Tories and their supporters’ faults. And it shouldn’t be about taxing people on eg 65k a year more. It’s about dealing with stuff at the SOURCE - big business.

Why are workers having to get their wages topped up with benefits if the company shareholders are making a profit?
Why are wages not rising?
Why were house prices artificially inflated during 2020?
Why has there not been a sensible cap on fuel bills?
Why is the NHS being run into the ground?
Why are water companies not forced to fix all leaks?
Why were all schools, now academies, handed over to their private ownership including land that belongs to us?
Why was the Royal Family given a financial stake in offshore wind farms for no reason?
Why did past governments not realise that relying on political foreign enemies for fuel was a bad idea?
Why have we not been investing more in other sources of energy eg making every new build have solar panels?
Why are a lot of the new builds in city centres being sold off to the Chinese/Russian/Saudi markets and not even being offered on sale to local people?

etc etc etc…

I’m so angry that people are still voting for these idiots. It’s wicked what’s happening and a lot of people don’t seem to care until something happens which affects them personally.

This I totally agree with! All your questions and no answers.
Some people seem to be just resigned to keep accepting this.
I cannot comprehend it.
I just want the whole of the current goverment gone for good.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 17:20

Jki · 12/08/2022 15:56

Thank you - my phone had distorted the
article, now I see it.

This is interesting but it doesn’t take into account net worth?

what about Assets and employment benefits that aren’t taxed as income? for example, I used to work in an office where many staff had drivers and company cars, if the Director wasn’t using the car/driver we could be utilise those resources without them being taxed to us as a benefit. Bad example in the scheme of monetary gain but all I can think of. Company would also buy cars for cash, list them as an asset, take the depreciation, and staff would get a new BMW without benefit taxation.

It’s fairly easy once your net worth reaches a certain level to legally avoid taxation in the U.K. so this seems to paint an odd picture.

I don’t know if I am making a lucid point or not but when I don’t have a migraine I will read these stats more thoroughly.

No, it’s all based on income (which, to be fair to me, was the metric in the post that I was replying to). We don’t have a wealth tax in the UK, nor any place where we have to officially declare our net worth, so there’s not any similar data for that.

Wealth distribution does matter, but it doesn’t always follow the distribution that you would expect, and throws up some confounding data. On the first point, egalitarian Sweden has higher wealth inequality than the UK, and on the second, a wealth-driven measure would show (for example) that a newly qualified lawyer on £100,000 a year who’s just spent his savings on some tailor-made shows and a Saville Row suit would be worse off than a pensioner on £100 per week who can’t heat their home but who has £200 in a teapot to put towards her funeral.

Jki · 12/08/2022 17:00

You’ talking about extreme wealth which is often hidden away. That is not what they were highlighting.

Yes, I think this is where my problem lies, the accumulation and acquisition of wealth among UHNW people isn’t fairly taxed and they represent what, some insane % of global wealth. To me, that % of people are far more relevant to global economics (and British) than people who earn over £100k in the U.K. .

Two different populations.

Mistlewoeandwhine · 12/08/2022 16:58

The government should step in and protect us - that’s literally their job. They are meant to represent our interests. This unholy mishmash of Brexit and rampant unchecked capitalism cannot be blamed on Covid and Putin otherwise other countries would be suffering equally. This is literally the Tories and their supporters’ faults. And it shouldn’t be about taxing people on eg 65k a year more. It’s about dealing with stuff at the SOURCE - big business.

Why are workers having to get their wages topped up with benefits if the company shareholders are making a profit?
Why are wages not rising?
Why were house prices artificially inflated during 2020?
Why has there not been a sensible cap on fuel bills?
Why is the NHS being run into the ground?
Why are water companies not forced to fix all leaks?
Why were all schools, now academies, handed over to their private ownership including land that belongs to us?
Why was the Royal Family given a financial stake in offshore wind farms for no reason?
Why did past governments not realise that relying on political foreign enemies for fuel was a bad idea?
Why have we not been investing more in other sources of energy eg making every new build have solar panels?
Why are a lot of the new builds in city centres being sold off to the Chinese/Russian/Saudi markets and not even being offered on sale to local people?

etc etc etc…

I’m so angry that people are still voting for these idiots. It’s wicked what’s happening and a lot of people don’t seem to care until something happens which affects them personally.

Itisasecret · 12/08/2022 16:39

Jki · 12/08/2022 15:56

Thank you - my phone had distorted the
article, now I see it.

This is interesting but it doesn’t take into account net worth?

what about Assets and employment benefits that aren’t taxed as income? for example, I used to work in an office where many staff had drivers and company cars, if the Director wasn’t using the car/driver we could be utilise those resources without them being taxed to us as a benefit. Bad example in the scheme of monetary gain but all I can think of. Company would also buy cars for cash, list them as an asset, take the depreciation, and staff would get a new BMW without benefit taxation.

It’s fairly easy once your net worth reaches a certain level to legally avoid taxation in the U.K. so this seems to paint an odd picture.

I don’t know if I am making a lucid point or not but when I don’t have a migraine I will read these stats more thoroughly.

What they are saying is that the top earners via paye etc already pay the biggest amount of tax out there and once you tip into 100k you hit 60% tax and then drop to 45% you then lose tax free pension contributions. They already shoulder 25% of the income tax. That’s before other taxes.

You can’t just keep taxing positive contributors more to provide even bigger packages for negative contributors.

You’ talking about extreme wealth which is often hidden away. That is not what they were highlighting.