Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what we do to help with the cost of social care?

215 replies

AdultsSocialCare · 10/08/2022 14:25

Adult and childrens social care takes up the majority of all council tax spend. This leaves a small amount for everything else that councils do.

What is the solution?

I feel like ultimately the central government need to give more money to councils but the chance of that has to be next to nil.

So, what else?

OP posts:
Madwife123 · 10/08/2022 18:49

@Friars23 That proposal completely ignored the fact that 70% of adult social care is spent on disabled adults, not the elderly.

Like my son who I have already mentioned costs the government £2000 a week. He is currently 19. He will never function independently. How much will he cost over his lifetime? How many other parents are in the same position with disabled children that are being supported by the government as the system for paying family carers in this country is abysmal?

Many of these disabled adults have relatives more than willing to care for them. But when it comes to a choice between feeding your other children and keeping a roof over their head vs letting social care take responsibility you’re not left with much choice.

giffyg · 10/08/2022 18:42

@CHIRIBAYA ignore the trolling

Friars23 · 10/08/2022 18:41

AdultsSocialCare · 10/08/2022 14:25

Adult and childrens social care takes up the majority of all council tax spend. This leaves a small amount for everything else that councils do.

What is the solution?

I feel like ultimately the central government need to give more money to councils but the chance of that has to be next to nil.

So, what else?

In the last year of the Labour government in 2010 Andy Burnham wrote a white paper proposing a National Care Scheme. It would be funded by taking 10% of a person’s estate when they die. It would be pooling risk like NHS. Personally I thought it sounded like it had merit. A Tory government would never go for it.

Under austerity councils had their budgets slashed by at least 30% yet still expected to fund adult care. People with savings over I think around £21,000 get nothing but even those who have it part funded have found their contribution has risen massively.

giffyg · 10/08/2022 18:41

Onlyfools - i agree. And they should remove the loophole that allows people to pass on their estates so they dont have to pay this - currently i think its seven years before you pass. I know two people who have used this loophole recently

plus it completely entrenches inequality, I know someone who just inherited 1m.

Madwife123 · 10/08/2022 18:39

@Miffee Direct payments are used to pay other people to care for your child. They cannot be paid to a relative of the person receiving the care. So yet again it costs the LA far far more to pay someone else to do a job I could do if I was given the financial support to do it.

Miffee · 10/08/2022 18:34

Madwife123 · 10/08/2022 17:51

Paying relatives to care for their own family would help for one!

I gave up my job to care for my severely disabled (now adult) son. £69 a week is what I was expected to live on!

So now I’m back at work and he goes to daycare funded by adult social care at a cost of £2000 a week! How does that make any sense?

I would happily care for him myself but I also need to pay my bills. A quarter of what he is currently costing the LA would mean I could afford to care for him and they would save a small fortune.

Did you ask for a direct payment?

CHIRIBAYA · 10/08/2022 18:34

"the mental health crisis starting with youngsters then into middle age is your sinkhole. Not only do they not contribute to the pot throughout their lifetime they drain it dry and beyond"

This has to be one of the most shocking, disgusting things I have ever read on this site. Do you realise how ageist your post it? So what should we do, bump them off?? Are you aware how much investment goes into childrens mental health in this country? In our area, I can safely say none. There is no mental health service for young people, it's just not deemed worthy of the expense. So if these young people end up contributing "nothing" , may I politely suggest that maybe if the adults in society had demanded better for them, the outcome might be different.

One could argue that those born with disabilities contribute nothing. One individual upthread costs the council 2k a week. Or how about the diabetics, costing the NHS God only knows how much a week. Draining the pot dry are they? Or is it just mental health that triggers your venom.

You are one sick individual.

Miffee · 10/08/2022 18:31

ancientgran · 10/08/2022 18:21

My son did his work experience in a school for children with very serious disabilities. He loved it, they loved him. If it wasn't for the fact that his school hours were the same as their school hours he would have loved to volunteer at the school.

Sounds amazing, well done him. I am assuming he did more than prep their meals and do office administration? That's what the pp was suggesting.

ancientgran · 10/08/2022 18:21

Miffee · 10/08/2022 15:02

I wouldn't be happy for my child to go off performing slave labour for profit. Would you?

My son did his work experience in a school for children with very serious disabilities. He loved it, they loved him. If it wasn't for the fact that his school hours were the same as their school hours he would have loved to volunteer at the school.

Namerchangerextraordinaire · 10/08/2022 18:17

Madwife123 · 10/08/2022 17:51

Paying relatives to care for their own family would help for one!

I gave up my job to care for my severely disabled (now adult) son. £69 a week is what I was expected to live on!

So now I’m back at work and he goes to daycare funded by adult social care at a cost of £2000 a week! How does that make any sense?

I would happily care for him myself but I also need to pay my bills. A quarter of what he is currently costing the LA would mean I could afford to care for him and they would save a small fortune.

This.

So many incredibly expensive places are required because carers are paid less than pretty much anyone else in society.

When you are told your value is less than £70 for a full time role, why would you think you should pay more for someone else to do the same job?

The govt values carers at peanuts, meaning so does everyone else.

gogohmm · 10/08/2022 18:01

It's unpopular but we need to plan ahead to fund our own care needs. I have parents who are older but currently fit and well, they have made financial provision for care costs

Madwife123 · 10/08/2022 17:51

Paying relatives to care for their own family would help for one!

I gave up my job to care for my severely disabled (now adult) son. £69 a week is what I was expected to live on!

So now I’m back at work and he goes to daycare funded by adult social care at a cost of £2000 a week! How does that make any sense?

I would happily care for him myself but I also need to pay my bills. A quarter of what he is currently costing the LA would mean I could afford to care for him and they would save a small fortune.

Miffee · 10/08/2022 17:46

Stripyhoglets1 · 10/08/2022 17:21

Care costs. If you need care then your savings account and house should be exempt up to a certain value. I think 100k but maybe more.
Then you fund with any assets you gave over that.
Much fairer than the tory proposal that you pay the first 100k and your family get whats left - so in north often nothing much as houses worth alot less. And better than the current situation where everything over 25k is used up.

Care for adults and children should be run by local authorities with no place for people to make any profit.

As should health

And schools for that matter!

It's 86k and it's not a proposal anymore, it's happening in Oct 23.

Stripyhoglets1 · 10/08/2022 17:42

I thought of that but alot of people needing care now won't have paid vast sums for housing - its value will be from house price rises.

No way is ideal - and some people will never need care and can pass on the lot - but I think that an initial sum of assets being ineligible being the same for everyone is fairer.

dreamingofsun · 10/08/2022 17:37

stripy - not sure i agree with your north/south view. just because you live in the north and have been lucky enough to have cheap housing why should you pay less than someone in the south who has had to pay a massive mortgage the whole of their working life to live in a shoe box? everyone should pay the same - public sector wages are the same nationally......you cant have it one way when it suits you.

Stripyhoglets1 · 10/08/2022 17:21

Care costs. If you need care then your savings account and house should be exempt up to a certain value. I think 100k but maybe more.
Then you fund with any assets you gave over that.
Much fairer than the tory proposal that you pay the first 100k and your family get whats left - so in north often nothing much as houses worth alot less. And better than the current situation where everything over 25k is used up.

Care for adults and children should be run by local authorities with no place for people to make any profit.

As should health

And schools for that matter!

Crumpleton · 10/08/2022 17:12

I remember during school we would visit residents in care homes, they had some stories.

But like everyone even the government only have a certain amount of money in the pot to go round and IMO it doesn't always go to the right places.

Bordem got the better of me last week and I Googled how much is the government's expenditure it's a massive amount and rising year on year.
Unfortunately it'll be the working tax payer that'll have to suffer if more money needs to be found, and for some it'll only be a matter of time before they realise the'd probably be better off not working....
But that's another thread.

Miffee · 10/08/2022 17:03

Underhisi · 10/08/2022 17:01

"Would it be a mean suggestion for council run homes for foster children or is that backwards and inhumane?"

Children who do not live with foster carers will have specific needs. They are in privately run residential accommodation because the council doesn't have anything to meet their needs. It's the same reason why independent special schools exist frequently with attached care homes.

The councils aren't supposed to have anything to meet their needs. Their job is to foster a private market not directly support people.

And if that sounds like a terrible idea that will surely lead to disaster... yes. Yes it is.

Underhisi · 10/08/2022 17:01

"Would it be a mean suggestion for council run homes for foster children or is that backwards and inhumane?"

Children who do not live with foster carers will have specific needs. They are in privately run residential accommodation because the council doesn't have anything to meet their needs. It's the same reason why independent special schools exist frequently with attached care homes.

KatieB55 · 10/08/2022 16:53

Miffee · 10/08/2022 14:58

Nationalise care providers.

Agreed. Panorama showed big profits going to companies registered overseas whilst care homes being run on as few staff as possible on minimum wage.

fallfallfall · 10/08/2022 16:52

@AdultsSocialCare elders in care have paid a lifelong of taxes. Generally they only spend the last 18 months of their life in a facility. That care when delivered costs approximately the equivalent to their monthly pension. There is a healthy profit margin.
remember they are not paying heating for the entire facility alone all costs once divided is not really over the money they collect.

HelloThereObiWan · 10/08/2022 16:49

We need a cultural change with regards to our attitude to social care.

I work for Adult Social Services. Too many times I see cases where an elderly person has declined a care package because us "robbing bastards" want them to pay for it, arguing that they shouldn't have to because they've "paid the stamp" etc.

The truth is, that unless you are a higher rate tax payer your entire life it's unlikely that you've paid enough taxes etc to cover all of the services that you have benefited from. And before you argue that you personally have never used the NHS blah blah blah, try to remember that you've also benefited from our police and security forces keeping you safe, the council and highways agency keeping you moving, the council and other agencies keeping your environment clean, etc.

The result is that people carry on without care until their case becomes more complex, requiring greater intervention (more ££), which perhaps could have been avoided if they had taken the initial package.

We therefore need to rethink how we regard care. We put money aside for rainy days, for when our houses need repairs etc. We need to put money aside to pay for our care or we need to agree to pay more taxes. Whether those taxes come from individual workers or companies etc is another debate, but we can't expect to be able to have a good quality care system if we're not prepared to pay for it somehow.

That way, we can spend more money attracting good quality workers into the profession, instead of paying minimum wage for back breaking work and being shocked when people quit and recruitment is difficult. Training needs to improve so that there is the availablity of career progression if you want to attract more young people into the roles.

Miffee · 10/08/2022 16:40

dreamingofsun · 10/08/2022 16:36

meredintof - interesting suggestion ref healthcare. Wouldnt that mean a lot of people having to use all their savings/house equity in their sixties though when they may live another 25 years? And having spent 40 years working their guts out want to enjoy life a little with some of their savings first.

I was thinking more in terms of why my son who lives in one room of a shared house with no hope of buying anywhere, should pay higher tax. so that someone can pass on their 5 bed house to someone rather than paying for care home fees.

Yes. That ls the system Boris just announced and nobody batted an eyelid.

Miffee · 10/08/2022 16:39

AdultsSocialCare · 10/08/2022 16:35

If everything coming back into council control / nationalisation would stop people making a profit from social care and allow the local government to control their own costs, why isn't this being done?

Money. People are making money. The people making money have influence.

A lot of care services are own by private equity firms. These firms have very close links with politicians, they either fund them, bribe them, hire them or in some cases literally are them.

dreamingofsun · 10/08/2022 16:36

meredintof - interesting suggestion ref healthcare. Wouldnt that mean a lot of people having to use all their savings/house equity in their sixties though when they may live another 25 years? And having spent 40 years working their guts out want to enjoy life a little with some of their savings first.

I was thinking more in terms of why my son who lives in one room of a shared house with no hope of buying anywhere, should pay higher tax. so that someone can pass on their 5 bed house to someone rather than paying for care home fees.