Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I the only one who thinks scrimping and saving can go and get fucked for bare essentials

335 replies

Freedomfromunfairbills · 11/08/2022 17:45

All the advice about cost of living seems to be ways you can scrimp and save to possible cobble together enough money to stay alive on bare necessities such as food, water, etc. Am I the only one thinking fuck this we just should not accept this when many of the companies jacking up their prices are making record profits. Even if it’s technically possible why on earth should I give up new clothes, gadgets, TV, holidays abroad, ect all to fund the obscene riches of the one percent. Instead of this advice on how to possibly meet these we actually need to say on mass no we are not surfs under the feudal system and we refuse to become a peasant class enough is enough. We should demand the government steps on and nationalises these companies and demand immediate taxes on the ultra rich to fund it all. I’ve always been fairly right wing and conservative but surely this is simply some kind of feudalism that will reduce many of us to little more than peasants and ruin the quality of life for many. Aibu?

OP posts:
ImWell · 12/08/2022 20:17

Jki · 12/08/2022 20:06

Top 1% of wealth is £688k, not income. I was wrong.

I can’t believe that is true, it seems very low.

It’s disappointing how many people are outraged / upset about issues like this without knowing the numbers.

That wealth figure includes property, so that’s not as large as it seems either.

AndreaC74 · 12/08/2022 20:13

MsPincher · 12/08/2022 18:36

We’ve already established the rich pay the highest percentage of income in tax though. Look up thread.

im not the rich but better to deal in facts.

So they might, though thats debatable, once you get past PAYE

However, they are also the ones with the most disposable income.

Average CEO FTSE100 pay is around £4m p.a.

More realistically, average director pay is 100k

Average adult social carer gets £10.50 ph.

When you are old and infirm, who will you value?

Jki · 12/08/2022 20:06

ImWell · 12/08/2022 20:02

Where are you getting that figure from? To be in the top 1% of adults in the UK requires an income of £120,000.

Top 1% of wealth is £688k, not income. I was wrong.

I can’t believe that is true, it seems very low.

Itisasecret · 12/08/2022 20:04

Jki · 12/08/2022 20:01

Never has income redistribution been so good

Im reasonably certain that this isn’t true.

You obviously can’t read then, the wild figures you’ve quoted show that. It is actual proven fact (ONS)

ImWell · 12/08/2022 20:03

Jki · 12/08/2022 20:01

Never has income redistribution been so good

Im reasonably certain that this isn’t true.

What data are you basing that on? I don’t know if it’s right or wrong, but presumably you have some figures behind your reasonable certainty?

ImWell · 12/08/2022 20:02

Jki · 12/08/2022 20:00

Your husband earns over £650k per year?

Where are you getting that figure from? To be in the top 1% of adults in the UK requires an income of £120,000.

Jki · 12/08/2022 20:01

Never has income redistribution been so good

Im reasonably certain that this isn’t true.

Itisasecret · 12/08/2022 20:00

bellac11 · 12/08/2022 19:43

I think if people are going to bandy around figures that they are paying so much in tax they need to really set out what the original income is

Are we talking 70k a year or 700 for example

Its the same at the other end of the income stream, someone will say they are a household only earning 20k but they forget to add on the benefits and child benefit they get

It makes it impossible to analyse really

The tax thresholds are out there for all to see. 20 > 40 > 45. There are some hidden ones for example, 100-120k is 60% tax as you lose personal allowance. So if you were to get a 20k bonus you’d see about 6. 14k out of that goes straight on deductions. You may not feel sorry for those people but low taxation it is not, they are certainly doing the heavy lifting.

Then after that you’ll be losing you pension tax relief. So if people actually want to look at how the tax burden significantly redistributes wealth it’s all out there and has already been posted on this thread.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 20:00

bellac11 · 12/08/2022 19:43

I think if people are going to bandy around figures that they are paying so much in tax they need to really set out what the original income is

Are we talking 70k a year or 700 for example

Its the same at the other end of the income stream, someone will say they are a household only earning 20k but they forget to add on the benefits and child benefit they get

It makes it impossible to analyse really

The quintiles are all in the ONS data I linked to above.

Jki · 12/08/2022 20:00

Itisasecret · 12/08/2022 19:15

What bollocks. We are in the top 1% of income or whatever it’s called (oh and I’m a labour voter). We’ve never paid so much tax as a household. The tax bill is literally eyewatering. My husband’s tax bill is significantly more than I earn and I’m a professional who went to uni for years.

He has never paid so much tax, swimming in a sea of bank noted and hoarding cash we are not. Don’t get me wrong we are comfy but there comes a point where actually you are paying so much tax as you hit the thresholds you’re not actually clearing much more. Educate yourself and look at the figures posted earlier about how much the tax burden is shouldered by the 1% and where it all goes. Never has income redistribution been so good which some may say makes a mockery of working in a high demand career.

Your husband earns over £650k per year?

Discrimination1234 · 12/08/2022 19:52

I find it really hard to believe the government is just throwing their hands up

  • can’t fix NHS
  • can’t do anything about inflation
  • can’t demand price capping for energy
  • can’t strike good trade deals
  • etc etc
Why not? Maybe it’s time for a change then????

Anyway many people have really struggled not for weeks or months but years. Many peoples stress levels are still high post pandemic and more and more stress is being loaded onto them with no relief. The leadership challenge seems to be an excuse not to deal with any of the many problems facing the UK at the moment. We used to feel government could and would help- in fact the government enjoyed the “nanny state” moniker- but that has all changed. The more desperate people feel, the more they will demand change.

bellac11 · 12/08/2022 19:43

I think if people are going to bandy around figures that they are paying so much in tax they need to really set out what the original income is

Are we talking 70k a year or 700 for example

Its the same at the other end of the income stream, someone will say they are a household only earning 20k but they forget to add on the benefits and child benefit they get

It makes it impossible to analyse really

ImWell · 12/08/2022 19:33

Being paid a significant fraction of your earnings brings home just high the tax rate is nowadays. You don’t tend to think about it the same way with monthly salary, you just see the net figure, but on the bonus, it really stands out.

Let’s say you are told that you are getting a relatively modest £2,000 bonus this year. That’s nice, you think, but of course, when it arrives, it’s actually £1060, with £940 in tax. Just under half of it gone.

On top of that your tax-free allowance has gone, you are no longer allowed to fund your pension, and your child benefit has been cancelled.

I don’t really understand where people are still getting the idea from that this government is offering low taxes to top earners; they really are not.

Itisasecret · 12/08/2022 19:15

User135644 · 12/08/2022 19:06

Regardless of whether you think essential utilities like water and energy should be in the hands of private companies and their shareholders, we can agree that the current crises are a lot worse for people because of decisions this government has made since 2010.

  1. Public services cut to the bone and local services decimated in Labour areas due to funding cuts (Sunak wasn't meant to voice in public that that's a Tory policy).

  2. The longest squeeze on living standards and wages in living memory, while the top 1% have been coining it in like never before.

  3. The national self harm that is Brexit

Things are bad everywhere but other countries can absorb it better.

What bollocks. We are in the top 1% of income or whatever it’s called (oh and I’m a labour voter). We’ve never paid so much tax as a household. The tax bill is literally eyewatering. My husband’s tax bill is significantly more than I earn and I’m a professional who went to uni for years.

He has never paid so much tax, swimming in a sea of bank noted and hoarding cash we are not. Don’t get me wrong we are comfy but there comes a point where actually you are paying so much tax as you hit the thresholds you’re not actually clearing much more. Educate yourself and look at the figures posted earlier about how much the tax burden is shouldered by the 1% and where it all goes. Never has income redistribution been so good which some may say makes a mockery of working in a high demand career.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 19:10

bellac11 · 12/08/2022 19:05

What do we mean by 'rich' anyway

I found out apparently Im in the top 10% of income or whatever its called

But Im a few quid over the higher rate tax threshold and to be fair Im not even sure if that is right. I might not be, I need to check it out

It’s an ever-moving definition.

People will say that taxing “the rich” more will bring in a lot of money, so start with a definition of “rich” that captures doctors, head-teachers and the like.

When it’s pointed out that that seems a bit unfair they say that they actually mean the oligarchs, the multi-billionaires and so on. This unfortunately is so few people that taxing them hugely makes very little difference.

User135644 · 12/08/2022 19:06

Regardless of whether you think essential utilities like water and energy should be in the hands of private companies and their shareholders, we can agree that the current crises are a lot worse for people because of decisions this government has made since 2010.

  1. Public services cut to the bone and local services decimated in Labour areas due to funding cuts (Sunak wasn't meant to voice in public that that's a Tory policy).

  2. The longest squeeze on living standards and wages in living memory, while the top 1% have been coining it in like never before.

  3. The national self harm that is Brexit

Things are bad everywhere but other countries can absorb it better.

bellac11 · 12/08/2022 19:05

What do we mean by 'rich' anyway

I found out apparently Im in the top 10% of income or whatever its called

But Im a few quid over the higher rate tax threshold and to be fair Im not even sure if that is right. I might not be, I need to check it out

Jki · 12/08/2022 19:03

ImWell · 12/08/2022 19:00

Which better-evidenced examples is it taken from then?

Thanks for the question, I don’t have enough knowledge to continue posting about it. I believe it’s called ignorance.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 19:00

Jki · 12/08/2022 18:46

All right then, I don’t have enough knowledge to keep posting about it.

my opinion isn’t backed by facts so it so just a another opinion. However my opinion isn’t formed from the one paltry example that I’ve given, that would be very naive.

Which better-evidenced examples is it taken from then?

ImWell · 12/08/2022 18:59

User135644 · 12/08/2022 18:46

The more money the working classes have in their pocket the more of it goes back into the economy (regardless of how they spend it).

Give money to the poor and it goes back in the economy, give money to the rich and it's hoarded in tax havens and investment banks. Yet since Thatcher and Reagan we've had to listen to the nonsensical myth of trickle down economics.

Hoarded in investment banks?

OK, this should be good…

Can you please explain what you think you mean by that? Investment banks, tending not to take deposits, seem a very strange place to suggest that the rich are hoarding their money.

MsPincher · 12/08/2022 18:56

Jki · 12/08/2022 18:46

All right then, I don’t have enough knowledge to keep posting about it.

my opinion isn’t backed by facts so it so just a another opinion. However my opinion isn’t formed from the one paltry example that I’ve given, that would be very naive.

Fair enough. it’s a bugbear of mine that people love to come up with easy answers on threads like this- Amazon should just pay all their tax (of course they already do) and everything will be fine. No need for the average person to pay any more tax or buy any less (of course that’s actually probably the main answer).

Generally it’s not that easy to legitimately avoid tax (hence why companies pay advisors). To be honest tax is extremely complicated and generally the reason companies need so much advice is because they are trying to pay the right amount.

Anyway tax is taxing…

Jki · 12/08/2022 18:46

MsPincher · 12/08/2022 18:42

In any event @Jki you seem to be basing an opinion that it’s easy for rich people to avoid tax on the fact you once worked at a company where there was a rumour that they were not properly paying taxes on company cars. That’s tax evasion rather than avoidance and you don’t even know it took place (unlikely I would say in a large company as they tend to be targets for HMRC).

All right then, I don’t have enough knowledge to keep posting about it.

my opinion isn’t backed by facts so it so just a another opinion. However my opinion isn’t formed from the one paltry example that I’ve given, that would be very naive.

User135644 · 12/08/2022 18:46

OlympicProcrastinator · 11/08/2022 20:17

It's mind blowing that people can be this ignorant (or just fucking selfish in the extreme)

Its very ignorant. Who the fuck is going to do the jobs that make the profit for those at the top if everyone ‘just earns more’? Who is going to take your bins? Deliver your goods? Produce your food? if they all ‘stop feeling entitled’ to a decent standard of living and ‘just earn more’ by working their way up? You can’t have everyone at the top and the people at the top wouldn’t earn a thing without the people doing lower paid work that keeps the economy going.
The comment from the poster that said people would ‘just go and buy Nikes’ if they had more money is probably one of the stupidest comments I’ve read on here in a while.

The more money the working classes have in their pocket the more of it goes back into the economy (regardless of how they spend it).

Give money to the poor and it goes back in the economy, give money to the rich and it's hoarded in tax havens and investment banks. Yet since Thatcher and Reagan we've had to listen to the nonsensical myth of trickle down economics.

MsPincher · 12/08/2022 18:43

Whitehorsegirl · 12/08/2022 18:42

The narrative is always that the big corporations can do whatever they want because profit comes above everything else in the UK, including human lives and basic standards of living.

And if people dare to complain they are branded as: work-shy, lazy, and stupid or whatever nonsense the right wing press is telling us to believe.

There is a weird, masochistic mentality of almost enjoying the serf/feudal system in England.

You only have to read some of the comment on this thread...

Many countries have chosen to keep utilities and transport in public ownership so it is not exploited by a few people who are only in it to make obscene profit.

So there is a perfectly good alternative. It just means moving from the Dickensian mentally into a more equal society.

I personally don't want hand-outs from government to pay my electricity bills so the money can go back into the pockets of the energy companies.

I want transport, water, electricity and gas to go back into public ownership and a government who stops pandering to the needs of a few non-doms donors and CEOs.

People who work should have a decent life style as a result. I don't see why millions of people are expected to work everyday and yet struggle to even buy food, keep a roof over their head and be able to heat their home.

Unfortunately OP you are part of the problem if you voted conservative. Everyone who voted for Johnson and for Brexit got us in this mess.

Next time learn your lesson. If you keep voting for right-wing, rich people who have gone to private school, have a network of equally rich friends and have never really done a day's work in their life, don't be surprised that they don't care about you or anyone else when things get tough.

Whose narrative is that?

MsPincher · 12/08/2022 18:42

ImWell · 12/08/2022 18:26

Those tax advisers were paid to find ways that the company was paying more tax than the state required them to.

The UK’s tax regime is ludicrously complicated, and firms can very easily overlook completely legitimate tax treatments that they are supposed to be using.

That’s very different to tax evasion, which definitely is a problem, but which is quite unlikely to be recommended by professional tax advisers.

In any event @Jki you seem to be basing an opinion that it’s easy for rich people to avoid tax on the fact you once worked at a company where there was a rumour that they were not properly paying taxes on company cars. That’s tax evasion rather than avoidance and you don’t even know it took place (unlikely I would say in a large company as they tend to be targets for HMRC).