Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I'm not being entitled with TV guarantee?

90 replies

Lurapuppypants · 10/08/2022 16:33

Three years ago DH and I splashed out on (for us) a very expensive TV at £1800 (including fitting). It was one which has the "art mode" so when it's on standby, it looks like a picture in a frame. We decorated our living room to incorporate the "art".

We bought it from John Lewis, mostly because it came with a 5 year guarantee.

We have had the TV now for 3 years, and it has developed a fault. John Lewis sent engineers round, but the part to fix it is no longer available. They accept completely that the TV's fault is nothing to do with us and shouldn't have happened.

John Lewis have offered us £1200 to spend on a new TV. The equivalent model to the one we currently have (same size, same brand, just a 2021 version as the 2019 we bought is no longer available) is now £1400 - so a lot less than we originally paid, but they won't cover this.

Their guarantee is supposed to cover an "equivalent" - I'm not demanding the £1800 we originally paid, of course - we've had the TV for 3 years - but I would expect them to replace like with like. Their reasoning is that with a new TV we would get another 5 year guarantee - but as this doesn't actually seem to cover what we need it to, it's hardly a selling point!

We literally just want the same TV we already have - we have offered to have a refurbed TV (they don't do them), to wait for a repair (not possible), or to have the same model that they currently sell (this is where they won't offer enough money towards it).

AIBU to expect the guarantee to actually cover like-for-like?

OP posts:
SwanBuster · 10/08/2022 17:08

Lurapuppypants · 10/08/2022 17:06

I do see what you're saying - that £200 for an upgrade plus warranty is a decent deal. BUT we would also have to pay for fitting (£125) and disposal of the old TV (£20), so we would essentially be £300 out of pocket to replace like-for-like. We haven't budgeted for that, and it's a worry with all the other expenses going up so much at the moment.

Yeah, that's not on.

The replacement should be fitted and the old one disposed of gratis. You should be back in the position you were in prior to the fault.

An equivalent or better TV on the wall with a 2 year warranty remaining.

Ponderingwindow · 10/08/2022 17:08

does the new tv they are proposing cover all the functionality of the old model?

if it does, then as frustrating as it feels, this is actually a really fair offer. Your tv has 3 years of depreciation and that gets factored in with a warranty. In its place you are getting a newer tv, get to start the warranty fresh, and it’s costing a pittance.

if the suggested tv is in some way inferior, I get the complaint, but otherwise I would just go with this.

GU24Mum · 10/08/2022 17:06

It's nothing to do with being grabby - you've paid for a 5 year guarantee so they need to stick to the terms as do you. So, if there is not one which is the same you need to ask how the cheaper one is equivalent if it's worse. If equivalent is more expensive (which it invariably will be after a period of time) that's not your fault.

This comes with the caveat that the policy wording might not quite say this.

Lurapuppypants · 10/08/2022 17:06

I do see what you're saying - that £200 for an upgrade plus warranty is a decent deal. BUT we would also have to pay for fitting (£125) and disposal of the old TV (£20), so we would essentially be £300 out of pocket to replace like-for-like. We haven't budgeted for that, and it's a worry with all the other expenses going up so much at the moment.

OP posts:
SwanBuster · 10/08/2022 17:06

Lurapuppypants · 10/08/2022 17:01

@SwanBuster No, it's a Samsung, The Frame. And screen burn isn't one of the things that's covered. (That's not the issue with ours - it's a faulty backlight.)

And I would absolutely love to swap the 2019 for the 2021 (or 2022) versions - but they won't offer us that. They will only offer us an amount that won't cover any of The Frame range.

Ah - cross posted. Ok, that changes things significantly - I guessed wrong.

Push for them reducing the warranty to 2 years on the replacement..

SwanBuster · 10/08/2022 17:03

Lurapuppypants · 10/08/2022 16:59

I would be tempted to agree with you - if it were not for the fact that the guarantee has proved itself not that useful.

It's like if you really liked Nike trainers and (OK, I appreciate this is stretching a simile to breaking point) had bought a guarantee for them, and when you claimed on it, they offered you some from M&S instead. Yes, they'll do the job, but it's not what you wanted.

Depends on your perspective.

I agree - it's not the ideal outcome if all you care about is the exact same feature set as previously. You are in the right.

But these are extraordinary times in the hardware industry and there's not a lot you can do.

Push for the modern equivalent then, but say you want the warranty reduced to two years. That seems fair.

But if I'm right about the model you have, although it seems 'wrong', it's actually a wonderful deal they have offered you even if it doesn't seem so. The 2021 models are a bug upgrade in many ways. That's the pragmatic way I'd see it.

JudithHarper · 10/08/2022 17:02

I think they have been quite generous with their offer. You have had three years use of your old TV. I would accept their offer, put your 200 in and get a new TV with another 5 year guarantee, unless I have misunderstood what you have written.

Lurapuppypants · 10/08/2022 17:01

@SwanBuster No, it's a Samsung, The Frame. And screen burn isn't one of the things that's covered. (That's not the issue with ours - it's a faulty backlight.)

And I would absolutely love to swap the 2019 for the 2021 (or 2022) versions - but they won't offer us that. They will only offer us an amount that won't cover any of The Frame range.

OP posts:
Lurapuppypants · 10/08/2022 16:59

SwanBuster · 10/08/2022 16:51

Mind you with their offer, an additional 3 year warranty on a £1400 item for in effect £200 is not an outrageously bad deal (could be seen as ~5% a year to insure), given the track record of the previous one.

If it's an OLED - which it must be, it's probably worth having due to the potential burn in issues.

I would be tempted to agree with you - if it were not for the fact that the guarantee has proved itself not that useful.

It's like if you really liked Nike trainers and (OK, I appreciate this is stretching a simile to breaking point) had bought a guarantee for them, and when you claimed on it, they offered you some from M&S instead. Yes, they'll do the job, but it's not what you wanted.

OP posts:
SwanBuster · 10/08/2022 16:58

Actually - I've changed my mind. I think what they are offering you should bite their hand off - it's an LG Oled, yeah? Gotta be 😂

I've just remembered that the 2021 models are a huge upgrade in terms of connectivity. They have HDMI 2.1 with 4k/120 support and the feature set also has an improved algo for dealing with burn in.

Honestly - £200 to swap your 2019 for that is a steal. You can rightly grumble but it's a good deal.

KrisAkabusi · 10/08/2022 16:58

Depends on the wording of the guarantee. An equivalent could be a working three year old tv, obviously worth a lot less than you would have originally paid. If they don't a refurb available, they're giving you what it's worth (and £1200 seems generous in that situation). It's annoying, but I'm not certain they a re wrong.

SwanBuster · 10/08/2022 16:51

Mind you with their offer, an additional 3 year warranty on a £1400 item for in effect £200 is not an outrageously bad deal (could be seen as ~5% a year to insure), given the track record of the previous one.

If it's an OLED - which it must be, it's probably worth having due to the potential burn in issues.

SwanBuster · 10/08/2022 16:48

I think you're in the right.

Since it can't be repaired, they should give you the modern equivalent, but reduce the warranty on that to two years, not another 5 (I'm stating the obvious there).

Antarcticant · 10/08/2022 16:44

Have you tried looking elsewhere for a refurbished one?

Piggieinthemiddle · 10/08/2022 16:42

We had exactly almost the same with JL - different TV, and not that much to start with, but the repair company could not get the part, and we were offered an amount of money to buy a TV they deemed 'equivalent' - it was a different brand, so we did not consider it so, but it was all we could get from them, so we took it in the end.

Swipe left for the next trending thread