Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DH is being too harsh here?

213 replies

TheLostNights · 11/08/2022 11:55

DD is 7. Baby of the family.
DH thinks she manipulates me. For example she gets upset if I can't take her to school even though I never really have done because of work. She will have a long crying fit the night before or in the morning meaning I am often running late for work. It's not because she dislikes the event or person sje is left with, she just wants me or DH.
DH says she should have grown out of this now and that I need to stop pandering to it. Aibu to say she is still a little girl and it's natural for her to do this?

OP posts:
SoSoSusan · 12/08/2022 21:44

Some posters are talking as if she is a dog to be trained

Personally I find young children and dogs similar anyway.

Delighted to go to the park - check.
Your best friend if you give them a tasty treat - check.
Exercise them thoroughly or the bastards will never sleep - check.
Teach them respect, so they know their place and who's in charge - check.
Reinforce positive behaviour with lots of praise - check.
Repetition is key for them to learn something new - check.

Phoenixwings1989 · 12/08/2022 21:35

The majority of these comments horrify me.

I'll tell you OP, I wish my mum had been as concerned about me as you are with your daughter. Maybe things would have been very different indeed. Unfortunately like most people here, my mum thought I was just 'playing up' and being 'a spoilt brat' which I can assure you was far from the truth. She was convinced by this by several people - one of these being the person who was abusing me physically and she stood by this while he dealt out his 'rightful' punishment. Tsk! Sure!

I can assure you, it sorted me right out. I didn't bother asking for help not did I whine and she thought everybody was right. They weren't. They couldn't have been more horrifically wrong. And it's due to these comments I don't confide in anybody because if you can't be a 7 year old with worries or extreme behaviours what hope does an adult have to express herself in the world?

I'll tell you. Bob hope and no hope.

I've studied child psychology as a hobby as a result of the trauma from my childhood (yes, I can imagine some of the commentators sniggering at that and shame on you!), if a child's behaviour changes suddenly then that's not a sign of misbehaviour. These are warning bells alerting you to a problem. This calls for investigation into what this problem is. But like me, I didn't tell anyone about what was happening at home due to all the negativity other people felt the need to throw in.

You know your DD best, OP. If this is new behaviour then please do get to the bottom of it. And please do not let my history worry you. My circumstances were extreme.

CatsnCoffee · 12/08/2022 21:32

@Staynow At last someone caring and sympathetic. Yes, great advice!

Beelezebub · 12/08/2022 21:24

I’ve got one of these. We allow it to go on for a period of time so he’s got space to talk about his feelings and why he feels them - that time can vary depending on whether he’s trying it on. (Because he’s not daft, and he’s absolutely 100% learned that behaving in this way gets a ‘reward’. Sometimes the time we allow is about 3 seconds.)

Then he gets a brisk reminder that everyone has things they feel that they don’t like and it’s time for x now. Because he also has to learn to deal with those feelings himself - we can’t do it for him. And he needs to learn that he will be disappointed or sad or what have you, but that the world won’t end.

You’re not teaching her anything helpful because you’re giving her no tools, just reinforcing her behaviour.

CatsnCoffee · 12/08/2022 21:23

A lot of people on here are jumping to some very strong conclusions on very slight information.
For context, we need to know if this behaviour is typical for your dd in all circumstances or is it unique to occasions where she’s being separated from you?
Is she generally a sensitive child? Could she be genuinely upset/fearful of separation?
If, as your DH suspects she’s being manipulative, is this observable in other contexts? If this is the only way in which she is ‘manipulative’ there may be more to it than that.
Maybe she just needs reassurance eg an extra 5 minutes of your time at bedtime; extra hugs when she sees you after school or just 5 minutes with you away from DH.

Poppinjay · 12/08/2022 21:15

@TheLostNights

Listen to your instincts. They are usually right.

Is tantrumming an effective way for your DD to get her own way? If it doesn't generally work for her and you don't take her to school when she cries, it's unlikely that this is manipulative behaviour. If it feels like genuine distress, she need you to help her by finding out the root of her emotions and helping to address it. Emotionally detatching from her when she is distressed may stop her outward behaviour but it won't reduce the underlying distress.

Please don't believe the myth that you can teach resilience by being tough on children. Children become resilient when their needs are met effectively and they feel secure and competent to manage the emotions that result from challenging situations. That comes from responsive parenting, not tough love.

Children are programmed to learn independence, just like they are programmed to learn to walk. They will do it in their own time and pushing them to do it before they are ready is likely to be counterproductive.

Follow the PP's advice and look into therapeutic parenting. It's much more likely to be your answer than going against your instincts and causing your DD additional distress.

Mandyjack · 12/08/2022 21:05

Instead of him coming down hard on her I think you need to try and get to the bottom of why she's so upset. Talk to her yourself, just you and her. It sounds like it could be she's feeling rejected by you both and wants more time with you. I agree she's still a little girl.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 12/08/2022 21:04

Stickworm · 12/08/2022 21:01

No telling them to stop being bratty and crying for no reason?

I’m so glad I’m not your kid 🙈

Me too! My kids are teens and adults now, I'm so glad I brought them up to respect the others around them and taught them you do not get your own way by crying and being bratty.

They are awesome!

Stickworm · 12/08/2022 21:01

No telling them to stop being bratty and crying for no reason?

I’m so glad I’m not your kid 🙈

Tallulah1972 · 12/08/2022 20:52

There might be some sort of attachment issue going on here. If you’re on Facebook, have a look at Therapeutic Parenting page. Put the same post on there & you’ll get so much more positive support.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 12/08/2022 20:50

Some posters are talking as if she is a dog to be trained

Nope she is a child that needs to be trained. Honestly some of the responses on here are unreal, Are we now saying we dont need to train our children to become normal functioning adults?

So no training to sleep on thier own? (I'm sure some of the cruncy mums will pick this one up).
No potty training?
No weaning?
No leaving them with anyone else other than mum?
No telling them to stop being bratty and crying for no reason?

I just don't get it!

Burgoo · 12/08/2022 20:36

@CoffeeDeprivation "I personally don't think they "manipulate" us at that age"

Naivety at its finest. Children will always manipulate their environment, much like adults. They do it to get what they need, attention, affection, food etc. It isn't a BAD thing, its just what it is.

Our 2 year old started (trying) playing my wife and I off each other a year ago! Some good old fashioned reinforcers and aversive consequences soon stopped that!

Incognitomum11 · 12/08/2022 20:35

@DarkFruitz yes…
it’s sad to read all the comments.

Burgoo · 12/08/2022 20:32

ALL behaviour is caused. Figuring out why this happens may be a good starting position.

That said, what are you unintentionally reinforcing? If you reward unwanted behaviour that will make it worse. If you remove distress you will also make the behaviour worse.

I'd say tell her what is expected and that you care AND at the same time it isn't happening.

winterchills · 12/08/2022 20:30

I'm team husband as well. You are enabling her. Yes she is a little girl but she is not a toddler and can't dictate who drops off.

Quia · 12/08/2022 20:29

Have you had the conversation with her when she's calm about how you don't have a choice, you just can't take her to school, and that crying about it can't change that? Does she accept that? Perhaps you could start with a reward system for when she doesn't make a fuss?

Violinist64 · 12/08/2022 20:28

Blossomtoes · 11/08/2022 12:20

A brisk “Off you go, see you later” every time will soon stop this. Team DH.

Couldn’t agree more more.

CoffeeDeprivation · 12/08/2022 20:25

I'd struggle as well. I have a 7yo and I do feel they are little. My eldest (now 10yo) had separation anxiety at bedtime around that age. She cried and cried and cried. We tried gentle parenting, we tried stern and firm. The latter was worse and I do believe that she's now more insecure because of it. I regretted it and wished we sympathised more. As I see it, cuddles and showing you care about their emotions is perfectly fine and healthy, just don't backtrack on whatever the action was. We let her cry out at the time and we don't think it was good for her in the long run.

If she only does it with you, then your behaviour is leading it, though. If she does it with your DH as well, even when he is on his own with her, I'd be inclined to think something else is going on. I would personally look into this a bit more. Has it always been like this or is it now more pronounced? Is she worrying only about you leaving or both of you? Is this since school stopped or throughout the year? Are there big changes happening in her close circle (family, best friends) such as moving abroad, separations, changing schools, etc that she might be worried about happening to her family unit? I personally don't think they "manipulate" us at that age but they "cry for help" and cry for attention, meaning something goes on in their heads.

EATmum · 12/08/2022 20:04

Just a different perspective. One of my DC became suddenly anxious around 7/8. Every time we left the house (even when we went to the loo!) she would panic and cry. It was very odd, came from nowhere, no incident. After a couple of months I took her to the doctor, as I had no idea how to help her and thought she might need counselling.

The doctor gently pointed out that she had a low grade fever, her glands were all up and that she had glandular fever. The anxiety was a symptom.

So, always accepting that you're probably a much better parent than me (who probably owns a digital thermometer and doesn't just rely on a hand on the forehead), you might want to check if there's a physical cause.

Redshell1976 · 12/08/2022 20:04

I just can’t read anymore of the comments, the amount of judgement is making me crazy. Your child, your choice, do the right thing by her and you and you can’t go far wrong. What’s wrong with her wanting hugs and wanting her mum, nothing. She is growing up and has big feelings. You do you.

DarkFruitz · 12/08/2022 20:04

@Incognitomum11 - I previously suggested looking into autism in girls, as I have an autistic DD who presented in the same way before she diagnosed.

I was told off by several posters as “not every child is autistic” and apparently there was “nothing in the OP’s posts” to suggest that, just bratty behaviour clearly 🤷🏻‍♀️

I’ve worked in mental health settings with seriously ill young people and, sadly, I’ve seen some of the effects of late diagnosis and the trauma of being labelled as naughty or manipulative, throughout primary school 😞

Incognitomum11 · 12/08/2022 19:56

Maybe your daughter is autistic…? I have two (now teens) who would behave in similar ways and one who never did. People are always so quick to shout spoiled when they have no idea.

Happyhappyday · 12/08/2022 19:47

She puts on such a big performance because you give her so much attention when she does it. NOT because it’s so distressing. Sometimes as a parent you do need to set clear boundaries to help kids feel safe, even if they do t like it.

I used to be an overnight camp counselor and 100% the worst thing parents would do got homesick kids would be to tell them they’d pick them up if they just stayed one more day, one more phone call etc. Kids would be distraught and unable to focus on camp and having fun. If the parent said, I understand you’re homesick but here are some great fun things you’re going to do, can’t wait to hear at the end of the week and that was the end of it, those kids quickly forgot about home and had fun.

indulging your daughters extreme reaction really isn’t doing her any favors. You say, it is different, and I would love to take you to school but I do need to go to work now. Love you, big hug. Sometimes you do need to physically unwrap arms and shut the door. 🤷‍♀️Literally toddlers are ok with this.

Nanny0gg · 12/08/2022 19:27

TheLostNights · 11/08/2022 18:16

She is not autistic. Nobody has ever suggested that. She has a lot of friends and outside of the tines I mentioned, is very happy when she's at home with me and DH.
To answer someone's question, she isnt getting onto the floor and tantrumming. She just sits there and cries loudly, telling us over and over again that she wants us to take her to school or camp. It's really hard seeing your child in distress. I know this can't continue but it isn't easy seeing your child so sad.

That's not sad.

That's manipulating and you're letting her

DrSK2 · 12/08/2022 19:20

I’m here to say that whatever the whole world thinks/reasons, it is the mother’s gut feeling that really does justice to a child. Please only listen to your own instincts and feelings, and never stop showing compassion towards your daughter — even if this means being late to work or doing the totally avoidable school run. They don’t matter in the grand scheme of things. Children will always remember how they are valued and cherished or dismissed — the feelings translate into self-worth or lack of it as they become adults.