Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To Remind Everyone That Self ID Was A Tory Policy?

233 replies

TooBigForMyBoots · 10/08/2022 19:31

I've seen so many posts over the past few years with people urging us to vote Tory because at least the Conservatives know what a woman is.🙄

This is nonsense for the following reasons:

  1. The Tories introduced Self ID under Theresa May's GRA Reform and Penny Mordaunt championed it.
  2. Tory MPs have reported women to the police for retweeting AHF posts and tweets by JKR.
  3. Trans contagion amongst teens happened under the Tory government.
  4. Trans women in women's spaces such as hospitals and prisons and Girl Guides happened under the Tory government.
  5. Rape in hospital that isn't considered "rape" because there was no man present? Tory government.
  6. It's a Trojan Horse. Bridgend Tories won the seat with a small majority. Their Tory MP, once safely in his seat announced that he was trans and intended to become a woman. I am gutted for any GC/feminist voters who held their nose and voted Conservative only to end up with Jamie Wallace.
  7. In the latest leadership race, Penny TWAW Mordaunt nearly became our new prime minister. Few (if any)Tories gave a fuck about her well documented TWAW stance.
  8. 1 week after Starmer refused to answer "what is a woman?", PM Boris Johnson did the same. This was not publicised to anywhere near the same extent.

So some Tories know what a woman is.
Some Tories don't.
Most don't give a shit about women or their rights either way, they're just happy to use us in their culture wars.🤷‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
FOJN · 11/08/2022 10:41

AntlerRose · 11/08/2022 10:12

@ReneBumsWombats I am explaining why i wont be voting conservative despite them being more likely to identify a women. I fear the route they are taking is a slide towards fascism and that matters to me more at this stage. I genuinley believe another party more respectful of democratic process, law and accountability can far more easily be persauded what a woman is than our ability to fix the country after another 5 years of removing accountability bit by bit. You dont have to agree b

I think we should all vote in accordance with our conscience but I'm genuinely interested in your view that there are other parties who are more respectful of the democratic process.

I am seeing a tendency towards authoritarianism on the left. Women in Labour, SNP and Greens have been subjected to sustained bullying campaigns within their own parties because they will not toe the line on self ID. Starmer has resisted even meeting with the Labour Party Women's declaration until now, Rosie Duffield has been subjected to terrible bullying and has recently held onto her seat after trial by party process. When senior Labour Party members do speak publicly they either refuse to make their views clear or resort to insulting anyone who has expressed concerns.

Labour and the LibDems don't want my vote if I won't agree with them on this issue. Can you think of any other issue where a party has told potential members or voters to toe the line or fuck off?

I can't even be bothered to detail the utter shit show which is the Green Party and what they've put party members through, it's truly shocking, some are pursuing legal action. I could understand them trying to find another reason for existing if we'd already sorted out climate change but...

I cannot see a single party who supports self ID respecting democracy. Our current Conservative government seem to be libertarians which upsets their socially conservative supporters so I'd say they are about a million miles from fascism.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 10:37

AntlerRose · 11/08/2022 10:24

@ImWell - yes, a slide towards it. Not actual fasism but further in that direction than our start point.

I like accountability and balances and checks to power in a political system. I dont like moves to remove them.

There are not moves to remove them. The left love to pretend that the Conservatives plan to tear up our beloved rights and institutions, yet despite them having been in power for most of the last century and all of the last twelve years that hasn’t happened.

By contrast Labour we’re taking about expropriating people’s property just ahead of the 2019 election, to redistribute it to their own voting base.

No, I’m far happier under the Conservatives for any number of reasons than under any other party. The fact that they are right on this issue is just another reason to lean that way.

That’s not to say that I support them; I don’t, but they are the least-worst option available.

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 10:36

AntlerRose · 11/08/2022 10:29

@ReneBumsWombats - no, my stance is I believe that another party can be more easily persauded what a women is, if we have an accountable government with checks and balances and a right to protest, than we can restore an accountable government with checks and balances after 5 more years of tory rule despite some of them knowing what a woman is.

No, this still doesn't follow. Even if it's an objective fact that the Tories are sliding towards fascism, they are still the only ones who currently are prepared to state what a woman is. So how can you argue that a different party could be more easily persuaded of what a woman is than the party stating it already?

SolasAnla · 11/08/2022 10:32

itsgettingweird · 11/08/2022 08:38

Well yes I hear a lie too.

Except it isn't so much a lie but semantics because it's all about self ID via gender than biological sex.

I can go about my daily life not being too much affected by trans woman in woman's spaces day in day out and can challenge where necessary.

The lies the Tory's have told for years have a daily impact on me.

No party will deal with the self ID stuff.

But I want someone in charge who will improve my life holistically.

Ireland has a problem that the law which protects women from pregnancy discrimination has to remove the word woman because of self ID.

Cant have words to id the bleeders or breeders.

How much of the everyday sexism is about semantics?

You think a law which would force you to provide social companions to a male want to be murder/rapist, is going to allow you to challange a bepenised in what you think should be a single sex space?

AntlerRose · 11/08/2022 10:29

@ReneBumsWombats - no, my stance is I believe that another party can be more easily persauded what a women is, if we have an accountable government with checks and balances and a right to protest, than we can restore an accountable government with checks and balances after 5 more years of tory rule despite some of them knowing what a woman is.

AntlerRose · 11/08/2022 10:24

@ImWell - yes, a slide towards it. Not actual fasism but further in that direction than our start point.

I like accountability and balances and checks to power in a political system. I dont like moves to remove them.

C8H10N4O2 · 11/08/2022 10:23

LearnedAxolotl · 10/08/2022 21:01

Well you obviously mix with people who can afford to worry about niche issues then. Good for you. Everyone i know is more worried about how we are going to pay for fuel and food this winter than what politicians think about trans people.

Niche issue which affects over 50% of the global population.

Within every social, ethnic and geographic group women are aborted, raped, abused, murdered, paid less, held accountable for all society's evils and are second class citizens. The fact that some wealthier women can mitigate this to some extent does not change that.

Erasing sex as a protected characteristic (which I note Stonewall have removed from their site but still push for) and denying biology is not even in the interest of trans people.

The question always is Cui Bono - who benefits from the erasure of women as a sex class and removal of provisions to address the disadvantages of female sex? Who benefits from reinforcing outdated stereotyped gender constructs for women?

First and foremost the beneficiaries are men.

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 10:23

AntlerRose · 11/08/2022 10:12

@ReneBumsWombats I am explaining why i wont be voting conservative despite them being more likely to identify a women. I fear the route they are taking is a slide towards fascism and that matters to me more at this stage. I genuinley believe another party more respectful of democratic process, law and accountability can far more easily be persauded what a woman is than our ability to fix the country after another 5 years of removing accountability bit by bit. You dont have to agree b

Yes, I know I don't have to agree, thank you.

I don't vote Conservative either. But I don't follow your logic here. You say that another party can be more easily persuaded of what a woman is than the Tories, even though the Tories are so far the only party to make a clear statement on it. Are you actually thinking this through?

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 11/08/2022 10:19

OP has an interesting point.

I first encontered gender ideology in far left activist groups. Back then I considered it one of our more extreme ideas and I didn't expect it to catch on.

When I got involved with more mainstream politics, I honestly never expected to come across it again.

I should have known better.

Gender ideology seemed to offer mainstream politicians a way to look progressive without spending any money or upsetting anyone important. So of course it caught on where wealth redistribution (just to give an example) did not.

The Tories probably thought that this was a niche issue where they could pick up some youth votes, improve their image on equalities and probably not even be noticed by their core voters.

Now that they understand there are wider implications and that women are upset they're backtracking.

The left have painted themselves into more of an ideological corner and sat in it for longer so they will find it harder to change their minds.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 10:15

AntlerRose · 11/08/2022 10:12

@ReneBumsWombats I am explaining why i wont be voting conservative despite them being more likely to identify a women. I fear the route they are taking is a slide towards fascism and that matters to me more at this stage. I genuinley believe another party more respectful of democratic process, law and accountability can far more easily be persauded what a woman is than our ability to fix the country after another 5 years of removing accountability bit by bit. You dont have to agree b

Fascism?

Oh dear.

AntlerRose · 11/08/2022 10:12

@ReneBumsWombats I am explaining why i wont be voting conservative despite them being more likely to identify a women. I fear the route they are taking is a slide towards fascism and that matters to me more at this stage. I genuinley believe another party more respectful of democratic process, law and accountability can far more easily be persauded what a woman is than our ability to fix the country after another 5 years of removing accountability bit by bit. You dont have to agree b

glomerulus · 11/08/2022 09:52

MalagaNights · 11/08/2022 07:48

"I said this on one of the threads about Kemi Badenoch but it bears repeating - knowing what a woman is doesn't qualify you to run the country."

Yeh, I wouldn't keep repeating it, it's not that clever.

It's not sufficient to know what a woman is, but it is essential.

I don't want anyone running the country who continues to lie that they don't know what a woman is.

It would be nice if they'd all never gone along with any of this, but I'll take a mea culpa and a change of mind from any labour or green politician who now wants to get back on board with reality.

There's no need to be rude, and I think we broadly agree on the issues, because I would also gladly take a reverse ferret from any of the left-leaning parties (and am hoping for just that before the next GE).

I stand by my point - I don't care that many Tories are smugly telling us that they know what a woman is. Everything they have done over the last 12 years has been a shitshow for women, whether it's self-ID, driving down the health service (midwife/hrt shortage disproportionately affecting women), basically de-criminalising rape, terrible early years funding/closing sure start centres, impact of covid on those with caring responsibilities, etc. And let's not start on who is going to feel the worst of the cost of living crisis....

They know what a woman is. And they don't care. And if ANY left-leaning party can get their house in order (and kudos to the brilliant women trying to affect change from within them), then at least we'll have some choice. Which has to be better, right?!

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 09:40

i dont think that affects democratic structures and processes no.

So the representation of women and their rights and needs in a democracy has nothing to do with being able to define and recognise them?

I see your claim to be respectful of other views and attempts to appear polite and reasonable, but it's still looking like the same old deflection and whataboutery to me. Sorry.

AntlerRose · 11/08/2022 09:36

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 09:27

I am particularly focussed on things that i think dilute democracy.

Like attempts to redefine half the population out of existence?

i dont think that affects democratic structures and processes no. I also feel reassured that they can attempt this but i would have had several legal methods available to try and stop it that could soon not be available.

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 09:27

I am particularly focussed on things that i think dilute democracy.

Like attempts to redefine half the population out of existence?

AntlerRose · 11/08/2022 09:25

This is a tough topic. I respect people who feel strongly about this issue but I feel equally strongly about other issues.
I am particularly focussed on things that i think dilute democracy. So attacks on the judiciary, limiting judicial review leaving the echr which is all about protecting people from their own government, proroging parliament, clamping down on protest rights, the idea of clause 22 where ministers can make law without gowing through parliament, filling lords with people who wont hold them to account. I dont think people understand the polictical system in the uk or just how much is in jeopardy. Id rather vote for a party that let itself be held accountable and use things like judical review, select committees, the european court of human rights and protest to argue for my other issues. Otherwise i could find that all gone and next time i have something I care about, i cant do anything.

Mississipi71 · 11/08/2022 09:12

Another Tory bashing thread. How original 🙄

LondonWolf · 11/08/2022 09:09

FOJN · 11/08/2022 06:51

The Tories already introduced Self ID. It was disastrous for women's rights. I hope they won't bring it back, but have no doubt they would if it suited them.

What are you talking about? The Tories accepted the recommendation of a cross party committee and agreed to update the GRA to include self ID but in light of new evidence they have backtracked because they can see it's a bad idea. Self ID is not law in the UK, although it may be in Scotland by the end of the year.

Where self ID has taken hold its because of Stonewall law, not the actual law which hasn't changed. Are you ignorant of the facts or willfully misrepresenting them?

You don't have to be grateful for our terrible government but you are being dishonest about their position on self ID. I notice you have nothing to say about the SNP who are forging ahead with self ID and haven't answered my question about all other political parties remaining committed to changing the GRA to allow self ID.

I think you keep posting about self ID being a Tory policy because you do have an agenda and know that some women are now single issue voters. The truth is that the Tories are the only ones who have changed their mind. If any other party had won the 2019 election then self ID would be law across the UK now, every party accepted the recommendations of the cross party committee which advocated for self ID.

Good post.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 11/08/2022 09:09

PronounssheRa · 11/08/2022 08:21

Id rather have a party that doesn't know what a woman is than one who doesn't know what a truth is.

When I hear Labour politicians saying males can be women I hear a lie, and if they are able to lie about something which is so obvious I wonder what else they will lie about.

Absolutely

ImWell · 11/08/2022 09:05

itsgettingweird · 11/08/2022 08:52

I know gender is not sex.

I'm not an idiot. I also don't believe trans woman are woman.

They are trans woman.

But I don't believe any politician believes you can change biological sex either. They believe in self I'd which is different.

David Lamy seems to believe it. Keir Starmer and Angela Rayner are definitely trying to give the impression that they believe it.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 09:03

itsgettingweird · 11/08/2022 08:38

Well yes I hear a lie too.

Except it isn't so much a lie but semantics because it's all about self ID via gender than biological sex.

I can go about my daily life not being too much affected by trans woman in woman's spaces day in day out and can challenge where necessary.

The lies the Tory's have told for years have a daily impact on me.

No party will deal with the self ID stuff.

But I want someone in charge who will improve my life holistically.

But the Conservatives already are dealing with self-ID. The AG made a speech on the subject yesterday, setting out very clearly where they stand.

FOJN · 11/08/2022 09:01

Id rather have a party that doesn't know what a woman is than one who doesn't know what a truth is.

Excuse me?

If you make a mistake a work you might be tempted to lie to save your arse, hopefully your integrity would prevail and you would be honest but most of us can relate to that temptation. If you decided to lie anyway and got found out then it's likely people would think less of your for lying than for making a mistake, I think that's quite understandable for most too. If you were found to repeatedly lie people would almost certainly make assumptions about your character which again is understandable.

Claiming that men can be women is not just a lie it's gaslighting. It's an ideological lie which demands compliance unless you want to be branded a bigot. You are being told to deny the evidence of your own eyes. This type of behaviour is sinister and very authoritarian. If a politician can lie and gaslight about things we can see are not true what else are the likely to lie about and demand compliance?

Self serving lies do not need to be approved of to be understood. Gaslighting is a different thing altogether and, when combined with authoritarianism, is areal threat to democracy.

MarshaBradyo · 11/08/2022 09:00

I agree it has been from ground up

I remember not really engaging then reading more on here - it’s those posters who explained well what was going on that really helped

And it’s not so niche it can’t end a candidate hopeful who was high polling

Accepting the use of female when it is a male is madness - and since it impacts laws and language not good for women

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 08:54

itsgettingweird · 11/08/2022 08:52

I know gender is not sex.

I'm not an idiot. I also don't believe trans woman are woman.

They are trans woman.

But I don't believe any politician believes you can change biological sex either. They believe in self I'd which is different.

But that amounts to the same thing: that to all intents and purposes, woman is not a fixed biological reality but a feeling, and anyone can become one merely by saying they are.

itsgettingweird · 11/08/2022 08:52

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 08:41

Except it isn't so much a lie but semantics because it's all about self ID via gender than biological sex.

If I hold up an apple and tell you it's a melon, that's not semantics. It's a lie.

You could say any lie is semantics if what you mean is that it would be truth if only you change the meaning of the words you're using. That's just absurd.

Gender is not sex.

I know gender is not sex.

I'm not an idiot. I also don't believe trans woman are woman.

They are trans woman.

But I don't believe any politician believes you can change biological sex either. They believe in self I'd which is different.