Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL upset at me seeing DH's SIL & kids

80 replies

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 11/08/2022 06:54

Sad circumstances in the family. Early last year, after a two year battle with depression, DH's father passed away by suicide. They live in a different country and this occurred across covid, and MIL didn't share with her two sons the ins and outs of what was happening with their father so it was a massive shock to them.

Fast forward to this year - June. There's always been tension between MIL and DH's SIL. They've been snipey/grumpy with each other for years. They both critique the other a lot, and it's simmered in the background. With her DH gone, MIL struggled to be as patient with her and snapped at her. The situation involved my daughter (I wasn't there) but apparently SIL made snipey comments to DD (7) when DH & DD visited e.g. should be eating pasta properly with sauce/her dd's did. MIL told SIL to "stop making negative comments about DD". It wasn't well-received, SIL was crying, her DH was cross.

MIL and BIL have chatted since & they have both shared lots of things they are feeling about the other. MIL's sister is ill at the moment so she told BIL she needed space.

Now it's August and I'm visiting with DH and DD. I suggested to DH that I take DD to see her cousins for a coffee/park play date as they are close. I asked if it would be OK and to check with his DM. He said it would be fine (I later find out he didn't check with her directly). We agreed as DD is an only, her relationship with her cousins is really important and she might not see them again until next year. It's nice for the girls and I will be there if SIL says anything snipey (I've only personally experienced her be a bit snipey once when dd was having a mega tantrum.) There was no expectation for DH (who has taken his mother's side and out of loyalty won't come) or DM to come.

I mentioned last night to her that I would be popping by for a coffee with DD to see her cousins. MIL was extremely upset, won't speak to us (only my DH when I'm not there), she went off for a drive to cool off. She says I have betrayed her as she was sticking up for DD (the argument isn't really about that - they have bigger issues & she says she is not ready to listen to her son's feelings about them). She says that none of us know what she's going through, she opened up about more scarring things that happened in the lead up to FIL's death/things he said. My DH came out of the conversation with her fragile and snipey to me but later apologised. I'm getting the silent treatment from MIL.

TBH I've always felt things between MIL and SIL are tense. I'm unsure whether to cancel seeing SIL & cousins. I hate all this arguing, MIL has said she doesn't want any pressure to heal the relationship so are we expected to stop the girls seeing each other until then? I was thinking of maybe popping by for an hour then picking DM some flowers up on the way back.

Perspective greatly appreciated. It's created a tense atmosphere in the house.

OP posts:
CanaryShoulderedThorn · 11/08/2022 10:02

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 11/08/2022 07:24

@Creepymanonagoatfarm to be fair she did say good morning to me when I said it (after she ignored me). She's being mono-sybillic with dd as well. She's just really upset, think it's good we're popping out for a few hours to give her some space.

Whoa!!! You are a grown woman, if you let her abuse you with her silent treatment then so be it, but don't let her start being "mono syllabic" with your child.
This destructive behaviour needs to stop right now. Your DH needs to step up.

10HailMarys · 11/08/2022 09:53

I don't think your MIL should be dictating whether her grandchildren are allowed to see each other. If she doesn't want to see SIL, that's up to her, but the children shouldn't be dragged into it. They're cousins and they've done nothing wrong here.

zingally · 11/08/2022 09:50

I'm a bit struggling to work out the relationships... Are MIL and SIL mother and daughter?
In which case, a mother fell out with her daughter because the daughter said something a bit critical about her niece?
If that's what triggered this falling out, that would suggest that MIL has her own issues.

What's your DHs role in all this? Has he been the golden child growing up? Never criticized, told off, everything he does is perfect? Perhaps SIL is seeing signs of that continuing to filter down to the next generation and snapped? HER children get snapped and pecked at, whereas the one time she dared to suggest that niece should have some sauce on her pasta... that was criticising the golden child's offspring and HELL NO.

Nahimjustaworm · 11/08/2022 09:41

Tell your MIL that you refuse to be emotionally blackmailed into deciding who you and your child do and don't see. She can choose to fall out with you but you refuse to get dragged into emotional BS. Be clear as well that you expect consistency for your dd in any relationships she has and if you don't get it you'll cut off ties altogether.

My in laws absolutely despise me. They have done some beyond horrendous things to me and my dh and dd and they make it obvious that they'll always hate me and worse still they pretend superficially to 'love' my dh and dd but it's obvious in their shitty-assed attitude that they will never be priority. I'm the b%*ch because I call them out on this. I just decided one day though that I'm done with the drama and I'm focussing on my dd having a good relationship with her cousins and trying my best to have a good relationship with my nieces. The rest of them can take a long walk off a short plank as far as I'm concerned but I realise that my dd at least needs the opportunity to have a relationship with her cousins as best as I can facilitate this. They are all innocent kids and don't deserve anything less. There's been a lot of drama in the past but I've now learned to refuse to engage with said drama. The biggest thing I've done is stopped trying so hard to be liked. I realised that if they haven't learned to at least treat me with respect in 15 years my ILs will always resent breathing the same air as me however hard I try. This will ultimately impact on their relationship with my dd no doubt but if I'm doing my best to give them access to my child and keeping my mouth shut then I'm doing my best for my child and that's all that matters.

Focus on your child and your immediate family unit. Refuse to dramatise things and get on with what's right for you. You won't go far wrong with your child if you do this. Most of us aren't lucky enough to have simple, fully functional extended families. Your dd will have to learn this one day. The most important thing you can teach her is how to deal with this and not to repeat the cycle...

JustWaking · 11/08/2022 09:24

Is DH's family Italian by any chance? The reference to pasta makes me wonder... and Italian matriarchs have some pretty crazy high expectations of the family - especially DILs - from what I understand.

Arenanewbie · 11/08/2022 09:23

You don’t know what happened in this pasta situation, your MIL told you that SIL snapped at your DD but it might be not the case and the context could be very different.
My mum always does this - she tells different accounts to me and my sister about what happened. We usually “compare notes” afterwards. I’m in a habit to question her every word. So I wonder if your MIL doesn’t want you to hear SIL’s account of events…
I wouldn’t buy flowers, I would be nice and polite but firm and short, I wouldn’t go into lengthy explanations. It’s your decision, as parents and it’s nothing to do with MIL.
What do you personally think about SIL by the way? Do you like her? Was she nice to you and your daughter before?

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 11/08/2022 09:16

Controlling and using children to hurt your SIL? Cold Shouldering you because you are not co-operating in her campaign? dragging you into it to make SIL feel alienated?

Your family are excusing this appalling behaviour because she is dealing with grief and no one knows what to do, but what she is doing is unacceptable. She needs therapy to deal with the grief, not take it out in a very nasty way on everyone else, particularly the children. Being kind to someone does not mean following every order they give. She needs support, but not this kind.
Instead of getting embroiled in this feud (which just encourages it) Are there any practical things that can be done for her, finding counseling? Places she could visit when she feels alone, or to talk to others in the same position?

CPL593H · 11/08/2022 09:07

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 11/08/2022 07:24

@Creepymanonagoatfarm to be fair she did say good morning to me when I said it (after she ignored me). She's being mono-sybillic with dd as well. She's just really upset, think it's good we're popping out for a few hours to give her some space.

The bit that would concern me is her extending the ill feeling to a 7 year old who has done precisely nothing wrong and actually has no control over seeing SIL, her cousins or anything else.

I would see your SIL and the cousins as planned, carry on treating MIL as you normally would, possibly try to talk to her and explain that while you appreciate her defence of your DD it is best when possible not to embroil children in the fallings out of adults and that a good relationship between the cousins is important to you.

Velvetbee · 11/08/2022 09:05

It’s none of MIL business what you do with your time.

user1471538283 · 11/08/2022 08:58

You cannot sacrifice your DD's relationship with her cousins because of your MIL. My DM sacrificed my relationship with her DM (she didn't see it like that) and I and I have never forgiven her for it.

aveline161 · 11/08/2022 08:55

This is the sort of straight talking I love

JustLyra · 11/08/2022 08:51

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 11/08/2022 07:24

@Creepymanonagoatfarm to be fair she did say good morning to me when I said it (after she ignored me). She's being mono-sybillic with dd as well. She's just really upset, think it's good we're popping out for a few hours to give her some space.

It’s understandable she’s upset about the loss of her husband, but being huffy with a child is completely unreasonable.

Was your MIL controlling in family relationships prior to being widowed?

Testina · 11/08/2022 08:49

Why is this all about your husband’s SIL?

Where is her husband, your husband’s brother, your MIL’s son in all this?

Is he alive?

Surely that’s answer here? You stop doing all the wifework and let your husband and his brother have some nice sibling time taking their kids out?

AlisonDonut · 11/08/2022 08:47

Flowers? Because you want your daughter to see her cousins?

This is madness, don't get into pacifying her with flowers.

She had two sons, it is entirely reasponable for their kids to see and know each other. She can't control you so she is using quite abusive tactics to stonewall you and your daughter. Don't collude with this, go see whoever you want to see.

MaChienEstUnDick · 11/08/2022 08:45

I really have little patience with all this not speaking nonsense. Either your BIL - your husbands brother and your MIL's son - is a terrible person with a terrible wife and terrible children, or your MIL is in a very bad place/a complete narcissist.

If it's the first then make up your own mind.

If it's anything else other than the first, behave like decent humans and go and spend time with the people who have also lost their father/FIL in desperate circumstances.

I don't think your DH is coming out of this very well at all, to be honest.

LookItsMeAgain · 11/08/2022 08:44

My advice is to draw a Venn diagram. You are in one circle (with your DD and your DH), your MiL is in another and your SIL is in a third, with her kids. They don't all have to overlap. They might intersect at one point which is where you all meet up together (I'd guess that that would be a small intersection). There would be a part of the diagram that your circle overlaps with your SiL's circle that doesn't overlap with your MiL. That's the bit that you're trying to maintain. It doesn't involve MiL at all. You shouldn't feel the need to involve her in the ins and outs of a friendship that is separate to the one you have with MiL.

I realise that maths doesn't always work to describe a situation but I hope the above makes sense.

justasking111 · 11/08/2022 08:35

bjjgirl · 11/08/2022 07:03

Negative emotional tyrants like your MIL attract tragedy and seek out drama, you will never do right by her

This. I would rise above it. Pretend every is fine and smile a lot. Fires need oxygen, narcs need attention.

GeriSignfeld · 11/08/2022 08:32

@LiarLiarKnickersAblaze That's very kind of you to say & good on you for standing up for your daughter. You sound like a great mum. All the best with the family fighting issues, understand how difficult they are to handle, older people can be so stuck in their ways.

@Sswhinesthebest Several years ago, one of my cousins was accepted back into the family, as she became estranged from her family, so she was welcomed back. We are still learning to navigate our new relationship & getting to know each other as adults, so many years lost. Doubt we will ever have the relationship we should have had, where you have a lifetime growing up together. Am deeply grateful to have one of them back in my life, even if the "sisterly" bond is still broken.
My other cousin is still not accepted back into the family. My grandma is on her last legs & really hope she will attend the funeral, so may have a chance to see her there.

Anyways didn't want to derail OP's thread & hope OP's MIL simmers down soon, so the kids can get on with their playdates in peace!

MichelleScarn · 11/08/2022 08:20

She says she's worried me and SIL are going to chat, and I'm going to take SIL's point of view and she can't handle that

Is the MIL definition of reason for fall out absolutely true? Did anyone else hear it?

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 11/08/2022 08:19

Is your mil one of these women who cries and creates drama to get her own way?
I wouldn't have asked her permission, if she is sulking with her dil its her problem, no one else's. Just go to the meet up and ignore the drama.
I am sorry about your fil though, this must be very difficult for her. She needs professional help to deal with this.

Sswhinesthebest · 11/08/2022 08:10

GeriSignfeld · 11/08/2022 07:56

When I was about your girl's age, our family had a huge bust up.

My cousins who were like my elder sisters was permanently severed & I didn't see them for over 20 years.

This had a massive impact on me growing up & internalised it as being my fault.

I have never forgiven my family for the trauma of having my cousins taken away.

That they allowed their selfish, silly family fighting to override the important relationship I had with my cousins.

Their fights were not of our making & we were. the collateral damage.

They never stopped to think of the impact their family fighting would have on the children.

For me it felt like my siblings died & I wasn't allowed to speak of them again.

What your MIL is doing is so wrong & shortsighted, there no words to describe her piss poor attitude

Do not send this woman flowers & pander to her idiotic behaviour.

To resent your daughter having a playdate with her cousin shows how deeply selfish she is.

It sounds like your MIL has narcissistic traits & enjoys being the gatekeeper/matriarch of the family. My grandmother is a similarly manipulative woman who can't lie straight in bed & enjoys having everyone bow to her whims.

Please be your daughter's advocate & do not enter into any notion that you will be keeping the cousins apart.

Also your husband sounds like a wet lettuce who needs to push back on his overbearing mother. He deserves a stern word for letting you both down here.

This post has seriously triggered me, as am your daughter in this situation & I never got over it, just buried it deep down & it exploded later in life.

Powerful reason to stand your ground op.

Hope you reconnected in later years Geri

Brefugee · 11/08/2022 08:09

MIL is still emotional and it is understandable that she is fragile.
However. You don't need her permission to take your DD to meet up with her cousins, and the fact that you aren't insisting/intending on DH going with you so he can stay with his mum is sensitive and fine.

I wouldn't have asked permission, tbh, i would have told her much closer to the time, and not been around for feedback. If MIL feels you and SIL are going to gripe about her then she must be feeling guilty about something? So a) don't do that and b) don't talk to MIL about it much more than maybe showing a photo or two of the cousins playing together?

It does sound awful for MIL and her sons, but family relationships need to be worked at, especially when distance is involved.

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 11/08/2022 08:06

@GeriSignfeld sending you lots of love, sorry to be a trigger for you this morning & thank you for sharing your story from the eyes of the children's perspective. It's helped me feel stronger that I'm doing the right thing for dd. Have a lovely day x

OP posts:
Musti · 11/08/2022 08:05

The FIL died and they’re being so petty about a comment/disagreement??

I would tell your MIL that you’re happy she stuck up for DD but it was a one off and tensions were high and you’re not going to discuss this any further with any of them and you would like your DD to have a relationship with both her and her cousin.

k80pie · 11/08/2022 08:05

Similar-ish family dynamic here. Don't buy flowers. You don't need permission to see your SIL or her kids. Don't kowtow to anyone. You are putting the kids first and that is great!

It took me therapy to get to this point. You have a right to your own relationships with each of them and should never have to ask permission from MIL or anyone - it's not your feud!

Swipe left for the next trending thread