Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed at this work situation? Advice appreciated.

142 replies

Celia24 · 10/08/2022 20:29

I've been working at a company for a little under a year. Really enjoyed it so far and especially in last couple of months have grown hugely in confidence and delivered key project.

Here's the messy/annoying part: my line manager is leaving and I'm disappointed as I love her. In our recent 1 to 1 she told me that she is putting me forward for a senior position in the team. To be clear, there is me (most junior but more 'associate' level), my manager (senior) and the director of department (my boss's boss who I also work with and know well).

She said she had sent on her list of objectives I needed to tick off to get that promotion to her boss. I anxiously asked who they were going to hire to replace her - and she tells me she is going to recommend they promote me and get someone more junior to work under me. At a recent work function two other colleagues approached me and asked if this meant I was getting promoted. And I feel ready.

Well...she is now on holiday and I've seen not one, but two, senior positions in the team open up (clearly instigated by boss's boss). I also spoke to this person yesterday who said he was impressed with me and keen to discuss my future but hadn't had a deep conversation with my manager (clearly: no promotion discussed despite what I've been lead to believe)

To my mind, I am already performing at that senior level. So to see they are now recruiting for two positions above me has really annoyed me. I even looked up one interviewee on LinkedIn and saw they were less experienced. How should I handle this?

OP posts:
ChampagneLassie · 11/08/2022 08:25

I think your misunderstanding this and this is the role with you in mind. Of course the job would need to be advertised and you'd need to apply.

rarelyontime · 11/08/2022 08:20

Your boss doesn't think you're quite ready yet. You think you are.

Your boss is leaving.

Your boss's boss is recruiting for the role you want.

If your boss's boss recruits people, you intend to quit.

Honestly, based on all you've said, you have very little to lose by applying directly and cutting your boss out of this process.

GeekyThings · 11/08/2022 08:17

You said the bosses boss said something that just made me realise what's going on "Boss's boss apologised for the delay - reiterated his interest in my progression (generally, no use of word 'promotion') and said we need to sit down with my manager to clarify what was actually discussed."

He didn't use the word promotion because there's really no such thing anymore to senior roles. There's progression, which means you learn on the job, in preparation either for applying for a role higher up, or in another department but in a field you're working towards. You don't just get moved up (not us lower down the rung people anyway, that's a director level thing to happen).

He also said he needed to clarify what your line manager had told you - that's code for him saying 'I can see that she's said you'll be getting a promotion, but she shouldn't have said that because it's not true, and she was in no position to offer any such thing'.

That doesn't mean you shouldn't apply for the job, far from it - take the initiative back, apply, prep for the interview. If you take the reins back you don't need to complain about her misleading you. You do need to apply soon, the longer you wait, the less likely it is you'll get it - do not wait for this discussion, it's not what you think it is, it'll be what I've just said it is above.

Brefugee · 11/08/2022 08:01

sorry posted too early

She is still my manager until she leaves though. Therefore she is still in charge of my progression so that should surely still mean something?

is this your first job, OP, or are you quite young? Your career progression is down to you. I'm an old war-horse and IME the way to get promoted is to work smart and make sure that you tell people about your successes and improvements. Every time. All the time.

And apply for promotions within your organisation, and jobs at a higher level outside your organisation. And take the one with the better prospects/money.

Annual evaluations are good for you to see what you need to be doing better, but they are generally also a good way for people to see who doesn't fit, who doesn't cut the mustard, and who they can safely leave in role for another year (and that includes the timid mice who do much more than required but don't apply for promotions).

Get out and hustle. If you want it, you have to show you want it, and that includes applying for it.

blisstwins · 11/08/2022 07:59

Celia24 · 10/08/2022 20:53

I think the root cause is down to a communication breakdown between the two managers.

When I spoke to the boss's boss yesterday he said he was really impressed with my handling of a recent project and how confident and far I'd come in a short time. Then said let's definitely talk more so 'im up to speed with the conversation you had with line manager'. By this point I'd been lead to believe the promotion had been discussed. Clearly not.

I think you are disappointed, emotional, and are taking this personally. Make your wishes clear. Your work thinks highly of you. Initiate the conversations, make your interest clear (by applying)., and see how it goes. Good luck!

Brefugee · 11/08/2022 07:56

When it comes to work don't wait for your talent to be spotted. You are already working at the level you want to be? (which in most places I've been is the minimum requirement for promotion anyway)

Think: what would a man do?
Yes, he would get his CV together, including a summary and examples of recent work at that level and throw his hat into the ring.

Do it. You have literally nothing to lose.

TrashyPanda · 11/08/2022 07:53

Just apply for the job

Elsiid · 11/08/2022 07:30

Just apply.

You seem to expect them to just give it to you but that's not going to happen. They are legally obliged to advertise it properly.

Is this your first job? Applying for a promotion is very, very standard. No need for all this overthinking and angst towards your boss. Good luck to you.

itrytomakemyway · 11/08/2022 07:30

I am sorry of I am misreading you OP, but you do seem a little entitled. You have not been with this company for very long and seem to think that you are going to be handed a promoted post without having to go through due processes. You also seem to think that your career progression is the responsibilty of others. If you do not apply for posts then be prepared to sit back and watch other people who do know how recruitment works, leap frog over you.

If you do apply and secure a line managers role I wonder if you will feel this responsible for the career progression/ automatic promotion of those you line manage?

rookiemere · 11/08/2022 07:24

I'm a Project Manager, you need to have a rhino like hide because any thing goes wrong, any tricky stakeholders and the PM is the one who gets the grief. It's fine because I have no technical skills so I figure it's my role to absorb grief on behalf of the team.

It's not a role for a wilting wallflower, it's also not a role for someone who relies on others promises.

Have the conversation with your bosses boss and apply for the role. Take it as a lesson for your job - trust no one until their deliverable is on the table.

Threelittlelambs · 11/08/2022 07:13

They say males will apply if they reach 50% of the non spec, females assume you need 100%

Apply for the job

Booksandwine80 · 11/08/2022 07:09

I’ve been doing a role as a secondment for best part of a year. When/if the role gets advertised I will have to apply like everyone else.
You’re tying yourself up in knots and wasting time that could be better spent preparing/applying 🙄
And please stop saying boss’s boss 🤣🤣

deeperthanallroses · 11/08/2022 07:07

You will definitely not get the job if you don’t apply for the role - you must apply well within the timing regardless of peoples holidays.
When I joined my company I had a coffee with my now boss. We clicked, it was apparent I fit the role he had in mind. He then had to do a position description, put it up internally and do 3 or 4 sets of interviews with me with progressively senior people. No one internal was a good fit for my job, and he wanted to hire me, but it had to be advertised and the others had to interview me and also agree on the hire. There is nothing personal about making someone follow the process- there might be some miscommunication going on but try not to take it as a personal grievance. Your approach should be ‘we didn’t discuss the two roles plan so that confused me a bit, I’ll be applying for role x I hope that’s what you all had in mind! Looking forward to the interview :)’

MushMonster · 11/08/2022 07:03

I think it is likely that the advertising comes from HR, not from any communication issues.
Just apply.

Trafficlight127 · 11/08/2022 07:00

There may be another colleague in your company with another boss who has also promised them the promotion and now this has caused a problem? Two people going for the same role and now it’s been opened up to give both a fair chance?

MushMonster · 11/08/2022 06:51

Apply for the position!
That is the promotion.
You have been given a list of things to prepare and all.
And being encouraged to it.
So what is the problem? I do not get you.

Tiani4 · 11/08/2022 06:51

I agree with other PPs
Apply for those senior roles

My understanding is that Equal Opps they have to advertise permanent roles (not Acting (interim) roles) , if you interview for a role & are a good candidate but unsuccessful due to strength of other applicants , then if a role comes up within 3 months the employer doesn't have to re advertise- they can offer you that role on basis of interviews already carried out. I'm not sure if I worded that right- I hope a HR person will come along to clarify

Aprilx · 11/08/2022 06:39

Celia24 · 10/08/2022 22:05

@Aprilx She is still my manager until she leaves though. Therefore she is still in charge of my progression so that should surely still mean something?

But it is obvious now I need to cut out the middle woman and speak to the boss's boss myself. I'm new to this kind of situation - clearly I need to take the bull by the horns. It's nerve wracking!

No isn’t in charge of your progression, you are. A manager should be coaching and developing, sounds like she is doing that for example she has given you guidance on what next steps might be or what is required for the next level. I have been in management for over 25 years, I have never prepared a set of slides for a particular employee to guide them in their career, I cannot imagine doing this, I have never heard of another manager preparing a slide show for an employee on a 1:1 basis. I think she has given you a generic set of competencies expected at the next level.

And I didn’t think you needed to “speak to boss’s boss” yourself. There are jobs you are interested in, you need to apply for one of them, you keep seeing to think you can speak to this person or that person and get in through the back door. I have operated at Head of department level, if I am recruiting internally, I will talk to candidates about the role at the interview. I would not be wanting to have side conversations with certain candidates. It may look inappropriate.

I see later on you have posted about talking to your bosses boss about your darn objectives slide show that the person who is leaving gave you. You would be better off, securing an internal interview and then taking the job description and person specification for that role and demonstrating how you meet the criteria.

BirdyWoof · 11/08/2022 01:14

k1233 · 11/08/2022 00:13

Do not trust anything not in a formal written offer. I've been screwed over time and again through lying bosses. If you are over performing in your role they won't want you to move out of it, so will keep you there as long as they can. Why - you're cheaper and they won't get the same if they promote you. If you're indispensable you're unpromotable.

Apply for all roles you see that you want to do. It raises your profile and gets you on people's radars. Do not sit back and wait for recognition of your worth / value and rely on someone else's word to get you where you want to be.

Just re-affirming my previous post, but @k1233 has it spot on, here.

I know your manager is leaving so it’s not entirely the same (as it isn’t going to benefit her whether you stay or go; she isn’t going to be there), but that doesn’t mean it won’t benefit her replacement.

As much as companies love promoting from within, they love having reliable, high performing, consistent candidates in steady roles, more. They don’t always want to lose someone from a role who can do the role with their eyes shut and do a great job every single time. Especially if your new manager has come from a different department or company altogether- they’ll still need consistency within the team to aid their transition into the role.

I was quite young when I started working for my current company. I was naive back then and just believed that if I did great work, I’d be praised for it, which would ultimately end up in me being trained for a promotion. That didn’t happen.
I then believed that if I made my career plans known and discussed these with my manager, showing willing and enthusiasm, they’d help me to get to where I wanted to get to. That also didn’t happen. Easier for them if I stayed where I was- one less new person to train to replace me.

I only got to where I wanted to get to by having weeks and weeks of shit in work, coming home and having a massive “fuck this” attitude change, pushing myself onto the radar and no longer letting other people influence my path with lies which only benefitted them.

Of course there’s a nuance to this- you have to actually be certain that you can do x job, but you need to be able to see the difference between constructive feedback which makes sense to why you wouldn’t be ready for x role, and excuses which are covering up the fact that someone doesn’t want you to move up because it would make it harder for them/someone else.

But, as @k1233 has said, don’t trust anything that isn’t a written offer. Until it’s written down, it sadly doesn’t exist, yet. Until that offer is written and confirmed, so what you need to do to make it happen.

BirdyWoof · 11/08/2022 00:51

My understanding of what you’ve described is that those above you don’t think you’re ready for the role yet.

As a result, you have two options, here.

Option 1 is apply for the job and use the interview to prove that you are ready for the next role. Whether they hire you for it or not is up to them, but it shows willing and enthusiasm for your own career progression.

Option 2 is you wait, complete your training over the 6 month period and then have a discussion about the role that is going to be “created” for you.

However, some advice-

I was in your situation a year ago. I was promised I’d get x, y and z training and be put forward for promotion as soon as possible. 4 months went by and I received absolutely 0 training (there was always an excuse; “too busy” on these days to do anything, can’t do it this week because x has left, etc, etc). My current role at the time was boring the tits off me by this point and I was no longer happy in work. I knew I had to do something off my own bat, as my manager certainly wasn’t going to fulfil what they had promised.

A role came up that was perfect for me and exactly what I was looking for. I applied. Out of decency, I did tell them before I applied. The conversation that followed was the most reaffirming conversation I’ve ever had in my numerous years for the company that you should always put yourself first. So many excuses for why I wouldn’t get the role (all centred around the training that they had failed to provide me). It was very clear at that point that they actually had no intention of training me, and wanted to keep me at the level I was at because it was easier for them.

I got the job (they hadn’t ever seen my CV as they were a replacement manager for the manager who had hired me, I had suitable experience that filled the gaps from another role I was previously in). I have done very well in the role and haven’t looked back. However, if I didn’t get the role, I was fully ready to leave and work for another company. I had already began my job search in case that role didn’t work out.

So, ultimately, I think you should apply for the role. Your manager might have honest intentions with their plans for you, but that doesn’t mean everyone else will.

Always put yourself first and don’t rely on promises until you see something in writing that confirms the position is going to be offered to you. In nearly every single job I’ve ever had, I’ve seen so many people screwed over by false promises/promises that were never delivered (for whatever reason). The thing that everyone had in common in all these circumstances was that they “trusted” their manager would sort it for them. They never did, or they rescinded the offer because someone they liked more was available, and other reasons similar to this.

You have to take control of your own career, and not leave it to chance. Work on your application over the weekend and have it ready to send off next week. Do interview prep and try to fill as many training gaps as you can in the next week or two.

Maybe you won’t get the role, but it’s better to try and know you didn’t let the opportunity pass you by, than not do anything and regret it.

littlefireseverywhere · 11/08/2022 00:37

Just apply for the role you think you’re most suitable for?

saltinesandcoffeecups · 11/08/2022 00:19

Op… as clearly and plainly as I can possibly put this.

  1. Stop overthinking this
  2. Apply for the position
  3. Tell both boss and boss’s boss that you’ve applied
  4. Continue to work on Checklist
  5. Stop arguing with those giving the same advice
It really is that simple. Imagine that “applying for position” is on your checklist. Because it really is. Doing anything else opens you up to not understanding how things work.

Good Luck

k1233 · 11/08/2022 00:13

Do not trust anything not in a formal written offer. I've been screwed over time and again through lying bosses. If you are over performing in your role they won't want you to move out of it, so will keep you there as long as they can. Why - you're cheaper and they won't get the same if they promote you. If you're indispensable you're unpromotable.

Apply for all roles you see that you want to do. It raises your profile and gets you on people's radars. Do not sit back and wait for recognition of your worth / value and rely on someone else's word to get you where you want to be.

FrankLampardsBrokenHand · 11/08/2022 00:12

Jesus fucking christ just apply for the bastard job!

I wouldn't promote you because you overthink so much don't exactly demonstrate having the ability to make decisions or communicate effectively.

Grimchmas · 11/08/2022 00:05

Apply for the post.

Email boss' boss to let him know you have applied for it. CC in boss.

Prepare for the meeting with BB

Have meeting with BB.

Swipe left for the next trending thread