Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think women are more toxic than people would like to admit?

505 replies

MarthaMayver · 10/08/2022 20:49

I'd like to start by saying by no means are all women toxic, I'm a female myself and have always been a huge supporter of feminism and "sisterhood" if you will. However the more behaviour I witness from women, I'm starting to stray away from seeing them as allies.

I have worked in female dominated sectors my entire life and have constantly had to witness cliques, gossiping, power plays, passive aggressiveness, and downright bullying. I had to leave my last job as it was affecting my mental health so badly.

I always thought this was just part and parcel of working in groups. However I started a new job last year, with an equal spread of male and female colleagues and there has been none of this. I'm now wondering if the problem with all of my previous workplaces was the fact that they were female dominated.

To me, it's very obvious in person how women favour men over their own gender, regardless of how much "female empowerment" and "Women Supporting Women" is preached these days. For example, they will let men get away with mistakes they wouldn't let other women get away with. Male incompetence is often seen as "cute", whereas the same behaviour coming from a woman would be laughed or sneered at.

There are so many stories coming out in recent years of mothers favouring their sons over their daughters, and at worst bullying and abusing their daughters whilst worshiping their sons. I now think back to my own childhood and I can remember many occasions where my mother would put me down for something, while supporting my male siblings for doing the same thing. There were also a lot of sly, underhand insults that I didn't realize at the time, that were never directed towards my brothers.

I'm prepared to be told IBU, but I'm also very interested in knowing how many people agree, or if anyone has any similar experiences.

OP posts:
gnilliwdog · 11/08/2022 20:24

@Tinaaaaarrrghhh I am just struggling with the idea that men in prehistoric times fought more because of testosterone i.e. that is what made them fight. It seems just as likely to me that they were fighting because they were physically stronger and because women may have been pregnant or breastfeeding. I don't imagine they wanted to fight at all. This was pre colonial times or military warfare. These were small groups of people wandering the planet looking for food and shelter. If they fought it may have been about resources, not because a hormone made them want to fight. We know very little about these people, as it is pre-history. We can find remnants of what they ate, where they lived, what tools they used. But it's very hard for us to imagine what their society was like.

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 20:17

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 20:13

@Pumperthepumper

No it wouldn’t. Not if they were less able to do so and more needed in the nurturing role as to compliment the aggressive role. They were splitting duties biologically speaking so that one didn’t have to do the others and they could maximise the chance off offspring survival.

And poison (chuckles) aside, primitive weapons are obviously much more effective when used by someone with more strength.

You don’t have to chuckle, they had poison. A lot of the crops we have today are the result of Neanderthal intelligence in crop propagation.

Do you have any evidence for any of this? Or is it just something that you think might have happened? How did their DNA know about the duty splitting? What about when one of the parents died and the other one had to take on the protector role?

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 20:13

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 20:04

Women being more aggressive wouldn’t be beneficial for humans evolutionary speaking if they were smaller than men, as they wouldn’t be as good at fighting off threats.

This doesn’t even make any sense - if you’re saying testosterone leads to an ability to protect their young then of course it would be beneficial for women to be equally as protective. And they wouldn’t need physical strength because they could use weapons or poison.

@Pumperthepumper

No it wouldn’t. Not if they were less able to do so and more needed in the nurturing role as to compliment the aggressive role. They were splitting duties biologically speaking so that one didn’t have to do the others and they could maximise the chance off offspring survival.

And poison (chuckles) aside, primitive weapons are obviously much more effective when used by someone with more strength.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 20:10

@gnilliwdog

I find it hard to believe they were fundamentally different from more recent tribal societies we’ve seen who were still living that lifestyle (when the “new” world was discovered and pacific islands and Australia first seen by Europeans or when Amazonian tribes were discovered). In all those societies men were very much in charge of “mens business” (like disputes and small scale warfare).
Tribal Hunter gatherer society doesn’t seem to have been much different from most historical society in that respect.

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 20:10

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 20:06

@Pumperthepumper

Use poison? We’re talking about caveman days not a Miss Marple case

Potatoes were poisonous until ‘cavemen’ worked out how to propínate them. No answer to the rest of the post though?

gnilliwdog · 11/08/2022 20:08

@YesJess Possibly men evolved to have testosterone to aid survival, I don't know. But I meant that the reason men appeared to fight more than women in prehistory may be because of practical considerations, rather than having an innate desire to fight due to testosterone.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 20:06

@Pumperthepumper

Use poison? We’re talking about caveman days not a Miss Marple case

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 20:04

Women being more aggressive wouldn’t be beneficial for humans evolutionary speaking if they were smaller than men, as they wouldn’t be as good at fighting off threats.

This doesn’t even make any sense - if you’re saying testosterone leads to an ability to protect their young then of course it would be beneficial for women to be equally as protective. And they wouldn’t need physical strength because they could use weapons or poison.

gnilliwdog · 11/08/2022 20:03

@Tinaaaaarrrghhh I thought you were talking about a hunter gatherer period, where I imagine there might be an occasional argument over resources and territory between neighbouring tribes. I don't know how we would know what women were telling men to do in those days?

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 20:01

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 19:56

@gnilliwdog

Unlikely. It’s not like women were telling them to seek out other men to fight or to push into other groups territories (what would come to be known as warfare). I’m not saying no women have ever benefited from male on male violence because they definitely have but they overtly didn’t cause it in the first place. It mirrors what happens in pretty much every other mammal and especially mirrors what happens with male chimps.

I agree that it would have been impractical for women to fight more at that point, but the truth is and for other animals too, it likely never occurred to them because the roles were decided by the biology and the agression and testosterone were a part of that.

Keep in mind in those days especially, male aggression was often put to use to protect one’s young in the same way you’ll see it in animals today (if you ever see a mum and dad duck with ducklings and then the dad duck takes a run at you or your car you know what I mean). It’s been lost on people in the modern day but aggression in males was a nurturing quality at one time, because it increased the chances off his offsprings survival.

I think it’s all intertwined and can’t be separated. Testosterone not only makes men more aggressive, it also makes them bigger and gives them more benefit from aggression. Women being more aggressive wouldn’t be beneficial for humans evolutionary speaking if they were smaller than men, as they wouldn’t be as good at fighting off threats. So then naturally men tend to make up those who decide what to do with that male aggression and these people would be the leaders and what have you of early society and then they socialise other men into that and women were in that more nurturing role (at that time). So mens testosterone and biology is actually causing socialisation not stemming from it. It may be the greatest driver of all human socialisation and progress really.

Do you have any evidence for any of this? Or is it just a theory that makes sense to you?

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 19:58

YesJess · 11/08/2022 19:52

They may have been the ones fighting for these practical reasons rather than because testosterone made them do it.

I think there's a fighting (excuse the pun) chance that men evolved to have higher testosterone in order to aid survival.

@YesJess

Yeah but when we say “men evolved”, they would have really had that long before they were even human men, they just continued on in the same vein as the primates and mammals they evolved from. It’s not like human men were the start of it.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 19:56

@gnilliwdog

Unlikely. It’s not like women were telling them to seek out other men to fight or to push into other groups territories (what would come to be known as warfare). I’m not saying no women have ever benefited from male on male violence because they definitely have but they overtly didn’t cause it in the first place. It mirrors what happens in pretty much every other mammal and especially mirrors what happens with male chimps.

I agree that it would have been impractical for women to fight more at that point, but the truth is and for other animals too, it likely never occurred to them because the roles were decided by the biology and the agression and testosterone were a part of that.

Keep in mind in those days especially, male aggression was often put to use to protect one’s young in the same way you’ll see it in animals today (if you ever see a mum and dad duck with ducklings and then the dad duck takes a run at you or your car you know what I mean). It’s been lost on people in the modern day but aggression in males was a nurturing quality at one time, because it increased the chances off his offsprings survival.

I think it’s all intertwined and can’t be separated. Testosterone not only makes men more aggressive, it also makes them bigger and gives them more benefit from aggression. Women being more aggressive wouldn’t be beneficial for humans evolutionary speaking if they were smaller than men, as they wouldn’t be as good at fighting off threats. So then naturally men tend to make up those who decide what to do with that male aggression and these people would be the leaders and what have you of early society and then they socialise other men into that and women were in that more nurturing role (at that time). So mens testosterone and biology is actually causing socialisation not stemming from it. It may be the greatest driver of all human socialisation and progress really.

YesJess · 11/08/2022 19:52

They may have been the ones fighting for these practical reasons rather than because testosterone made them do it.

I think there's a fighting (excuse the pun) chance that men evolved to have higher testosterone in order to aid survival.

gnilliwdog · 11/08/2022 19:42

@Tinaaaaarrrghhh

gnilliwdog · 11/08/2022 19:41

'Men we’re more aggressive long before complex societies back when we were barely human yet. They were more aggressive in pre history (as the bone record shows evidence of their injuries and violence through small scale conflict to each other). They’ve been more aggressive at every stage throughout history and they’re more aggressive now'

But maybe men were fighting each other because they were stronger than women and did not have a baby at the breast or were pregnant? They may have been the ones fighting for these practical reasons rather than because testosterone made them do it.

youboozeyoulose · 11/08/2022 19:37

MarthaMayver · 11/08/2022 10:43

I think the way some posters are shifting the focus onto mens bad behaviour are proving my point that society isn't willing to admit womens toxic personality traits.

I'm also not just talking about female dominated workplaces, I'm talking how women treat others as a whole.

For example, in male friendship groups there's always more of a sense of camaraderie, whereas in female friendship groups there always seems to be some element of drama, backstabbing, gossiping etc. Many studies have been done on this.

Mothers turn on their daughters in a way that is basically unheard of in father-son relationship dynamics.

I've also witnessed firsthand how women will publicly put down their husbands/partners and then play the victim. For example, sly insults about his hair line, weight, penis size, etc, all disguised as "banter". If it was a man making jokes about his wifes weight gain, or appearance in general, it wouldn't go down very well.

Women also seem to be more controlling than men in relationships as a whole. You hear countless stories of women telling their partners they can't go out to see their friends, or they have to be back by a certain time, and even down to domineering his relationships with his own family, etc. There have also been studies done on this.

On the subject of controlling, you always seem to hear stories on over-involved, controlling mothers. It never seems to be fathers who exhibit this behaviour.

This post is the biggest load of rubbish I have read in a long time.

OP, quite seriously, I don't think this way of thinking is very healthy at all.

YesJess · 11/08/2022 19:36

I don't support women because we share the same chromosomes and reproductive organs (actually we don't as I have had a hysterectomy). I will support women if need be, and will support men if need be.

Pretty much my view.

YesJess · 11/08/2022 19:34

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 19:16

@gnilliwdog

At a species wide level it’s pretty certain that they are. Couple that with the fact we evolved from primate types where males are more agressive and have more testosterone (couple this with the fact it’s true of basically every mammal).

Men we’re more aggressive long before complex societies back when we were barely human yet. They were more aggressive in pre history (as the bone record shows evidence of their injuries and violence through small scale conflict to each other). They’ve been more aggressive at every stage throughout history and they’re more aggressive now. Just like every other primate and every other mammal the males who have higher testosterone are far more aggressive species wide.

Now we live ina complex society. And they’re still more aggressive just as they’ve always been.

I mean what more do you need?

Im not saying you shouldn’t help individuals who that is causing problems for or make room for men who aren’t. I’m not even saying it’s bad all the time.

100% this

thesurrealist · 11/08/2022 19:25

Having worked in education and the NHS for most of my career I've encountered some absolute twats - some of whom were women and some men.

I have found that men tend to get promoted quicker despite obvious incompetence, but then I've met a number of incompetent women in positions that they should never have been given. The difference is that the women are accused (overtly in general) of getting there by offering sexual favours, whilst the men never get that.

I've also found that some senior male clinicians tend to treat women in senior positions like they are admin. I've definitely experienced the very important man asking me to make coffee for the meeting instead of my male junior. Luckily I've seen a change in attitude in recent years - or maybe I'm just more arsey.

A lot of the women I have worked with do tend to judge me by my reproductive status rather than getting to know me. I have definitely worked with women with "golden womb syndrome" and have had comments about how I'm not a proper woman, don't knkw love etc all the usual cliches women without children hear every fucking day.
Men just see me.

I don't support women because we share the same chromosomes and reproductive organs (actually we don't as I have had a hysterectomy). I will support women if need be, and will support men if need be.

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 19:20

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 19:18

@Pumperthepumper

And when did men start suppressing the emotions which females who more which they would otherwise be showing?

Dont you think you may just be thinking that men are suppressing their emotions because your ideological stance means you can’t accept they don’t feel the same way as you because they are not the same as women?

I’m not sure what this means but I think we might just be back to you thinking men are biologically violent.

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 19:18

The studies don’t say what you’re claiming they say though. Who do you think I’m biased towards?

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 19:18

@Pumperthepumper

And when did men start suppressing the emotions which females who more which they would otherwise be showing?

Dont you think you may just be thinking that men are suppressing their emotions because your ideological stance means you can’t accept they don’t feel the same way as you because they are not the same as women?

YesJess · 11/08/2022 19:17

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 19:09

I’m saying the exact opposite. I’m saying they can be helped because violence is not innate in them.

I think we will have to agree to disagree. You’re absolutely determined to believe men are biologically violent even when all the evidence you provided tells you otherwise. I’m not really sure what else there is to say.

The evidence shows strong links between violence and higher testosterone, and that it's a common trait shared in violent offenders.

I don't think we should derail this thread anymore. The studies are there and I'm confident most unbiased readers will connect the dots.

Tinaaaaarrrghhh · 11/08/2022 19:16

gnilliwdog · 11/08/2022 19:08

I would be cautious about saying men are biologically more violent than women. That's like saying women are biologically more emotional. There must be loads of intersecting factors that influence any individual's behaviour. I hear what people are saying about animals, but we do live in a much more complex society than they do and are subject to many more influences.

@gnilliwdog

At a species wide level it’s pretty certain that they are. Couple that with the fact we evolved from primate types where males are more agressive and have more testosterone (couple this with the fact it’s true of basically every mammal).

Men we’re more aggressive long before complex societies back when we were barely human yet. They were more aggressive in pre history (as the bone record shows evidence of their injuries and violence through small scale conflict to each other). They’ve been more aggressive at every stage throughout history and they’re more aggressive now. Just like every other primate and every other mammal the males who have higher testosterone are far more aggressive species wide.

Now we live ina complex society. And they’re still more aggressive just as they’ve always been.

I mean what more do you need?

Im not saying you shouldn’t help individuals who that is causing problems for or make room for men who aren’t. I’m not even saying it’s bad all the time.

Pumperthepumper · 11/08/2022 19:15

I don’t think women are more emotional either. I think societally men are taught to suppress their emotions so they do.