Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I'm not being entitled with TV guarantee?

90 replies

Lurapuppypants · 10/08/2022 16:33

Three years ago DH and I splashed out on (for us) a very expensive TV at £1800 (including fitting). It was one which has the "art mode" so when it's on standby, it looks like a picture in a frame. We decorated our living room to incorporate the "art".

We bought it from John Lewis, mostly because it came with a 5 year guarantee.

We have had the TV now for 3 years, and it has developed a fault. John Lewis sent engineers round, but the part to fix it is no longer available. They accept completely that the TV's fault is nothing to do with us and shouldn't have happened.

John Lewis have offered us £1200 to spend on a new TV. The equivalent model to the one we currently have (same size, same brand, just a 2021 version as the 2019 we bought is no longer available) is now £1400 - so a lot less than we originally paid, but they won't cover this.

Their guarantee is supposed to cover an "equivalent" - I'm not demanding the £1800 we originally paid, of course - we've had the TV for 3 years - but I would expect them to replace like with like. Their reasoning is that with a new TV we would get another 5 year guarantee - but as this doesn't actually seem to cover what we need it to, it's hardly a selling point!

We literally just want the same TV we already have - we have offered to have a refurbed TV (they don't do them), to wait for a repair (not possible), or to have the same model that they currently sell (this is where they won't offer enough money towards it).

AIBU to expect the guarantee to actually cover like-for-like?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ukparenting · 18/10/2023 12:29

Lurapuppypants · 17/08/2022 10:32

Some good news. After hearing nothing from emailing the tech support (as requested by JL staff), and chasing it twice and being told I would get a response within 24 hours, I escalated to the head of customer service, and mentioned several of the things I got as good advice on this thread - including the Sale of Goods Act..

Again, I was told I would get a reply within 24 hours but it was actually more than 48 hours.

HOWEVER! They have agreed to provide me with a gift card to cover the cost of the same size The Frame TV, plus the cost of installation.

It's been a whole lot of hassle, and not what I expected from John Lewis, but at least we have agreed a satisfactory resolution.

Good to see you got a positive result. Im in a very similar position now. Bought a 65" Samsung Frame TV in 2019, recently the LED backlight was going to called them up, they sent a repair guy who took the tv away but after a month have said they can't get hold of the parts.

The TV cost us £1320 with the 5 year cover and they are offering 850. Ive said no as I expected a like for like replacement and they are now going to "re-avaluate the offer" so waiting to hear back from them...

Any tips or advice on how I should persuade them?

Madcats · 17/08/2022 14:19

Excellent news. Enjoy your new TV; hopefully this one will outlive the warranty!

Lougle · 17/08/2022 11:49

Fantastic news!

Lurapuppypants · 17/08/2022 10:32

Some good news. After hearing nothing from emailing the tech support (as requested by JL staff), and chasing it twice and being told I would get a response within 24 hours, I escalated to the head of customer service, and mentioned several of the things I got as good advice on this thread - including the Sale of Goods Act..

Again, I was told I would get a reply within 24 hours but it was actually more than 48 hours.

HOWEVER! They have agreed to provide me with a gift card to cover the cost of the same size The Frame TV, plus the cost of installation.

It's been a whole lot of hassle, and not what I expected from John Lewis, but at least we have agreed a satisfactory resolution.

OP posts:
Lurapuppypants · 12/08/2022 15:26

Lougle · 12/08/2022 14:58

So yours was a 65"?

No, 55" and no desire to go any bigger. That's the one they suggested matched the spec. We just want The Frame functionality.

OP posts:
Lougle · 12/08/2022 14:58

So yours was a 65"?

MightyMouse101 · 12/08/2022 14:55

@Lurapuppypants Equivalent spec in my case apparently meant the same model and year of manufacture even though it was no longer available. I wish I'd pushed harder to get a proper replacement with them rather than paying more elsewhere so best of luck!

Lurapuppypants · 12/08/2022 14:54

This is the one they're suggesting: www.johnlewis.com/lg-65qned816qa-2022-qned-hdr-4k-ultra-hd-smart-tv-65-inch-with-freeview-hd-freesat-hd-dark-meteor-titan/p6134061

OP posts:
Dreikanter · 12/08/2022 14:52

If you bought the TV because of its art feature, that is a salient feature that you want replacing.

And point out that they have the equivalent The Frame model (features / size etc) on their website so please could they honour the guarantee wording: “If we can't repair your TV, we'll replace it with a TV of equivalent specification”.

You could also quote their on-line product description: “Combining TV entertainment and fine art, when you're not watching TV with cinematic Dolby Atmos sound, its glare-free QLED 4K display turns into a canvas to exhibit art pieces, or even your own photos.”

I wonder if they’ve offered £1200 because they consider this one an equivalent model:

www.johnlewis.com/samsung-qe55q80b-2022-qled-hdr-1500-4k-ultra-hd-smart-tv-55-inch-with-tvplus-freesat-hd-dolby-atmos-black/p6196934

Lurapuppypants · 12/08/2022 14:50

They use the weasel words "equivalent specification" and choose that to mean solely size and screen resolution. Which isn't the full spec by any means.

If I really can't get anywhere with them, my next step is to ask for the refund in cash and buy it elsewhere.

OP posts:
gatehouseoffleet · 12/08/2022 14:29

I think you need to go back to them again and say it doesn't matter what their policy is in their heads, it's what its terms say that matter.

If its terms say that they will replace like for like, then that's what they have to do.

They cannot pick and choose the features they say are like for like. If you bought the TV because of its art feature, that is a salient feature that you want replacing.

They can't fix it, and they can't provide the same TV, so they need to provide enough money for you to source it elsewhere.

It's also worth pointing out to them, as I mentioned upthread, that you also have rights against them under the Consumer Rights Act and if they don't honour the warranty terms, you will take action under the CRA. The warranty is in addition to the CRA rights, not instead of. So if you don't like their response under the warranty, you can raise it again under the CRA. A TV should last for more than 3 years, so if they can't offer a repair, they should provide a replacement, or the means to get one.

Have they actually checked properly that the part is no longer available? 3 years isn't very long. It might just be a supply chain issue.

Lurapuppypants · 12/08/2022 14:21

Dreikanter · 12/08/2022 14:10

You have to purchase Protect Plus policy separately as it provides the additional accidental damage cover.

Yes we didn't purchase Protect Plus so I wonder if they've even got an underwriter for their own guarantee.

OP posts:
Dreikanter · 12/08/2022 14:10

You have to purchase Protect Plus policy separately as it provides the additional accidental damage cover.

Madcats · 12/08/2022 13:59

Lurapuppypants · 12/08/2022 13:47

It's interesting for those of you mentioning the insurance ombudsman, as I didn't pay for insurance, would it still count or is it a "goodwill" warranty on behalf of JL?

I can't find any details of underwriters etc. on the 5-year guarantee link they shared with me.

I will keep escalating.

Following that link (click on the bold "Protect Plus"), you arrive here:

www.johnlewis.com/our-services/protect-plus

Here are the full T&Cs:

johnlewis.scene7.com/is/content/JohnLewis/Protect-Plus-Accidental-Damage-Terms-Conditionspdf

Domestic & General are the insurer (John Lewis paid for you to get the cover). You can still complain.

Lougle · 12/08/2022 13:50

The cheapest I've found that TV (55") is £729 here but tbh, I'd pay the extra £20 to get it from Amazon for £749 here and pay the £78 for 3 year warranty.

Have you thought about mentioning small claims court?

Lurapuppypants · 12/08/2022 13:47

It's interesting for those of you mentioning the insurance ombudsman, as I didn't pay for insurance, would it still count or is it a "goodwill" warranty on behalf of JL?

I can't find any details of underwriters etc. on the 5-year guarantee link they shared with me.

I will keep escalating.

OP posts:
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 12/08/2022 13:45

Lougle · 11/08/2022 07:22

Years ago my laptop got damaged. I claimed on Currys insurance. My laptop had 4 USB ports. The only laptop that had 4 USB ports was double the price of all the others. I should have pushed for it but let them convince me that 2 USB ports was reasonable. Don't let John Lewis do this to you. I reckon you'd win in Small Claims Court.

Currys are shocking - they were supposed to repair our TV but sent back what I believe was a different TV as the screen was cracked, it was dirty and had a different plug. After a lot of arguing they agreed to replace it but gave us a lot less than we needed to get like for like.

When we did get a new TV it didn't work properly, half the picture was missing, and the store manager told me it was a feature of the set! He then threatened to have me arrested when I complained loudly about the poor service. That was despite him asking me what part no don't I understand when I asked him to replace the faulty set!

Ive always thought JL would be a better bet but they all sound as bad as each other!

MightyMouse101 · 12/08/2022 13:33

I've just had the same issue with a washing machine. I had to admit defeat, take the refund as JL couldn't replace my machine with the same model (which is all they were offering, making a mockery of their own guarantee) and pay for a new machine with another retailer.

Madcats · 12/08/2022 13:31

It's not OPs fault that Domestic & General can't source a refurbished TV.

It might involve you and you family looking sad in a Saturday newspaper, but this is the sort of thing the newspaper consumer rights champions like pursuing.

This is the Telegraph:

www.telegraph.co.uk/money/katie-investigates/katie-morley-investigates-contact-form/

OP I suggest that you reply to the insurance clerk:

"..... before I refer this matter to a Newspaper Consumer Champion and/or the Insurance Ombudsmen, I would like to give you a further opportunity to resolve this to my satisfaction. This is damaging the reputation of your employer and John Lewis....."

Subaru4336 · 12/08/2022 13:09

I've had issues with JL Customer Service in the past, I stuck with it, as I knew I was right, and kept escalating. Eventually someone fairly high up agreed, apologised profusely, replaced my item with a new one and gave me £50 for the inconvenience.

@Lurapuppypants I think you're absolutely right to ask for enough to buy an equivalent, with the artwork, so keep trying and escalating would be my advice! Good luck!

Lurapuppypants · 12/08/2022 13:01

Blossomtoes · 12/08/2022 12:44

But you do want a new TV or you wouldn’t be pissed off because they won’t give you the same make and model, despite having been offered a new replacement that isn’t the same. I think you’re being unreasonable. You’ve had three years use of an item that depreciated the moment it left the shop.

I want the same make and model because of the features it has.

I would be happy with my current set repaired. I don't need a new tv, I just want the same make and model and features I originally paid for.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 12/08/2022 12:44

But you do want a new TV or you wouldn’t be pissed off because they won’t give you the same make and model, despite having been offered a new replacement that isn’t the same. I think you’re being unreasonable. You’ve had three years use of an item that depreciated the moment it left the shop.

Lurapuppypants · 12/08/2022 11:42

@Blossomtoes I don't want a new tv though. I want my current one working. They can't do that, can't provide me with a refurbished one but do still sell the same make/model, but won't provide it.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 12/08/2022 11:26

Lurapuppypants · 10/08/2022 17:06

I do see what you're saying - that £200 for an upgrade plus warranty is a decent deal. BUT we would also have to pay for fitting (£125) and disposal of the old TV (£20), so we would essentially be £300 out of pocket to replace like-for-like. We haven't budgeted for that, and it's a worry with all the other expenses going up so much at the moment.

Haggle. Get them to include fitting and disposal of the old set. Then accept. It’s pretty unreasonable to expect a new TV after three years use.

Lurapuppypants · 12/08/2022 11:17

This is their latest response, which also doesn't make sense as they say the most they would give is the selling price of the TV - which was nearly £1800.

They have also provided a link to their guarantee.

"The guarantee info is here:

www.johnlewis.com/customer-services/guarantees-and-troubleshooting-guides?dt=guarantees-electricals-electricalTv

It is relatively broad as the specs used to match need adjusting as we go due to ever changing tech and functionality in the audio visual market.

Manaufacturer is not a spec we look at, sadly neither are aestheics. If we can, we would always do so, but it is not always possible within the original selling value, which is the absolute most we could be expected to provide. Key points are image quality and, size - where we cannot offer a match, we upgrade so the value offerred is fair and can be used towards a TV of your choosing."

I'm so upset with them. I'll never buy a large electrical appliance with them again.

OP posts: