Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DH is being too harsh here?

213 replies

TheLostNights · 11/08/2022 11:55

DD is 7. Baby of the family.
DH thinks she manipulates me. For example she gets upset if I can't take her to school even though I never really have done because of work. She will have a long crying fit the night before or in the morning meaning I am often running late for work. It's not because she dislikes the event or person sje is left with, she just wants me or DH.
DH says she should have grown out of this now and that I need to stop pandering to it. Aibu to say she is still a little girl and it's natural for her to do this?

OP posts:
Horoscopegubbins · 12/08/2022 19:20

Stop indulging. Just be factual - ' auntie Anne is taking you today. See you later darling.' Quick kiss. Bit of tactical ignoring is necessary. My mum always worked and I never tried it on because I knew she didn't have time for it.

Itsgettinghotinhre · 12/08/2022 19:18

Has it always been like this OP? I think at 7 unless it's a newish routine your DD should be used to different family members doing school drop offs.

Perhaps your DH is being harsh because he is fed up buy doesn't mean to come across that way.

Can you sit DD down and explain to her and take her for a nice treat with the understanding that she must not tantrum as you both need to work!

pollymere · 12/08/2022 19:12

Agewise I'm assuming she'll be going into KS3 in September. You are still treating her like a toddler. She needs to learn to be independent and realise she is making you late in the mornings. Plan how you are going to set her up so she can go into class on her own, and be confidently picked up at the end of the day.

amccabe15 · 12/08/2022 19:10

Maybe you could speak to her teacher (or the ta) to see if there is an underlying need. Is she needy at school? Maybe you could create special time for the two of you? I loved school but hated leaving my
mum on Monday morning or after school hols. NB I was the youngest too.

Luredbyapomegranate · 12/08/2022 18:42

She is just acting out OP

You need to be jollying her out of it, not encouraging it. If she likes her aunt there’s no reason she should make a fuss about being with her,

As long as she’s getting a decent amount of attention there’s no need for this. But I would try humour over stern words.

Insertcreativenamehere · 12/08/2022 18:40

its parenting like this that is allowing the snowflake generation to grow. They never hear ‘No’ so can’t deal with it when they do. It’s called resilience - do right by your daughter and allow her to see that the world isn’t going to fall apart if you don’t mollycoddle her.

Debbacat6 · 12/08/2022 18:34

Its you with the issue not her
Stop enabling her behaviour, be brisk and she will adapt

Maryminx · 12/08/2022 18:33

He is right.she is not a baby.
don’t tell her the night before who is taking her to school.
I feel she is not really naughty, she has got into a bad habit.

Mischance · 12/08/2022 18:30

One of my DDs read Charlotte's Web at about that age and became very clingy indeed, because the book had introduced the idea that mothers can die.

Needless to say I did not treat her as if she was being naughty and manipulative - I tried to understand and deal with it kindly.

If this child were behaving in a "manipulative" way in other areas of her life in order to get her own way then one approach might be appropriate. But this behaviour is limited to this situation, so maybe a different approach is needed. In either, an attempt to understand is the right thing.

Some posters are talking as if she is a dog to be trained.

TheHighStreetsAreDying · 12/08/2022 18:17

Going to go slightly against the grain here, but it's very common for 5-8 years olds to have episodes of separation anxiety. I remember vividly at the age of 7 not wanting my mum to leave me at school, and then crying quietly in the classroom for ages once she'd gone (this was the 1970s). I also remember being very concerned with the idea of 'losing' my parents at that age too - I used to pray every night for the house not to burn down, for example.

And over the years, now with my own children, and friends with theirs, there does seem to be a pattern of separation anxiety around the early Key Stage 2 years.

I will say my mum never 'pandered to me' because she had places to be, but that didn't make any difference to how I felt at the time. TBH, even writing this in support of the OP, I'm remembering the tight feelings in my chest of the anxiety back then.

OP, I hope you find a way through.

Starseeking · 12/08/2022 17:18

I'd expect that sort of behaviour from a 3 year old going to nursery, not a 7 year old attending school in Key Stage 2. Time for you to help her grow up, and stop treating your DD as a baby; you're not doing her any favours.

rightonthyme · 12/08/2022 17:09

She's 7!! YANBU bloody hell. Is she anxious or scared? Has she recently learned about death/bereavement and secretly worried one of you will get hurt and leave her?

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 12/08/2022 16:37

Mischance · 12/08/2022 15:08

She’s crying in order to control the situation, but sometimes, unfortunately especially when we’re children, we just have to do what other people tell us is happening.

And why does she feel the need to control this situation? What is it about this specific thing that makes her so fearful? When you are afraid, you do try and control the situation so that the feared outcome does not happen.

Or are we to assume that she has a malevolent desire to control?

Not everything a 7 year old does has a reason behind it, let alone a malevolent one.

So many people seem to forget that sometimes kids just do stuff. And sometimes they get into bad habits. Maybe this child genuinely felt upset that mum wasn’t about for drop off and cried, and now she’s taking advantage of that. There’s no moral judgment to that because she’s a child! But we can still describe it as manipulation because it is.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 12/08/2022 16:35

Purpleplaydohperson · 12/08/2022 12:50

I think it’s sad there is a lot of talk of ‘manipulating’ the op on this thread. I was an anxious child and I couldn’t help but cry when I was worried about something seemingly innocuous like this. I hated it and tried to stop myself but I couldn’t. If I had been given three wishes, my top wish would have been not to cry anymore, I just couldn’t help it. I had a list of lost things and losing shoes would have definitely provoked tears.
This was in the 90s so no help, no support from school etc.

There’s a lot of talk from both sides. Literally all of us are making assumptions based on what the OP is telling us.

I’m on the husband‘s side based on that.

Be honest - if you were anxious and crying because neither parent could take you to day camp, would it have helped if mum patted and shushed and there there’d you for hours? I suspect not.

There’s a middle ground between what OP is doing and suggestions to just completely ignore her.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 12/08/2022 15:40

She may not be fearful, she may well have learned that crying gets her what she wants. If a toddler has a tantrum because a parent won't buy them a cake you deal with it by removing them from the situation, giving them a cuddle , telling them no, or other methods. What you don't do is a, buy the cake or b spend hours sat in the supermarket waiting for them to stop.

If the DD knows crying is going to get her mummy to take her to school or camp or mummy to spend hours sat with her then thats what she is going to do.

Mischance · 12/08/2022 15:08

She’s crying in order to control the situation, but sometimes, unfortunately especially when we’re children, we just have to do what other people tell us is happening.

And why does she feel the need to control this situation? What is it about this specific thing that makes her so fearful? When you are afraid, you do try and control the situation so that the feared outcome does not happen.

Or are we to assume that she has a malevolent desire to control?

VariationsonaTheme · 12/08/2022 14:59

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 11/08/2022 18:26

Also, SEN or not, a child who is unable to self-regulate needs a trusted adult to help co-regulate them until they learn coping skills themselves.

You don’t teach someone to be “resilient” by abandoning them when they are distressed, or by “distracting” or “being firm.”

This!

Im not saying it’s “normal” or desirable behaviour, but there’ll be a reason that needs to be dealt with, not just manipulating Mum for shits and giggles. A 7 yo wouldn’t normally want to be seen crying, for example, unless it was something really bad - they like to appear grown up even when they aren’t.

Find the reason and you can solve the problem. Just “being firm” won’t help her to become and emotionally secure adult.

Bring firm and calm is modelling the appropriate emotional response for the situation though, and that is how children learn to self-regulate.

She’s crying in order to control the situation, but sometimes, unfortunately especially when we’re children, we just have to do what other people tell us is happening.

autienotnaughty · 12/08/2022 14:43

Stickworm · 12/08/2022 14:23

I find it so funny how many people on mumsnet forums seem to demonise children as if they’re all out to get us 😂

I think they have been watching the Midwich Cookoos 😂😂

Softplayhooray · 12/08/2022 14:38

SpeckofDustUponMySoul · 11/08/2022 21:52

Fucking hell, OP, you either have the patience of a Saint, or a total wet blanket, as there is no way I could ensure 'hours' of my child crying like this.
YOU are the adult. Take. Charge. And, that doesn't mean you have to be authoritarian or harsh, but equip yourself with the skills to support your child in moving beyond this behaviour.
I'm not suggesting she is throwing tantrums, manipulating you, spoilt etc, but you are doing her, yourself and your husband no favours by your namby pamby response to this.
You don't appear to have taken on any feedback from PPs and are still explaining how hard it is to see your 'baby' (she's 7, FFS) so 'sad'.
What is undesirable and age inappropriate behaviour now will be somewhat repugnant when she is nearing high school age.
You need to shut this shit down.

Why so aggressive for a post about a 7 year old?

Softplayhooray · 12/08/2022 14:34

TheLostNights · 11/08/2022 12:21

But that's all I do. Sympathise, talk to her and hug her to show I understand. I agree it goes on too long, it's just hard to reason with her at times. DH's method just seems more cold. Sometimes it also happens when she can't find her favourite shoes to wear which I agree is not not age appropriate but a lot of the time it's because she wants us to stay. We have rarely used help from family before or friends as work has allowed us to do drop offs and pick ups so because things have changed, I think she is reacting to that.

Going against the grain here, but I think there is something else going on. Every kid is different and it sounds like some kind of anxiety, maybe manifesting as separation anxiety. OP I think you are doing the right thing by being reassuring if that's the case, and maybe it'd be a good idea to speak to the GP or investigate a bit further. Kids can suffer anxiety just like an adult and if she has it, comments like she's being babied, or entitled, are going to make it all a lot worse.

Stickworm · 12/08/2022 14:23

I find it so funny how many people on mumsnet forums seem to demonise children as if they’re all out to get us 😂

Stickworm · 12/08/2022 14:23

@Snaketime what do you think she is trying to gain from ‘manipulation’ rather than just wanting her mum and dad?

Snaketime · 12/08/2022 13:07

TheLostNights · 11/08/2022 18:16

She is not autistic. Nobody has ever suggested that. She has a lot of friends and outside of the tines I mentioned, is very happy when she's at home with me and DH.
To answer someone's question, she isnt getting onto the floor and tantrumming. She just sits there and cries loudly, telling us over and over again that she wants us to take her to school or camp. It's really hard seeing your child in distress. I know this can't continue but it isn't easy seeing your child so sad.

She isn't actually sad though she is manipulating you and you are dragging it out and making it worse.
My DD8 is like yours OP and my DS4 has started copying her. You don't have to be cold, but you need to stop pandering to her. When she is crying because she wants you to take her to school just give her a big hug and whilst hugging her say "I know you want me to take you to school, I wish I could too, but I can't because of xyz" then give her a kiss and walk away. Do not engage more than that.

Purpleplaydohperson · 12/08/2022 12:50

I think it’s sad there is a lot of talk of ‘manipulating’ the op on this thread. I was an anxious child and I couldn’t help but cry when I was worried about something seemingly innocuous like this. I hated it and tried to stop myself but I couldn’t. If I had been given three wishes, my top wish would have been not to cry anymore, I just couldn’t help it. I had a list of lost things and losing shoes would have definitely provoked tears.
This was in the 90s so no help, no support from school etc.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/08/2022 12:28

I am not for one second suggesting you should just tell your daughter to get on with it, but I wonder if you have developed a strange codependency dynamic here. Where she cries which is they rewarded by lots of attention and cuddles and her ultimately getting her own way.
You can be sympathetic and response to your child, while still holding boundaries. No boundaries isn't a good thing.