Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to make DS pay for his own cleats?

90 replies

CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 06:59

DS is newly 15 and has been working at an ice cream place this summer (we’re American so he is out of school from the end of May until the first week of September). It’s only open through Halloween so he just has a handful of paychecks left (if he doesn’t get another job through the winter, which he might as I think he’s gotten pretty used to spending money!)

The reason he got a job (most kids in his year haven’t yet) is that he wants to go on an expensive band trip next year. I told him he’d have to get a job and make half the money (or at least show that he was putting forth the effort) because we couldn’t afford to pay for the whole thing. He agreed and got the job.

The issue is, he’s saved nothing. He buys snacks and drinks almost daily, protein powder, bought a custom color baseball glove for $200, and has bought 4 or 5 hats that cost upwards of $50 apiece, as well as various other stuff (t-shirts, various teen boy stuff).

He came to me today and said he needs new cleats for football that’s just starting up. These cleats are anywhere from $100-$200 and I just don’t have it to spare this week, nor are we likely to in the next few weeks.

With school starting soon DH and I have got all three of them to buy for (he has a little brother and sister, 9 and 7), all of their school supplies and odds and ends, parkas (we live in a cold climate so solid winter gear is a must).

Tonight I told him if he needs the cleats soon he’s going to have to buy them himself. He acted completely shocked and like I was being utterly ridiculous.

Am I? I feel bad. It’s just that we have paid a ridiculous amount for sports stuff in the past few years…wrestling camps, baseball camps, batting gloves, baseball gloves, cleats for two sports and wrestling shoes, the fees for three sports themselves, mouth guards etc, and everything has to be “the best”. As well as all this protein powder he thinks he needs and a gym membership that’s $50/month. DH grumbles about it but I have just always felt that this is what you do when you have kids, you pay for their passions and opportunities.

I can’t pay for the cleats right now regardless as I just do not have it, but AIBU to have him buy them? Should I pay him back for them later?

He’s our oldest so I’ve never dealt with any kind of teen/money stuff before.

OP posts:
CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 09:33

perimenofertility · 11/08/2022 09:29

I think you are being unfair with this. He's 15 so still a child and he needs them for football. That's your responsibility.
But I definitely wouldn't be paying for his band trip next year. You made it clear that he would need to save part of the cost for you to also pay part of the cost but he hasn't, he's chosen to use his money for other things.

Again, we do not have a choice about paying for the band trip.

OP posts:
CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 09:32

Shinyandnew1 · 11/08/2022 09:25

So he’s worked al summer, nearly paid off a holiday, bought himself clothes and paid for a new phone. Isn’t that all good?! You can’t change the goal posts now.

He hasn’t paid anything to the holiday so far because the first few installments had to be paid when he wasn’t working yet, so we paid them.

I am proud that he’s worked and that he bought his own phone and I already see him taking much better care of it than the previous one, so I think that’s been a good lesson in treating things well when you have some skin in the game!

He got the job because of the trip, yes, but we did say it would also pay for some extras here and there (movies etc) I guess it’s just whether or not cleats count as extra!

I found a good cheap pair on eBay but he said they won’t get here in time, so I’m going to have a look with him tomorrow and explain what I can pay now and what I can’t.

and then we’re going to discuss the trip savings!

OP posts:
perimenofertility · 11/08/2022 09:31

To add also that a 15 year old suddenly earning money - of course he's going to enjoy spending it! It's a parents responsibility to give him some financial education, budgeting advice, etc. How else will he learn?!

perimenofertility · 11/08/2022 09:29

I think you are being unfair with this. He's 15 so still a child and he needs them for football. That's your responsibility.
But I definitely wouldn't be paying for his band trip next year. You made it clear that he would need to save part of the cost for you to also pay part of the cost but he hasn't, he's chosen to use his money for other things.

CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 09:27

Smellywellyhoo · 11/08/2022 09:17

You need to buy the cleats (whatever they are). The job isn't to provide a back up funding source for when you've over spent.

Okay. However, I literally don’t have the money.

I could be wrong, and I apologize if I am, but I feel like you’re insinuating something by saying I’ve “overspent.”

I haven’t frittered away hundreds of thousands of dollars on mink stoles and diamond tiaras.

My husband lost his job a few years back (he’s now working again)and we were just beginning to claw our way back out of massive debt when COVID hit, which had a huge effect on our finances.

We owe thousands to the mortgage and the electric, we have three kids have been home for three solid months, which also affected our work schedules as it does all American parents every summer. Gas for DH to drive to 40 miles to work three days a week is insanity.

Now the start of school is just around the corner and they all have grown out of everything and need 8000 notebooks and pencils and folders and Kleenex and Lysol wipes and a vial full of unicorn tears or what have you 🤣 on top of sports fees for all three and the gym membership and DH’s appointments to the chiropractor that our insurance doesn’t cover and who knows what else.

It’s life and it costs money and that’s fine, but it bothers me to hear you say I’ve “overspent” when I’m doing the best that I can.

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 11/08/2022 09:25

CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 09:18

Oh! I did forget that a chunk of his early money from when he started working in May went to a new phone.

He had a phone, I asked him to choose a case for it, he never did, and (you might see where this is going) it broke. 🤦‍♀️ I told him when he got the job that he could use some of this money to get a new phone if he wanted a fancier one than I was willing to provide, which he did.

So I guess he hasn’t spent it ALL on baseball hats.

So he’s worked al summer, nearly paid off a holiday, bought himself clothes and paid for a new phone. Isn’t that all good?! You can’t change the goal posts now.

CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 09:18

Oh! I did forget that a chunk of his early money from when he started working in May went to a new phone.

He had a phone, I asked him to choose a case for it, he never did, and (you might see where this is going) it broke. 🤦‍♀️ I told him when he got the job that he could use some of this money to get a new phone if he wanted a fancier one than I was willing to provide, which he did.

So I guess he hasn’t spent it ALL on baseball hats.

OP posts:
Smellywellyhoo · 11/08/2022 09:17

You need to buy the cleats (whatever they are). The job isn't to provide a back up funding source for when you've over spent.

CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 09:16

Shinyandnew1 · 11/08/2022 09:11

Ah right- I thought you meant he had that left in his savings.

So he can earn that in the next fortnight and the holiday is paid off?

I think so- at least it’s close enough to the amount due that I’d be satisfied with it, and if any other costs do arise related to the trip, I’ll be willing to pay them with strict parameters of things he can do around the house or for his grandparents to earn it.

OP posts:
CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 09:15

Brefugee · 11/08/2022 09:03

When I asked about the savings I should have pressed harder, I know, because he would give me vague answers or what I now know must have been outright lies about his account balance. My husband has that information on his phone; I’m going to have to start checking it regularly as clearly he has not been.

just spotted this OP. Why don't you just pass it over to your husband since he could have been monitoring it loosely all along?

Because he’ll just say DS needs to pay for the cleats himself full stop and that’s the end of it.

He also wanted him to pay for the sports fees and other things too and I said no, that’s not on and we’re paying them.

DH isn’t overly harsh normally, he’s actually a giant pushover as he doesn’t do conflict, I’m the tough one lots of the time.

But he grew up on a dairy farm and got up every morning at 5 am to milk from the time he was 7 or 8 until he was 17. He wasn’t allowed to play sports or anything else in school past age 13 or so because he was needed on the farm. He never had trips away or birthday parties or anything like that 😞

So he and DS butt heads on a lot of things and he sees DS as spoiled and somewhat selfish, whereas I (who had to do much less than DS and barely graduated because I didn’t apply myself at all), see him as a basically good kid who is the normal amount of selfish for his age and want to give him the opportunities I can.

Which just unfortunately do not extend to cleats this week.

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 11/08/2022 09:11

CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 09:07

When I said he has $350 left, I meant he has $350 left to pay on the trip.

Ah right- I thought you meant he had that left in his savings.

So he can earn that in the next fortnight and the holiday is paid off?

CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 09:07

Shinyandnew1 · 11/08/2022 08:57

How much is the trip?

When I said he has $350 left, I meant he has $350 left to pay on the trip.

OP posts:
FawnFrenchieMum · 11/08/2022 09:06

This is definitely on you for not telling how much he needed to give you each week towards the trip (you could have then used this for the cleats and put it back later on if needed).

My ds15 is working over the summer for the first time. We agreed before he started that each week 50% needed to go into a savings account so that he still has money once he’s back at school in Sept. Each week that’s what he’s done. Some weeks he has had other money left over so added that as well.

We are still providing anything we would have done pre-summer job. You can’t punish them for going out and working otherwise they might not bother next time.

CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 09:06

Brefugee · 11/08/2022 08:51

And yes the two hours in the gym are done as well. I appreciate he wants to work hard physically and advance in his sport, but the insurance at the school’s fitness center does not allow for under 16s to be alone and his father and I both have other things to do as well. So there will have to be compromises made there

I'd definitely be teaching about the Opportunity Cost to you in terms of the 2 hours you spend at the gym vs things that you would like to be doing. Not in a way that says you begrudge it (even if you do) but in a way that says "adults have to make choices/compromises" and now he's growing into adulthood he needs to start thinking about how to make those choices for himself, and how what he does impacts on future-him and present-family members.
Again - not to be mean, but because these are the things that my DCs have told me they appreciated learning (they see that their flatmates/friends are clueless about some things they do automatically)

It’s okay, you’re not being mean! :)

We have tried to have this talk with him (or sort of) many times because he is extremely reluctant to help out around the house yet wants us to drop everything and run to get what he needs or drive him someplace or whatever. Which is obviously totally normal for a teen!

I have two jobs, one as a liquor store clerk 4 days a week and one as a City Councilor, which varies wildly but is extremely time consuming. (I’m about a year and a half into my first term and tbh I think we’re all still adjusting!)

Anyway, late last winter I told him (well all the kids really, as well as DH 🙄) that I couldn’t do every single thing at home and still work that many days, so if they didn’t start helping out a bit I’d have to go down to three days at the liquor store and that would mean less fun little extras.

They said they’d help (obviously I’m not talking heavy duty stuff, just pet care and putting away laundry and whatnot), they didn’t, I went down to three days briefly and said “sorry, we don’t have the money for that” to a few fun things they wanted to do, and hey presto, they started being quite a bit more helpful.

It’s just such a fine line between wanting to teach responsibility and “he’s only a kid”, you know?

OP posts:
Brefugee · 11/08/2022 09:03

When I asked about the savings I should have pressed harder, I know, because he would give me vague answers or what I now know must have been outright lies about his account balance. My husband has that information on his phone; I’m going to have to start checking it regularly as clearly he has not been.

just spotted this OP. Why don't you just pass it over to your husband since he could have been monitoring it loosely all along?

Shinyandnew1 · 11/08/2022 08:57

CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 08:50

I believe he has $350 left but I’m not quite sure (I have the information somewhere but not close at the moment).

How much he is paid varies wildly because they’re flexible with his schedule (he just had a week off because he had a baseball tournament and has this upcoming Friday through Tuesday off because he’s going to be visiting his grandparents), but I would say on average he gets paid upwards of $250 to $400 every two weeks depending on how much he’s worked. So depending on his next few checks, he could have the trip money set aside in a month just paying half.

He goes back to school September 6th, and will have football practice every weekday after school as well as Thursday and Friday games, but will be able to do a few evening and weekend shifts until the end of the season.

I do see him wanting a winter job as well, since he seems to like those paychecks!

How much is the trip?

CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 08:56

ClocksGoingBackwards · 11/08/2022 08:54

You have mixed up issues. The issue about your son needing cleats is entirely separate to the fact that he hasn’t done well saving for the trip. They are two completely separate things and you can’t use a 15yo budgeting badly to justify you not providing things that a parent is supposed to provide.

Even if your son doesn’t save enough for the trip before it happens, there’s nothing stopping you making him pay it all back even if some of it has to come after the trip. Start helping him to budget and pay for the things that are your responsibility yourself.

I understand they are separate issues and that I should be providing them.

I’m saying that I literally do not have the money, unless I spend what DH will need for gas to get to work this week.

OP posts:
CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 08:54

SuperCamp · 11/08/2022 08:49

He’s been 14 for the majority of his earning and spending. Not many sports mad 14 yo boys would have the maturity and discipline to budget and save without help, guidance, supervision.

You saw the expensive stuff coming into the house (does a 14 yo have a debit card to be able to order online?) , it would have been a good idea to intervene early on. Tell him that as you and his Dad have had to commit to paying for the trip he needed to transfer xxx to you on each payday, maybe put xxx in savings, and suggest he budgets out his remaining spending money.

He did well to get a job and work through his holiday, but needed a lot more help.

I think you do need to pay for his ongoing needs, such as cleats, and address how he pays for the trip separately.

I really didn’t see it. I guess I sort of registered that he would have a new tshirt here and there or a new hat, but I didn’t know he would have spent so much on them, plus he and his friends borrow each other’s things or trade shirts they don’t like etc so often that I really wasn’t aware. He has friends who are 16+ or have older siblings who are, so he has been riding to the mall with a group of them on some of his days off, so I wasn’t there to see him spend it.

When I asked about the savings I should have pressed harder, I know, because he would give me vague answers or what I now know must have been outright lies about his account balance. My husband has that information on his phone; I’m going to have to start checking it regularly as clearly he has not been.

OP posts:
ClocksGoingBackwards · 11/08/2022 08:54

You have mixed up issues. The issue about your son needing cleats is entirely separate to the fact that he hasn’t done well saving for the trip. They are two completely separate things and you can’t use a 15yo budgeting badly to justify you not providing things that a parent is supposed to provide.

Even if your son doesn’t save enough for the trip before it happens, there’s nothing stopping you making him pay it all back even if some of it has to come after the trip. Start helping him to budget and pay for the things that are your responsibility yourself.

Brefugee · 11/08/2022 08:51

And yes the two hours in the gym are done as well. I appreciate he wants to work hard physically and advance in his sport, but the insurance at the school’s fitness center does not allow for under 16s to be alone and his father and I both have other things to do as well. So there will have to be compromises made there

I'd definitely be teaching about the Opportunity Cost to you in terms of the 2 hours you spend at the gym vs things that you would like to be doing. Not in a way that says you begrudge it (even if you do) but in a way that says "adults have to make choices/compromises" and now he's growing into adulthood he needs to start thinking about how to make those choices for himself, and how what he does impacts on future-him and present-family members.
Again - not to be mean, but because these are the things that my DCs have told me they appreciated learning (they see that their flatmates/friends are clueless about some things they do automatically)

CheerfulYank · 11/08/2022 08:50

Shinyandnew1 · 11/08/2022 08:36

How much is the trip and how much does he earn in a week?

I believe he has $350 left but I’m not quite sure (I have the information somewhere but not close at the moment).

How much he is paid varies wildly because they’re flexible with his schedule (he just had a week off because he had a baseball tournament and has this upcoming Friday through Tuesday off because he’s going to be visiting his grandparents), but I would say on average he gets paid upwards of $250 to $400 every two weeks depending on how much he’s worked. So depending on his next few checks, he could have the trip money set aside in a month just paying half.

He goes back to school September 6th, and will have football practice every weekday after school as well as Thursday and Friday games, but will be able to do a few evening and weekend shifts until the end of the season.

I do see him wanting a winter job as well, since he seems to like those paychecks!

OP posts:
SuperCamp · 11/08/2022 08:49

He’s been 14 for the majority of his earning and spending. Not many sports mad 14 yo boys would have the maturity and discipline to budget and save without help, guidance, supervision.

You saw the expensive stuff coming into the house (does a 14 yo have a debit card to be able to order online?) , it would have been a good idea to intervene early on. Tell him that as you and his Dad have had to commit to paying for the trip he needed to transfer xxx to you on each payday, maybe put xxx in savings, and suggest he budgets out his remaining spending money.

He did well to get a job and work through his holiday, but needed a lot more help.

I think you do need to pay for his ongoing needs, such as cleats, and address how he pays for the trip separately.

Darkness22 · 11/08/2022 08:48

Going forward I would sit down with him with a spreadsheet and look at the finances of the trip, how much he will need to save each month etc. I think this could take some of the emotion out of it and he can see it in black and white. It's also a bit of a puzzle/game.

He could always sell some bits on ebay etc.

Whataretheodds · 11/08/2022 08:47

There are loads of options:
Why does he need new ones?
Can he buy second hand?
He can sell unnecessary items to pay for them
He can take extra shifts or earn more money another way.

Lollypop701 · 11/08/2022 08:46

The 100 can be a down payment to his trip. Then split whatever he still needs to save into monthly amounts and take it off him each payday. He will also need money whilst away get him to save this himself and tell him if he doesn’t you won’t be funding it. He is taking the piss. I actually showed my kids the monthly bills to get them to understand how much life costs… they were much better after that