Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what we do to help with the cost of social care?

215 replies

AdultsSocialCare · 10/08/2022 14:25

Adult and childrens social care takes up the majority of all council tax spend. This leaves a small amount for everything else that councils do.

What is the solution?

I feel like ultimately the central government need to give more money to councils but the chance of that has to be next to nil.

So, what else?

OP posts:
PollyRockets · 16/08/2022 15:51

Legalising euthanasia

Sounds mean but we can't support our ageing population the way things are now

Friars23 · 16/08/2022 15:50

dreamingofsun, exactly what kind of utilility company were you working at? Thanks.

dreamingofsun · 16/08/2022 13:35

I worked for a utility company that had been privatised. You cannot assume that privatisation is always bad. Pre-privatisation you had to go on a waiting list for our services and there was no innovation at all. Workers skived off regularly and many didnt look that good at their jobs anyway. Post privatisation they were much more efficient, innovative and the service for customers was far superior.

StickyFloor · 16/08/2022 01:33

Madwife123 · 10/08/2022 17:51

Paying relatives to care for their own family would help for one!

I gave up my job to care for my severely disabled (now adult) son. £69 a week is what I was expected to live on!

So now I’m back at work and he goes to daycare funded by adult social care at a cost of £2000 a week! How does that make any sense?

I would happily care for him myself but I also need to pay my bills. A quarter of what he is currently costing the LA would mean I could afford to care for him and they would save a small fortune.

THIS is so important to address this.

There are so many totally unpaid carers, or carers relying on £69pw, which is not sustainable. But when free family care eventually breaks down because nobody can do that indefinitely then the Council may find themselves paying for the care at a much higher rate.

Our council have now set a weekly budget of £2700 for dd but I’ve been doing it for nothing doe years at cost to my career, health and finances.

It would save money and rescue families to pay family member carers somewhere sensible between £69 pw and £2700pw!

Secondly, The provision of care needs to be put back directly into Council hands. The construct of private care homes and care agencies provides massive profits for those companies and strangles individuals and Councils.

Our £2700 budget is based on an hourly rate of £16 but we can’t find private carers willing to do the job. Private agencies have carers available but demand £25ph or more. If we can’t find people within our budget then the Council are obliged to provide someone regardless of cost anyway. The carers aren’t receiving that £25 so the Council is directly handing out money to profit private companies.

PorkPieandPickle · 15/08/2022 13:38

Social care system -> privatised -> broken
gas and electric companies -> privatised -> broken
water companies -> privatised -> broken
train travel -> privatised -> broken

gosh it’s almost like when profit becomes the number one priority it screws stuff up, who knew 🤔

Wingedharpy · 15/08/2022 12:10

Wingedharpy · 14/08/2022 14:03

This sounds like a good idea @Plantstrees .

I've often wondered if there could be some sort of reciprocal arrangement between an elderly person, living alone, just needing a bit of help with shopping, housework, gardening, companionship etc (though not personal care!) in exchange for free accommodation.

I'm not sure how you would police that though to ensure a vulnerable elderly person wasn't being fleeced or that the free lodger wasn't being used as a personal slave.

It seems I'm not the only one who thought the help/companionship in exchange for accommodation was a good idea.
It already exists and is called "Helpful Housemates".

Crumpleton · 14/08/2022 15:42

I remember my Grandma looking after her GC if needed while her DC worked and in turns as she aged her DC and GC looking after her. But in today's world with a growing elderly population a lot of family members have no choice but to work FT in order to pay the bills. Equally due to lack of real affordable housing in areas where they've grown up families are forced to live miles away from their parents so it's impossible to be able to be available at the drop of a hat.

Wingedharpy · 14/08/2022 14:03

Plantstrees · 10/08/2022 15:27

I watched a documentary a while ago about a place in Holland where university students were given free housing in nursing homes. It appeared to work really well. www.vitainternational.media/en/interview/2018/05/29/the-nursing-home-offering-free-housing-to-students/41/

This sounds like a good idea @Plantstrees .

I've often wondered if there could be some sort of reciprocal arrangement between an elderly person, living alone, just needing a bit of help with shopping, housework, gardening, companionship etc (though not personal care!) in exchange for free accommodation.

I'm not sure how you would police that though to ensure a vulnerable elderly person wasn't being fleeced or that the free lodger wasn't being used as a personal slave.

Friars23 · 14/08/2022 13:24

Sugarplumfairy65 · 14/08/2022 11:12

This is untrue. I gave up my full time job to care for my mother in law with the agreement of social services. She was in receipt of direct payments at the time but neither them or I could find a care company or home who could give her the level and type of care she needed. She needed a hoist and was bedbound so we employed someone else to come in 4 times per day to help me hoist her.
I took a small salary drop but that was balanced out by no commuting costs and it worked out cheaper for social services than a specialist home.

That’s good to hear it can be possible. Like Madwife I was told when I started Direct Payments that I could not employ relatives. Sounds like there could be discretion but the blanket rule is no for my county.

Direct Payments is an excellent scheme for my needs and it’s much cheaper than using an agency. It’s not often schemes are good but i credit the people who designed it. The scheme doesn’t suit everybody but as said for those it does it works really well.

gatehouseoffleet · 14/08/2022 13:11

I think 2 weeks work experience for year 11's could be in a care home for an extra GCSE, credits for Uni, vouchers etc

Definitely not. Who would want a resentful 15 or 16 year old looking after them? Care should be properly paid for those who want to do it and will do it well.

There is something to be said for the granny annexe idea but then people will benefit from that once the person has died, so they don't really need the financial help (and if the elderly person is selling a house, they can afford to pay for the granny annexe anyway, you might need some sort of low cost bridging loan).

Bottom line is that we all need to pay more tax and the tax needs to go to pay for decent public services including preventative healthcare.

No silly tinkering at the edges.

christmas2022 · 14/08/2022 12:40

reesewithoutaspoon · 14/08/2022 11:33

Councils used to run daycare for the elderly. Clients would be picked up and brought to the centre. They had company, activities, visiting chiropodist and hairdresser. Staff would bathe those who needed it. A hot meal and drinks. That was ended and now people sit alone at home with visiting carers who appear for 30 minutes. Families could cope with caring for their relatives because they could continue to work and they got respite. Now the option seems to be manage at home or full time residential. It's a shame they were closed,

That is a shame.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 14/08/2022 11:33

Madwife123 · 10/08/2022 20:05

@Miffee Well regardless that’s the policy of my LA and as such they would rather pay a private company £2000 a week to care for my 19 year son, likely for the rest of his life. Then financially support me to stay at home and care for him myself for a fraction of the cost. Literally all they offered me was £69 a week. Totally not liveable!

You can appeal against this and ask for your son to be awarded direct payments with you employed as his full time carer. I know because ive done it.
It took some fighting for but they agreed it was the best solution in the end.

reesewithoutaspoon · 14/08/2022 11:33

Councils used to run daycare for the elderly. Clients would be picked up and brought to the centre. They had company, activities, visiting chiropodist and hairdresser. Staff would bathe those who needed it. A hot meal and drinks. That was ended and now people sit alone at home with visiting carers who appear for 30 minutes. Families could cope with caring for their relatives because they could continue to work and they got respite. Now the option seems to be manage at home or full time residential. It's a shame they were closed,

dreamingofsun · 14/08/2022 11:29

Surely what you would have to pay someone to look after a relative would depend partly on the job they were leaving to do it? I couldnt have afforded to give up work to look after my mother - i would have needed at least 40k and a guarantee that my employer would take me back afterwards (I live in a low paying area in the south with few job opportunities)

Dalaidramailama · 14/08/2022 11:23

Chuckling to myself at sending GCSE students into a care home 😂😂😂

Good luck to them with the personal care and using the slings and hoists safely. LOL

Sugarplumfairy65 · 14/08/2022 11:21

christmas2022 · 14/08/2022 10:20

What would the cost difference be do you think if we paid relatives to care rather than say be in a care home?

When I cared for my mother in law, social services saved around £300 per week. She did need 24/7 care though. I did the majority of care but my husband who had retired did the cooking and all her washing, which was at least 2 loads per day. He was also the first to get up with her during the night and only woke me if she needed personal care.
The direct payments also covered 4 weeks respite per year but unfortunately we never found anywhere that could take her.
We only did it for 2 years until she died though. I'm not sure how much longer we would have managed without respite.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 14/08/2022 11:12

Madwife123 · 10/08/2022 18:39

@Miffee Direct payments are used to pay other people to care for your child. They cannot be paid to a relative of the person receiving the care. So yet again it costs the LA far far more to pay someone else to do a job I could do if I was given the financial support to do it.

This is untrue. I gave up my full time job to care for my mother in law with the agreement of social services. She was in receipt of direct payments at the time but neither them or I could find a care company or home who could give her the level and type of care she needed. She needed a hoist and was bedbound so we employed someone else to come in 4 times per day to help me hoist her.
I took a small salary drop but that was balanced out by no commuting costs and it worked out cheaper for social services than a specialist home.

Spikeyball · 14/08/2022 10:49

"What would the cost difference be do you think if we paid relatives to care rather than say be in a care home?"

At what point will caring for a family member ( either receiving carers allowance or not if you earn too much or if the care is provided by multiple people) cross over into becoming a paid carer for your family member? That will make a difference to the overall cost.

Spikeyball · 14/08/2022 10:31

The people I know who are looking at care homes for relatives are doing it because the 24/7 care required is too much for relatives to do.

christmas2022 · 14/08/2022 10:20

What would the cost difference be do you think if we paid relatives to care rather than say be in a care home?

loopylum · 14/08/2022 09:05

Plantstrees · 13/08/2022 17:09

I do think this is the way forward. Young people used to look after their older relatives but now they just push them into homes. It is very sad. I agree that we should be incentivising families to look after their own relatives at home for as long as possible.

It was young women, and now we have full time jobs so can't look after our relatives.

Plantstrees · 13/08/2022 17:09

Madwife123 · 10/08/2022 17:51

Paying relatives to care for their own family would help for one!

I gave up my job to care for my severely disabled (now adult) son. £69 a week is what I was expected to live on!

So now I’m back at work and he goes to daycare funded by adult social care at a cost of £2000 a week! How does that make any sense?

I would happily care for him myself but I also need to pay my bills. A quarter of what he is currently costing the LA would mean I could afford to care for him and they would save a small fortune.

I do think this is the way forward. Young people used to look after their older relatives but now they just push them into homes. It is very sad. I agree that we should be incentivising families to look after their own relatives at home for as long as possible.

anniegun · 12/08/2022 17:36

Stop privately owned care homes taking money out of the system. The government could take over the running of them and save the profit element. Offer visas to anyone who will come to this country to work as care givers. Tax inheritance/gifts to children (above a certain level) as income and remove all the ways that people avoid this tax currently

Friars23 · 12/08/2022 17:29

I saw this wild statistic today from the Financial Times. Social care funding is still below 2010 levels while the population it serves has grown by more than 60%.

To ask what we do to help with the cost of social care?
fallfallfall · 10/08/2022 21:54

the cost of antisocial behavior and crime in the uk is equally 50 billion.