Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I'm not being entitled with TV guarantee?

90 replies

Lurapuppypants · 10/08/2022 16:33

Three years ago DH and I splashed out on (for us) a very expensive TV at £1800 (including fitting). It was one which has the "art mode" so when it's on standby, it looks like a picture in a frame. We decorated our living room to incorporate the "art".

We bought it from John Lewis, mostly because it came with a 5 year guarantee.

We have had the TV now for 3 years, and it has developed a fault. John Lewis sent engineers round, but the part to fix it is no longer available. They accept completely that the TV's fault is nothing to do with us and shouldn't have happened.

John Lewis have offered us £1200 to spend on a new TV. The equivalent model to the one we currently have (same size, same brand, just a 2021 version as the 2019 we bought is no longer available) is now £1400 - so a lot less than we originally paid, but they won't cover this.

Their guarantee is supposed to cover an "equivalent" - I'm not demanding the £1800 we originally paid, of course - we've had the TV for 3 years - but I would expect them to replace like with like. Their reasoning is that with a new TV we would get another 5 year guarantee - but as this doesn't actually seem to cover what we need it to, it's hardly a selling point!

We literally just want the same TV we already have - we have offered to have a refurbed TV (they don't do them), to wait for a repair (not possible), or to have the same model that they currently sell (this is where they won't offer enough money towards it).

AIBU to expect the guarantee to actually cover like-for-like?

OP posts:
Madcats · 11/08/2022 17:44

I've been there OP (albeit with household insurance). The loss adjuster was originally proposing to send us off to DFS to replace persian carpets and ££ sofas after an accidental water leak.

After an exchange of letters, we highlighted the "like for like clause" and supplied estimates from the original retailers. It turned out to be a rather expensive claim.

I suspect the person you are dealing with is new to the job or the Insurer is trying to keep their claims costs down. Incorrectly in your particular instance.

PurpleFlower1983 · 11/08/2022 16:42

We have a Samsung frame and it dropped £500 between order and delivery, the sale began in September. It was more difficult than I though to sort it with John Lewis but they did it in the end.

PurpleFlower1983 · 11/08/2022 16:40

Just wait a couple of months and they will likely be reduced.

AnneElliott · 11/08/2022 16:37

I'd definitely escalate the issue to someone senior. That reply they sent you was awful!

I agree they need to give you the Frame TV or refund your original £1400 as the product was faulty. You can then buy a TV elsewhere.

Lurapuppypants · 11/08/2022 16:19

Madcats · 11/08/2022 16:12

I have looked at the current TV and the associated warranty. It is a Domestic & General Policy provided on behalf of John Lewis by an Insurance Company called Domestic and General. This is what the current version says about replacements:
"For accepted claims, we may decide (at our discretion) to arrange for
you to receive either a replacement item or give you a John Lewis &
Partners gift card, rather than carry out a repair (for example where
we cannot repair it or we decide that it is uneconomical for us to
repair your product). For items such as laptops, wearable technology,
tablets, headphones or game consoles, we may decide to provide
you with either a remanufactured or a refurbished replacement,
rather than a new one. All replacements will be of the same or
similar make and technical specification as your product. However,
it may not be the same colour as your original product. We will not
transfer your data to a replacement device" "
"Gift cards: The gift card will be for the then current John Lewis &
Partners full retail price of a replacement product of the same or
similar make and technical specification and for the cost of delivery.
Where the replaced product is a television, the gift card value
will also include the cost of installation by John Lewis & Partners
(excluding the enhanced wall mount service)".

The USP of the this Samsung Lifestyle Range TV (in this case) The Screen as per John Lewis's website:
"Samsung's The Frame is a stunningly slim TV that can be endlessly transformed. All to reflect your taste and reinvent your everyday space. It's the perfect balance of fine art and epic TV entertainment, all on a revolutionary, glare-free QLED display. So when you’re not watching TV, The Frame turns into a glare-free canvas to showcase iconic art or your treasured pics".

So for me an equivalent product would need to be a glare-free canvas with interchangeable frames to showcase my art/holiday pictures. If the proposed replacement can't be "endlessly transformed" it isn't a suitable replacement. If you wanted a huge black screen in your lounge, you would have bought a huge black screened TV, not a Samsung Frame

John Lewis still sell such TVs, albeit at a higher spec than what you originally had (but it is reasonable to expect technology to advance).

The policy is silent on making deductions for wear and tear. If wear and tear deductions were to apply it would be in the policy wording.

The insurance clerk's interpretation of the insurance cover is incorrect. Ask to escalate your complaint.

I love Mumsnet at moments like this. It's like having access to my own legal team.

I am still awaiting a reply to the email I sent them yesterday morning. I'll chase again if I've still heard nothing by tomorrow.

OP posts:
Lurapuppypants · 11/08/2022 16:17

Lougle · 11/08/2022 15:49

What size is it? Samsung have it for £899 for the 55" here

Ooh! Excellent spot!

JL have been silent so far about whether the amount is cash or store credit, but if we reach a deadlock over the amount and they won't budge, I'll ask for cash and buy it here (just hope it stays in stock!).

Apparently Richer Sounds do a 6 year guarantee as standard. Just a shame it's out of stock with them.

OP posts:
Madcats · 11/08/2022 16:12

I have looked at the current TV and the associated warranty. It is a Domestic & General Policy provided on behalf of John Lewis by an Insurance Company called Domestic and General. This is what the current version says about replacements:
"For accepted claims, we may decide (at our discretion) to arrange for
you to receive either a replacement item or give you a John Lewis &
Partners gift card, rather than carry out a repair (for example where
we cannot repair it or we decide that it is uneconomical for us to
repair your product). For items such as laptops, wearable technology,
tablets, headphones or game consoles, we may decide to provide
you with either a remanufactured or a refurbished replacement,
rather than a new one. All replacements will be of the same or
similar make and technical specification as your product. However,
it may not be the same colour as your original product. We will not
transfer your data to a replacement device" "
"Gift cards: The gift card will be for the then current John Lewis &
Partners full retail price of a replacement product of the same or
similar make and technical specification and for the cost of delivery.
Where the replaced product is a television, the gift card value
will also include the cost of installation by John Lewis & Partners
(excluding the enhanced wall mount service)".

The USP of the this Samsung Lifestyle Range TV (in this case) The Screen as per John Lewis's website:
"Samsung's The Frame is a stunningly slim TV that can be endlessly transformed. All to reflect your taste and reinvent your everyday space. It's the perfect balance of fine art and epic TV entertainment, all on a revolutionary, glare-free QLED display. So when you’re not watching TV, The Frame turns into a glare-free canvas to showcase iconic art or your treasured pics".

So for me an equivalent product would need to be a glare-free canvas with interchangeable frames to showcase my art/holiday pictures. If the proposed replacement can't be "endlessly transformed" it isn't a suitable replacement. If you wanted a huge black screen in your lounge, you would have bought a huge black screened TV, not a Samsung Frame

John Lewis still sell such TVs, albeit at a higher spec than what you originally had (but it is reasonable to expect technology to advance).

The policy is silent on making deductions for wear and tear. If wear and tear deductions were to apply it would be in the policy wording.

The insurance clerk's interpretation of the insurance cover is incorrect. Ask to escalate your complaint.

SwanBuster · 11/08/2022 15:55

SwanBuster · 11/08/2022 15:55

Ok, so based on what @Lougle just found - Samsung are flogging off the 2022 version for £900.

If the refund is cash, take it, buy that, and pocket £300. It won’t be rocket science to install it as another poster said. Unscrew the mounting bracket from the old tv, put it on the new one, job done.

*sorry 2021 version. When are we going to get an edit post option!

SwanBuster · 11/08/2022 15:55

Lurapuppypants · 11/08/2022 15:15

This was their last response (spelling mistakes not mine!). I was also very clear I did not expect a full refund:

"I do fully appreciate where you are coming from, so I am sorry that we cannot offer you a full refund. If we were to provide you a full refund, it would mean that you would have had your TV for 3 years at no cost, I hope I have explained it well to you. The TV we have found for you (which you do not have to purchase) does have similar specifications which means we have stuck to our guarantee, the Frame is an aesthetic and not how the TV functions, which is why it doesn't come in to concideration when we make the settlement offer.

We don't sell the same TV anymore, you purchased a 2019 model and we only have the 2021/2022 ones. We will only be able to offer you a partial refund of £1200 on this occasion."

Ok, so based on what @Lougle just found - Samsung are flogging off the 2022 version for £900.

If the refund is cash, take it, buy that, and pocket £300. It won’t be rocket science to install it as another poster said. Unscrew the mounting bracket from the old tv, put it on the new one, job done.

Madcats · 11/08/2022 15:50

Hi OP what does the warranty actually say it will cover? That is the important part.

Lougle · 11/08/2022 15:49

What size is it? Samsung have it for £899 for the 55" here

Lurapuppypants · 11/08/2022 15:15

This was their last response (spelling mistakes not mine!). I was also very clear I did not expect a full refund:

"I do fully appreciate where you are coming from, so I am sorry that we cannot offer you a full refund. If we were to provide you a full refund, it would mean that you would have had your TV for 3 years at no cost, I hope I have explained it well to you. The TV we have found for you (which you do not have to purchase) does have similar specifications which means we have stuck to our guarantee, the Frame is an aesthetic and not how the TV functions, which is why it doesn't come in to concideration when we make the settlement offer.

We don't sell the same TV anymore, you purchased a 2019 model and we only have the 2021/2022 ones. We will only be able to offer you a partial refund of £1200 on this occasion."

OP posts:
Elsiebear90 · 11/08/2022 12:40

Whenever I have claimed on a guarantee they’ve replaced it with either a refurbished model of the same age or given the newer version. So I don’t think they’re right to say you should accept less money than you paid or have a TV that doesn’t do the main thing you bought it to do.

SisyphusDad · 11/08/2022 12:14

...part...

SisyphusDad · 11/08/2022 12:14

I agree with all the other posters who say that the 'Frame' feature (and the very low profile on the wall) are absolutely pay of the specification.

'Letter before action' and Small Claims Court perhaps?

gatehouseoffleet · 11/08/2022 12:01

Plantpotpetal · 11/08/2022 07:30

Surely a TV should last longer than 3 years anyway? So guarantee or not, what about your statutory rights?

Yes I was also thinking this, Forget the warranty and look at the Consumer Rights Act.

www.which.co.uk/consumer-rights/regulation/consumer-rights-act-aKJYx8n5KiSl

www.businesscompanion.info/en/quick-guides/goods/sale-and-supply-of-goods (this is advice for businesses but still useful)

SwanBuster · 11/08/2022 11:48

EmergencyHepNeeded · 11/08/2022 11:11

If the art feature isn't on the replacement then it's not like for like.

Indeed. Especially given the name of the TV

The frame

it’s literally the primary selling point. There is no argument.

EmergencyHepNeeded · 11/08/2022 11:11

If the art feature isn't on the replacement then it's not like for like.

mummyh2016 · 11/08/2022 10:43

Are they offering £1200 cash or a voucher?

Dreikanter · 11/08/2022 10:13

If it were me, I’d take the £1200 on offer and buy the 2021 50”, as long as I got the £400 balance plus the 5 year guarantee (but then I’m not overly fussed about huge TVs).

billyt · 11/08/2022 08:55

Slightly off the subject, but who pays £125 for installation?

Any new TV should be able to be mounted on the same mounting frame.

Lift old one off, put new one on.

Lurapuppypants · 11/08/2022 08:49

Dreikanter · 11/08/2022 08:17

John Lewis have offered us £1200 to spend on a new TV. The equivalent model to the one we currently have (same size, same brand, just a 2021 version as the 2019 we bought is no longer available) is now £1400 - so a lot less than we originally paid, but they won't cover this.

What size is the faulty TV?

JL website has a 2021 50” The Frame for £799. The 2022 50” model is £1399.

It's a 55 inch.

OP posts:
Idontevenknow · 11/08/2022 08:34

I would continue pushing for the 1400. I agree with you.

We had a smiliar issue with our expensive couch and chairs- the chair broke a good way into the guarantee and they no longer made the part. We were offered to go in and choose something to the same value as we originally paid, we chose something a few hundred less and they refunded the difference too.

Dreikanter · 11/08/2022 08:17

John Lewis have offered us £1200 to spend on a new TV. The equivalent model to the one we currently have (same size, same brand, just a 2021 version as the 2019 we bought is no longer available) is now £1400 - so a lot less than we originally paid, but they won't cover this.

What size is the faulty TV?

JL website has a 2021 50” The Frame for £799. The 2022 50” model is £1399.

CornishTiger · 11/08/2022 07:39

Keep pushing.

I had a stressful experience with a phone recently from JL. They’ve lost my repeated custom.

Swipe left for the next trending thread