Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed at this work situation? Advice appreciated.

142 replies

Celia24 · 10/08/2022 20:29

I've been working at a company for a little under a year. Really enjoyed it so far and especially in last couple of months have grown hugely in confidence and delivered key project.

Here's the messy/annoying part: my line manager is leaving and I'm disappointed as I love her. In our recent 1 to 1 she told me that she is putting me forward for a senior position in the team. To be clear, there is me (most junior but more 'associate' level), my manager (senior) and the director of department (my boss's boss who I also work with and know well).

She said she had sent on her list of objectives I needed to tick off to get that promotion to her boss. I anxiously asked who they were going to hire to replace her - and she tells me she is going to recommend they promote me and get someone more junior to work under me. At a recent work function two other colleagues approached me and asked if this meant I was getting promoted. And I feel ready.

Well...she is now on holiday and I've seen not one, but two, senior positions in the team open up (clearly instigated by boss's boss). I also spoke to this person yesterday who said he was impressed with me and keen to discuss my future but hadn't had a deep conversation with my manager (clearly: no promotion discussed despite what I've been lead to believe)

To my mind, I am already performing at that senior level. So to see they are now recruiting for two positions above me has really annoyed me. I even looked up one interviewee on LinkedIn and saw they were less experienced. How should I handle this?

OP posts:
JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 10/08/2022 23:01

Goodness me - you're getting yourself in a right tizzy. Any company I've worked at has always advertised any role they have, regardless of whether they have a certain person in mind or not. You HAVE to apply for the role. There's nothing awkward about it! It happens where I am all the time.

Sometimes people get the job sometimes they don't. But they're putting themselves out there and they get fantastic feedback if they don't get the role.

It would be highly unethical for you to be 'given' your boss's job - what if someone else within the company wanted/could do the job and wasn't given a chance to interview for the role?

You need to apply - and forget all about misunderstandings and miscommunications. The company are behaving really fairly! They sound like a good company.

You don't sound very old? Is this your first job OP?

Celia24 · 10/08/2022 22:59

Im really surprised to hear so many people think I'm BU about this. Yes, you should be your own advocate (and people are right to reiterate this to me) but a good manager should be that cheerleader supporting your progression.

OP posts:
Celia24 · 10/08/2022 22:57

@BatsAtDawn My line manager presented me with a set of slides some weeks ago outlining the objectives I'd need to meet to be promoted in 6 months. She then passed this over to boss's boss for approval. I've heard nothing since and now my manager is on holiday.

So I gave boss's boss a nudge as I have not had sight of the objectives since then. I made it clear I want to know what I am working towards. Boss's boss apologised for the delay - reiterated his interest in my progression (generally, no use of word 'promotion') and said we need to sit down with my manager to clarify what was actually discussed.

I am annoyed because I feel the carrot has been dangled and after several weeks of seeing these objectives Ive been waiting in a holding pattern for the so called promotion only to discover boss's boss seemingly knows nothing about it. I feel in limbo.

OP posts:
AlisonDonut · 10/08/2022 22:56

Fucking hells bells. Apply. Don't apply. Whatever. They don't have to run their decisions past you, you know.

Celia24 · 10/08/2022 22:51

saltofcelery · 10/08/2022 22:48

How did you only just see the advert on your way home yet also know who an interviewee is?

Separate role. My boss's boss told me a few days ago he was recruiting for one role to replace my line manager. All fine... although he did say he had been struggling to recruit someone senior and experienced enough.

But now another role is being advertised as of today for a second senior role in the team (a rung below that one).

OP posts:
BatsAtDawn · 10/08/2022 22:50

So your manager spoke about creating a new role and recommending you as the preferred candidate. Then two separate senior roles - different from the one you had spoken about - were advertised and you are unhappy you haven't been approached or allocated either? Or that your manager didn't tell you about the two other headcount being added, even though she may not have known given she is leaving?

You need to take more ownership of your own career here and apply for the job(s) you want. Your managers role is to support you, not spoon-feed you, so it's down to you to apply.

For new roles, like the one discussed with you, its entirely normal to advertise and apply even where there is a preferred candidate.

figmaofmyimagination · 10/08/2022 22:50

Stop cutting out middle people or trying to have off record conversations- just APPLY, before the closing date, or you’ll miss it!

Celia24 · 10/08/2022 22:49

Sheepreallylikerichteabiscuits · 10/08/2022 22:43

I completely agree, I just wondered if the OP was getting this kind of senario confused with a traditional promotion, as that would make far more sense of the getting objectives signed off and the 6 month timescale

My line manager definitely said a promotion. She said she wanted to be clear that is what it was and explained that I would receive an increase in salary as well.

She said that she was more junior than me previously and wanted her departure to give me the chance to move up the ranks. All well and good as some have said...

OP posts:
saltofcelery · 10/08/2022 22:48

How did you only just see the advert on your way home yet also know who an interviewee is?

Sheepreallylikerichteabiscuits · 10/08/2022 22:43

Scepticalwotsits · 10/08/2022 22:41

Usually that example isn’t a promotion in a traditional sense just moving up a banding range within your role. A developer is still a developer and a junior, associate, senior is usually a distinction of skill rather than responsibility (although this will vary by workplace)

I completely agree, I just wondered if the OP was getting this kind of senario confused with a traditional promotion, as that would make far more sense of the getting objectives signed off and the 6 month timescale

Scepticalwotsits · 10/08/2022 22:41

Sheepreallylikerichteabiscuits · 10/08/2022 21:08

This is why I asked if you were in the UK, but I actually now realise it also depends on your line of work

So generally speaking in the UK you have to apply for a promotion, particularly if it involves line management, and usually it will be advertised externally as well.

That said there are some careers where it might not be the case. For example you might enter as a junior developer (coder), then become a developer, then a senior developer without necessarily applying for a promotion. But even that's not always the case and quite often you would need to apply for a senior or lead position.

Usually that example isn’t a promotion in a traditional sense just moving up a banding range within your role. A developer is still a developer and a junior, associate, senior is usually a distinction of skill rather than responsibility (although this will vary by workplace)

StClare101 · 10/08/2022 22:40

what? Most companies have a policy of advertising all roles. Apply for the job for gods sake!!!

Sheepreallylikerichteabiscuits · 10/08/2022 22:40

Celia24 · 10/08/2022 22:05

@Aprilx She is still my manager until she leaves though. Therefore she is still in charge of my progression so that should surely still mean something?

But it is obvious now I need to cut out the middle woman and speak to the boss's boss myself. I'm new to this kind of situation - clearly I need to take the bull by the horns. It's nerve wracking!

The only person in charge of your career is you

Not thinking that can have you held back by a bad manager as much as promoted by a good one

StreetwiseHercules · 10/08/2022 22:38

I think it’s a bit of a messy situation. There are two different lines here. Performing in a role and being promoted can be distinct from applying for a higher grade role and being successful. Often the 2 are conflated.

I think given you have been looking at other applicants details there might be a question mark around actually applying. Hiring processes are supposed to be confidential.

I would have a straight out conversation with your boss’s boss and try to get to the bottom of it.

OppsUpsSide · 10/08/2022 22:35

Apply for the position and stop mithering.

AHobbyaweek · 10/08/2022 22:30

Always apply! Even if you can only tick 80% or so of the criteria always apply. Worst they can say is no. Best is you get the job.
I have done this before and not got the job but still go a prompt and pay rise. It can't hurt.

ForensicFlossy · 10/08/2022 22:25

Celia24 · 10/08/2022 22:05

@Aprilx She is still my manager until she leaves though. Therefore she is still in charge of my progression so that should surely still mean something?

But it is obvious now I need to cut out the middle woman and speak to the boss's boss myself. I'm new to this kind of situation - clearly I need to take the bull by the horns. It's nerve wracking!

You are in charge of your progression. You need to apply for the job, that is how you show your bosses boss that you want the promotion.

I was given a promotion a couple of the years ago, the job was mine, it was virtually guaranteed but I still had to apply and interview.

gah2teenagers · 10/08/2022 22:25

Crumbs overthinking much. Just apply for the bloody job. I’m bored reading this. Maybe there’s a reason they are leaving you out of the loop if you overthink this much.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 10/08/2022 22:18

When I asked the boss's boss yesterday it was very clear no promotion had been discussed. Or he's playing dumb

My money would be on the second option; with the requirements around advertising externally managers can be sensitive around being seen to have "lined someone up", and I certainly wouldn't assume what has been discussed and what hasn't

As nearly everyone's said, get your application in, carry on with the progession and keep your fingers crossed

PurpleFlower1983 · 10/08/2022 22:12

Apply. Whatever has been said or not said you have zero chance without applying.

FinallyHere · 10/08/2022 22:06

- so it seems like jumping the gun.

Applying will indicate that you are interested in promotion and keen to find out what you need to do to be promoted.

Waiting until you are 'ready' may still lead to promotion by much, much more slowly.

Which approach do you prefer?

Successful business is a lot to do with taking calculated risks.

Celia24 · 10/08/2022 22:05

@Aprilx She is still my manager until she leaves though. Therefore she is still in charge of my progression so that should surely still mean something?

But it is obvious now I need to cut out the middle woman and speak to the boss's boss myself. I'm new to this kind of situation - clearly I need to take the bull by the horns. It's nerve wracking!

OP posts:
whoopdedo · 10/08/2022 21:51

They can't just give it to you directly. Most companies have a policy where they must absolutely advertise a role and usually the way it works is a quiet conversation with the person they want in it (which your manager has had with you), then you apply like anyone else, then you will be interviewed and you may even see others being interviewed. That's just how it works as it's a new role for you. If you stayed in your current role they might put you up a grade and not interview etc but that's not a new role for you then really is it. It's basically still your existing role but with a higher grade.

Aprilx · 10/08/2022 21:42

Celia24 · 10/08/2022 20:41

I feel my own line manager had a duty to pass on my desire for that role before the recruitment process began as she said she had. I made it clear I wanted the position.

For them to not have done that and said something vague about objectives is not what I was lead to believe was happening. I think there has been a communication breakdown to an extent between these two bosses.

No you need to take responsibility for your own career, not leave it in the hands of somebody who is leaving the organisation. She did not “have a duty” to do anything.

It can be very demoralising in an organisation is when somebody is handed a position without it being advertised or them going through a recruitment process. For transparency, it is better for organisations to run a process that at least looks fair!

You are being unrealistic to expect that somebody who is leaving the organisation, gets a say in who will be recruited into vacant positions after they have left. If you want the job, you need to apply for it and hopefully the good reputation you have built up will stand you in good stead.

Butterfly44 · 10/08/2022 21:37

You either apply for one of the positions, or you don't.
Your line manger is leaving; their boss is organising the ads.

Swipe left for the next trending thread