Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to make DS pay for his own cleats?

90 replies

CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 06:59

DS is newly 15 and has been working at an ice cream place this summer (we’re American so he is out of school from the end of May until the first week of September). It’s only open through Halloween so he just has a handful of paychecks left (if he doesn’t get another job through the winter, which he might as I think he’s gotten pretty used to spending money!)

The reason he got a job (most kids in his year haven’t yet) is that he wants to go on an expensive band trip next year. I told him he’d have to get a job and make half the money (or at least show that he was putting forth the effort) because we couldn’t afford to pay for the whole thing. He agreed and got the job.

The issue is, he’s saved nothing. He buys snacks and drinks almost daily, protein powder, bought a custom color baseball glove for $200, and has bought 4 or 5 hats that cost upwards of $50 apiece, as well as various other stuff (t-shirts, various teen boy stuff).

He came to me today and said he needs new cleats for football that’s just starting up. These cleats are anywhere from $100-$200 and I just don’t have it to spare this week, nor are we likely to in the next few weeks.

With school starting soon DH and I have got all three of them to buy for (he has a little brother and sister, 9 and 7), all of their school supplies and odds and ends, parkas (we live in a cold climate so solid winter gear is a must).

Tonight I told him if he needs the cleats soon he’s going to have to buy them himself. He acted completely shocked and like I was being utterly ridiculous.

Am I? I feel bad. It’s just that we have paid a ridiculous amount for sports stuff in the past few years…wrestling camps, baseball camps, batting gloves, baseball gloves, cleats for two sports and wrestling shoes, the fees for three sports themselves, mouth guards etc, and everything has to be “the best”. As well as all this protein powder he thinks he needs and a gym membership that’s $50/month. DH grumbles about it but I have just always felt that this is what you do when you have kids, you pay for their passions and opportunities.

I can’t pay for the cleats right now regardless as I just do not have it, but AIBU to have him buy them? Should I pay him back for them later?

He’s our oldest so I’ve never dealt with any kind of teen/money stuff before.

OP posts:
HesA10ButNothing · 11/08/2022 07:32

And he needs some lessons in saving money and being more organised! At 15 my son wasn’t the most organised but by 16/17, he was much better.

Needmorelego · 11/08/2022 07:30

Is football played through his school? Do they not provide equipment for those unable to afford it? Or have a scheme to pay for it in instalments? Could you buy secondhand ones from an older teen who has left the team?

HesA10ButNothing · 11/08/2022 07:29

Just seen the trip is now not something he can nog go on. On that case he needs to give you money each month that will cover the trip, no excuses, he hands it over when he’s gets paid. But you still need to buy other things he needs for football.

CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 07:29

HesA10ButNothing · 11/08/2022 07:26

The job was to pay for the trip. If he doesn’t save, he doesn’t get to go. That’s fair as that was the discussed. But it’s not fair that just because he has got a job, that he now has to pay for things he’d have needed anyway, not at 15.

He will get to go regardless as we are not allowed to back out. That feels frustrating to me as I feel like he knows that and isn’t taking it seriously.

I’m okay with paying for the cleats but I can’t do it now and didn’t know he needed them until today because he said he didn’t (through a misunderstanding).

OP posts:
TheTeenageYears · 11/08/2022 07:26

He's 15 so job or not it's still your responsibility to pay for things the DC need. What constitutes a need will vary depending on your situation. If the cleats are for a school non optional activity they are a need. If they are for an optional activity then you can as a parent explain you unfortunately aren't in a position to pay for extras currently but all 3 DC need to be treated equally with regards to extra's. You made the rules clear about the trip so if he doesn't save half the money because he's wasted it that's down to him and he won't get to go - just remind him of that when he's bought something new.

HesA10ButNothing · 11/08/2022 07:26

The job was to pay for the trip. If he doesn’t save, he doesn’t get to go. That’s fair as that was the discussed. But it’s not fair that just because he has got a job, that he now has to pay for things he’d have needed anyway, not at 15.

CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 07:25

LoveKingGary · 11/08/2022 07:07

I'd pay for the cleats, or pay him back if he pays, but I'd absolutely reinforce to him he will not be going on the band trip unless he saves towards it and pays his share.

It's tough because on some level he seems to think you'll just bail him out in the end for the trip and that's not the message you want to send!

Yes, and unfortunately we can’t back out of the trip, so if he doesn’t save the money, DH and I will be left holding the bag.

I’m attempting to help him look for budget friendly options he can get since he all of a sudden needs them by Monday (he told me he was good for the year, but thought I meant baseball cleats, so this is new information to me too 🤦‍♀️), but if he gets cheapies for practice I will purchase better ones in a few weeks for games.

OP posts:
CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 07:21

Brefugee · 11/08/2022 07:14

While i think you're being a bit unfair to spring this on him, i do think that you might say "can you buy them from your savings, and I'll reimburse you next month when we have a bit more slack in the budget?"

And you say he hasn't been saving? You need to have a chat with him about this so that he doesn't have to cancel the trip. He's 15 and he must learn about these things, but he needs closer supervision from you at this age.

Right, and the part that’s making me really anxious is that we CANNOT cancel the trip. Because they pro-rate it based on the number of students going, once you’re in, you’re in.

So yes I think a serious chat is in order and going forward he’ll have to not spend on extras until the money for the trip has been set aside and verified by me and his dad.

OP posts:
CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 07:19

It doesn’t feel unfair to me that he’s spending it while I’m paying bills, I meant, RealBecca. :) Of course I expect to be paying for the bills and I’m glad he’s had a good summer and bought fun things. I just wish that he had listened to what I said.

OP posts:
CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 07:18

RealBecca · 11/08/2022 07:11

I think you're being massively unfair. Hes 15 and at that age parents pay for the things that come with the sports they support their child on doing. You would pay if he didn't have a job.

I get it, it feels unfair that he has all this free spending money and you have bills to pay. He got that job to earn money for a trip, not to pay for his essential sportswear. FWIW it's entirely reasonable to buy budget and allow him to pay the rest for top of the range.

I'm sorry, i's just parent/child life. This is the only time he will have this time of his life.

But I think you should have an adult conversation along the lines of him knowing how hard it is to earn that money and you just dont have it right now so he will need to wait or accept basic equipment.

Ultimately I dont think at 15 he should be penalised for being immature or expected to pay for himself in the way an adult would.

It doesn’t really feel unfair as such, I certainly do expect him to spend a lot of it on fun things since he’s just 15.

It’s just difficult as I really absolutely do not have it right now, and I asked him a few months back if he would need cleats this year. He said no, but we got our wires crossed as he thought I meant baseball.

I think most of my irritation stems from the fact that I did not know how much he was spending and I had repeatedly expressed that I wanted him to set the trip money aside first and foremost and then decide what to do with the rest, and he’s not done that.

OP posts:
Brefugee · 11/08/2022 07:14

While i think you're being a bit unfair to spring this on him, i do think that you might say "can you buy them from your savings, and I'll reimburse you next month when we have a bit more slack in the budget?"

And you say he hasn't been saving? You need to have a chat with him about this so that he doesn't have to cancel the trip. He's 15 and he must learn about these things, but he needs closer supervision from you at this age.

RealBecca · 11/08/2022 07:11

I think you're being massively unfair. Hes 15 and at that age parents pay for the things that come with the sports they support their child on doing. You would pay if he didn't have a job.

I get it, it feels unfair that he has all this free spending money and you have bills to pay. He got that job to earn money for a trip, not to pay for his essential sportswear. FWIW it's entirely reasonable to buy budget and allow him to pay the rest for top of the range.

I'm sorry, i's just parent/child life. This is the only time he will have this time of his life.

But I think you should have an adult conversation along the lines of him knowing how hard it is to earn that money and you just dont have it right now so he will need to wait or accept basic equipment.

Ultimately I dont think at 15 he should be penalised for being immature or expected to pay for himself in the way an adult would.

LoveKingGary · 11/08/2022 07:07

I'd pay for the cleats, or pay him back if he pays, but I'd absolutely reinforce to him he will not be going on the band trip unless he saves towards it and pays his share.

It's tough because on some level he seems to think you'll just bail him out in the end for the trip and that's not the message you want to send!

HikingforScenery · 11/08/2022 07:04

You’re kind of moving the goalposts. You asked him to pay for his trip, not his usual sports equipment. He’s still a minor so I think you should pay, especially as you gave him no warning beforehand

Findahouse21 · 11/08/2022 07:03

I think it's unreasonable just to spring it on him without notice - how would he know to save for them unless you told him what his wages needed to cover? I think he needed more guidance and support - that's a lot of 'disposable' income for a youngish teen so not surprising that he has spent it.