Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think women are more toxic than people would like to admit?

505 replies

MarthaMayver · 10/08/2022 20:49

I'd like to start by saying by no means are all women toxic, I'm a female myself and have always been a huge supporter of feminism and "sisterhood" if you will. However the more behaviour I witness from women, I'm starting to stray away from seeing them as allies.

I have worked in female dominated sectors my entire life and have constantly had to witness cliques, gossiping, power plays, passive aggressiveness, and downright bullying. I had to leave my last job as it was affecting my mental health so badly.

I always thought this was just part and parcel of working in groups. However I started a new job last year, with an equal spread of male and female colleagues and there has been none of this. I'm now wondering if the problem with all of my previous workplaces was the fact that they were female dominated.

To me, it's very obvious in person how women favour men over their own gender, regardless of how much "female empowerment" and "Women Supporting Women" is preached these days. For example, they will let men get away with mistakes they wouldn't let other women get away with. Male incompetence is often seen as "cute", whereas the same behaviour coming from a woman would be laughed or sneered at.

There are so many stories coming out in recent years of mothers favouring their sons over their daughters, and at worst bullying and abusing their daughters whilst worshiping their sons. I now think back to my own childhood and I can remember many occasions where my mother would put me down for something, while supporting my male siblings for doing the same thing. There were also a lot of sly, underhand insults that I didn't realize at the time, that were never directed towards my brothers.

I'm prepared to be told IBU, but I'm also very interested in knowing how many people agree, or if anyone has any similar experiences.

OP posts:
Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:51

@gnilliwdog
@Pumperthepumper

Testosterone isn’t a theory, it really does cause different beahviour.

This whole idea of “socialisation” being responsible for human beahviour is nonsense - what caused the socialisation? Biology and hormones that’s what. Imagine thinking it was the other way around lol, that before socialisation we were just doughy unmoulded clay then like the Big Bang one day socialisation just happened and made men and women different and toxic in differing ways.

No other animal would we say such nonsense about. Humans follow other primate beahviour in many ways and more agressive male behaviour and in fighting for position amongst females in normal. Why are we surprised when we do the same.

Do we believe that all animal behaviour is socialisation or just human behaviour?
It seems very unscientific and more in the realm of some kind of feminist fantasy to pretend that human behaviour (or most of it) is all socialisation

Discovereads · 11/08/2022 15:47

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:28

@Discovereads

Very likely. Of course these things must make a difference.

Im not even saying it like it’s something to be solved. It’s just a thing. Some people here it and they can’t accept it because it means we can’t change. But that’s right, we can’t and there’s nothing to be done about it.

Forget your human and Imagine if you were watching some nature documentary about some long forgotten species called humans and this information was given in the program, people wouldn’t find it hard to believe at all.

Hmmm. I agree some people hear it and can’t accept it because it seems like something that can’t be helped or changed, so an excuse or get out of jail free card. And you can’t blame them really, many people feel the same way about the criminally insane or even the mentally ill who are abusive because of their illness. “Mental illness is not an excuse to be a dick” is often said on here.

But I do think if sex hormones do contribute to aggressive behaviour, why can’t it be solved? Sex hormones make us desire sex, make us fertile and makes babies. Generations before us thought that this cannot be changed and our lot in life is to constantly have babies because- unless we removed ourselves from human contact to live as as celibates in closed communities (which only a very tiny minority could actually succeed in doing this mind over body life path).

But we know enough about these hormones to adjust them in our bodies to prevent unwanted pregnancy and even to abort pregnancies, so we can control hormones to an extent already. Obviously, we are still having babies, the “control” isn’t perfect as even hormonal contraception isn’t 100% effective. But what a difference it has made to female equality of life!

So if an excess of sex hormones also affect our behaviour- and there are links that have been studied showing this may be so, then we definitely have the medical knowledge to try and at least reduce toxic behaviour by correcting excess hormones.

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 15:47

Here’s a study:

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31785281/

Testosterone is often considered a critical regulator of aggressive behaviour. There is castration/replacement evidence that testosterone indeed drives aggression in some species, but causal evidence in humans is generally lacking and/or-for the few studies that have pharmacologically manipulated testosterone concentrations-inconsistent.

Or here:
www.scientificamerican.com/article/strange-but-true-testosterone-alone-doesnt-cause-violence/

Or here, as a kind of background to why people think it does (trigger warning though)

lithub.com/it-turns-out-theres-not-a-lot-of-science-linking-testosterone-to-violence/

gnilliwdog · 11/08/2022 15:44

@Pumperthepumper I agree socialisation is more likely the cause of behaviours. Even if some hormones promote aggression an individual could channel that into ambition, sports, creative endeavour, all sorts of activities that have a positive outcome.

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 15:40

Ilovemycat1 · 11/08/2022 15:18

@Tinaaaaarrrghhh

Never mind the statistics about sexual abuse and homicide caused by men... its not them to blame. Its their hOrMoNeS. That molecule testosterone has alot to blame. Maybe Hitler had too much.

Lets all get the violins out as we are all victims of our hormones

As a female boss I am going to bully my employees - I am expected to with all that estrogen circulating around me. Not my fault. Its the hormones 🥺 I will be in tears after being so volatile and emotional.

I find this such an interesting argument though because as I said upthread, testosterone theory has been debunked but if you do believe in it, that means logically you think men have innate violence. Men have a natural, genetic violence in their make up.

To me, how we’re socialised is massively more likely to affect how we respond to others.

gnilliwdog · 11/08/2022 15:39

I think the idea that autistic people don't feel empathy is a myth, by the way.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:38

@Ilovemycat1

Also female toxicity

gnilliwdog · 11/08/2022 15:37

Hormones are an interesting point. I am sure I read something about some fish failing to reproduce as the presence of antidepressant residue from human waste leached into their water. It prevented them from risk taking behaviour I think. I am guessing if you use tap water your hormones are affected by the traces of medications in the water.

Ilovemycat1 · 11/08/2022 15:35

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:23

@Ilovemycat1

Im not saying it can’t be controlled at all just that their are limits. Men will always be more prone to sometoxic behaviours and women others.
Its like if you think of an autistic person, of course they can control some of their beahviour and try to be more empathetic but it has limits as to how much can be changed.

You have just compared autism - a complex and limiting neurodevelopmental disorder with male toxicity.

I am done.

Walkaround · 11/08/2022 15:31

KettrickenSmiled · 11/08/2022 15:06

I was snark about it because it's bullshit.
That doesn't mean I'm snarking at YOU @Tinaaaaarrrghhh - just the notion that women are unhappy & aggressive "because hormones".

Men have hormones too. Testosterone is not an excuse for aggression.

Tell that to the campaigners wanting more recognition of the effects of peri-menopause and menopause, including depression, hot flushes, brain fog, anxiety, etc. They are very vociferously and actively arguing that female hormonal fluctuations can have significant effects both physically and emotionally throughout a woman’s life, and that allowances should be made for these - so going further than simply arguing that hormones can help explain some behaviours and suggesting women may actually need help, understanding and support due to the effects of their hormones. Men don’t tend to get the same levels of support - their hormones are just viewed as toxic and that men should have better control over their behaviours regardless.

Not everyone of the same sex reacts in the same way to hormones, or has the same hormonal fluctuations, of course, but it’s ridiculous to argue hormones don’t have powerful effects on our behaviours.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:29

Or try to find a solution, they’d just accept it as the way that species was

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:28

@Discovereads

Very likely. Of course these things must make a difference.

Im not even saying it like it’s something to be solved. It’s just a thing. Some people here it and they can’t accept it because it means we can’t change. But that’s right, we can’t and there’s nothing to be done about it.

Forget your human and Imagine if you were watching some nature documentary about some long forgotten species called humans and this information was given in the program, people wouldn’t find it hard to believe at all.

Discovereads · 11/08/2022 15:24

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:10

@KettrickenSmiled

Its not bullshit though, it’s well studied. Estrogen does make you more likely to be dissatisfied in a relationship as well as have a higher chance of neurotic traits - I didn’t say it made you more agressive - violence doesn’t always start or continue in outright Im agression in couples, it can start over petty squabbling and be low level.

And testosterone does make you more agressive, that’s a fact.

Humans are animals like any other. Why do we act like they’re not and hormones don’t make a difference?

It’s an interesting hypothesis that some toxic behaviour can be caused by excess sex hormones. It’s true that excess testosterone is linked to violent aggression in men. It is also true that excess estrogen (estrogen dominance) is linked to irritability and mood swings…both of which might then cause passive aggression in women?

Perhaps a way to reduce human aggression (violent and passive) is to put everyone on hormone balancing medication? Could it be that simple?

Of course there is an interesting sci fi film called equilibrium that concluded such an attempt would result in a totalitarian dystopia and eventually fall into anarchy.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:23

@Ilovemycat1

Im not saying it can’t be controlled at all just that their are limits. Men will always be more prone to sometoxic behaviours and women others.
Its like if you think of an autistic person, of course they can control some of their beahviour and try to be more empathetic but it has limits as to how much can be changed.

Ilovemycat1 · 11/08/2022 15:18

@Tinaaaaarrrghhh

Never mind the statistics about sexual abuse and homicide caused by men... its not them to blame. Its their hOrMoNeS. That molecule testosterone has alot to blame. Maybe Hitler had too much.

Lets all get the violins out as we are all victims of our hormones

As a female boss I am going to bully my employees - I am expected to with all that estrogen circulating around me. Not my fault. Its the hormones 🥺 I will be in tears after being so volatile and emotional.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:13

@SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain

They say women are a socialising influence on men but I think the opposite is also true.

I also think feminism is in some cases used to justify toxic female beahviour because some people cling to the label because they are the types who really can’t believe they can do any wrong or ever be wrong so it offers a confident justification for dismissing any one who disagrees with them as sexist.

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 11/08/2022 15:11

I am a feminist to my bones, but I have had some horrible experiences in some all woman environments. People spreading nasty gossip, bullying and cliques and so many social cowards following the Queen bees even to their own detriment. I imagine it is just a microcosm of a toxic society. Perhaps women behave better when there are men around. I don't know, but it always disappoints me to see women behaving so badly.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:10

KettrickenSmiled · 11/08/2022 15:06

I was snark about it because it's bullshit.
That doesn't mean I'm snarking at YOU @Tinaaaaarrrghhh - just the notion that women are unhappy & aggressive "because hormones".

Men have hormones too. Testosterone is not an excuse for aggression.

@KettrickenSmiled

Its not bullshit though, it’s well studied. Estrogen does make you more likely to be dissatisfied in a relationship as well as have a higher chance of neurotic traits - I didn’t say it made you more agressive - violence doesn’t always start or continue in outright Im agression in couples, it can start over petty squabbling and be low level.

And testosterone does make you more agressive, that’s a fact.

Humans are animals like any other. Why do we act like they’re not and hormones don’t make a difference?

KettrickenSmiled · 11/08/2022 15:06

I was snark about it because it's bullshit.
That doesn't mean I'm snarking at YOU @Tinaaaaarrrghhh - just the notion that women are unhappy & aggressive "because hormones".

Men have hormones too. Testosterone is not an excuse for aggression.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:06

Ilovemycat1 · 11/08/2022 14:46

@Tinaaaaarrrghhh

Estrogen is not the reason
Socialisation is the reason

Overweight woman have more circulating estrogen (adipose tissue contains estrogen) - does that make then more aggressive

HRT replaces estrogen - are woman commenced on HRT the office cow?

Men who carry more weight also have more estrogen. Are they the office bullies?

@Ilovemycat1

Socialisation comes from our biology though, it’s absurd to think it’s the other way round. We are animals like any other.

And actually men who have high estrogen can have problems with trouble regulating emotions and so on.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:04

KettrickenSmiled · 11/08/2022 14:49

Im guessing because in the lesbian relationships you have double the estrogen but there’s only one woman’s count in the straight relationships.

Wow. How does that work? Does all the oestrogen just leak out of their pores & combine to make them miserable? How very unsettling.
No wonder so may PP think female-only groups & workplaces are so toxic. Can't be anything to do with joining the wrong groups or workplaces, can it?

@KettrickenSmiled

I don’t see why you were snark about it. It’s what I read I don’t know exactly em how it works. I was just guessing that two people with higher likelihood of dissatisfaction in a relationship would make for a more volatile relationship. The research didn’t say everyone with high estrogen would be unsatisfied just that it was more likely. So logically you double your chances of that with two women as opposed to one in a Hetero couple

KettrickenSmiled · 11/08/2022 15:02

No wonder the patriachy continues

All that estrogen

😂😂😂Too right @Ilovemycat1 !

So far on this thread I have learned that

  1. the patriarchy causes female toxicity
  2. female toxicity props up the patriarchy
  3. it's all the fault of oestrogen
  4. some PP don't much like women, but instead of saying so, say they prefer men because all women are bitches.

I need a cup of tea before my brain falls out.

SweetSenorita · 11/08/2022 15:00

the80sweregreat · 10/08/2022 21:04

I totally agree ! ( I am a woman)

I totally disagree. I'm also a woman.

Mississipi71 · 11/08/2022 14:58

Greenginghamdress · 11/08/2022 10:37

I've had male and female bosses.

The males are lovely, friendly and professional.
The women I used to work for, completely different story. Their bitchiness, back stabbing and being my friend one day then enemy the next made my life a misery.
I completely agree with you.
Apart from my oldest female best friends I'd rather hang out with men.

Agree with you

Ilovemycat1 · 11/08/2022 14:54

KettrickenSmiled · 11/08/2022 14:49

Im guessing because in the lesbian relationships you have double the estrogen but there’s only one woman’s count in the straight relationships.

Wow. How does that work? Does all the oestrogen just leak out of their pores & combine to make them miserable? How very unsettling.
No wonder so may PP think female-only groups & workplaces are so toxic. Can't be anything to do with joining the wrong groups or workplaces, can it?

No wonder the patriachy continues

All that estrogen

Swipe left for the next trending thread