Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that no, you don’t “deserve” new clothes.

161 replies

TraceyTheHamster · 11/08/2022 15:25

I know I’m being snobby, but can anyone see where I’m coming from?

I’ve got a friend who is always skint. I know it isn’t easy for her; as Universal credit is her only income. I’m regularly lending her money for everyday expenses; food, rent etc. she owes me several hundred pounds at this point.

We’d pre-arranged to meet in town for a coffee this morning. She’s asks if we can pop to town for a couple bits… turns out she’s had the £300 cost of living payment and has just spent pretty much all of it on new clothes, make-up etc.

I had visions of getting a text from her in a weeks time asking to borrow £20 for food… so I gently suggested that she save some of it.

She got a bit snotty with me and replied that she hasn’t had been clothes in ages and “deserves” them.

Aibu to think this isn’t what the cost of living payment is for!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ImWell · 12/08/2022 18:41

I’d be fascinated to see genuine budgets of both people on average or low wages who are struggling, and those who are not. I think that the second group could really help out the first with some advice about how to do things differently.

I spent some time on MoneySavingExpert.com, and was appalled at what some people posted on there who were struggling.

Two new-ish cars on finance, a financed sofa, a PlayStation from BrightHouse, and so on. Others would live like monks in virtually nothing then crack and book a £4,000 holiday to make up for having gone without any decent food for six months.

Unfortunately the question of what this subset could do better seems to be taboo.

southlondonerhere · 12/08/2022 18:33

I think people should be able to spend their money however they choose... as long as they live with the consequences of their decisions, stop bailing her out!!

BaileySharp · 12/08/2022 18:31

It's difficult when others don't spend their money in what seems a sensible way but their money is tight. People don't like being told how to spend their money though, she's an adult and can do as she pleases. If it bothers you I'd stop lending her money though!

Sunnyqueen · 12/08/2022 18:04

Save your outrage for the parents who spent the weekend putting it up their nose then begging people for £20 on the Monday saying they've nothing in for the kids 🙄 and stop lending her money, your not getting it back.

Carofay · 12/08/2022 17:58

SunnyNunny · 12/08/2022 11:15

I bought some additional ‘value’ supermarket essentials for the food bank collection I had seen at the entrance. The lady running the collection scowled at my donation and actually said ‘You know poor people deserve NICE things too’. I showed her my own shopping bag full of the same value essentials. Not wasting my money on that again.

Similarly friend volunteered for charity distributing donating food/clothes/anything asked for to local families in need. Eventually stopped when realised 90% of the homes she was making deliveries to were significantly nicer than hers. She had downsized when couldn’t afford her lifestyle anymore. They asked others to subsidise them.

Yep. And this is why I don't buy items for food banks (although I do donate to charities). Saw a feature on TV once where a woman was saying that she felt no shame in accessing a food bank as she was struggling atm. Her house was significantly nicer than mine, oak beams and all. I've been unemployed and on low wages in the past and prioritised buying food and paying for energy. Didn't buy any new clothes for several years.

Wowwe · 12/08/2022 12:14

How many more people are going to misunderstand the 'cost of living payment'
It's for 'cost of living' which can mean anything, clothes, bills, rent, anything really! It's not for energy only! 🙄

And stop lending her money.

SunnyNunny · 12/08/2022 11:32

ImWell · 12/08/2022 11:25

The whole idea of deserve is a very strange one. Where do we get the idea from that anyone deserves anything?

If I do my job, then I deserve the pay that we agreed when I took it on, and if I buy a round in a pub most people would probably agree that I deserve to be bought one back, but beyond that, what does this “deserve” mean?

Who deserves what, and who has the obligation to work to provide it for them?

I think we can have a hope, and maybe an expectation that the state will use redistribution to protect and care for those who cannot manage to take care of themselves, but the idea that anyone “deserves” a load of nice new clothes, or a foreign holiday, iPhone or the like; that doesn’t work for me.

You deserve shelter/basic food/heat/electricity. Ideally you need to work for these. Sometimes that is not possible (as in actually not possible, not just don't quite fancy it/it's hard for me/people won't just pay me £25/hr even though I have zero work experience so not 'worth' my time) and that's ok. That's why we thankfully live somewhere that has a safety net. I am all for cost of living payments. Many people do NEED them.

But no, you don't deserve NEW clothes (many, many people who do not qualify for these payments rely on second hand clothes for themselves, second hand school uniform, etc), holidays (again many of us cannot afford these), a car (yes, also incredibly crap not to have in many situations, but even when living in places with shoddy transport I had many (employed) periods in my life where I had to take the sodding bus/cycle 10 miles (on my crappy freecycle bike), and so on. Why am I paying for you to have things I cannot afford? WTAF?

ImWell · 12/08/2022 11:25

SunnyNunny · 12/08/2022 11:15

I bought some additional ‘value’ supermarket essentials for the food bank collection I had seen at the entrance. The lady running the collection scowled at my donation and actually said ‘You know poor people deserve NICE things too’. I showed her my own shopping bag full of the same value essentials. Not wasting my money on that again.

Similarly friend volunteered for charity distributing donating food/clothes/anything asked for to local families in need. Eventually stopped when realised 90% of the homes she was making deliveries to were significantly nicer than hers. She had downsized when couldn’t afford her lifestyle anymore. They asked others to subsidise them.

The whole idea of deserve is a very strange one. Where do we get the idea from that anyone deserves anything?

If I do my job, then I deserve the pay that we agreed when I took it on, and if I buy a round in a pub most people would probably agree that I deserve to be bought one back, but beyond that, what does this “deserve” mean?

Who deserves what, and who has the obligation to work to provide it for them?

I think we can have a hope, and maybe an expectation that the state will use redistribution to protect and care for those who cannot manage to take care of themselves, but the idea that anyone “deserves” a load of nice new clothes, or a foreign holiday, iPhone or the like; that doesn’t work for me.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/08/2022 11:21

Don't get involved in how she spends her money.

Don't give/ lend her anymore money.

SunnyNunny · 12/08/2022 11:19

XenoBitch · 12/08/2022 00:43

Ok, so anyone that does not have a job has to dress in sack cloth and eat gruel.

Nice. Maybe pop back to the Daily Mail/The Sun comments section.

Nope but they should maybe consider shopping for charity shops/second hand like most people I know who work.

SunnyNunny · 12/08/2022 11:15

I bought some additional ‘value’ supermarket essentials for the food bank collection I had seen at the entrance. The lady running the collection scowled at my donation and actually said ‘You know poor people deserve NICE things too’. I showed her my own shopping bag full of the same value essentials. Not wasting my money on that again.

Similarly friend volunteered for charity distributing donating food/clothes/anything asked for to local families in need. Eventually stopped when realised 90% of the homes she was making deliveries to were significantly nicer than hers. She had downsized when couldn’t afford her lifestyle anymore. They asked others to subsidise them.

ImWell · 12/08/2022 11:06

autienotnaughty · 12/08/2022 04:16

What do you think your taxes pay? It's many things including nhs, community services, social care etc. you pay tax based on what you earn as a contribution to society you are not paying people directly and therefore get to have some sense of entitlement. If I were you I'd worry more about what the rich are doing with their money because if they paid their taxes properly our country would be in a significantly better place.

The highest earners pay a disproportionately high amount of tax. Where are you getting the idea from that they don’t?

converseandjeans · 12/08/2022 09:42

XenoBitch

Why are some people so concerned with how the poorest in society spend their money?

Well OP has lent her money & seen nothing. She's not unreasonable to want some repaid is she?

Also she's now anticipating being asked to help again with bills as her friend has spent all the government top up.

autienotnaughty · 12/08/2022 04:17

Op you don't get to dictate how other adults spend their money. But you can say no to lending money.

autienotnaughty · 12/08/2022 04:16

AtwilightRebellion · 11/08/2022 20:15

Why are some people so concerned with how the poorest in society spend their money

ERR, because of their taxes.

What do you think your taxes pay? It's many things including nhs, community services, social care etc. you pay tax based on what you earn as a contribution to society you are not paying people directly and therefore get to have some sense of entitlement. If I were you I'd worry more about what the rich are doing with their money because if they paid their taxes properly our country would be in a significantly better place.

Liorae · 12/08/2022 03:50

cadburyegg · 11/08/2022 16:02

I think it's rude of you to tell her what to do with her money. Maybe she hasn't had new clothes in ages and does need some. She can't turn up to job interviews in rags.

FWIW I spent my first cost of living payment on school uniform and swimming lessons for my kids. I'll put the next one in my octopus account. I'm sure some people will judge me for it but it's none of their business.

Don't lend her any more money. You're creating a bit of an imbalance where you feel resentful of what she spends her money on

To how many people did you owe money at the time that you did not pay back?

Lightning020 · 12/08/2022 03:42

What she needs is a job. An actual focus. Then she would have something for her beyond the children.

stayinghometoday · 12/08/2022 03:29

@XenoBitch

Ok, so anyone that does not have a job has to dress in sack cloth and eat gruel.

Or use half of that money to pay a friend back. People tend to buy more clothes than they need and spend to much on them. H&M is pretty cheap and buying second hand can be really great value. I buy a lot of second hand clothes and we're on 150k a year. People don't need a zillion dresses and tops. A capsule wardrobe with just a few flattering colours is a much better idea both financially and style wise.

CactusBlossom · 12/08/2022 02:56

The suggestion should have been for her to pay you back some of what you loaned to her. Tell her you deserve that! Don't lend her any more. I know where you are coming from, though; I have loaned money to friends. One said she couldn't put food on the table, but then showed off her fancy new kettle... 😳

ImWell · 12/08/2022 02:28

You seem to be implying that the OP’s friend was right to spend the payment on clothes, not keeping any back for a rainy day or to pay back what she owed.

XenoBitch · 12/08/2022 00:43

AtwilightRebellion · 11/08/2022 20:16

They do.

If they work for them.

Ok, so anyone that does not have a job has to dress in sack cloth and eat gruel.

Nice. Maybe pop back to the Daily Mail/The Sun comments section.

FreyaStorm · 11/08/2022 21:16

entropynow · 11/08/2022 19:12

Oh, you sweet summer child.
I've personally known several people just like this, but do crack in pretending they're all made up.

Seconded!

AtwilightRebellion · 11/08/2022 20:16

Mamai90 · 11/08/2022 20:15

Yes, everyone deserves to be able to buy clothes.

Stop lending her money and then keep your nose out.

They do.

If they work for them.

Mamai90 · 11/08/2022 20:16

XenoBitch · 11/08/2022 19:54

Where should the payment have gone then?

From the comments about it on MN that I have seen, a lot of people used it for school uniform, some replaced broken appliances. Some people just saw it get them into the black again. A friend of mine bought a new bed and shoes with hers... both very much needed items.

Why are some people so concerned with how the poorest in society spend their money?

I agree @XenoBitch

AtwilightRebellion · 11/08/2022 20:15

Why are some people so concerned with how the poorest in society spend their money

ERR, because of their taxes.