Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DH is being too harsh here?

213 replies

TheLostNights · 11/08/2022 11:55

DD is 7. Baby of the family.
DH thinks she manipulates me. For example she gets upset if I can't take her to school even though I never really have done because of work. She will have a long crying fit the night before or in the morning meaning I am often running late for work. It's not because she dislikes the event or person sje is left with, she just wants me or DH.
DH says she should have grown out of this now and that I need to stop pandering to it. Aibu to say she is still a little girl and it's natural for her to do this?

OP posts:
SnooozyTree · 11/08/2022 15:57

I've got one of those, op. She's 8.5 now and gets upset a lot more easily and a lot more often than her siblings. She's a real home body, and likes things to stay the same. She hates being away from me overnight, for example, whereas the other 2 love it. She can't help but burst into very dramatic tears when upset.

She will also regularly tell me about times she felt really sad, nervous or scared in the past - she might not have had the words or maturity at the time to do anything except cry, but she remembers very vividly.

She can have episodes like you describe where she just keeps getting upset about something over and over. I don't see it as manipulation in any way. She genuinely finds feeling big feelings difficult.

I will always listen and help her deal with the feelings when she's upset about something, but I set limits. So after we've talked about it and faced up to the fact that whatever it is has to be the way it is and had our hugs etc, I've had to get very firm and close down any further upset and discussion. "I know you are upset/you don't like it. It's hard for you. We've talked about it and I know you understand why it needs to happen like this. We cannot talk about it anymore. I'm going to go do xyz now." I might suggest she draws a picture or writes something about what's going on in her head.

It's been hard, but she's getting better at parking the thing and accepting the rational reasoning and moving on. It has also helped a lot to talk about feelings in general (when she's not upset) and reassure her that it's normal to feel apprehensive, worried, anxious, etc. Everyone does. And talk about the ways to deal with it.

I think your DH is right, to an extent, in that you have to help her set a limit and find a way to move on. But I don't think it's fair to say its manipulation. It's tough to deal with, and you have my sympathy.

One last thing to mention is that my older dd goes completely silent when upset or angry. She cannot describe her feelings, which worries me more in the longer term. So, while she is less dramatic, I don't think it's necessarily better.

Nat6999 · 11/08/2022 15:48

I would investigate autism, your dd sounds just like ds & we didn't get a diagnosis until he was 9.

mewkins · 11/08/2022 15:43

Op, it isn't clear whether it is tantrums or anxious crying. There have been a few kids in my children's classes who have been really anxious over their parents leaving them. They aren't badly behaved children at all but clearly emotional and anxious. I can relate as think this was me as a child (though I internalised it. I think you all need to understand what is going on in her head a bit more before you can address it properly and not have it manifest itself in other ways.

Thatboymum · 11/08/2022 15:37

i think your dh is quite rite your babying her and she’s turning into a nightmare for it, you need to stop pandering to it because you are teaching her absolutely nothing. At 7 I would find this super annoying, my 4 year old would behave like this occasionally but my 7 year old doesn’t and would swiftly be told to stop acting like a baby and do as he was told

NeverDropYourMooncup · 11/08/2022 15:31

You've given her a role as the 'baby of the family' and she's fulfilling what you have taught her to do.

That's not fair on her or anybody else.

DarkFruitz · 11/08/2022 15:29

Also, SEN or not, a child who is unable to self-regulate needs a trusted adult to help co-regulate them until they learn coping skills themselves.

You don’t teach someone to be “resilient” by abandoning them when they are distressed, or by “distracting” or “being firm.”

snowqu33n · 11/08/2022 15:28

She’s a pandemic kid.
I don’t think you can expect all the kids that have been through lockdowns and disruptions to be at the same stage socially as they might’ve been in past years.
I think some responses on the thread have been harsh OP.
If her behavior overall is good then it’s not that she’s being naughty.
She’s feeling insecure and it’s frustrating for you but it’s up to you to decide how to handle it next time. Come up with ideas and discuss them with your DH. Figure out a strategy and stick with the plan.

You don’t have to agree to handle it in a way you feel is too harsh, but you do need to come to an agreement and be on the same page as your DH or that will become an issue in itself.

Herejustforthisone · 11/08/2022 15:27

Stop indulging her spoilt behaviour. You’ll fuck her up.

BunnyHopDance · 11/08/2022 15:24

Your DH is right. This is happening because you are allowing it to happen.

You are not teaching your daughter how to be emotionally resilient, which means she’s really going to struggle.

DarkFruitz · 11/08/2022 15:23

@Mally100 - SEN is often mentioned for a reason. Do you know much about autism? If not, maybe pipe down and be glad that you haven’t had to educate yourself about it. FFS.

OP, my DD started to behave like this about school at 6/7. She seems overly attached to me but then could be “fine” when I wasn’t there. This even led school to insinuate, at drop off, that she was “manipulating” me. She showed, and still did, a real preference for me and showed her emotions to and around me. That is because she was masking around other people. I was her safe person.

To cut a long story short, my lovely, bright, kind, “normal but very anxious” little girl had a complete breakdown when she was 8. She was so unwell that she couldn’t go out or sleep and showed some really alarming behaviours and even talked about wanting to die. She has been supported by CAMHS and is still unable to attend school full-time although she is making progress.

We now know that she is autistic and was completely burnt out from trying to hold it together all the time. Her diagnosis report even explains the subtle signs that mean girls can be missed, and the effect that has on mental health.

There were a couple of things that stood out to be in your OP, might just be worth looking into autism and masking in girls:

sunsetsandsandybeaches · 11/08/2022 15:18

TheLostNights · 11/08/2022 14:33

DH just tells me that I am being manipulated by her. The other night, she was crying to me saying that she wanted me to take her to camp, it went on for hours and I was naturally concerned. DH said to her that it wasn't a possibility, that we wouldn't be able to, that other kids have childminders and other family members looking after them etc. He then told me to leave her be. She just seems so distraught and as a mother, it's so hard to deal with. She loves her aunt, just doesn't like it when she's there in place of us. Just feels hard seeing her in so much distress. She has always been an emotional child and I'm hoping she will just grow out of this.

Your DH is absolutely right.

Why are you concerned and pandering to her tantrum for hours? That's insanity. Just a straightforward "X is taking you tomorrow as mummy has to work. Now, do you want to sit and waste your day crying or shall we go and do X together?"

She's playing you like a fiddle. She's seven, not three, and more than capable of understanding that you can't always be there to take her to school or camp. But she's learnt that if she throws a fit, you'll come running and she'll get hours of your attention and fuss.

Just stop. Let her cry.

germsandcoffee · 11/08/2022 15:16

I'm not the kind of parent that panders to my child and I've got other perfectly fine children too ,but one of mine suffers from emotional regulation issues and believe me it's bloody hard work!
Child is receiving therapy for this and even the therapist says the child is hard work!
Everyone is unique and it's not always down to pandering!

PeekAtYou · 11/08/2022 15:14

It's normal for children not to get what they want all the time. Her wanting to be taken by you or her dad is also normal but being upset for hours is not. (You say that she loves her aunt so she is a suitable person to do the drop off)

I think offering a hug because she's disappointed is fine (everybody can be disappointed about something not going their way) but she'll never learn to deal with emotions if you're there n E ct to her for hours. It's ok for her to be on her own for a bit until the sadness passes. By staying with her for hours, it makes a little disappointment into a massive deal and teaches her that this is how she has your attention for hours.

When she was 2/3 did you sit by her side as soon as she tantrummed? Or did you wait until she started to calm down and help her at that point ?

If you could take her to camp but having SIL do it instead then you should feel guilty but you're working which is a legitimate reason not to be available. Don't feel guilty. People need to work.

Staynow · 11/08/2022 15:07

TheLostNights · 11/08/2022 14:33

DH just tells me that I am being manipulated by her. The other night, she was crying to me saying that she wanted me to take her to camp, it went on for hours and I was naturally concerned. DH said to her that it wasn't a possibility, that we wouldn't be able to, that other kids have childminders and other family members looking after them etc. He then told me to leave her be. She just seems so distraught and as a mother, it's so hard to deal with. She loves her aunt, just doesn't like it when she's there in place of us. Just feels hard seeing her in so much distress. She has always been an emotional child and I'm hoping she will just grow out of this.

I really wouldn't just 'leave her be'. Much better to try distracting her with a game or a story. I really wouldn't get annoyed or angry with her that will just make her more upset, lower her self esteem and/or make her feel she has to keep her emotions to herself.

You need to help her look for the positives IMO - you might not be able to take her to camp tomorrow but you can play a fun game with her right now! If she isn't interested in anything you suggest THEN you can 'leave her to it' by saying 'well if you change your mind I'll be downstairs doing x'. As soon as you gently walk away you might then find she suddenly is up for that game.

Staynow · 11/08/2022 15:00

I think it must be really hard if you've been able to take her to school for a few years and now can't. I know I would have really hated that as a child and having worked in before and after school club I know some kids (older than yours too) that struggled with it. For some it's a breeze and for others it's really tough and just feels like a really long day.

If there's no other choice then the best thing you can do is to help her make it ok for her, there are lots of things that people do for separation anxiety that might help. A hanky with your perfume on it, or something else of yours to keep in her pocket and look after for you - obviously nothing that you don't mind possibly getting lost!! Taking something else that is comforting to her to childcare, a favourite soft toy. Or perhaps having a special toy that is only for when she goes to child care. Planning what you are going to do together when you get home from work - a lovely routine, perhaps reading her a bit of story, a game and having a snack together. You can then chat on positively about how you can't wait to do this with her, what you'll read, what's happening in the story, what game you're going to play etc any time that she starts getting anxious/upset - just make sure you always follow through of course. You need to stay positive and talk up the good stuff and that will hopefully help her be more positive about it.

Sellorkeep · 11/08/2022 14:56

Op it is entirely normal that she prefers her parents to do stuff for her. As a stepmum i have had to grow a thick skin around this kind of stuff 😞.
But your daughter’s reaction and how long it goes on for us completely out of proportion. Your DH is right.

theremustonlybeone · 11/08/2022 14:52

Well your not helping the situation by hugging and responding to her the way you do. Its quite simple, as you know mummy works and i cant. No need to feed into the sobbing narrative, She is emotional as you haven't made any changes to your own response to her. She knows you work, she is old enough to understand that and you wont be taking her, You are the person that needs to change your response and you may find your DD will change hers. Sobbing and getting hysterical and it leading you to be late is ridiculous. I have a 7yr old and he doesn't sob and cry and isnt 'little'. I can have a conversation with him.

DubiousGoals · 11/08/2022 14:50

I just want to be sympathetic to that as it's a change for her

But that's just reinforcing the idea that change is a negative thing

Nietzschethehiker · 11/08/2022 14:39

What frustrates me about your posts op is that you aren't actually concerned with doing right by her. You are concerned with your emotions that you don't like seeing her upset. Frankly this is quite a selfish parenting response.

Ds at 6 went through this last year. I knew why , I knew the changes that he had been through. Thing is I hated seeing him upset so wanted to give him all the hugs etc etc. It is natural to feel like that but as parent she shouldn't be putting our feelings first.

If I had done that it would have made that phase three times as long. He was getting upset and if I had done the fluffy bit it would have confirmed there was something to be upset about. So I sucked it up and put my own feelings to one side. There were a lot of breezy " Come on kiddo we got this " with a quick squeeze. Ranging to a clear boundary. Anything else would have prolonged his distress.

His need to adapt and feel secure with a change and know that the adults had him covered was more important than me performance wailing or smothering him because I didn't like him being upset.

Ultimately you are making these incidents take longer with your pandering to it.

It comes to this is your need to baby her and show her your feelings more important than helping her through this stage in a way that causes least distress ?

Most of your posts have been about you and your feelings which is very telling

KettrickenSmiled · 11/08/2022 14:39

TheLostNights · 11/08/2022 14:33

DH just tells me that I am being manipulated by her. The other night, she was crying to me saying that she wanted me to take her to camp, it went on for hours and I was naturally concerned. DH said to her that it wasn't a possibility, that we wouldn't be able to, that other kids have childminders and other family members looking after them etc. He then told me to leave her be. She just seems so distraught and as a mother, it's so hard to deal with. She loves her aunt, just doesn't like it when she's there in place of us. Just feels hard seeing her in so much distress. She has always been an emotional child and I'm hoping she will just grow out of this.

She won't just grow out of it if you keep rewarding her for it with hours of your time OP.
it went on for hours and I was naturally concerned

Of course it's hard seeing her in distress, but your job as her parent is to teach her resilience & self-sufficiency.

And YES she is manipulating you. You have taught her that it works. That doesn't make her a bad child or you a bad parent. But it does mean that DH is correct & you need to change your method.

PastaCheese · 11/08/2022 14:37

TheLostNights · 11/08/2022 14:33

DH just tells me that I am being manipulated by her. The other night, she was crying to me saying that she wanted me to take her to camp, it went on for hours and I was naturally concerned. DH said to her that it wasn't a possibility, that we wouldn't be able to, that other kids have childminders and other family members looking after them etc. He then told me to leave her be. She just seems so distraught and as a mother, it's so hard to deal with. She loves her aunt, just doesn't like it when she's there in place of us. Just feels hard seeing her in so much distress. She has always been an emotional child and I'm hoping she will just grow out of this.

How will she grow out of it when you refuse to help her deal with these emotions properly?

You are seriously failing your DD and I'm not surprised your DH is annoyed with it

Mally100 · 11/08/2022 14:36

TheLostNights · 11/08/2022 14:33

DH just tells me that I am being manipulated by her. The other night, she was crying to me saying that she wanted me to take her to camp, it went on for hours and I was naturally concerned. DH said to her that it wasn't a possibility, that we wouldn't be able to, that other kids have childminders and other family members looking after them etc. He then told me to leave her be. She just seems so distraught and as a mother, it's so hard to deal with. She loves her aunt, just doesn't like it when she's there in place of us. Just feels hard seeing her in so much distress. She has always been an emotional child and I'm hoping she will just grow out of this.

Well that's not going to happen if you carry on the way you do. You are indulging her into behaving badly.

TheLostNights · 11/08/2022 14:33

DH just tells me that I am being manipulated by her. The other night, she was crying to me saying that she wanted me to take her to camp, it went on for hours and I was naturally concerned. DH said to her that it wasn't a possibility, that we wouldn't be able to, that other kids have childminders and other family members looking after them etc. He then told me to leave her be. She just seems so distraught and as a mother, it's so hard to deal with. She loves her aunt, just doesn't like it when she's there in place of us. Just feels hard seeing her in so much distress. She has always been an emotional child and I'm hoping she will just grow out of this.

OP posts:
Fushiadreams · 11/08/2022 14:24

Yes he’s right.

Hankunamatata · 11/08/2022 14:20

You dont make yourself late for work for a start. You give her one hug then go