Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can I give alcohol to this person?

90 replies

BeaAndTiscuits · 11/08/2022 00:14

There's a young girl at my work who is 17. She will be turning 18 in 2 weeks.
Usually quite chatty, and up for a laugh but recently she has been very reserved. She's only worked with us for a few weeks and has the independent, I don't need anyone attitude.
I noticed she was quiet and asked if she was ok, she told me she was fine quite aggressively and that was it, I left it at that. Next shift she was still very reserved but I still tried to involve her in any conversations, she only gave one word answers and that was it. That evening she text me to apologise and said she had alot going on. I told her it was fine, she didn't need to apologise, but if she needed someone to talk to then she could message me any time.
A few days later she messaged saying she did need someone to talk to, so we exchanged some messages where she didn't really give alot of info but she needed to cut someone out as they were hurting her. I gave her some advice and offered some support, she said thanks and that was that. She was in today and talking about her birthday coming up, she said she doesn't care about birthdays and that she wasn't doing anything and no family to give her any gifts, she then told me she was in care. She also has an operation coming up. We talked about what she does outside of work, she didn't give much but she said she has one friend and that she'll sometimes have some drinks with her. This evening she's text again saying thank you to me for caring about her and that she doesn't have many people who care.

I wanted to get her something, to put in her locker for her birthday. It's her 18th and I feel like she's never really had anyone throughout her life, she said she likes vodka so I thought I could get her a small quarter bottle and some chocolate. Would this be inappropriate? I go on holiday on Friday, so I'd have to leave it at work for her which means she'd get it before actually turning 18. I don't know much else about her as she's a very closed book, and with only having tomorrow to get something, it's all I could think. Or any suggestions of something else I could get quickly? Thank you.

OP posts:
RedHelenB · 11/08/2022 07:54

Society · 11/08/2022 07:16

As it's a special birthday for her could you not get everyone to sign a card and donate to some nice flowers?

This would be a good.idea.

RedHelenB · 11/08/2022 07:52

Alcohol is a traditional 18th birthday present , all my kids and friends got given it for presents when they turned 18. So I think it would be fine, but give it her once she's 18 and at the end of work.

Georgeskitchen · 11/08/2022 07:46

No alcohol, just some.chocs and bath pampering stuff.or a gift card. It's nice that you care and it's a shame that there are so many (predictable) unpleasant comments on mumsnet.
Just let her know your are there if she needs someone , but stay in the background IYGWIM

gogohmm · 11/08/2022 07:37

I think you sound lovely. Btw ignore the naysayers

gogohmm · 11/08/2022 07:35

Chocolates is fine, don't get bath things, she may only have a shower

Mybeautifulfriend22 · 11/08/2022 07:33

Some people definitely just use this forum to be nasty to people too. FFS.

5zeds · 11/08/2022 07:32

Are you older and male?

Mybeautifulfriend22 · 11/08/2022 07:30

Op you sound caring not over invested please don’t back away from this girl completely she’s found a friend in you.

You can keep it low key but supportive.
It sounds like she would appreciate someone thinking of her on her birthday so a card, smellies or chocolates would probably be enough of a kind gesture to someone having a shit time.

Mummadeze · 11/08/2022 07:29

i think a card and a cake would be perfect. You sound kind and thoughtful, not over invested at all.

drawacircleroundit · 11/08/2022 07:28

Just managed to respond to my own reply, ffs.

drawacircleroundit · 11/08/2022 07:27

drawacircleroundit · 11/08/2022 07:25

I’d be very, very careful around this one, OP. You sound lovely, but she is 17, damaged, and, without wanting to sound like a suspicious grump, people can turn. If you do something to offend or upset her later, or if you have to report her behaviour, then this could come back to bite you. I know you want to support her, but you could get sucked into a relationship that becomes toxic.
You also don’t want to be the rescuer. It’s not your job but she could very slowly make it seem like it is.

No - DO get her something! Just not something big or alcoholic!
A PP mentioned a cactus - that’s perfect.

Soontobe60 · 11/08/2022 07:25

BeaAndTiscuits · 11/08/2022 00:36

Yeah I thought it was maybe inappropriate, that's why I asked. Sorry I thought I'd wrote in the original post, she had said that with her friend she likes to go and "chill with her and have a couple of vodkas". I'm shit at gift giving, but I also hate buying gifts that are meaningless. I know vodka isn't like a great gift, but it's just because she said that's what she drinks.

She’s 17, she’s vulnerable and she’s using alcohol to relax. Don’t encourage this by providing her with more alcohol!

drawacircleroundit · 11/08/2022 07:25

I’d be very, very careful around this one, OP. You sound lovely, but she is 17, damaged, and, without wanting to sound like a suspicious grump, people can turn. If you do something to offend or upset her later, or if you have to report her behaviour, then this could come back to bite you. I know you want to support her, but you could get sucked into a relationship that becomes toxic.
You also don’t want to be the rescuer. It’s not your job but she could very slowly make it seem like it is.

notanothertakeaway · 11/08/2022 07:20

As older colleagues, I think you have a duty to be responsible and sensible. This does not include giving alcohol to any 17 year old, but especially one in care who appears vulnerable

Card from the office (with an 18 badge), plus flowers, box of chocolates for her or cakes / doughnuts to share in the office

Don't spend too much. It should just be a small token

Society · 11/08/2022 07:16

As it's a special birthday for her could you not get everyone to sign a card and donate to some nice flowers?

Sunnyqueen · 11/08/2022 07:15

Well done for being decent, caring human being, that's obviously too much of a stretch for some people to wrap their heads round. Doesn't mean you are over invested at all. Girls obviously had a shit time, 'care' is absolutely awful (how it's even called 'care' is a joke).

That being said I, thought you were going to say a bottle of prosecco or champagne which may be more appropriate along with a card and some chocolates.

Beetlewings · 11/08/2022 07:07

I think that's a nice idea. Not vodka but one of those little bottles of champagne maybe as it's her 18th?

Whattodoaboutworknow · 11/08/2022 06:55

why alcohol? She’s struggling, alcohol is not the answer.

Thefruitbatdancer · 11/08/2022 06:49

What you could do is mention to the office that it's her 18th & get everyone to sign a card. This way its the whole office giving a card & gift of chocs. Takes the pressure off you filling the 'caring role' while you're still being nice.

GeriSignfeld · 11/08/2022 06:21

A teenager who has worked with you for a mere few weeks seems suddenly depressed/out of sorts so your first instinct is to give them hard liquor?

Yeah, na mate that sounds like an awful idea & question that judgement.

You have alluded to being non- neurotypical by stating that you don't understand some social norms, which makes sense in this situation.

Recommend you toughen up here - it's not wise to let people's life tales of woe make you go overboard with kindness & sympathy, especially when it comes to monetary gifts.

People with that mindset are susceptible to being exploited by others.

You don't know this person & if any of what they are saying is actually true.

Being kind to them should be more than enough, you don't need to buy them presents & go overboard.

Unless everyone at work is chipping in for a gift do not buy them a personal gift from you. It's 1) weird 2) creepy 3) unnecessary

You sounds older & this is a young colleague. In the interests of your job it's best to keep a pleasant but professional distance.

The last thing you need is her making a complaint about you because you've gone overboard with a gift & creeped her out.

MrPakora · 11/08/2022 06:11

You don't give alcohol to someone you know is in a bad place and struggling unless you're on the sideline hoping to catch some drama. Some people get suicidal when drunk so I wouldnt gift alcohol unless I know the person well (that they drink) and that they are in a happy place in their life.
I would just give non alcoholic chocolate and a card.
You posted too much about her life, I hope she doesn't find this thread. Maybe ask for it to be deleted.

badbaduncle · 11/08/2022 03:06

If she is a care leaver I would get her some nice toiletries or some chocolate

jennyofthenorth · 11/08/2022 02:52

so I work with great coworkers. I would do a card, and mabye a not expensive box of chocolates. That says "I care" but Im not trying to be your new best friend!

sweeetpotato · 11/08/2022 02:46

God some people on here are miserable arse holes.

OP, you are getting an unnecessarily hard time time. You don't sound over invested, you sound kind and thoughtful, and cautious for good reason.

I wouldn't get straight vodka, it could he harmful in large quantities for a young, inexperienced and vulnerable person. But alcohol is often given as an 18th present so it want a wild crazy idea!

What about a few mini cans of spirit + mixers, with some chocolate and bath stuff? It's a grown up/adult present that recognises she's turning 18 but not ott on the alcohol content.

ToGanymedeAndTitan · 11/08/2022 02:20

You had the instinct; why do you need MN to back it up for you?
Why do people need MN for anything?!
If we did away with people asking for advice/what they thought of so and so problem then AIBU and Chat would suddenly cease to exist 😁

Swipe left for the next trending thread