Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I the only one who thinks scrimping and saving can go and get fucked for bare essentials

335 replies

Freedomfromunfairbills · 11/08/2022 17:45

All the advice about cost of living seems to be ways you can scrimp and save to possible cobble together enough money to stay alive on bare necessities such as food, water, etc. Am I the only one thinking fuck this we just should not accept this when many of the companies jacking up their prices are making record profits. Even if it’s technically possible why on earth should I give up new clothes, gadgets, TV, holidays abroad, ect all to fund the obscene riches of the one percent. Instead of this advice on how to possibly meet these we actually need to say on mass no we are not surfs under the feudal system and we refuse to become a peasant class enough is enough. We should demand the government steps on and nationalises these companies and demand immediate taxes on the ultra rich to fund it all. I’ve always been fairly right wing and conservative but surely this is simply some kind of feudalism that will reduce many of us to little more than peasants and ruin the quality of life for many. Aibu?

OP posts:
Whitehorsegirl · 12/08/2022 18:42

The narrative is always that the big corporations can do whatever they want because profit comes above everything else in the UK, including human lives and basic standards of living.

And if people dare to complain they are branded as: work-shy, lazy, and stupid or whatever nonsense the right wing press is telling us to believe.

There is a weird, masochistic mentality of almost enjoying the serf/feudal system in England.

You only have to read some of the comment on this thread...

Many countries have chosen to keep utilities and transport in public ownership so it is not exploited by a few people who are only in it to make obscene profit.

So there is a perfectly good alternative. It just means moving from the Dickensian mentally into a more equal society.

I personally don't want hand-outs from government to pay my electricity bills so the money can go back into the pockets of the energy companies.

I want transport, water, electricity and gas to go back into public ownership and a government who stops pandering to the needs of a few non-doms donors and CEOs.

People who work should have a decent life style as a result. I don't see why millions of people are expected to work everyday and yet struggle to even buy food, keep a roof over their head and be able to heat their home.

Unfortunately OP you are part of the problem if you voted conservative. Everyone who voted for Johnson and for Brexit got us in this mess.

Next time learn your lesson. If you keep voting for right-wing, rich people who have gone to private school, have a network of equally rich friends and have never really done a day's work in their life, don't be surprised that they don't care about you or anyone else when things get tough.

User135644 · 12/08/2022 18:38

QuandaleDingle · 11/08/2022 19:29

Agree one hundred percent

I earn plenty of money but now these cunts think they can rape my pay packet every month im going to be a lot worse off. I'll survive but that's all

I work fucking hard to earn the money I do like most of us. and it should be more than plenty to provide both the basics of life AND still have the treats / fun stuff that make life worth living as well as save a bit

I flit between anger and despair these days

I suppose paying for the anti-depressants all this misery causes is a luxury as well now. You'll need to cut them back on them as well as not renew your TV license (luxury) and trade in your Iphone for an old Nokia. No alcohol either, that's a luxury.

Working full time and still living in penury is madness.

MsPincher · 12/08/2022 18:36

likeminded · 12/08/2022 18:32

They will just end up taxing the already overtaxed middle class like they always do. The rich make up the laws to benefit themselves and make up the tax laws so they don't have to pay tax.

We’ve already established the rich pay the highest percentage of income in tax though. Look up thread.

im not the rich but better to deal in facts.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 18:34

User135644 · 12/08/2022 18:27

Well, Boris Johnson is hardly a fiscal Conservative for one thing. Also because the whole economic system has collapsed anyway. They have to look after pensioners because hardly anyone under about 50 - who isn't rich - actually vote Conservative anymore.

It's workers who are having to bear the brunt of the insane energy madness while big business makes a ton of profit. Nobody can afford to buy a home anymore either after Thatcher sold off all the council homes and stopped building them.

We're living in an oligarchy.

You seem to be conflating workers with lower-earners there, which I don’t think makes sense. Very few people who are very high earners aren’t working. Bankers, lawyers, surgeons, hedge-fund managers, racing drivers, footballers, they all work.

MsPincher · 12/08/2022 18:34

Mistlewoeandwhine · 12/08/2022 16:58

The government should step in and protect us - that’s literally their job. They are meant to represent our interests. This unholy mishmash of Brexit and rampant unchecked capitalism cannot be blamed on Covid and Putin otherwise other countries would be suffering equally. This is literally the Tories and their supporters’ faults. And it shouldn’t be about taxing people on eg 65k a year more. It’s about dealing with stuff at the SOURCE - big business.

Why are workers having to get their wages topped up with benefits if the company shareholders are making a profit?
Why are wages not rising?
Why were house prices artificially inflated during 2020?
Why has there not been a sensible cap on fuel bills?
Why is the NHS being run into the ground?
Why are water companies not forced to fix all leaks?
Why were all schools, now academies, handed over to their private ownership including land that belongs to us?
Why was the Royal Family given a financial stake in offshore wind farms for no reason?
Why did past governments not realise that relying on political foreign enemies for fuel was a bad idea?
Why have we not been investing more in other sources of energy eg making every new build have solar panels?
Why are a lot of the new builds in city centres being sold off to the Chinese/Russian/Saudi markets and not even being offered on sale to local people?

etc etc etc…

I’m so angry that people are still voting for these idiots. It’s wicked what’s happening and a lot of people don’t seem to care until something happens which affects them personally.

Most of these questions show a lack of understanding of facts though and an unwillingness to see practically and perhaps some indulgence in conspiracy theories. I suggest you look into the answers using reliable sources.

for example: the royal family was not “given” any stake in offshore wind farms. The coastal shelf belongs to the crown estates (perhaps where you are getting confused). The revenues of the crown estates belong to the uk gov treasury. Obviously if a wind farm operator wants to put turbines on the crown estates land they need to lease it from them.

another example: generally planning conditions do require new build properties to have solar panels. So that question makes no sense.

Another example: common sense tells me that it is impossible to identify every leak in the many millions of miles of water pipes, never mind fix them all. Clearly it would not be practical to fix them all at once anyway.

and so on.

likeminded · 12/08/2022 18:32

They will just end up taxing the already overtaxed middle class like they always do. The rich make up the laws to benefit themselves and make up the tax laws so they don't have to pay tax.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 18:28

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 18:16

Wales isn't a separate country & has limited powers/spending.

Try looking at EU countries and how their utilities are managed.

Such as in France, where each municipality has to negotiate the water supply with private companies to come up with their own deal?

OK, taking that as the example, and given the well-known problems with it, what do you feel is better or worse there than the model in England?

User135644 · 12/08/2022 18:27

ImWell · 12/08/2022 18:10

Wow, that’s quite a swerve to completely avoid engaging with the facts that disproved your previous post.

Do you even realise that you were doing it, or did your cognitive dissonance take,over your higher executive functions for a minute?

Come on, have some integrity here; how can you square your claim that they only care for the rich with the fact that they have increased the minimum wage, pensions and and tax-free allowance so much, funded by increases in tax and NI for the highest earners and by removing their allowances?

Well, Boris Johnson is hardly a fiscal Conservative for one thing. Also because the whole economic system has collapsed anyway. They have to look after pensioners because hardly anyone under about 50 - who isn't rich - actually vote Conservative anymore.

It's workers who are having to bear the brunt of the insane energy madness while big business makes a ton of profit. Nobody can afford to buy a home anymore either after Thatcher sold off all the council homes and stopped building them.

We're living in an oligarchy.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 18:26

Jki · 12/08/2022 18:16

Yes, you are correct, It is possible that use of the car owned by the company was taxed as a benefit in kind to the employee. Rumour was that it wasn’t.

the cars were usually sold after 3 years and replaced, all in order there.

The company constantly hired tax advisors (might have had a different title) to help us reduce corporate taxes - they were paid on commission as a % of reduced taxes. So this is more what I mean by it is “easier to avoid taxes when you have more money” people who have more wealth can afford to find more and more ways to avoid taxation. I have seen it in small ways and I’m sure it happens amongst friends at the top 0.01% who hold an astonishing disproportionate % of wealth.

Those tax advisers were paid to find ways that the company was paying more tax than the state required them to.

The UK’s tax regime is ludicrously complicated, and firms can very easily overlook completely legitimate tax treatments that they are supposed to be using.

That’s very different to tax evasion, which definitely is a problem, but which is quite unlikely to be recommended by professional tax advisers.

Itisasecret · 12/08/2022 18:26

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 18:22

@Itisasecret I haven't called anyone anything at all, thats against MN rules but if you want rid of the Tories, constantly criticising Labour/Starmer but rarely the Tories, seems an odd way to achieve it.

All that will get you is another 5 years of the Cons and a long list of posts saying how terrible tory voters are.

I sometimes think that many people are just happy being in opposition.

I think that’s the issue, Labour are happy being in opposition because they are not opposing anything. They need to sort it out and pronto.

If they keep doing what they are doing, a Truss government with tax cuts and cooperation cuts will win another election. The Labour Party ate itself in the last election (still is) and that’s partly why we are where we are. That’s on them.

bellac11 · 12/08/2022 18:25

User135644 · 12/08/2022 18:02

New clothes/shoes need to be bought at some point (if you've got growing children they're essentials). Smart phones are basically essentials now for day-to-day life with apps and a paperless society. Holidays abroad are a luxury that people will need to give up but going on holiday, in itself, is hardly 'capitalism'

Tv also becomes more of a need if you're stuck at home all the time because you can't afford to go anywhere.

Capitalism creates all these so called luxuries that often become essentials and cost a lot of money. Having clothes on your back and shoes on your feet is not a luxury.

All those things should be bought second hand to be honest.

But I agree about the rhetoric about Milliband and Corbyn although never liked Corbyn myself

I remember the 'warning' given to the public by Cameron about Milliband, 'vote Labour and get chaos with Ed Milliband'

and look where we are now 'Dave'.

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 18:22

@Itisasecret I haven't called anyone anything at all, thats against MN rules but if you want rid of the Tories, constantly criticising Labour/Starmer but rarely the Tories, seems an odd way to achieve it.

All that will get you is another 5 years of the Cons and a long list of posts saying how terrible tory voters are.

I sometimes think that many people are just happy being in opposition.

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 18:16

justasking111 · 12/08/2022 18:14

Water and rail is nationalised in Wales both have the same problems as the private sector does in England. So it's a weak argument

Wales isn't a separate country & has limited powers/spending.

Try looking at EU countries and how their utilities are managed.

Itisasecret · 12/08/2022 18:16

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 18:14

@Itisasecret
Nah, that’s lazy and a lie. Plus troll hunting is against MN rules. I am a lifelong labour voter, previous paid up member of the party and in a unionised profession. Their “action” has been non existent. Where have they been when the Tories have been destroying the country? My posting history will show I’m no bot, I’ve got nothing but disdain for this government
Others I’ve seen posting are the same. However, being disappointed in a rubbish government and equally calling out Labour for being a rubbish opposition does not a troll make. Even if you don’t agree with it. That’s lazy, lacks critical thinking and is against mn rules. If people were so inclined they could report and get all the shill accusations removed so stop wasting your time. It’s a bad argument anyway

Sure some are genuine but anyone who says Labour and Tories are the same, clearly hasn't bothered to find out anything about the party or just wants to plant the seed in peoples minds that as they are all the same, might as well stick with what we've got i.e a Tory supporter.

See it all the time on here etc.

Or they have an opinion which they are entitled to have. People can be equally fed up with both parties. Calling people like that trolls or shills is pretty pathetic.

Jki · 12/08/2022 18:16

MsPincher · 12/08/2022 17:52

I was a tax advisor for years. Any provision of a company car should be reported as a benefit in kind. Passing ownership of a car for under value is also a benefit in kind. Both are fully taxable if you are using them for personal use. What your ex employer was doing sounds like tax evasion (or perhaps you just misunderstood what they were paying in tax).

it’s actually not at all easy to legitimately avoid tax at all (lots of weird myths on mn but irl it really isn’t). Of course there are schemes set up by the government to avoid tax but promote other behavior (like pensions) but beyond that it’s pretty tough these days.

Yes, you are correct, It is possible that use of the car owned by the company was taxed as a benefit in kind to the employee. Rumour was that it wasn’t.

the cars were usually sold after 3 years and replaced, all in order there.

The company constantly hired tax advisors (might have had a different title) to help us reduce corporate taxes - they were paid on commission as a % of reduced taxes. So this is more what I mean by it is “easier to avoid taxes when you have more money” people who have more wealth can afford to find more and more ways to avoid taxation. I have seen it in small ways and I’m sure it happens amongst friends at the top 0.01% who hold an astonishing disproportionate % of wealth.

bellac11 · 12/08/2022 18:14

Jki · 12/08/2022 15:56

Thank you - my phone had distorted the
article, now I see it.

This is interesting but it doesn’t take into account net worth?

what about Assets and employment benefits that aren’t taxed as income? for example, I used to work in an office where many staff had drivers and company cars, if the Director wasn’t using the car/driver we could be utilise those resources without them being taxed to us as a benefit. Bad example in the scheme of monetary gain but all I can think of. Company would also buy cars for cash, list them as an asset, take the depreciation, and staff would get a new BMW without benefit taxation.

It’s fairly easy once your net worth reaches a certain level to legally avoid taxation in the U.K. so this seems to paint an odd picture.

I don’t know if I am making a lucid point or not but when I don’t have a migraine I will read these stats more thoroughly.

I think the only way of measuring that properly is to use people that are employed rather than people who dont pay tax at source otherwise its hard to calculate accurately. The figures are skewed

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 18:14

@Itisasecret
Nah, that’s lazy and a lie. Plus troll hunting is against MN rules. I am a lifelong labour voter, previous paid up member of the party and in a unionised profession. Their “action” has been non existent. Where have they been when the Tories have been destroying the country? My posting history will show I’m no bot, I’ve got nothing but disdain for this government
Others I’ve seen posting are the same. However, being disappointed in a rubbish government and equally calling out Labour for being a rubbish opposition does not a troll make. Even if you don’t agree with it. That’s lazy, lacks critical thinking and is against mn rules. If people were so inclined they could report and get all the shill accusations removed so stop wasting your time. It’s a bad argument anyway

Sure some are genuine but anyone who says Labour and Tories are the same, clearly hasn't bothered to find out anything about the party or just wants to plant the seed in peoples minds that as they are all the same, might as well stick with what we've got i.e a Tory supporter.

See it all the time on here etc.

justasking111 · 12/08/2022 18:14

Water and rail is nationalised in Wales both have the same problems as the private sector does in England. So it's a weak argument

Itisasecret · 12/08/2022 18:11

User135644 · 12/08/2022 18:03

Privatising water, energy and rail is working out so well isn't it?

The country is falling apart at the seams ffs and a lot of chickens coming home to roost at once.

You have missed the point and you know it. As they were highlighting to you, you’re wrong. High earners have never paid so much in tax as they have under the Tories to fund the reliefs given to those on lower wages.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 18:10

User135644 · 12/08/2022 18:03

Privatising water, energy and rail is working out so well isn't it?

The country is falling apart at the seams ffs and a lot of chickens coming home to roost at once.

Wow, that’s quite a swerve to completely avoid engaging with the facts that disproved your previous post.

Do you even realise that you were doing it, or did your cognitive dissonance take,over your higher executive functions for a minute?

Come on, have some integrity here; how can you square your claim that they only care for the rich with the fact that they have increased the minimum wage, pensions and and tax-free allowance so much, funded by increases in tax and NI for the highest earners and by removing their allowances?

bellac11 · 12/08/2022 18:09

Jki · 12/08/2022 13:40

I read your link @ImWell could you tell me exactly where that point is made? I can’t find it.

this seems fairly obvious though:

“The richest fifth of people pay 2.3 times more in indirect taxes (£8,500) than the poorest fifth (£3,800), driven by greater expenditure. However, richer households pay a smaller proportion of disposable income on indirect taxes (9%) than the poorest fifth (23%).”

I dont like that sort of explanation

2.3 times is a proportion not a percentage

9% and 23% are percentages not proportion

The measurement needs to add up

And Im not sure whether indirect taxes is a good measure, are we talking VAT and duty?

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 18:09

I'm starting to think Labour doesn't actually WANT to win an election because they don't know what to do.

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 18:08

@Proudboomer
If you want new clothes, gadgets, TV, holidays abroad, ect then you like capitalism but you think the rich should fund it for you?

Anyone working full time should be able to afford some luxuries, atm many are working 40hrs pw to be poor.

Many of the rich rely on the less well off spending money & paying VAT etc if they have none, we will all suffer.

bellac11 · 12/08/2022 18:05

Itisasecret · 12/08/2022 12:01

Nah, that’s lazy and a lie. Plus troll hunting is against MN rules. I am a lifelong labour voter, previous paid up member of the party and in a unionised profession. Their “action” has been non existent. Where have they been when the Tories have been destroying the country? My posting history will show I’m no bot, I’ve got nothing but disdain for this government.

Others I’ve seen posting are the same. However, being disappointed in a rubbish government and equally calling out Labour for being a rubbish opposition does not a troll make. Even if you don’t agree with it. That’s lazy, lacks critical thinking and is against mn rules. If people were so inclined they could report and get all the shill accusations removed so stop wasting your time. It’s a bad argument anyway.

Totally agree. Im a lifelong Labour voter, I will continue to be. I cant vote anyone else, who else is there?

And I had high hopes for Starmer but unfortunately as someone else said on the thread, Labour have no shape or force about them. They are also playing the game of identity and culture wars and I think thats not only dangerous but utterly unhelpful to society. People want jobs, money in their pockets, they want affordable housing, affordable public transport, affordable utilities, good schools, good health care. I dont hear about this

We need a Blair. No one seems to like that sort of comment but its true.

User135644 · 12/08/2022 18:03

ImWell · 12/08/2022 17:58

Yes, they really do have it in for the low-paid, with those inflation-busting minimum wage rises, big increases in the tax-free allowance and the pensions triple lock, paid for by (checks notes) oh yes, higher taxes on top earners and the loss of their tax allowances.

Still, let’s not let facts get in the way of good old-fashioned ignorance and prejudice, eh?

Do you also blame the government for your waistline and general feeling of lethargy?

Privatising water, energy and rail is working out so well isn't it?

The country is falling apart at the seams ffs and a lot of chickens coming home to roost at once.