Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I'm not being entitled with TV guarantee?

90 replies

Lurapuppypants · 10/08/2022 16:33

Three years ago DH and I splashed out on (for us) a very expensive TV at £1800 (including fitting). It was one which has the "art mode" so when it's on standby, it looks like a picture in a frame. We decorated our living room to incorporate the "art".

We bought it from John Lewis, mostly because it came with a 5 year guarantee.

We have had the TV now for 3 years, and it has developed a fault. John Lewis sent engineers round, but the part to fix it is no longer available. They accept completely that the TV's fault is nothing to do with us and shouldn't have happened.

John Lewis have offered us £1200 to spend on a new TV. The equivalent model to the one we currently have (same size, same brand, just a 2021 version as the 2019 we bought is no longer available) is now £1400 - so a lot less than we originally paid, but they won't cover this.

Their guarantee is supposed to cover an "equivalent" - I'm not demanding the £1800 we originally paid, of course - we've had the TV for 3 years - but I would expect them to replace like with like. Their reasoning is that with a new TV we would get another 5 year guarantee - but as this doesn't actually seem to cover what we need it to, it's hardly a selling point!

We literally just want the same TV we already have - we have offered to have a refurbed TV (they don't do them), to wait for a repair (not possible), or to have the same model that they currently sell (this is where they won't offer enough money towards it).

AIBU to expect the guarantee to actually cover like-for-like?

OP posts:
Harridan1981 · 11/08/2022 07:35

I would push for paying the £200 (worth it for a new warranty) but they fit for free and dispose of the old one.

Plantpotpetal · 11/08/2022 07:30

Surely a TV should last longer than 3 years anyway? So guarantee or not, what about your statutory rights?

Lougle · 11/08/2022 07:22

Years ago my laptop got damaged. I claimed on Currys insurance. My laptop had 4 USB ports. The only laptop that had 4 USB ports was double the price of all the others. I should have pushed for it but let them convince me that 2 USB ports was reasonable. Don't let John Lewis do this to you. I reckon you'd win in Small Claims Court.

rnsaslkih · 11/08/2022 06:50

Typical JL these days. They should pay for the 2021 model and deliver/install for free. Doesn’t matter that you’d then be better off. They guaranteed an item that buggered up and they need to replace it like for like or better. I don’t trust them anymore anyway after they tried to screw me over with a faulty washing machine.

bridgetreilly · 10/08/2022 22:48

OP, I also have a Frame TV, which I absolutely love for the same reason as you - the art mode. I would not accept as equivalent replacement any TV which would leave me with a black screen in the middle of my gallery wall. Stand your ground!

autienotnaughty · 10/08/2022 20:35

If you feel you have a case you could go to ombudsman? I think there's a protocol so takes about six weeks to get started.

SwanBuster · 10/08/2022 20:02

As always - a bit of 'public' nagging on twitter might be worth it - companies tend to like making customers happy when their slightly awkward policies become more visible.

SwanBuster · 10/08/2022 19:59

Lurapuppypants · 10/08/2022 19:36

I agree. They're saying the art feature is not part of the "spec" - so doesn't count. But it is a selling point and the reason I bought it in the first place.

Yeah that's such BS. I don't think a warranty should be any different to insurance in a lot of ways.

Years ago I had a laptop stolen. It's selling point was that at the time it was a rare type with a proper graphics card in it. It had cost £700 online. That was the reason I bought that one. The rest of the spec was very average.

My insurance company Only would allow me to find a replacement from currys PC world, which at the time had a very limited selection. They had plenty of excellent machines, but the only laptop with a discrete graphics card they sold as £1500. A lovely machine in every way.

They gave me that laptop, because I argued that was the only one that matched the part of the feature set that I specifically needed.

Tl;Dr - the specification and the features matter.

Madcats · 10/08/2022 19:58

I am going to assume that is a Samsung "the frame" TV. I've just looked at the current J Lewis blurb for one of these sets. I would say that the "picture" aspect was fairly fundamental.

Keep arguing OP. If you can find/make a PDF of your warranty....

magicstar1 · 10/08/2022 19:45

I think you're right to keep pushing for a proper replacement with no cost to yourself. You shouldn't have to pay for installation either.
I bought a tv from Aldi once - it cost €650, and had a 3 year warranty. After two and a half years it stopped working. They had no televisions on special at the time so the manager gave me a full refund. A few weeks later a better tv came on sale for only €350, so I bought that. I was lucky to get the money back, but if the timing was right, I would have taken the new tv.

Ponderingwindow · 10/08/2022 19:40

So the new tv doesn’t have the art mode? Then i agree, it’s not an appropriate offer.

Lurapuppypants · 10/08/2022 19:36

Lougle · 10/08/2022 18:11

DM fell and broke Mum and Dad's TV. DF had paid £800 for it a few years ago, then covered it with insurance by Domestic and General. They agreed to pay for replacement, and having looked at the spec, said that £369 covered it. They were right - the spec could be met for that amount. It didn't feel brilliant for DF, because the TV was a very 'good' TV when they bought it, but now it seems fairly basic, but it did achieve like for like. Also, when their dishwasher failed, Currys worked it all out so that they still got the installation paid for, because they'd paid it on the old dishwasher.

You need to push for an equivalent. £1200 doesn't allow that.

I agree. They're saying the art feature is not part of the "spec" - so doesn't count. But it is a selling point and the reason I bought it in the first place.

OP posts:
Angelofthenortheast · 10/08/2022 18:58

They know that people buy their tvs from JL for the 5 year guarantee. Otherwise we'd go somewhere cheaper.

Honestly they shouldn't pull an M&S and try and trade off their old good reputation when they're acting like Curry's would.

Lougle · 10/08/2022 18:11

DM fell and broke Mum and Dad's TV. DF had paid £800 for it a few years ago, then covered it with insurance by Domestic and General. They agreed to pay for replacement, and having looked at the spec, said that £369 covered it. They were right - the spec could be met for that amount. It didn't feel brilliant for DF, because the TV was a very 'good' TV when they bought it, but now it seems fairly basic, but it did achieve like for like. Also, when their dishwasher failed, Currys worked it all out so that they still got the installation paid for, because they'd paid it on the old dishwasher.

You need to push for an equivalent. £1200 doesn't allow that.

Georgyporky · 10/08/2022 17:58

Have you asked them about fitting the new one & disposing of the old?

If they'll cover that, it's not such a bad deal, IMO.

TeaTurtle · 10/08/2022 17:57

Yes exactly mrcow it’s not greedy to want the service you’ve paid for!!

JL and any warranty underwriters know that models and specs are likely to change, they win more on some, they win less some, it’s part of the business model. They shouldn’t be trying to cheat customers.

Keep on at them OP. I hope they come to their senses.

mrcow · 10/08/2022 17:42

As for the posters saying you are in “profit” - err, no! You’re missing the point completely!

The tv broke and needs replacing. There should be no additional outlay required by the customer!

mrcow · 10/08/2022 17:38

So you paid for a guarantee with John Lewis for a repair or replacement and they are trying to barter with you?! That’s not what you paid for!

This is shocking, and a terrible advert for John Lewis. What is going on with them - seriously?! I keep hearing stuff about them lately.They used to have the best customer service around. They need to sort themselves out.

TeaTurtle · 10/08/2022 17:34

JL are doing themselves no favours with this attitude. It’s one reason to choose them over another supplier.

As Butterflymum says the starting point is a TV of an equivalent specification. This has to be one of the Frame TVs. The frame feature being the USP and reason for purchase. If there is no identical model then they need to look at the nearest specs of the Frame TVs available and offer that Tv or the value.

It’s not complicated, they are just trying to save money and cheat the customer. It’s really poor.

Lurapuppypants · 10/08/2022 17:33

@butterflymum This is pretty much what I've done. Grin

OP posts:
Lurapuppypants · 10/08/2022 17:32

Getoff · 10/08/2022 17:28

So if you think of the TV as having a guaranteed life of five years, and decide to depreciate its value to zero over that time, a guaranteed-life-year is currently worth £1400/5 = £280. For an outlay of £300, you are gaining 3 x £280 = £840 of years. So you are £540 in profit. I think that is quite a good deal.

But what if we don't have an extra £300 to spend on a new TV right now?

I genuinely don't want to profit on the situation - just want the same brand (and model) of TV that we currently have. I'm not looking to get a bigger one, or a higher-spec. I just don't want to pay additional cash to get something replaced that has failed whilst under guarantee.

OP posts:
Getoff · 10/08/2022 17:28

So if you think of the TV as having a guaranteed life of five years, and decide to depreciate its value to zero over that time, a guaranteed-life-year is currently worth £1400/5 = £280. For an outlay of £300, you are gaining 3 x £280 = £840 of years. So you are £540 in profit. I think that is quite a good deal.

butterflymum · 10/08/2022 17:22

Their guarantee says:

"If we can't repair your TV, we'll replace it with a TV of equivalent specification. If no equivalent product is available, we'll either offer you the nearest equivalent specification or its selling price value, and we'll always do our best to make sure you're satisfied with the outcome."

So, go back to them, stating what the guarantee says, and ask for an indication of what tv they believe is equivalent (and unavailable), nearest equivalent (and unavailable and usual selling price when available). State why you believe the £1400 model fits as equivalent/nearest equivalent and ask that they reconsider this as at the moment, you are not satisfied with their original proposed outcome.

Lurapuppypants · 10/08/2022 17:19

Ponderingwindow · 10/08/2022 17:08

does the new tv they are proposing cover all the functionality of the old model?

if it does, then as frustrating as it feels, this is actually a really fair offer. Your tv has 3 years of depreciation and that gets factored in with a warranty. In its place you are getting a newer tv, get to start the warranty fresh, and it’s costing a pittance.

if the suggested tv is in some way inferior, I get the complaint, but otherwise I would just go with this.

That's what they're claiming - the functionality is the same, but I bought it for the Art Mode (it displays works of art when in standby mode so fits into decor more than just a blank screen on the wall). They're suggesting something that I believe has fundamentally different functionality, or else asking me to pay £300+ to get the same (albeit 2 years later) product.

I have told them we'd be perfectly happy with a repair or replacement of the old model, which they no longer stock.

OP posts:
Getoff · 10/08/2022 17:18

This doesn't help OP, but for anyone else thinking about where to buy TV's: about 4.5 years into ownership of Oled from Curry, I noticed some screen burn where news channels put their headlines. About two months before the 5 year mark, I reported it to their helpline. They repaired, replacing the screen. The new screen may be better than the original, I know it's not identical as it's get a 1mm silver frame, which the original didn't have.

I had no paperwork to indicate that I had a 5-year warranty, I just recalled that the TV had been advertised with it, as I knew I had considered John Lewis, and only switched to Curry's when I realised they had the same warranty. It was a non-issue when I reported the fault to their helpline, they simply got me to try and few things, and when that didn't sort out the problem, arranged a pick-up of the TV. A week later, the repaired TV was delivered back to my TV, and delivery guys helped me put it back on the stand.

I assume Curry's support had my details on my database from when I ordered the TV. The existence of the 5 year warranty wasn't mentioned by me or them during the conversation, they simply fixed the problem I reported.

Swipe left for the next trending thread