Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can I give alcohol to this person?

90 replies

BeaAndTiscuits · 11/08/2022 00:14

There's a young girl at my work who is 17. She will be turning 18 in 2 weeks.
Usually quite chatty, and up for a laugh but recently she has been very reserved. She's only worked with us for a few weeks and has the independent, I don't need anyone attitude.
I noticed she was quiet and asked if she was ok, she told me she was fine quite aggressively and that was it, I left it at that. Next shift she was still very reserved but I still tried to involve her in any conversations, she only gave one word answers and that was it. That evening she text me to apologise and said she had alot going on. I told her it was fine, she didn't need to apologise, but if she needed someone to talk to then she could message me any time.
A few days later she messaged saying she did need someone to talk to, so we exchanged some messages where she didn't really give alot of info but she needed to cut someone out as they were hurting her. I gave her some advice and offered some support, she said thanks and that was that. She was in today and talking about her birthday coming up, she said she doesn't care about birthdays and that she wasn't doing anything and no family to give her any gifts, she then told me she was in care. She also has an operation coming up. We talked about what she does outside of work, she didn't give much but she said she has one friend and that she'll sometimes have some drinks with her. This evening she's text again saying thank you to me for caring about her and that she doesn't have many people who care.

I wanted to get her something, to put in her locker for her birthday. It's her 18th and I feel like she's never really had anyone throughout her life, she said she likes vodka so I thought I could get her a small quarter bottle and some chocolate. Would this be inappropriate? I go on holiday on Friday, so I'd have to leave it at work for her which means she'd get it before actually turning 18. I don't know much else about her as she's a very closed book, and with only having tomorrow to get something, it's all I could think. Or any suggestions of something else I could get quickly? Thank you.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
knackeredagain · 11/08/2022 22:25

What’s the usual thing for milestone birthdays at your work?
Id have a word with your colleagues and send a card round, and give her a cake. You could do her a little gift bag with chocolate, voucher, etc if you wanted to do something extra. Or those chocolate bouquets go down really well with the older teens I know.

Its really kind to want to spoil her a little bit.

Colin the Caterpillar is the man for the job here! The youngsters love him and it sounds like she’s probably missed out.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 11/08/2022 22:06

As awful as it sounds, I’d be wary of becoming this girl’s emotional crutch. It’s hard work being that for someone and not everyone has the time or emotional capacity

Derbee · 11/08/2022 20:47

@BeaAndTiscuits ah ok. Not a stupid thought, just maybe not thought through too well. But the concept of marking her birthday and letting her know people care is still a nice idea, and you sound very kind!

BeaAndTiscuits · 11/08/2022 15:02

@Derbee sorry, not evading, just forgot to reply. I'm female, late thirties and also a parent. I just felt a shame for her never having someone who made a fuss of her on her birthday and as it was an 18th I thought it would be nice. Usually in my family we'd give a small bottle of alcohol as an 18th gift. I had thought it was maybe inappropriate as she'd only be 17 at the time of handing over, I wasn't going to say it was from me, just place in her locker. But after reading many perspectives on the situation I realise now that was a stupid first thought.

OP posts:
Derbee · 11/08/2022 14:41

Also, you seem to be evading the question of whether you are male. It’s relevant unfortunately, because an older male buying a young teenage girl a bottle of vodka could clearly cause all sorts of issues

GreenLunchBox · 11/08/2022 13:17

It could be seen as grooming, especially if you are male.

I'll probably get jumped on for this (a lot of cool mums on this thread) but it is what we are taught in safeguarding.

Watchkeys · 11/08/2022 11:03

ToGanymedeAndTitan · 11/08/2022 02:20

You had the instinct; why do you need MN to back it up for you?
Why do people need MN for anything?!
If we did away with people asking for advice/what they thought of so and so problem then AIBU and Chat would suddenly cease to exist 😁

Yes, and that would be a representation of people having better boundaries and knowing how to uphold them for themselves.

OP asked for advice re a boundary and I'm questioning why they're lacking in conviction to make their own boundaries.

Why are you vetting that?

zingally · 11/08/2022 10:26

Vodka, for a young person in care, just isn't appropriate.

You are kind to think about getting her a gift, but maybe some nice shower gel, a bit of pretty jewellery, or a gift voucher would be a better option.

Emmelina · 11/08/2022 10:03

She seems quite introverted, I don’t get the impression she’ll be sharing the vodka with friends so it seems inappropriate to encourage alone-drinking.
how about a bubble tea kit? From the mass of young adults spilling out of my nearest bubble tea place it feels like it might land?

InquiringMinds · 11/08/2022 10:00

Just a card from you and your work colleagues sounds so much better.

InquiringMinds · 11/08/2022 09:57

IfOnlyOurEyesSawSouls · 11/08/2022 00:33

It's inappropriate.

She is a vulnerable young woman who has social and emotional problems.

The last thing I would give her is vodka.

I agree, no vodka! More than inappropriate, it could lead to further problems.

AMIAMIBU · 11/08/2022 09:49

Play it safe with a non alcohol present I think.

GoodThinkingMax · 11/08/2022 09:16

And also, you’re being very kind and thoughtful. Not overinvested as some PP say. Just a kind human being.

GoodThinkingMax · 11/08/2022 09:15

Don’t give her vodka. Give her some nice chocolates.

rainbowstardrops · 11/08/2022 09:14

Bloody hell, there were some unnecessary comments on here during the night!

@BeaAndTiscuits you sound lovely and kind and certainly not over-invested 🙄
I sometimes think MN is a parallel universe to the one I live in.

As others have said, give a card and a small gift. Maybe ask the rest of the office to sign it too. It'll probably make her day.

fluffyteach · 11/08/2022 09:00

Anyone would think you were the only person to give any details about someone on here… good lord you’ve had some nasty comments.

If you’re buying alcohol I’d buy one of those one glass sized bottles of Prosecco. And some flowers. Just shows you’re thinking of them but it’s not too much.

DorisWallis · 11/08/2022 08:59

Spot on with every comment @ladydimitrescu 🙌

ladydimitrescu · 11/08/2022 08:50

Christ from some of these comments you'd think op offered to main line heroin into the girls eyeball. Calm the fuck down for Christs sake.

Op, it's a lovely gesture. I would do a card, one of those individual mini bday cakes you can get, and a mini Prosecco or champagne as it's her 18th, maybe a candle or something depending on your budget.
This young girl has no one and is alone, you sound like a really caring person. Please ignore everyone who are trying to make you feel like shit for no reason. Flowers

P0ndering · 11/08/2022 08:45

If she's in care and got noone, having a tough time getting something from someone on her 18th is going to mean loads. Its a great instinct. Don't give up on the idea entirely. A card is a bit rubbish. Especially as your willing to spend something in this girl. Something to keep, the cheap card shops have loads of fairly cheap (maybe naff to some) 18th gif things, something, even a Teddy holding an 18 that hers and she can hold to say somebody cared about me on my 18th could be massively significant in her life. Care leavers have a tough time becoming adults. Do get her something

ohblowmedown · 11/08/2022 08:27

Why not ask if the others at work want to club together for a gift card since it's a special birthday?

Ukholidaysaregreat · 11/08/2022 08:21

I think a card and chocolates is really nice. If she is growing up in care she probably hasn't had much for birthdays and if she is turning 18 that would be really nice of you. Did people hear see the thread yesterday where a GP had really helped a young girl and she wanted to write to her and thank her. This thread is reminding me of that. I think you are doing a nice thing OP.

liveforsummer · 11/08/2022 08:20

To add to my first post giving a gift from the team rather than just from you will save any risk of her thinking you're too over invested if that's what you're worried about after some of the responses on this post.

liveforsummer · 11/08/2022 08:16

TeapotTitties · 11/08/2022 00:54

Look, if she drinks vodka that means she can source vodka.

Just get her a box of chocolates or some bubble bath and stop telling her life story on a public forum, because if she ever stumbles across this she'll really feel as though you've let her down.

Strange response. A huge proportion of posts on here are people giving anonymous details of other people. In a lot of topics it's pretty much the point of them ...

liveforsummer · 11/08/2022 08:14

In my work place we'd do gifts for milestone birthdays and usually those that know a colleague fairly well chip in. Nothing over invested about it. Why not see if other staff members want to chip in? Get her a voucher for a shop that seeks the type of clothes she wears, or for a salon, some nice chocolates and some self care stuff. It's a lovely idea .

LibbyL92 · 11/08/2022 08:11

I think a gift is a nice gesture, i think you’ve been absolutely lovely towards her.

id try not to get too involved though.

however, speaking of gifts how about a Lush gift set? They are beautifully presented and smell lovely.