Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL upset at me seeing DH's SIL & kids

80 replies

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 11/08/2022 06:54

Sad circumstances in the family. Early last year, after a two year battle with depression, DH's father passed away by suicide. They live in a different country and this occurred across covid, and MIL didn't share with her two sons the ins and outs of what was happening with their father so it was a massive shock to them.

Fast forward to this year - June. There's always been tension between MIL and DH's SIL. They've been snipey/grumpy with each other for years. They both critique the other a lot, and it's simmered in the background. With her DH gone, MIL struggled to be as patient with her and snapped at her. The situation involved my daughter (I wasn't there) but apparently SIL made snipey comments to DD (7) when DH & DD visited e.g. should be eating pasta properly with sauce/her dd's did. MIL told SIL to "stop making negative comments about DD". It wasn't well-received, SIL was crying, her DH was cross.

MIL and BIL have chatted since & they have both shared lots of things they are feeling about the other. MIL's sister is ill at the moment so she told BIL she needed space.

Now it's August and I'm visiting with DH and DD. I suggested to DH that I take DD to see her cousins for a coffee/park play date as they are close. I asked if it would be OK and to check with his DM. He said it would be fine (I later find out he didn't check with her directly). We agreed as DD is an only, her relationship with her cousins is really important and she might not see them again until next year. It's nice for the girls and I will be there if SIL says anything snipey (I've only personally experienced her be a bit snipey once when dd was having a mega tantrum.) There was no expectation for DH (who has taken his mother's side and out of loyalty won't come) or DM to come.

I mentioned last night to her that I would be popping by for a coffee with DD to see her cousins. MIL was extremely upset, won't speak to us (only my DH when I'm not there), she went off for a drive to cool off. She says I have betrayed her as she was sticking up for DD (the argument isn't really about that - they have bigger issues & she says she is not ready to listen to her son's feelings about them). She says that none of us know what she's going through, she opened up about more scarring things that happened in the lead up to FIL's death/things he said. My DH came out of the conversation with her fragile and snipey to me but later apologised. I'm getting the silent treatment from MIL.

TBH I've always felt things between MIL and SIL are tense. I'm unsure whether to cancel seeing SIL & cousins. I hate all this arguing, MIL has said she doesn't want any pressure to heal the relationship so are we expected to stop the girls seeing each other until then? I was thinking of maybe popping by for an hour then picking DM some flowers up on the way back.

Perspective greatly appreciated. It's created a tense atmosphere in the house.

OP posts:
sonjadog · 11/08/2022 08:03

I would just get on with your day and plans as normal and ignore her behaviour. If she has never behaved like this before, then it may well be linked to grief, but that doesn't mean you have to pander to it. Grief does not give someone a pass to control other people. I would be concerned if you let her have her way this time, it would set a precedent for every time you do something she doesn't like. She will probably come around when she sees that nothing terrible came from you meeting up with your SiL and niece.

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 11/08/2022 08:03

@saraclara

I think saying that you appreciated her having your DD's back would be a welcome acknowledgment. And that whatever is happening among the adults, the two girls are each other's family and need the relationship.

I said this to her last night and about the girls seeing each other (they usually see each almost every day when we visit). However, she was upset last night so will re-iterate with flowers later today. I appreciate the tension but I don't want DD in the middle of it as it's not fair to centre the argument on those events (and therefore bring me into the fray) - this is about stuff way bigger and longer rooted, and it will take time to find a new balance in the family. I really hope MIL and BIL talk soon.

OP posts:
ILikeHotWaterBottles · 11/08/2022 08:02

I'd laugh at them all. Bunch of bloody children they are, sniping and bitching about each other, crying over hurt feelings. They need to grow up and act like adults.

Thinkingblonde · 11/08/2022 07:57

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 11/08/2022 07:14

@Sparklybanana - this is what I repeated last night. I think she is at her limit emotion wise and I'm not trying to add to that. She says she's worried me and SIL are going to chat, and I'm going to take SIL's point of view and she can't handle that. I've said we're not going to talk about it. I don't really have the intention to. SIL don't normally have 'big' conversations and keep it generally nice/superficial.

What is she so worried about? Is she worried a few home truths are going to emerge from you and SIL chatting?
She’s acting very strangely, controlling, punishing your dd, this needs addressing. Your dd has done nothing wrong here. Neither have you.

GeriSignfeld · 11/08/2022 07:56

When I was about your girl's age, our family had a huge bust up.

My cousins who were like my elder sisters was permanently severed & I didn't see them for over 20 years.

This had a massive impact on me growing up & internalised it as being my fault.

I have never forgiven my family for the trauma of having my cousins taken away.

That they allowed their selfish, silly family fighting to override the important relationship I had with my cousins.

Their fights were not of our making & we were. the collateral damage.

They never stopped to think of the impact their family fighting would have on the children.

For me it felt like my siblings died & I wasn't allowed to speak of them again.

What your MIL is doing is so wrong & shortsighted, there no words to describe her piss poor attitude

Do not send this woman flowers & pander to her idiotic behaviour.

To resent your daughter having a playdate with her cousin shows how deeply selfish she is.

It sounds like your MIL has narcissistic traits & enjoys being the gatekeeper/matriarch of the family. My grandmother is a similarly manipulative woman who can't lie straight in bed & enjoys having everyone bow to her whims.

Please be your daughter's advocate & do not enter into any notion that you will be keeping the cousins apart.

Also your husband sounds like a wet lettuce who needs to push back on his overbearing mother. He deserves a stern word for letting you both down here.

This post has seriously triggered me, as am your daughter in this situation & I never got over it, just buried it deep down & it exploded later in life.

HoppingPavlova · 11/08/2022 07:55

I asked if it would be OK and to check with his DM. He said it would be fine (I later find out he didn't check with her directly).

What??? Why check with DM at all? You are adults, not children, if you would like to see someone you do, no need to ask for permission. Bizarre.

What a drama. Just ignore the drama llama and go visit.

saraclara · 11/08/2022 07:49

I'd talk to her and say you appreciate her standing up for her granddaughter and the only reason you want to go is purely so dd has a relationship with her cousin.

That. The woman is a mess. Her DH took his own life and she's clearly nowhere near recovered from that. Yes, her behaviour is wrong, but responding as of she was a well person behaving vindictively would be inappropriate.

I think saying that you appreciated her having your DD's back would be a welcome acknowledgment. And that whatever is happening among the adults, the two girls are each other's family and need the relationship.

Thewheelsfalloffthebus · 11/08/2022 07:44

You don’t need your MILs permission to forgive your SIL for one snipey comment about how your daughter eats pasta and to resume your relationship with her and your nieces/nephews.
You have hit the nail on the head when you say it’s not really about the sauce with pasta comment. You don’t have to take sides in this feud.

deeperthanallroses · 11/08/2022 07:43

absolutely facilitate the cousins hanging out. My mil once asked dh and me to unfriend on Fb a family member who was divorcing. I told Dh I wasn’t ok with that and he told his mum we wouldn’t do that.

Thinkingblonde · 11/08/2022 07:43

Sparklybanana · 11/08/2022 07:11

It sounds like she's hurt and can't deal with the level of emotion. I'd talk to her and say you appreciate her standing up for her granddaughter and the only reason you want to go is purely so dd has a relationship with her cousin. Neither of them should be penalised for something that they aren't involved in. Buy the flowers, but this isn't really her choice and you're not supporting anyone but dd.

This. Excellent advice.
Your’s and dd’s relationship’s with SIL and cousins isn’t up to MIL to police. Yes she’s grieving, she isn’t grieving alone though.
You’ve all lost a father, grandfather, father in law, you’re all grieving for the same person.

Just10moreminutesplease · 11/08/2022 07:38

I’m sorry for your FIL’s death but this does not give your MIL the right to dictate who you see.

In your shoes, I wouldn’t engage with her dramatics. You have every right to take your daughter to see her auntie and cousins, don’t apologise for it.

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 11/08/2022 07:31

@TheLionTheWitchAndTheChesterDraws - In hindsight I think he assumed it would be fine and told me to accept the invite as it would just be DD & I popping over to theirs. I presumed he had mentioned it so me breezily saying "we're popping over to SIL's tomorrow morning" was the first MIL heard of it. Then there was an emotional avalanche, crying/driving off in car, heavy conversations with DH. DH was adamant it was fine & that she'd messaged them herself to tell them we were here. I think she was upset that that message was ignored but at the same time she's said she wants space from BIL/SIL.

OP posts:
Creepymanonagoatfarm · 11/08/2022 07:31

Break the chain op. Mil is used to getting her own way using this method..

De88 · 11/08/2022 07:29

Don't stop the children from seeing each other, whatever you do. I imagine it must be awful for good friends to not see each other because of something that has nothing to do with them.

MiddleParking · 11/08/2022 07:28

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 11/08/2022 07:24

@Creepymanonagoatfarm to be fair she did say good morning to me when I said it (after she ignored me). She's being mono-sybillic with dd as well. She's just really upset, think it's good we're popping out for a few hours to give her some space.

I mean, that really puts paid to the idea that she believes she’s acting in DD’s best interests. Sending flowers would be approximately the last thing on my mind in this scenario.

TheLionTheWitchAndTheChesterDraws · 11/08/2022 07:25

Have I understood this right? You and your DH both agreed it was important for your DD to maintain a relationship with her cousins. You asked your DH to check whether it would cause any problems if you took her to see her cousins and he told you he had checked, it would be fine and to go ahead. Having since discovered that it would not be fine, he first got snappy with you and is now the only one out of the two of you who your MiL is willing to talk to?

Somebody needs to buy some apology flowers here. I don’t think it’s you! Why isn’t he explaining to his mother that it was him who told you to take your DD? Why are you getting the blame for something that he told you was ok?

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 11/08/2022 07:24

@Creepymanonagoatfarm to be fair she did say good morning to me when I said it (after she ignored me). She's being mono-sybillic with dd as well. She's just really upset, think it's good we're popping out for a few hours to give her some space.

OP posts:
Goldbar · 11/08/2022 07:22

Your DH needs to deal with this. He needs to tell MIL that he okayed this and that, SIL aside, both of you want your DD to have a relationship with her cousins. So regardless of how the adults choose to behave, you will be trying your best to promote opportunities to play together for the children.

Creepymanonagoatfarm · 11/08/2022 07:20

Flowers? Slap with a wet fish imo.
Grown woman remember op. You aren't dealing with another dc here.
Silent treatment? Embrace the peace.
Silent treatment is legally classed as abuse now too.

Plantpotpetal · 11/08/2022 07:18

You don’t need permission to see your SIL! No wonder she fell out with MIL and looks like you’re now going the same way. Bereavement aside, MIL sounds awful!

LearnedAxolotl · 11/08/2022 07:17

Why should you dds suffer because of the adults? Everyone needs to put their egos to one side for the children's sake. MIL sounds incredibly controlling.

TheUsualChaos · 11/08/2022 07:16

Yet another situation where the DH ducks put of of dealing with their own DM and her issues. He needs to talk to her like he should have done beforehand.

OP you are doing nothing wrong, in fact being really lovely, in trying to ensure the DC maintain a relationship despite the behaviour of some of the adults in the family.

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 11/08/2022 07:14

@Sparklybanana - this is what I repeated last night. I think she is at her limit emotion wise and I'm not trying to add to that. She says she's worried me and SIL are going to chat, and I'm going to take SIL's point of view and she can't handle that. I've said we're not going to talk about it. I don't really have the intention to. SIL don't normally have 'big' conversations and keep it generally nice/superficial.

OP posts:
Sparklybanana · 11/08/2022 07:11

It sounds like she's hurt and can't deal with the level of emotion. I'd talk to her and say you appreciate her standing up for her granddaughter and the only reason you want to go is purely so dd has a relationship with her cousin. Neither of them should be penalised for something that they aren't involved in. Buy the flowers, but this isn't really her choice and you're not supporting anyone but dd.

clickychicky · 11/08/2022 07:09

@HeartofTeFiti Has suggested a perfectly balanced response. I would go with this. Acknowledge the difficult feelings.

Swipe left for the next trending thread