Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To Remind Everyone That Self ID Was A Tory Policy?

233 replies

TooBigForMyBoots · 10/08/2022 19:31

I've seen so many posts over the past few years with people urging us to vote Tory because at least the Conservatives know what a woman is.🙄

This is nonsense for the following reasons:

  1. The Tories introduced Self ID under Theresa May's GRA Reform and Penny Mordaunt championed it.
  2. Tory MPs have reported women to the police for retweeting AHF posts and tweets by JKR.
  3. Trans contagion amongst teens happened under the Tory government.
  4. Trans women in women's spaces such as hospitals and prisons and Girl Guides happened under the Tory government.
  5. Rape in hospital that isn't considered "rape" because there was no man present? Tory government.
  6. It's a Trojan Horse. Bridgend Tories won the seat with a small majority. Their Tory MP, once safely in his seat announced that he was trans and intended to become a woman. I am gutted for any GC/feminist voters who held their nose and voted Conservative only to end up with Jamie Wallace.
  7. In the latest leadership race, Penny TWAW Mordaunt nearly became our new prime minister. Few (if any)Tories gave a fuck about her well documented TWAW stance.
  8. 1 week after Starmer refused to answer "what is a woman?", PM Boris Johnson did the same. This was not publicised to anywhere near the same extent.

So some Tories know what a woman is.
Some Tories don't.
Most don't give a shit about women or their rights either way, they're just happy to use us in their culture wars.🤷‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
PronounssheRa · 11/08/2022 14:34

Most policies come from Cross party committees. MPs work on them all the time in all the departments. The ruling party decides which ones to promote to/adopt as policy. In the case of Self ID, it was the Tories.

Which they followed up with a public consultation, they listened to and acted on the responses to that. Self ID isn't a Tory policy and lots of government departments are leaving the various stonewall schemes which promoted stonewall law.

There is a lot to go at with the Tories but your inaccurate framing of this issue does you no favours.

DobbyHasASock · 11/08/2022 14:29

You may think that. I disagree. The general tone of this particular hobby horse does not come across how you intend.

MangyInseam · 11/08/2022 14:28

Maybe we should play,

Whose Policy Is It Now?!

I suspect that five years ago many of us who now think it's a terrible idea thought it was fine, so it's difficult to see that your point is relevant, OP.

I am generally glad when a political party is able to see that a policy they thought was good, actually isn't, and change their mind. If only all the other parties didn't seem incapable of that it was more common.

TooBigForMyBoots · 11/08/2022 14:22

I don't sneeringly deride voters. I criticise the Conservative government for the damage they have done to women over the twelve years they've been in power.

Most policies come from Cross party committees. MPs work on them all the time in all the departments. The ruling party decides which ones to promote to/adopt as policy. In the case of Self ID, it was the Tories.

OP posts:
DobbyHasASock · 11/08/2022 14:16

You may rarely mention the parties you vote for but you regularly sneeringly deride anyone who even considers voting conservative.
I can read. It's always you popping up and ignoring facts like the cross party introduction of self I'd I've seen you ignore this point on countless other threads too.
Can't work out if you are genuinely self unaware of just gaslighting now.

TooBigForMyBoots · 11/08/2022 14:08

DobbyHasASock · 11/08/2022 12:51

No its definitely you.

It definitely isn't. I rarely mention the parties I vote for and if you saw one of these rare posts you would know that Conservative/Labour/Lib dems don't feature at all.

I don't tell people who to vote for. I don't even make suggestions.

OP posts:
FOJN · 11/08/2022 13:39

ImWell · 11/08/2022 10:50

There was a tweet shown on another thread by a shadow cabinet minister literally saying to a constituent, in response to a polite question about Mermaids, that he didn’t want votes off a bigot.

The job of an MP is to represent their constituents, not tell them to fuck off if they aren’t on board with the agenda on trans issues.

That would be this delightful chap...

He's taking a leaf out of Gordon Browns book, if you don't like what someone says just call them a bigot.

AIBU To Remind Everyone That Self ID Was A Tory Policy?
AIBU To Remind Everyone That Self ID Was A Tory Policy?
ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 13:28

But my point politically is that ALL parties are as weak as each other on this point

But they're not. The Tories have made a clear stance of protecting single sex spaces. Lynne Featherstone has told any woman who doesn't agree to intact males having full, unfettered access to female spaces to stay out of the party.

I don't vote Tory, so I don't appreciate having to reiterate the fact thar they're right on point of fact here. But your statement just isn't true.

FOJN · 11/08/2022 13:14

Here's a summary of the main political parties manifestos from the last election. The Conservatives are the only ones not making a commitment to self ID.

uncommongroundmedia.com/where-each-party-stands-on-self-id-and-womens-rights/

In fact despite TM's words the Tory Party have never put a commitment to self ID in any of their manifestos.

www.theguardian.com/society/2017/oct/18/theresa-may-plans-to-let-people-change-gender-without-medical-checks

Self ID has never been a Conservative party policy or manifesto pledge. Their failing has been to allow lobby groups to charge companies for providing incorrect information on the law and for not challenging creeping self ID sooner.

DobbyHasASock · 11/08/2022 12:51

No its definitely you.

TooBigForMyBoots · 11/08/2022 12:34

C8H10N4O2 · 11/08/2022 11:06

There are forced birthers on both sides of the house and in the smaller parties. They all have a good number of members trying to chip away at abortion rights, this is not the preserve of any one party.

Just like you'll find support and opposition of Self ID across the parties. The Conservative Bill of Rights is bad news for women and I think it's being opposed by all the other parties. Not that it will make any difference, the Tories have a massive majority.
www.endviolenceagainstwomen.org.uk/british-bill-of-rights-major-step-back-for-women-and-survivors/

OP posts:
PronounssheRa · 11/08/2022 12:26

They are responsible for the erosion and damage to women's rights over the past 12 years with their policies, including Self ID

The tories don't have a self id policy. They proposed it, held a consultation and actually listened to and acted on the responses.

There is unofficial self ID but much of that is a result of stonewalls legally incorrect advice under the guise of the stonewall champions scheme etc. Thankfully many government departments are now leaving that scheme.

ImWell · 11/08/2022 12:24

TooBigForMyBoots · 11/08/2022 12:19

I think you must have me mixed up with someone else @DobbyHasASock , I have no slavishness to tribal politics. I decide on the day. Nor have I been hyperbolic. I'm just telling the truth about the Conservative party: They are responsible for the erosion and damage to women's rights over the past 12 years with their policies, including Self ID🤷‍♀️

But they don’t have a policy of self-ID, and your posts absolutely do show an obsession with the Conservatives.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 11/08/2022 12:22

Well put OP!

TooBigForMyBoots · 11/08/2022 12:19

DobbyHasASock · 11/08/2022 07:49

I know you think you are being well informed and persuasive op.
But your many, many, many posts on this subject, where you display a slavishness to tribal politics, ignore facts and complexities, ignore current harms Labour are doing and double down on the all Tories are evil rhetoric have persuaded me that me voting Conservative is probably the best thing.
If you came up with a concrete, non emotive argument I'd obviously listen, bit the fact that you can't leads me to think there isn't one.
So you are more persuasive than you think. Perhaps not in the way you want though.
Drop the polar hyperbole and engage with points and people might listen.
I think women's rights is important btw, so telling me it's a niche position is a good way to let me know our values don't align.

I think you must have me mixed up with someone else @DobbyHasASock , I have no slavishness to tribal politics. I decide on the day. Nor have I been hyperbolic. I'm just telling the truth about the Conservative party: They are responsible for the erosion and damage to women's rights over the past 12 years with their policies, including Self ID🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
AntlerRose · 11/08/2022 11:45

@ReneBumsWombats - it wont be easier to get them to change their mind once elected than before they are elected and yes once lost rights take years to win back.

itsgettingweird · 11/08/2022 11:20

Well yes Rene and that's the issue.

I have nonissue with any man saying they are a woman or woman saying they are a man.

I know a trans woman and it's far more complicated than that in reality for many trans a people. For example she doesn't feel safe in male facilities but won't use woman's facilities out of respect. But when she uses accessible facilities she gets bullied for that too.

My issue is that they allow TW into biological woman spaces.

But my point politically is that ALL parties are as weak as each other on this point IMO therefore when I come to vote it's not an issue I vote on. I think whatever party is in power we need to work on making sure everyone has a safe space and there are 3rd spaces.

So I won't be voting Tory again because if their current inability to run the country as a cohesive party - not on this point alone.

And I may vote for another party despite them having the same stance or rather lack of on the trans issue if I think they can benefit me and the country in other ways.

C8H10N4O2 · 11/08/2022 11:06

beguilingeyes · 11/08/2022 10:59

There are forced birthers on both sides of the house and in the smaller parties. They all have a good number of members trying to chip away at abortion rights, this is not the preserve of any one party.

MarshaBradyo · 11/08/2022 11:04

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 10:57

Why will it be easier to persuade Labour/LD of what a woman is only after you've voted them in? Why can't they do it now?

Agree. Why would a party change after they have the votes? They will take it as a mandate for what they ran on

Laws will change and take years to reverse if ever. All the ground gained would be lost. It has taken years for women speaking and focusing on this to get us to this point, only to lose it

Madness to rely on a change after a vote

AntlerRose · 11/08/2022 11:04

@FOJN - those are very interesting points and more relevant to mine. Yes I agree that labour comes across as very authoritarian. I wouldnt vote for them either. As far as I am aware they havent spoken about leaving the echr though or spoken much about limiting judicial review which are important to me.

I live in an area where they have one of those alliances so i dont get to vote freely as it were. I previously voted for a single issue candidate on the NHS and then I had lib dem or conservative or independent last time.

beguilingeyes · 11/08/2022 10:59

Has anyone mentioned that the Tories are moving further to the right on abortion?

www.theguardian.com/global-development/2022/jul/27/senior-tory-urges-liz-truss-to-explain-deletion-of-abortion-rights-from-statement-caroline-nokes

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 10:57

AntlerRose · 11/08/2022 10:50

@ReneBumsWombats because i am not saying that a party can be more easily persauded what a woman is compared to another party already saying what a woman is as that would ba daft.

I am saying that i believe it is easier to persaude a party on what a woman is than persaude another party over a completley different issue which is more important to me as it impact on my ability to fight for lots of issues.

So i think its easier to persaude person a to eat custard than person b to go on a bike ride

Why will it be easier to persuade Labour/LD of what a woman is only after you've voted them in? Why can't they do it now?

ImWell · 11/08/2022 10:50

There was a tweet shown on another thread by a shadow cabinet minister literally saying to a constituent, in response to a polite question about Mermaids, that he didn’t want votes off a bigot.

The job of an MP is to represent their constituents, not tell them to fuck off if they aren’t on board with the agenda on trans issues.

AntlerRose · 11/08/2022 10:50

@ReneBumsWombats because i am not saying that a party can be more easily persauded what a woman is compared to another party already saying what a woman is as that would ba daft.

I am saying that i believe it is easier to persaude a party on what a woman is than persaude another party over a completley different issue which is more important to me as it impact on my ability to fight for lots of issues.

So i think its easier to persaude person a to eat custard than person b to go on a bike ride

ReneBumsWombats · 11/08/2022 10:48

Labour and the LibDems don't want my vote if I won't agree with them on this issue. Can you think of any other issue where a party has told potential members or voters to toe the line or fuck off?

To add to this: women are being criticised for being single issue voters over this. Yet the parties themselves are telling voters who don't fall in line on this one matter to fuck off entirely.

Why is this the one issue for which there is no room for any dissent whatsoever? And why are women voters being blamed for responding accordingly?