Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think women are more toxic than people would like to admit?

505 replies

MarthaMayver · 10/08/2022 20:49

I'd like to start by saying by no means are all women toxic, I'm a female myself and have always been a huge supporter of feminism and "sisterhood" if you will. However the more behaviour I witness from women, I'm starting to stray away from seeing them as allies.

I have worked in female dominated sectors my entire life and have constantly had to witness cliques, gossiping, power plays, passive aggressiveness, and downright bullying. I had to leave my last job as it was affecting my mental health so badly.

I always thought this was just part and parcel of working in groups. However I started a new job last year, with an equal spread of male and female colleagues and there has been none of this. I'm now wondering if the problem with all of my previous workplaces was the fact that they were female dominated.

To me, it's very obvious in person how women favour men over their own gender, regardless of how much "female empowerment" and "Women Supporting Women" is preached these days. For example, they will let men get away with mistakes they wouldn't let other women get away with. Male incompetence is often seen as "cute", whereas the same behaviour coming from a woman would be laughed or sneered at.

There are so many stories coming out in recent years of mothers favouring their sons over their daughters, and at worst bullying and abusing their daughters whilst worshiping their sons. I now think back to my own childhood and I can remember many occasions where my mother would put me down for something, while supporting my male siblings for doing the same thing. There were also a lot of sly, underhand insults that I didn't realize at the time, that were never directed towards my brothers.

I'm prepared to be told IBU, but I'm also very interested in knowing how many people agree, or if anyone has any similar experiences.

OP posts:
Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 16:28

@gnilliwdog

It shouldn’t come as much surprise that stupid men with an excess of energy and motivation to do something (while lacking the intelligence to actual do something constructive) are probably responsible for a lot of crime and violence in society.

WinterDeWinter · 11/08/2022 16:27

Women are humans and have the same human failings as men. What they don't have is a society structured around their needs, so 'bad women' have far less impact, and 'pretty good women' who just take what's offered even if it's unethical (as pretty good men do by 'helping out' at home rather than splitting 50/50 for eg) also have far less impact on those around them.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 16:26

@gnilliwdog

Some women have high amounts for women, but it’s still likely to be ten times less than mens even if high. But yes it interplays with other things. For instance If a man is of very low intelligence high testosterone is unlikely to cause much good for himself or others (unless your a successful boxer or sportsman or something). But if he can channel it into other areas which he would probably also need other traits to be able to do it can result in good or even great things.

gnilliwdog · 11/08/2022 16:21

@Tinaaaaarrrghhh yes, I see what you are saying. I believe testosterone may be linked to risk taking behaviour. So this could be innate in anyone who has high levels of this hormone. The willingness to take risks doesn't have to result in violence which I think is where socialisation comes in. If you are right and we are determined by our hormones we could channel those drives towards something creative. I am not really sure about the testosterone case- don't some women have high levels of this too? And isn't there a chance that its interaction with an individual's particular biology will have very different effects?

ShreddedMarmalade · 11/08/2022 16:21

I work in a fairly evenly- split environment and can confirm their are unpleasant people of both sexes. Off the top of my head, there are more unpleasant mean than women. Their issues seem to stem from fragile or inflated egos or misogyny. My current immediate team is all female and there is no nastiness. My female boss is the best boss I've had.

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 16:11

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 16:09

@Pumperthepumper

because it is also responsible for good things and it’s just our species. Remove it and you wouldn’t have men.

And Who is we? Do you and the local feminist group fancy trying to go door to door and round up all the men? Sounds like a practical plan.

Curing it would be curing humanity of men and who even knows if we could survive without it despite all the negatives

We is society. If we have such an easy cure for male violence, why don’t we use it? What ‘good things’ would say, Ian Huntley lose?

Discovereads · 11/08/2022 16:10

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 16:07

So for men you add natural hormone of testosterone that is linked to violent aggression + socialisation that overt aggression is socially acceptable and you rather predictably get violence, lots of violence.

This keeps coming up but as I said, it’s not true. If you can find a study that definitively links testosterone with aggression then I’d be happy to read it.

Ah my battery is dying, so to give you a tip, there have been numerous studies done on male prison inmates that found those convicted of violent offences had significantly higher testosterone levels than those convicted of nonviolent offences and also than those not ever convicted of any crime. Now, in case you are wondering, stress reduces testosterone in men so the high stress of a prison environment could not cause the elevated levels of testosterone observed.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 16:09

@Pumperthepumper

because it is also responsible for good things and it’s just our species. Remove it and you wouldn’t have men.

And Who is we? Do you and the local feminist group fancy trying to go door to door and round up all the men? Sounds like a practical plan.

Curing it would be curing humanity of men and who even knows if we could survive without it despite all the negatives

Crabbyboot · 11/08/2022 16:09

I work in a female dominated industry and I have had a mixture of toxic environments and positive environments. I really think it depends on the people you are working with.
How do you explain the bullying that goes on in the building industry to the apprentices? Is it "just banter" because it's males doing it? If it were females it would probably be considered "toxic" bullying behaviour.

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 16:08

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 16:06

@Pumperthepumper

Im saying it’s not chicken or egg - the hormones came before the socialisation and before humanity was fully human. They led to socialisation as we have known it, socialisation is a human behaviour not just a cause of human behaviour.

There is plenty of proof testosterone causes aggression which can lead to violence and anyone not ideologically invested in socialisation being a bogey man that cause all evil can easily see it is true. It’s true for almost all male mammals and animals in general.

There isn’t though. Again, if you find a study that says testosterone is 100% linked to increased aggression I’d love to read it.

Ilovemycat1 · 11/08/2022 16:07

My
Mother was fairly toxic in all honesty

She used to say that me and my sisters should expect an arsehole of a partner 'because he is a man'. Also that testosterone is the reason for cheating because they cannot help it

😭😭

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 16:07

Discovereads · 11/08/2022 16:04

It’s probably both tbh. Nature and nurture as these types of things tend to be.
We have urges/emotions influenced by hormones and socialisation teaches us how to regulate and channel them. If we are poorly socialised, we have less capability to regulate and channel our urges/emotions. (All this is in context of a person who is mentally well btw, mental illness is a whole other discussion).

We already know that “boys will be boys” is poor socialisation because it is socialisation that overt aggression is accepted in boys. This is further enforced by the socialisation of girls to “be kind” which means that society does not accept overt aggression in girls, and that assertiveness is also not acceptable. Boys are socialised to exhibit dominance behaviours while girls are socialised to exhibit submissive behaviours.

So for men you add natural hormone of testosterone that is linked to violent aggression + socialisation that overt aggression is socially acceptable and you rather predictably get violence, lots of violence.

For women you add natural hormone of estrogen that might be linked to passive aggression + socialisation that zero aggression and assertiveness is acceptable and you get also rather predictably non-violence.

It’s also very clear that women are held to a higher standard than men in terms of controlling our behaviour. We are trained in it from birth. So yes, changes to socialisation are also essential to combat male violence.

So for men you add natural hormone of testosterone that is linked to violent aggression + socialisation that overt aggression is socially acceptable and you rather predictably get violence, lots of violence.

This keeps coming up but as I said, it’s not true. If you can find a study that definitively links testosterone with aggression then I’d be happy to read it.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 16:06

@Pumperthepumper

Im saying it’s not chicken or egg - the hormones came before the socialisation and before humanity was fully human. They led to socialisation as we have known it, socialisation is a human behaviour not just a cause of human behaviour.

There is plenty of proof testosterone causes aggression which can lead to violence and anyone not ideologically invested in socialisation being a bogey man that cause all evil can easily see it is true. It’s true for almost all male mammals and animals in general.

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 16:05

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 16:02

@Pumperthepumper

How do you suggest going about that I wonder?
Testosterone extractions? All men report to the great pink temple for estrogen enhancement and testosterone dehancement by 22:00

The thing your missing is this isn’t all negative, it causes both positive and negative like estrogen.

Yes, exactly that. If testosterone is responsible for violence, why don’t we inject violent men with a different hormone as a cure?

Discovereads · 11/08/2022 16:04

gnilliwdog · 11/08/2022 15:44

@Pumperthepumper I agree socialisation is more likely the cause of behaviours. Even if some hormones promote aggression an individual could channel that into ambition, sports, creative endeavour, all sorts of activities that have a positive outcome.

It’s probably both tbh. Nature and nurture as these types of things tend to be.
We have urges/emotions influenced by hormones and socialisation teaches us how to regulate and channel them. If we are poorly socialised, we have less capability to regulate and channel our urges/emotions. (All this is in context of a person who is mentally well btw, mental illness is a whole other discussion).

We already know that “boys will be boys” is poor socialisation because it is socialisation that overt aggression is accepted in boys. This is further enforced by the socialisation of girls to “be kind” which means that society does not accept overt aggression in girls, and that assertiveness is also not acceptable. Boys are socialised to exhibit dominance behaviours while girls are socialised to exhibit submissive behaviours.

So for men you add natural hormone of testosterone that is linked to violent aggression + socialisation that overt aggression is socially acceptable and you rather predictably get violence, lots of violence.

For women you add natural hormone of estrogen that might be linked to passive aggression + socialisation that zero aggression and assertiveness is acceptable and you get also rather predictably non-violence.

It’s also very clear that women are held to a higher standard than men in terms of controlling our behaviour. We are trained in it from birth. So yes, changes to socialisation are also essential to combat male violence.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 16:03

It’s who we are as a species

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 16:02

@Pumperthepumper

How do you suggest going about that I wonder?
Testosterone extractions? All men report to the great pink temple for estrogen enhancement and testosterone dehancement by 22:00

The thing your missing is this isn’t all negative, it causes both positive and negative like estrogen.

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 16:01

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:59

@Pumperthepumper

yes and what causes the socialisation? It’s not learned by experience it re emerges even amongst groups re introduced to the wild. Biology and hormones are the reason socialisation has taken the turns that it has. We weren’t once sought balls of clay all non toxic and then socialisation started, our biology and our socialisation are one and the same and forever intertwined.

I don’t think I’m following this, do you mean it’s a chicken or egg situation? Socialisation or hormones?

Regardless, it’s still incorrect. We have no proof that testosterone causes violence. We have loads that says socialisation does.

Quirrelsotherface · 11/08/2022 15:59

There is a nastiness, a competition and a bitchiness towards attractive, slim, bright women. God help you if you're confident with it. There is a jealousy amongst women, probably coming from competition over men or male attention. It's there whether it's admitted or not.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:59

@Pumperthepumper

yes and what causes the socialisation? It’s not learned by experience it re emerges even amongst groups re introduced to the wild. Biology and hormones are the reason socialisation has taken the turns that it has. We weren’t once sought balls of clay all non toxic and then socialisation started, our biology and our socialisation are one and the same and forever intertwined.

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 15:58

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:57

@Pumperthepumper

Actually we couldn’t end testosterone overnight

We could end male violence overnight. Why not?

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:57

@Pumperthepumper

Actually we couldn’t end testosterone overnight

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 15:56

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:51

@gnilliwdog
@Pumperthepumper

Testosterone isn’t a theory, it really does cause different beahviour.

This whole idea of “socialisation” being responsible for human beahviour is nonsense - what caused the socialisation? Biology and hormones that’s what. Imagine thinking it was the other way around lol, that before socialisation we were just doughy unmoulded clay then like the Big Bang one day socialisation just happened and made men and women different and toxic in differing ways.

No other animal would we say such nonsense about. Humans follow other primate beahviour in many ways and more agressive male behaviour and in fighting for position amongst females in normal. Why are we surprised when we do the same.

Do we believe that all animal behaviour is socialisation or just human behaviour?
It seems very unscientific and more in the realm of some kind of feminist fantasy to pretend that human behaviour (or most of it) is all socialisation

Animal behaviour is socially motivated in certain animales though - elephants and gorillas (and maybe lions?) treat male and female offspring differently. And we know that abuse is cyclical - you’re much more likely to become abusive yourself if you were raised in an abusive household.

And we do socialise girls and boys differently - take a wander into your local toy shop and look at what toys are marketed to each sex, and how. Not to mention ‘boys will be boys!’ and all these other microagressions.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 15:53

gnilliwdog · 11/08/2022 15:44

@Pumperthepumper I agree socialisation is more likely the cause of behaviours. Even if some hormones promote aggression an individual could channel that into ambition, sports, creative endeavour, all sorts of activities that have a positive outcome.

@gnilliwdog

But that would also mean hormones were causing those positive behaviours. Nobody said hormones could only cause toxicity and nothing good. It seems to me there’s a need to believe socialisation is the bogey man so that we can do something about it.

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 15:53

@Discovereads thats exactly the problem though - you’re absolutely right, if testosterone was the reason for male violence we could end it overnight. But it’s not, so we can’t.