Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To Remind Everyone That Self ID Was A Tory Policy?

233 replies

TooBigForMyBoots · 10/08/2022 19:31

I've seen so many posts over the past few years with people urging us to vote Tory because at least the Conservatives know what a woman is.🙄

This is nonsense for the following reasons:

  1. The Tories introduced Self ID under Theresa May's GRA Reform and Penny Mordaunt championed it.
  2. Tory MPs have reported women to the police for retweeting AHF posts and tweets by JKR.
  3. Trans contagion amongst teens happened under the Tory government.
  4. Trans women in women's spaces such as hospitals and prisons and Girl Guides happened under the Tory government.
  5. Rape in hospital that isn't considered "rape" because there was no man present? Tory government.
  6. It's a Trojan Horse. Bridgend Tories won the seat with a small majority. Their Tory MP, once safely in his seat announced that he was trans and intended to become a woman. I am gutted for any GC/feminist voters who held their nose and voted Conservative only to end up with Jamie Wallace.
  7. In the latest leadership race, Penny TWAW Mordaunt nearly became our new prime minister. Few (if any)Tories gave a fuck about her well documented TWAW stance.
  8. 1 week after Starmer refused to answer "what is a woman?", PM Boris Johnson did the same. This was not publicised to anywhere near the same extent.

So some Tories know what a woman is.
Some Tories don't.
Most don't give a shit about women or their rights either way, they're just happy to use us in their culture wars.🤷‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ReneBumsWombats · 14/08/2022 08:26

TooBigForMyBoots · 14/08/2022 03:15

Conservative Politician's Logic: How much power many votes can I get, by being an utter cunt willing to manipulate people's fears?

And this is the point where people look to Labour to see how they'll save us.

TooBigForMyBoots · 14/08/2022 03:15

Conservative Politician's Logic: How much power many votes can I get, by being an utter cunt willing to manipulate people's fears?

OP posts:
Thefruitbatdancer · 13/08/2022 23:12

DdraigGoch · 12/08/2022 21:18

The wilful absurdity does my head in. If I want to set up a cat shelter, I need to be able to define a cat. And if I decide I also want to admit dogs, that's fine, but it is no longer a cat shelter. Not unless you accept that dogs can be cats. And maybe you do, but in that case, cats do not exist as distinct from dogs. And what exactly is a cat?

It's politician's logic.

"All cats have four legs"
"My dog has four legs"
"Therefore my dog is a cat"

See also:

"Girls wear pink"
"My son wears pink"
"Therefore my son is a girl"

Even though they can't see the sexist, stereotyping behind the gender roles. People can't accept that children play with whatever they like to play with. Just because little Jimmy likes Barbies that doesn't make him a girl. Little Jimmy is rejecting socially constructed gender stereotypes & just playing with what he likes. End of; but society can't accept that gender is a socially constructed concept whereas biological sex is a scientific fact.

DdraigGoch · 12/08/2022 21:18

The wilful absurdity does my head in. If I want to set up a cat shelter, I need to be able to define a cat. And if I decide I also want to admit dogs, that's fine, but it is no longer a cat shelter. Not unless you accept that dogs can be cats. And maybe you do, but in that case, cats do not exist as distinct from dogs. And what exactly is a cat?

It's politician's logic.

"All cats have four legs"
"My dog has four legs"
"Therefore my dog is a cat"

See also:

"Girls wear pink"
"My son wears pink"
"Therefore my son is a girl"

MarshaBradyo · 12/08/2022 20:57

DdraigGoch · 12/08/2022 20:18

"TWAW" is a pretty extreme position. It's on a par with "the Earth is flat", "vaccines contain microchips", and "unicorns walk among us" in terms of its basis in reality.

True!

it’s weird how flipped it has become

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 20:55

All these "absolutist" statements seem to be the ones saying that woman is an immutable biological reality and sometimes that matters. As before, one poster had no trouble with the statement "it should be possible to set up a gender neutral rape crisis centre". But "it should be possible to set up a female-only rape crisis centre" was an unhelpful blanket statement that lacked nuance. Or even "you can't protect women if you don't know what a woman is".

The wilful absurdity does my head in. If I want to set up a cat shelter, I need to be able to define a cat. And if I decide I also want to admit dogs, that's fine, but it is no longer a cat shelter. Not unless you accept that dogs can be cats. And maybe you do, but in that case, cats do not exist as distinct from dogs. And what exactly is a cat?

DdraigGoch · 12/08/2022 20:18

MarshaBradyo · 11/08/2022 17:44

Can you give an example of this extreme position?

"TWAW" is a pretty extreme position. It's on a par with "the Earth is flat", "vaccines contain microchips", and "unicorns walk among us" in terms of its basis in reality.

ReneBumsWombats · 12/08/2022 15:38

I see absolutism about certain political parties, I.e. "they can't protect women if they can't define them". To me that is an absolutist position

But why?

How can you protect any group of people if there is no meaningful definition or term for them? How do you know who you're protecting? How do you discern what protections this group needs that those outside of it do not?

It's not sophistry or obfuscation. It's a crucial, clear starting point.

Thelnebriati · 12/08/2022 15:29

i don’t want to sound facetious, or to speak for others. but if you spoke to these parents and said ‘we can give you enough money to feed your kids, but in exchange you may bump into a trans woman at the swimming baths’ then my suspicion is they would bite your hands off

Just imagine thinking this is a winning argument. Of course people who are hungry now are going to care less about other issues than the immediate problems they face.

The most marginalised and vulnerable women are being told to sit down and shut up. If self ID comes in, women will still face the same poverty issues as before, and in addition no single sex spaces or facilities at.
Its not just swimming baths; its the changing rooms.
And its hospital wards.
Psychiatric wards.
Prisons and bail hostels.
Domestic abuse centres.
Rape crisis support.
Homeless shelters.

Women are not taking anything away from food banks. We aren't the ones breaking equality laws, or forcing schoolgirls to use mixed sex toilets.

Beowulfa · 12/08/2022 15:16

All parties have been asleep at the wheel on this issue. The way I see it, the Tories are starting to blink groggily out of the window and look at some of the road signs, whilst Labour/Lib Dems/Greens snore comfortably on.

TooBigForMyBoots · 12/08/2022 12:10

@FOJN, how many times do I have to say it? I'm not telling people to vote for any party. There is no election for another couple of years.🤷‍♀️

It's OK for citizens of a democratic country to criticise the government.

OP posts:
glomerulus · 12/08/2022 11:29

I won't speak for others, but for me the absolutism isn't about single sex spaces, but rather who/how we engage in the debate. I see absolutism about certain political parties, I.e. "they can't protect women if they can't define them". To me that is an absolutist position, and not a very helpful one because it closes down an entire route of engagement. I also think that there are some aspects of protecting/enhancing women's lives that can happen regardless of one's position on self-ID, whether that's improved women's health care, increased rates of rape/dv conviction,etc.

I don't think women should have to compromise on their dignity or safety within this debate. But we probably will have to negotiate in good faith with people that hold fundamentally different views, as many have always done. For me this means leaving enough wiggle room for major political parties and other organisations to amend their views, rather than writing them off. I also appreciate that this is a very uncomfortable thing to do given that many of these groups have unfairly derided women as bigots in the recent past for defending their rights. But it's more important to me that we get to the right outcome, not that we "win the argument".

FOJN · 12/08/2022 10:10

glomerulus · 12/08/2022 07:32

The OP and others are not "ignoring the information", they are giving a different viewpoint on the same information. There's a few posters jumping on the OP here for hating the Tories/not understanding the issue properly and some of the replies here are pretty unpleasant and personal.

The irony here is that most posters want the same thing - single sex services where required and better outcomes for women and society in general. Some posters are being very absolutist about how that can be achieved, which is just as offputting to me as the "no debate" stance.

There's a lot more to be done across all parts of the political spectrum before women's rights are where they need to be. It's not uncalled for to point out how the current party of government have contributed to (and in some cases been solely responsible for) all of the difficulties women are currently facing.

OP is ignoring the detailed information given about the history of the current situation and ignoring inconvenient questions. I'm not convinced the OP has researched the topic thoroughly or if they have they have selected the information which suits them. OP is free to hate the conservative party, it's hardly as if they haven't given cause for many people to feel that way but it's choosing this issue which doesn't make sense.

What is the OP hoping to achieve here? Is the intention to encourage people to punish the Conservatives, for not acting quickly, by not voting for them and vote, instead, for a party that will actually make things worse. The Conservatives are the only party not planning to introduce self ID and are taking steps to address the issue of organisations changing their policies, "to get ahead of the law", as advised by Stonewall. If you are going to post a thread (or several on the same subject) then it's not unreasonable for people to ask questions and to draw attention to the fact you seem to be avoiding providing any answers.

A number of posters have commented that some of us have an absolutist position on single sex spaces but have not offered any details about what they understand that absolutist position to mean. Nuance and compromise happended in 2004 with the GRA and now in 2022 we have people claiming anyone can be a man/woman just because the say so and women are being raped in what should be single sex spaces. I'd suggest the compromise experiment hasn't worked.

There is no point in being anything other than absolutist about single sex spaces, the minute any male, however they identify, enters a female space it stops being a single sex space and becomes a mixed sex space. Plenty of people have tried to avoid this truth and every time they do it makes me think they would happily throw women under the bus just to appear reasonable. It is not reasonable to demand 50% of the population makes compromises on their privacy, safety and dignity to accommodate a tiny proportion of people and in the process expose women to threats from people who would abuse the law for nefarious reasons.

Tanith · 12/08/2022 07:51

“Try asking some of the women evicted from the Labour in recent years for refusing to comply with the removal of sex as a protected characteristic and deny biology.”

‘Evicted”? I’m aware of women who have resigned from Labour over this issue.

glomerulus · 12/08/2022 07:32

FOJN · 12/08/2022 05:24

The Tory party failing IMO has been it's destruction of women's rights in the twelve years they've been in government.

How would another party making self ID law help?

You didn't answer my question earlier in the thread.

If creeping self ID under the Tories has been a disaster then what does it tell us about the parties who would still like to make it law? What does it say about their attitude to women's rights?

I don't think any of them can claim not to know about the problems it causes and it's hardly as if women have been silent on the issue. Are they just not listening or do they just not care.

I don't expect you to answer this time either.

You clearly hate the Tories, you can vote for whoever you like (I'm not typically a Tory voter either) but criticising them on this issue when other parties actually want to make self ID law is strange. It's not as of there aren't plenty of things to find fault with that other parties are actually not guilty of.

You appear to have selectively or superficially informed yourself on the topic but it's not important enough for you to made the effort to really understand the bigger picture and wider implications.

And yet...

You have made multiple threads on this one issue and each time you ignore all the information you have previously been given and make the same points, why?

The OP and others are not "ignoring the information", they are giving a different viewpoint on the same information. There's a few posters jumping on the OP here for hating the Tories/not understanding the issue properly and some of the replies here are pretty unpleasant and personal.

The irony here is that most posters want the same thing - single sex services where required and better outcomes for women and society in general. Some posters are being very absolutist about how that can be achieved, which is just as offputting to me as the "no debate" stance.

There's a lot more to be done across all parts of the political spectrum before women's rights are where they need to be. It's not uncalled for to point out how the current party of government have contributed to (and in some cases been solely responsible for) all of the difficulties women are currently facing.

FOJN · 12/08/2022 05:24

The Tory party failing IMO has been it's destruction of women's rights in the twelve years they've been in government.

How would another party making self ID law help?

You didn't answer my question earlier in the thread.

If creeping self ID under the Tories has been a disaster then what does it tell us about the parties who would still like to make it law? What does it say about their attitude to women's rights?

I don't think any of them can claim not to know about the problems it causes and it's hardly as if women have been silent on the issue. Are they just not listening or do they just not care.

I don't expect you to answer this time either.

You clearly hate the Tories, you can vote for whoever you like (I'm not typically a Tory voter either) but criticising them on this issue when other parties actually want to make self ID law is strange. It's not as of there aren't plenty of things to find fault with that other parties are actually not guilty of.

You appear to have selectively or superficially informed yourself on the topic but it's not important enough for you to made the effort to really understand the bigger picture and wider implications.

And yet...

You have made multiple threads on this one issue and each time you ignore all the information you have previously been given and make the same points, why?

ImWell · 12/08/2022 02:25

thedancingbear · 11/08/2022 21:26

well, yes and no. I would dispute ‘only’. The fact that labour are a busted flush on women’s rights would be less of a problem if the tories hadn’t fucked the country so comprehensively in every other sense. whatever their policy failings, they’ve not been in power for over a decade

The country isn’t “fucked”. Try not to judge the nation from your own circle, you are not representative.

TooBigForMyBoots · 12/08/2022 00:09

FOJN · 11/08/2022 13:14

Here's a summary of the main political parties manifestos from the last election. The Conservatives are the only ones not making a commitment to self ID.

uncommongroundmedia.com/where-each-party-stands-on-self-id-and-womens-rights/

In fact despite TM's words the Tory Party have never put a commitment to self ID in any of their manifestos.

www.theguardian.com/society/2017/oct/18/theresa-may-plans-to-let-people-change-gender-without-medical-checks

Self ID has never been a Conservative party policy or manifesto pledge. Their failing has been to allow lobby groups to charge companies for providing incorrect information on the law and for not challenging creeping self ID sooner.

Theresa May announced it as policy when she was PM.

The Tory party failing IMO has been it's destruction of women's rights in the twelve years they've been in government.

OP posts:
BarmyBrunhilde · 11/08/2022 22:16

C8H10N4O2 · 11/08/2022 21:38

A great many women have been reported, doxxed and had their jobs threatened by Labour MPs and activists.

You evaded my point. How many Tory women MPs and key activists have been forced out of the party for wrongthink on biology?

The Labour party under Corbyn took a sharp switch back to authoritarianism of the type I've not seen since before Kinnock did battle with Militant. Its still not close to being a broad church again which can tolerate a range of left to centre left views and a range of views on issues which are not even right/left issues, however hard ideologist try to make it so.
The idea that these authoritarians give a toss about anything except ideology is for the birds.

Which Labour MPs have been involved in doxxing women and threatening their jobs (I assume you have a list with links?)

C8H10N4O2 · 11/08/2022 21:38

TooBigForMyBoots · 11/08/2022 21:06

Tory MPs have reported women to the police for retweeting the AHF definition and JKR. Resulting in them being suspended from their jobs, arrested and questioned by the police and sacked.

The Torries have no problem bullying and harassing women as their record shows.

A great many women have been reported, doxxed and had their jobs threatened by Labour MPs and activists.

You evaded my point. How many Tory women MPs and key activists have been forced out of the party for wrongthink on biology?

The Labour party under Corbyn took a sharp switch back to authoritarianism of the type I've not seen since before Kinnock did battle with Militant. Its still not close to being a broad church again which can tolerate a range of left to centre left views and a range of views on issues which are not even right/left issues, however hard ideologist try to make it so.
The idea that these authoritarians give a toss about anything except ideology is for the birds.

thedancingbear · 11/08/2022 21:26

PronounssheRa · 11/08/2022 21:16

i don’t want to sound facetious, or to speak for others. but if you spoke to these parents and said ‘we can give you enough money to feed your kids, but in exchange you may bump into a trans woman at the swimming baths’ then my suspicion is they would bite your hands off

The only reason this is an either/or situation is because Labour refuse to respect women's rights and boundaries, hell they won't even speak to women. This is an issue of their making.

well, yes and no. I would dispute ‘only’. The fact that labour are a busted flush on women’s rights would be less of a problem if the tories hadn’t fucked the country so comprehensively in every other sense. whatever their policy failings, they’ve not been in power for over a decade

PronounssheRa · 11/08/2022 21:16

i don’t want to sound facetious, or to speak for others. but if you spoke to these parents and said ‘we can give you enough money to feed your kids, but in exchange you may bump into a trans woman at the swimming baths’ then my suspicion is they would bite your hands off

The only reason this is an either/or situation is because Labour refuse to respect women's rights and boundaries, hell they won't even speak to women. This is an issue of their making.

FOJN · 11/08/2022 21:16

Even if you frame it as a choice between womens rights and the cost of living crisis not everyone thinks that Labour have the right approach to that either.

tribunemag.co.uk/2022/06/labour-party-rishi-sunak-treasury-obr-budget-cost-of-living

Hopefully the Tribune is sufficiently left wing enough not to be considered a mouthpiece for Tory propaganda.

LampLighter414 · 11/08/2022 21:10

Sorry but for me TWAW and policy moves have generally been good

TooBigForMyBoots · 11/08/2022 21:06

Tory MPs have reported women to the police for retweeting the AHF definition and JKR. Resulting in them being suspended from their jobs, arrested and questioned by the police and sacked.

The Torries have no problem bullying and harassing women as their record shows.

OP posts: