Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that no, you don’t “deserve” new clothes.

161 replies

TraceyTheHamster · 11/08/2022 15:25

I know I’m being snobby, but can anyone see where I’m coming from?

I’ve got a friend who is always skint. I know it isn’t easy for her; as Universal credit is her only income. I’m regularly lending her money for everyday expenses; food, rent etc. she owes me several hundred pounds at this point.

We’d pre-arranged to meet in town for a coffee this morning. She’s asks if we can pop to town for a couple bits… turns out she’s had the £300 cost of living payment and has just spent pretty much all of it on new clothes, make-up etc.

I had visions of getting a text from her in a weeks time asking to borrow £20 for food… so I gently suggested that she save some of it.

She got a bit snotty with me and replied that she hasn’t had been clothes in ages and “deserves” them.

Aibu to think this isn’t what the cost of living payment is for!

OP posts:
LearnedAxolotl · 11/08/2022 17:09

She doesn't need to save her money. You'll bail her out.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 17:08

lisavanderpumpscloset · 11/08/2022 15:28

It's nothing to do with you what she spends her money on.

But stop giving her money.

In effect that’s the OP’s money that she decided to spend. You can’t really owe someone hundreds of pounds and think it reasonable to go on a spending spree rather than repay them.

RenegadeMatron · 11/08/2022 17:05

The only reason you’re ‘miffed’ is because it highlights just how much of a mug you are for continually giving her money.

OP - there is a mind-boggling obvious solution to this. Confused

RB68 · 11/08/2022 17:04

Don't be so controlling. If you give her 20 quid every now and then that's great but don't tot it up as monies owed back to you - and certainly you can't dictate how she spends monies received EVEN IF SHE OWES YOU IN YOUR VIEW. Does she know you expect it back, that it is conditional on allowing you to tell her what she should be spending on? If she is reliant on benefits there is very little room for maneuver on any of the things you mention ie no spending on clothes, a bit of make up and a hair cut which most women take for granted. I support a friend of mine who unfortunately will never get off benefits now for a variety of reasons (much to her utter disappointment) and I willingly give her money when I can. When she had money she was one of the most generous people I knew. She helped me in tight spots and I have never forgotten and I don't care if I pay it back 50 times over she will NEVER owe me a penny.

What is 20 quid to someone with money - hardly even a round of drinks of cheap meal for 1. Its one T shirt with a fancy name (if that) a pair of flip flops. But to others its alot more. She clearly planned her splurge with the extra, at least she will have clothes to put on against the cold this winter

user1471538283 · 11/08/2022 17:01

You no longer lend her money. Some people cannot see the long game and she probably thinks she can continue to borrow money from you so she doesnt need to be more responsible.

NellesVilla · 11/08/2022 17:01

She sounds like a lazy cow and shouldn’t be getting this extra handout, but OP, did you really need to stick the boot in by ensuring we know she’s on benefits?!

Diablocircus · 11/08/2022 17:01

I have a friend like this too, OP.

It’s a hard lesson, but some people just can’t comprehend financial responsibility.

It’s not taught in school and quite often they people have parents who view money in the same way, so there aren’t good role models and the cycle continues.

I don’t think you’ll see that money again, you know that. Don’t lend any more cash, if you want to buy something do that instead, but if you lend money and then get irritated over how it’s spent (rightly so) it’ll cause friction and you could lose the friendship.

raisinghell · 11/08/2022 16:58

Op, sometimes you can be too gentle. "You're bloody kidding me aren't you? You've gone out and spent that much money when you owe me £x00?" When do you plan to give me my money back?

JudgeJ · 11/08/2022 16:57

YouCantSpellAmericaWithoutErica · 11/08/2022 15:37

Never loan money you can’t afford to lose yourself. That’s on you.

As for how your friend spends her money, that’s not any of your business.

So because the OP has tried to be kind and supportive to her friend she, the OP, is at fault? Hopefully her purse will be shut tight once the friend decides she needs another hand-out from her.

raisinghell · 11/08/2022 16:56

lisavanderpumpscloset · 11/08/2022 15:28

It's nothing to do with you what she spends her money on.

But stop giving her money.

How do you work that out when she owes Op money?

skyeisthelimit · 11/08/2022 16:56

YANBU but you this behaviour shows that she doesn't prioritise her living costs above everything else. so stop lending her money. People who can't manage their money will never manage it while other people bail them out all the time. If they blow the lot on clothes then can't afford to eat, that is nobody's problem but their own.

Nobody deserves or needs clothes other than basics so you have enough to wear and wash etc. People can want what they like but if they cant afford it then that is that.

She is the same sort of person who would put holidays, clothes, nights out etc on a credit card rather than realise that she just can't afford it.

Scrapologist · 11/08/2022 16:56

I'd resent her too much to stay friends with her, if I had to watch her spend every free £ she lays hands on, only to come asking for my financial support when she needs money for the basics. I'd think up a response about being unable to loan more money and have that ready for the next request. She'll never pay you back if she can't even bring herself to save for her own very predictable needs. Stop adding to the amount you'll probably never get back.

Horoscopegubbins · 11/08/2022 16:52

Well she's obviously using you... just say no to lending money. Bet she stops bothering with you.

HailAdrian · 11/08/2022 16:49

It's depressing as fuck when you can never afford anything nice for yourself so I get it tbh.

Bananalanacake · 11/08/2022 16:49

I can't get over the buying milkshakes from Maccys for the dog, is it ok for them.

switchoff1 · 11/08/2022 16:47

YABU in terms of questioning what she spends her money on as such, I get it as you lend her money and she owes you money too, I can see why you’d question it at the end of the day it’s her decision. However as much as she’s your friend I wouldn’t lend her anymore money at least in the short term. If she asks you then just say you don’t have it available I wouldn’t mention it’s because of spending her cost of living money.

Ulovememore · 11/08/2022 16:47

Good sense spoken on this thread but I feel like I should say it’s important we aren’t bashing people pushed beyond their limits by the cost of living crisis. Some of us are working every day and still barely able to get food and not in minimum wage jobs. So, there’s that. The relentlessness of it can get alot

WhereYouLeftIt · 11/08/2022 16:44

The 'deserve' comment would probably piss me off, but if she'd used the word 'need' instead - I may well have agreed with her.

  • Winter coat / boots /warm clothing - because let's face it, all our houses will be cold this winter :(
  • Underwear - when the elastic is so stretched your knickers barely stay up any more, and the underwiring has come out of your bra and your fingers have created holes either side of the fastening at the back
  • Shoes - there comes a point when your everyday shoes genuinely wear out and you can feel every pavement irregularity through the thinned soles
  • General clothing - clothes do wear out! If you wear a small number of items day after day, your t-shirts will develop holes at the underarms, maybe a tiny hole or two in the main body, rub through on seams, that coffee stain you can't get out - sometimes, you do need to replace worn-out clothes.
So it would very much depend what she meant by 'deserve'.
HMSSophia · 11/08/2022 16:40

"I deserve" is an indicator of how selfish, greedy and short-termist we in the West have become. I cringe when I hear it. It's got fuck all to do with self-care, valuing yourself, and everything to do with indulging yourself regardless of the subsequent consequences.

bloodywhitecat · 11/08/2022 16:40

You need to close the Bank of Friend.

TheNoodlesIncident · 11/08/2022 16:36

You're enabling her to not learn by lending her money when she has spent it all. If you stop doing that, she'll have to find other mugs ways to pay her way.

But you won't get your money back from her and most likely she'll drop you like a hot potato if you don't "lend" her any more. This is because she is a user masquerading as a friend. Suppose her thought process is along the lines of "If I spend this on clothes and make up I might be short for the gas bill, but I can get £x from TraceyTheHamster for that". Would you be comfortable with that?

UseOfWeapons · 11/08/2022 16:35

You’re being unreasonable to lend her any money. She never be able work within such a limited budget if you keep supplementing her income. Ask her to pay you back at a small sum a week until it’s paid off, then no more. If you are expecting to be repaid, that is.

catandcoffee · 11/08/2022 16:34

Regardless of how she spent that money, she'd not get a penny off me again.
Will you continue to fund her lifestyle, OP. ?

RethinkingLife · 11/08/2022 16:34

Stop giving her money. She has a completely unrealistic outlook on budgeting because you're plausibly not the only person from whom she 'borrows'.

NewMoney1000000 · 11/08/2022 16:33

My DS claimed universal credit for one month while in between jobs, he unexpectedly got the payment and spent on an item to add to a collection he has.