Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To Remind Everyone That Self ID Was A Tory Policy?

233 replies

TooBigForMyBoots · 10/08/2022 19:31

I've seen so many posts over the past few years with people urging us to vote Tory because at least the Conservatives know what a woman is.🙄

This is nonsense for the following reasons:

  1. The Tories introduced Self ID under Theresa May's GRA Reform and Penny Mordaunt championed it.
  2. Tory MPs have reported women to the police for retweeting AHF posts and tweets by JKR.
  3. Trans contagion amongst teens happened under the Tory government.
  4. Trans women in women's spaces such as hospitals and prisons and Girl Guides happened under the Tory government.
  5. Rape in hospital that isn't considered "rape" because there was no man present? Tory government.
  6. It's a Trojan Horse. Bridgend Tories won the seat with a small majority. Their Tory MP, once safely in his seat announced that he was trans and intended to become a woman. I am gutted for any GC/feminist voters who held their nose and voted Conservative only to end up with Jamie Wallace.
  7. In the latest leadership race, Penny TWAW Mordaunt nearly became our new prime minister. Few (if any)Tories gave a fuck about her well documented TWAW stance.
  8. 1 week after Starmer refused to answer "what is a woman?", PM Boris Johnson did the same. This was not publicised to anywhere near the same extent.

So some Tories know what a woman is.
Some Tories don't.
Most don't give a shit about women or their rights either way, they're just happy to use us in their culture wars.🤷‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
balalake · 11/08/2022 07:34

Even if it was not a Tory policy, the government has had seven years to ensure it did not become one by practice or default.

Mr Johnson does not care about women, unless he can have a relationship with them, and then only to a limited extent.

zen1 · 11/08/2022 07:34

I am not a Tory voter, but recently (including before the leadership debate), more high profile Tories than high profile MPs of other parties, have been prepared to state what a woman is and tackle some of the concerns women have around the importance of being able to clearly define our sex. Javid stressed the need for clarity of language in the NHS when talking about health problems that only affect females. I totally lost respect for Labour when I heard various members of the shadow cabinet stating that men can have a cervix.

sashagabadon · 11/08/2022 07:33

For me it’s a bit like lockdown ( the second one) yes the Tories went with it because of overwhelming pressure from media etc but their heart wasn’t really in it and labour were crying More! Longer! Shut the schools!

Boris then said no more and gave us freedom day ( Keir openly critical, reckless etc)
This is the same , went along with gender ideology due to media etc but their heart wasn’t really in it. Now hand break turn and hard stop ( thanks to Mumsnet et al) now the multiple issues are apparent to anyone with a brain but Keir rather than acknowledging the clash of rights and that he is wrong, he tells us that not only women can have a cervix I think this is because he genuinely agrees with gender ideology and he genuinely thinks this is true and that’s my concern.

Sistanotcista · 11/08/2022 07:31

CorvusPurpureus · 10/08/2022 20:09

Yes, I know all of this. & I don't kid myself that they aren't essentially a self replicating organism - the purpose & principle of the Tory party is to maintain the hegemony of the Tory party. Got it. Fully understood.

So if Labour want me back, all they need to do is take positions I can vote on, as a woman & a mother of daughters.

I'd be bloody delighted to reinstate my membership (held for 30 years & I told them to shove it 2 years ago), any time they want to express policies I want to vote or campaign for.

Nicely put!

ClocksGoingBackwards · 11/08/2022 07:18

I've seen so many posts over the past few years with people urging us to vote Tory because at least the Conservatives know what a woman is

I haven’t seen this. I’ve seen plenty of threads that are just Tory bashing and sometimes posters have popped up and said that they don’t agree with the OP and appreciate that the tories seem to know what a woman is better than the other parties, which is fair enough. But I haven’t seen threads deliberately designed to encourage Tory voting because at least the conservatives know what a women is.

TheLionTheWitchAndTheChesterDraws · 11/08/2022 07:06

Well, many are still there, still standing up for women’s rights. Did you think those people have all changed their minds?

They are still there now. Many took no notice of the fanatics demanding they leave. They prefer to stay and fight, and they’ve already done a lot of work. Don’t belittle their efforts.

@Tanith That’s great. I have admiration for them and in no way mean to belittle their efforts. So other than the three mentioned above (two of them by me) who are they?

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 07:02

knowing what a woman is doesn't qualify you to run the country.

No, but not knowing what a woman is should certainly disqualify you because you must be an absolute tool.

FOJN · 11/08/2022 06:51

The Tories already introduced Self ID. It was disastrous for women's rights. I hope they won't bring it back, but have no doubt they would if it suited them.

What are you talking about? The Tories accepted the recommendation of a cross party committee and agreed to update the GRA to include self ID but in light of new evidence they have backtracked because they can see it's a bad idea. Self ID is not law in the UK, although it may be in Scotland by the end of the year.

Where self ID has taken hold its because of Stonewall law, not the actual law which hasn't changed. Are you ignorant of the facts or willfully misrepresenting them?

You don't have to be grateful for our terrible government but you are being dishonest about their position on self ID. I notice you have nothing to say about the SNP who are forging ahead with self ID and haven't answered my question about all other political parties remaining committed to changing the GRA to allow self ID.

I think you keep posting about self ID being a Tory policy because you do have an agenda and know that some women are now single issue voters. The truth is that the Tories are the only ones who have changed their mind. If any other party had won the 2019 election then self ID would be law across the UK now, every party accepted the recommendations of the cross party committee which advocated for self ID.

agedasiago · 11/08/2022 05:27

Self-ID only became a focus because Gender Recognition Certificates exist. Gender Recognition Certificates exist because in 2004, the UK was held to account by the European Court of Human Rights for (among other things) refusing to let male-born Christine Goodwin marry a male partner. The Labour Government of the day couldn't bring themselves to legalise same sex marriage, so instead they wasted two years cobbling together a badly-constructed piece of legislation that satisfied no one and whipping their MPs to vote for it. There's plenty of blame to go around.

I am gutted for any GC/feminist voters who held their nose and voted Conservative only to end up with Jamie Wallace.

I'm not a fan of Jamie Wallace because I don't like his politics and have issues with his (allegedly) leaving the scene of an accident. I'm not sure why his being trans, rather than his policies and behaviour, would make someone regret voting for him.

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 04:05

TooBigForMyBoots · 11/08/2022 00:58

The Tories already introduced Self ID. It was disastrous for women's rights. I hope they won't bring it back, but have no doubt they would if it suited them.

They're throwing crumbs and we're all supposed to be grateful? Fuck that. Anyway I've learnt not to believe a thing the Tories say.

I don't trust the Tories but Labour's job is literally to criticise and point out the problems in everything they do. There are exceptions but a massive fucking women's rights issue that has women protesting and losing opportunities and being threatened and intimidated, not to mention clinics putting children straight on untested drugs with no alternatives explored while they finish growing up, shouldn't be one of them. So I don't trust them either.

I'll never vote Tory but at least they're showing more signs of realising it was a mistake than the fucking gatekeepers. I don't care if it's a vote winner or genuine act of protection, as long as it's the right thing.

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 03:57

LearnedAxolotl · 10/08/2022 21:01

Well you obviously mix with people who can afford to worry about niche issues then. Good for you. Everyone i know is more worried about how we are going to pay for fuel and food this winter than what politicians think about trans people.

But you're worried enough to be trivialising it on here. We get people on here a lot who tell us why we're stupid for being concerned about a non issue and should drop it, but strangely won't drop it themselves.

COL crisis will disproportionately affect women since overall they earn less and are more likely to be sole or main/resident carers. But we're not supposed to be concerned about having that huge demographically trait obfuscated and erased?

Not that you need that excuse. Before COL, you lot always had some form of whataboutery and if COL got entirely solved tomorrow you'd find something else. The only constant is that it's always women who should just roll over and cede the fight along with their rights and very existence. It's only unimportant where they're concerned.

If it's true that nobody gives a toss in real life, why waste your energy on it here? Just let us spend ourselves and our energy pointlessly. That's what I'd do if I saw my enemies carrying out a supreme own goal....

Crunchyb · 11/08/2022 03:50

The self-ID policy was put forward by a select committee made up of people of different political parties. At that time all political parties thought it was an easy way to score LGBT brownie points. There was little consideration of the impact on women or anyone else.

When Women’s Place UK and Fair Play for Women began to raise concerns about the potential impact of self-ID on women, the Tories were the only major party to have a rethink on the issue, which I think is how politics should work. Their reasons may not be entirely pure but sometimes you have to take what you can get.

There is great dishonesty in Labour about this issue. I don’t think there is a vast difference between the genuine beliefs of senior labour and conservative MPs but Labour are terrified of losing their fervent campaigners if they start to speak sense on this.

TooBigForMyBoots · 11/08/2022 00:58

FOJN · 10/08/2022 23:40

For goodness sake, you've been trying to misrepresent the arguments women have been making for ages. The Tories are not planning to introduce self ID, for many of us that matters.

Are you prepared to answer the question at the end of my last post? You seem to shy away from answering the difficult questions.

The Tories already introduced Self ID. It was disastrous for women's rights. I hope they won't bring it back, but have no doubt they would if it suited them.

They're throwing crumbs and we're all supposed to be grateful? Fuck that. Anyway I've learnt not to believe a thing the Tories say.

OP posts:
Furries · 11/08/2022 00:48

Yeah, women are a niche issue. FFS 🤦🏻‍♀️

As an aside, no one has been “banging on for years” that at least the Tories know what a woman is. That became a “thing” a few months ago. And thank fuck it became a thing, because no other party seems willing to stand up and say it - in fact may even be saying along the lines of “we don’t want your vote if you don’t agree with our bullshit”.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 00:06

TooBigForMyBoots · 10/08/2022 23:27

I this because I was tired of people posting the lie that "at least the Tories know what a woman is". I read it on another thread and thought it would be helpful to give it a thread of its own to clear up some common misconceptions on the issue.

As per the AG’s speech today, they do know this.

It’s quite bizarre that you are just blithely pretending that you don’t understand this on a day that a shadow cabinet member made a very public visit to support Mermaids.

FOJN · 10/08/2022 23:40

TooBigForMyBoots · 10/08/2022 23:27

I this because I was tired of people posting the lie that "at least the Tories know what a woman is". I read it on another thread and thought it would be helpful to give it a thread of its own to clear up some common misconceptions on the issue.

For goodness sake, you've been trying to misrepresent the arguments women have been making for ages. The Tories are not planning to introduce self ID, for many of us that matters.

Are you prepared to answer the question at the end of my last post? You seem to shy away from answering the difficult questions.

MarshaBradyo · 10/08/2022 23:31

Whatever government was in power had to address this as most other progressive countries have in recent years

true and the high watermark will depend on when each country decides to reverse the trend

TooBigForMyBoots · 10/08/2022 23:27

I this because I was tired of people posting the lie that "at least the Tories know what a woman is". I read it on another thread and thought it would be helpful to give it a thread of its own to clear up some common misconceptions on the issue.

OP posts:
FOJN · 10/08/2022 23:27

OK OP let's go with the self ID shit show is all the Tories fault and they hate women.

So we can say that under the Tories we've had a trial run of self ID and it hasn't turned out very well as the list in your OP details.

In light of this experience they have changed their mind and continue to take steps to reverse the damage that has been done. Despite being presented with plenty of evidence to the contrary (which has been presented to you multiple times) I anticipate you will deny the have taken any corrective action but can we at least agree they have said they no longer plan to implement self ID?

What does it tell us about other political parties and their attitudes to women when they remain committed to self ID despite the shit show of the trial run whilst the Tories have been in power? They must really hate us, right?

ImWell · 10/08/2022 22:48

TooBigForMyBoots · 10/08/2022 22:41

It is quite a niche issue @SecretMoomin and one that the Tories don't give a monkeys about. Penny Mordaunt made it into third place in the parliamentary leadership race. If it had been important to MPs, she would have been knocked out earlier.

Had she made it into the last two, she was a shoe-in for our next Prime Minister.😱 If TWAW argument was important that wouldn't have been the case.🤷‍♀️

As it stands, she'll probably get a cabinet post.

And, again, did you post this without having heard the AG’s speech, or because of it?

HRTQueen · 10/08/2022 22:48

Whatever government was in power had to address this as most other progressive countries have in recent years

what party will listen to many women concerns and what party will ignore many women’s concerns that is more the issue

ImWell · 10/08/2022 22:47

LearnedAxolotl · 10/08/2022 21:01

Well you obviously mix with people who can afford to worry about niche issues then. Good for you. Everyone i know is more worried about how we are going to pay for fuel and food this winter than what politicians think about trans people.

I know literally no-one who worries about paying for fuel, but a great many women who fear their fundamental rights are under threat.

Tanith · 10/08/2022 22:45

“It was Green, LibDem and Labour men and women who were first sounding the alarm when Theresa May's government were loudly parroting TWAW
So where were they when Rosie was receiving death threats? Where were they when the Greens were working with a certain individual who I believe then went on to be a mod for a popular internet site? Where were they when Labour and Lib Dem women were being told to leave the party if they didn’t accept that twaw? Genuine question. Other than Rosie and Joanna, who is standing up to the current gender policies of their party?”

Well, many are still there, still standing up for women’s rights. Did you think those people have all changed their minds?
They are still there now. Many took no notice of the fanatics demanding they leave. They prefer to stay and fight, and they’ve already done a lot of work. Don’t belittle their efforts.

TooBigForMyBoots · 10/08/2022 22:41

It is quite a niche issue @SecretMoomin and one that the Tories don't give a monkeys about. Penny Mordaunt made it into third place in the parliamentary leadership race. If it had been important to MPs, she would have been knocked out earlier.

Had she made it into the last two, she was a shoe-in for our next Prime Minister.😱 If TWAW argument was important that wouldn't have been the case.🤷‍♀️

As it stands, she'll probably get a cabinet post.

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 10/08/2022 22:40

I said this on one of the threads about Kemi Badenoch but it bears repeating - knowing what a woman is doesn't qualify you to run the country.

No, but acting as if you don't know is the sort of either dishonesty or stupidity that should disqualify you in my book.

Swipe left for the next trending thread