Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs in cars - Why do people STILL do this?

39 replies

WildFlowerBees · 11/08/2022 14:41

Again today the police broke into a car to rescue a dog who'd been left in the car no windows open.

Are people really so stupid that they are unaware of how dangerous not to mention bloody cruel this is?

Year upon year there's social media and news information on this very topic yet every year some cruel twat locks their dog in a car.

Some people really don't deserve to have an animal.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fluffymule · 11/08/2022 20:54

It has to be stupidity.

I've noticed that when these stupid pet owners return to the scene of their negligence to be confronted with concerned people, or police/firefighters who have smashed a window to rescue the poor animal, they are belligerent in their outrage and refuse to accept they've done anything wrong.

user1745 · 11/08/2022 20:51

Everyone thinks their situation is the exception. "That rule's just for other, more stupid, people, but we're only going to be gone 20 minutes so it's fine"

x2boys · 11/08/2022 20:42

REP22 · 11/08/2022 20:10

@Changechangychange. I agree. I love that site but the debate in that one really riled me too. I made the mistake of reading the article linked-to in the commentary about parents whose kids had died after they'd left them in their cars. That's some grim knowledge that I can't unlearn. And the fact that other (presumably intelligent people) had also read or knew of that piece and STILL argued that it was OK to leave a baby in a car for hours ("the engine was left running, so the air-conditioning was on!")... Ye gods.

@WildFlowerBees is absolutely right. It's so cruel and stupid that it defies belief. And yet every year it happens.

We once had a dog at the vets who had been at the beach with his family all day. He was very, very ill and it was a bit of a mystery as the chap and his wife said "oh, he's been drinking OK". Except that they hadn't had any fresh water at all for the dog, they'd not even brought or sourced any tap water in a little bowl for the dog. The only water the dog had access to was sea water, and that's what he'd been drinking. All day. It was (I think) the worst case of salt-poisoning the duty vet had seen. And the bloke didn't think he'd done anything wrong - "but he's been drinking ok, all day!" Yes, you irredeemable c*ckwomble, and it's almost killed him. But I wasn't allowed to say things like that to clients' faces. Unfortunately.

Ffs who thinks it's OK to feed a dog salt water even if I forget to bring the dog bowl and water if we go to the beach I buy her a bottle of water.

Florenz · 11/08/2022 20:36

Anyone who does this should be banned for life from keeping dogs in their household, with a cast iron guarantee 5 year jail sentence if they are found with a dog in their house. No excuses, no nothing. A dog is in your house and you go to jail for 5 years. The law is a joke in this country.

WildFlowerBees · 11/08/2022 20:33

No sane person would walk on the pavement in bare feet in 30 plus degree heat, or go to the beach and fill up their water bottle with saltwater, sit in a hot car with the windows closed and a jumper on for 30 plus minutes so why can't they extend this sort of common sense to their pet? I look at our local rescue which is now full of 2 yr old dogs from lockdown and feel utter contempt for people and their selfishness.

We humans are such parasites.

OP posts:
x2boys · 11/08/2022 20:29

I mean I'm not the worlds best dog owner but I really feel for my dog right now,I keep putting ice cubes in her water bowl to keep it cool .

Changechangychange · 11/08/2022 20:23

@REP22 that saltwater story is terrible - that poor poor dog.

momager1 · 11/08/2022 20:18
gatehouseoffleet · 11/08/2022 20:14

The only water the dog had access to was sea water I really just give up.

Between leaving them in cars, walking them when it's hot, getting them to drink salt water...

...and then the other thread about fireworks in this heat and it being ok to pollute the atmosphere to keep the aircon in the car on, I just give up. Humans are completely beyond redemption. Why has nobody got any common sense anymore?

gatehouseoffleet · 11/08/2022 20:12

I am surprised how many dogs I've seen being walked today as well. Not at lunchtime (!) but this morning when it was already quite warm and this evening around 6.30 when it was still hot.

Sorry but if you have a dog you have to get up early and be out and back before 7am in this sort of weather, or wait until about now to take them out.

REP22 · 11/08/2022 20:10

@Changechangychange. I agree. I love that site but the debate in that one really riled me too. I made the mistake of reading the article linked-to in the commentary about parents whose kids had died after they'd left them in their cars. That's some grim knowledge that I can't unlearn. And the fact that other (presumably intelligent people) had also read or knew of that piece and STILL argued that it was OK to leave a baby in a car for hours ("the engine was left running, so the air-conditioning was on!")... Ye gods.

@WildFlowerBees is absolutely right. It's so cruel and stupid that it defies belief. And yet every year it happens.

We once had a dog at the vets who had been at the beach with his family all day. He was very, very ill and it was a bit of a mystery as the chap and his wife said "oh, he's been drinking OK". Except that they hadn't had any fresh water at all for the dog, they'd not even brought or sourced any tap water in a little bowl for the dog. The only water the dog had access to was sea water, and that's what he'd been drinking. All day. It was (I think) the worst case of salt-poisoning the duty vet had seen. And the bloke didn't think he'd done anything wrong - "but he's been drinking ok, all day!" Yes, you irredeemable c*ckwomble, and it's almost killed him. But I wasn't allowed to say things like that to clients' faces. Unfortunately.

theremustonlybeone · 11/08/2022 20:03

Shocking never mind the walking the dogs in the shearing heat too. Burning they’re paws until they bleed and owners not realising that the pavements are burning them - muppets

mac1974 · 11/08/2022 20:02

@Changechangychange that's absolutely awful. It's hard to comprehend that an employer would allow that to happen. It's hard to imagine what pressure the parent must be under to have made that choice. It makes me feel sick. That could have gone so very wrong.

Creepymanonagoatfarm · 11/08/2022 20:01

Americas are wanting a sensor fitted to cars to text if anyone gets left in! Just look after ya friggin dc!!

x2boys · 11/08/2022 20:00

Changechangychange · 11/08/2022 19:43

@x2boys Agreed, and I can see why she might have felt driven to it, but honestly just call in sick or something. It was an office, not retail, you get sick leave even if it’s unpaid.

Oh totally but the idea that you have to either leave your newborn alone at home or in the car is quite barbaric ,just awful
Not arguing with you at all, just sickens me that is the choices some women might be left with .

WildFlowerBees · 11/08/2022 20:00

It makes me so angry, I wish there were a system that vets the suitability of people as pet owners. The guy around the corner from me 'walks' his dog around the green opposite, doesn't pick up after it on his phone couldn't give a shit. Poor bloody dog has such a crap life.

I hate people sometimes, if you love animals then take proper care of them!

OP posts:
crosstalk · 11/08/2022 19:59

@Minfilia Believe it or not, very few of us have cars like that. There's another thread where someone was reluctant to drive 400 miles in the heat and some people said "but don't you have an airconditioned car?" Most of us don't and certainly not one that stays airconditioned without the engine on.

crosstalk · 11/08/2022 19:55

I don't know why there aren't warning signs up in areas where people might leave dogs in cars - with a note saying if your dog looks as if it might die, police have every right to smash your car window. There must be some record of where these things happen nationally. But people do get very defensive/aggressive - I reported two spaniels in a locked car in distress in a small city. Top of a car park, blazing sun. Police arrived at the same time as owner with two young children. "I was only away half an hour," she said, "the dogs are fine." Hmmm.

Can anyone link to the video a vet made sitting in a locked car in the heat himself with a thermometer. It was brilliant - and made the point as the heat rose rapidly at least he could get out.

Minfilia · 11/08/2022 19:51

I mean, this isn’t always the case, but with modern cars you can programme the climate so it stays cool. My car is WONDERFUL for this. It’s lovely to get into a pre air conditioned car in this heat 😊

MrsMitford3 · 11/08/2022 19:48

A neighbour and I were passing on the high st and stopped to chat in front of a car with 3 panting, frantically barking dogs-teeny crack in window but dogs obviously unhappy. As we were standing there debating calling the police the owner walked up-he was very dismissive and told us we were ridiculous...some ppl never learn!

Changechangychange · 11/08/2022 19:43

@x2boys Agreed, and I can see why she might have felt driven to it, but honestly just call in sick or something. It was an office, not retail, you get sick leave even if it’s unpaid.

x2boys · 11/08/2022 19:36

Changechangychange · 11/08/2022 19:10

It’s stupidity. I got in an argument on a US forum I frequent about somebody who had left their three month old baby in the car while they went to work, nipping out to feed them every few hours.

People were insisting it was safer than leaving the baby at home alone. Um no, for an immobile newborn baby it literally isn’t safer, they can cook in cars in under 30mins, whereas at home you will come home to a dehydrated, hoarse baby with nappy rash, but most likely not dead.

But leaving them alone at home is more likely to attract attention from the neighbours who will see you go to work and hear the baby crying, so selfishly risking your child’s life in a staff car park seems better to the parent.

Aargh, it was a really annoying conversation. Still cross just thinking about it Angry

That's awful and whilst I'm not condoning her actions in the slightest, we do at least get maternity leave in the UK, help ( for some( towards childcare) and we have a welfare state
I'm on various American disbilluty groups ,and I have yo say I'm glad I'm the parents of a disabled child in the UK rather than the US

BeanieTeen · 11/08/2022 19:31

I presume they don’t mean to harm their dogs - so it can only be sheer stupidity. And if you’re that stupid I don’t think you should own a dog. Or any pet of any kind.
I don’t see how you need social media and police warnings to work out a car gets hot, even with the window slightly cracked. You literally feel it every time the weather is hot and you open the car door. It’s just so insanely stupid to not understand this. It’s so stupid it hurts.

Leafy3 · 11/08/2022 19:28

Saw someone walking a chihuahua in a fleece today.
And another small dog in a bonnet.
😡😡

Changechangychange · 11/08/2022 19:27

@REP22 Yep. The amount of “oh she might have lost her job otherwise, what else could she do other than put her tiny baby’s life at serious risk” justification was just appalling.

Not from everyone, obviously, but it didn’t feel like many people really clocked how incredibly, incredibly dangerous it was - checking on the baby every two hours did not make it remotely safer, FFS.

And it is such a hideous, gruesome way to die - it’s not normally a site I feel the need to get into arguments on, but I honestly felt there needed to be visible pushback for anyone else reading who was tempted to do the same thing.