Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel increasingly alienated by Tory voters?

358 replies

BarmyBrunhilde · 10/08/2022 14:11

I am in despair as to where our country is at. With the cost of living crisis looming (and already beginning), this winter is going to be brutal and likely life ending for so many in the UK, and the current aspiring leadership of the Tory party seem to be more interested in litigating culture wars and appeasing NIMBY pensioners in the Home countries than actually addressing any of the serious problems in the UK.

I've never been a Tory voter, but I've always been able to get along with people who have different views (provided they aren't racist/homophobic etc). But how anyone could see all the misery and deprivation on the horizon, look at the prospective leaders and frontbenchers with their complete lack of sultions, and continue with supporting them is genuinely beyond me. I find myself slowly being consumed by bitterness and rage against people for their views, and it frightens me. Am I alone in this?

OP posts:
Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 17:39

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 17:34

Well up until my last pay packet I did. It'll now be £25000 after pension deductions.Labour's plans would take a further £1000, which I don't think is unfair at all. It still leaves the vast majority in my pocket. If Labour then improved the NHS so that I didn't have to pay privately for some of the medical care my kids have received, or gave students a fairer loan system and rate of tax there, or ensured that my parents received better social care, I'd be happy with that. Twelve years of the Tories have shown me that they are very much not going to do any of these things. Time for a change.

So after saying you pay 18k tax which is not a 6 figure salary which you then claim to earn. You then roughly work out the tax burden for 100k bang on. Yeah ok. Come back once you’ve hit 60% and then 45% and talk about the tax burden. 6 figure salary indeed.

Fluffyboo · 10/08/2022 17:37

Also are you really suggesting that everyone secretly agrees with you? I don't talk about trans issues pretty much ever, so how would they know what a terribly 'capture handmaid' I am, in order to censor themselves?

To be fair an awful lot of people won't talk about it, even with people they are close to, for fear of being labelled as a 'terf' and the pitchforks coming out. Unless people do openly talk about their views then often it's just not worth the risk

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 17:34

Well up until my last pay packet I did. It'll now be £25000 after pension deductions.Labour's plans would take a further £1000, which I don't think is unfair at all. It still leaves the vast majority in my pocket. If Labour then improved the NHS so that I didn't have to pay privately for some of the medical care my kids have received, or gave students a fairer loan system and rate of tax there, or ensured that my parents received better social care, I'd be happy with that. Twelve years of the Tories have shown me that they are very much not going to do any of these things. Time for a change.

stopringingme · 10/08/2022 17:33

Whatkindoflifeisthis · 10/08/2022 17:30

I vote who I vote for and other people can vote who they wish to vote for. Everyone has the right, in a democratic society, to vote for who they wish. And long may that continue. I'm not that self important to get annoyed or angry because people dare to vote differently to me.

Well said - I agree with every word.

Whatkindoflifeisthis · 10/08/2022 17:30

I vote who I vote for and other people can vote who they wish to vote for. Everyone has the right, in a democratic society, to vote for who they wish. And long may that continue. I'm not that self important to get annoyed or angry because people dare to vote differently to me.

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 17:30

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 17:28

As it happens I started the new job this month so not completely sure what tax will be - the £18000 was for the previous post.
I don't think that 1% of six figure salaries, however, is particularly out of kilter with salaries in other countries and the percentage of those earning at that level.

So you don’t. Didn’t think so as that’s way off what someone on six figures pays in tax. The salaries are really that off which why we will be emigrating.

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 17:28

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 17:24

You said you paid 18k tax per year? That’s no where near six figure salary amounts.

I’ll rephrase, most people with talent and up to date skill sets are leaving. Think engineering and tech and nothing is keeping them here.

As it happens I started the new job this month so not completely sure what tax will be - the £18000 was for the previous post.
I don't think that 1% of six figure salaries, however, is particularly out of kilter with salaries in other countries and the percentage of those earning at that level.

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 17:25

BarmyBrunhilde · 10/08/2022 17:21

No it isn't actually, there could be all kinds of reasons for that. Until you provide evidence (which I doubt you can) I would encourage all to remain sceptical of that claim.

Remain sceptical. You just want to post hate all over the internet about people you know nothing about. It’s out of order Ps, I’m a labour voter.

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 17:24

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 17:21

Most don't leave at all. I am on a six-figure salary and would be happy to have paid what Labour proposed which was 45% on anything over £80000. That would have been only a small amount more over the year. I think people are happy to pay tax if they can see that the money is being invested fairly and wisely. Under the Tories over the last twelve years it very much has not been.

You said you paid 18k tax per year? That’s no where near six figure salary amounts.

I’ll rephrase, most people with talent and up to date skill sets are leaving. Think engineering and tech and nothing is keeping them here.

BarmyBrunhilde · 10/08/2022 17:21

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 17:20

The very fact that they make up less than 1% of earners is pretty obvious enough.

No it isn't actually, there could be all kinds of reasons for that. Until you provide evidence (which I doubt you can) I would encourage all to remain sceptical of that claim.

OP posts:
Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 17:21

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 17:17

Those on 100k already pay 60% tax which is why most leave.

Most don't leave at all. I am on a six-figure salary and would be happy to have paid what Labour proposed which was 45% on anything over £80000. That would have been only a small amount more over the year. I think people are happy to pay tax if they can see that the money is being invested fairly and wisely. Under the Tories over the last twelve years it very much has not been.

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 17:20

BarmyBrunhilde · 10/08/2022 17:19

Can you give a reliable citation for the statement that most Brits earning 100k leave the country?

The very fact that they make up less than 1% of earners is pretty obvious enough.

BarmyBrunhilde · 10/08/2022 17:19

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 17:17

Those on 100k already pay 60% tax which is why most leave.

Can you give a reliable citation for the statement that most Brits earning 100k leave the country?

OP posts:
BarmyBrunhilde · 10/08/2022 17:18

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 17:16

You’ve completely ignored all my posts until now. 70k-80k isn’t a high salary when tax burdens are considered. Especially in in demand industries such at tech and engineering. One example I can give is 150k here vs 750k+ abroad. Labour would lose all talent left in this country. We are a low wage, high tax country. The people quoted already pay 25% of all income tax and they are leaving. They won’t be around to tax anymore. The Conservatives are doing a good enough job with losing talent in this country as it is.

It all started with Labour and their crazy state funding and subsidising income from CTC/WTC. It has bred a generation of poor salaries and state reliance on top up. It’s not as simple as the Tories are all bad and some of the posts on these threads are turning into hate territory. We have a govt who are asleep at the wheel and Labour are partly responsible. That’s past decisions and they too are an opposition asleep at the wheel. They have also alienated a lot of their voters. So yeah, they are all to blame, it’s not a Tory thing. It’s an issue across the whole country, their sense of entitlement and poor political parties.

When Labour were suggesting this policy in 2017, 80k put you in the top 5% of salaries. And salaries certainly won't be high if the majority of the population have not disposable income because they are crippled by bills - that's how a recession starts!

OP posts:
Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 17:17

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 17:09

But Labour is suggesting taxes on the energy companies which could then be used to subsidise ordinary taxpayers.
They are suggesting more taxes on those over £`100000 - they aren't targetting people struggling on 40% tax on £50000.
They are suggesting closing the tax loopholes so that the likes of JRM would pay tax. Of course those with the broadest shoulders should pay more. Most of us would be far better off.
I just don't understand why people keep complaining about the tax burden right now and then continuing to say that we have to keep voting Tory because there are no other ideas. Labour has been asking for windfall taxes for ages now and talking about how they'd tax the very wealthy. That's not extra tax for most of us.

Those on 100k already pay 60% tax which is why most leave.

BarmyBrunhilde · 10/08/2022 17:16

@Fluffyboo If you had read my comments, you would have seen that I said I had friends who voted in 2019, and while I disagreed I could accept their position. It's those who continue to express support for the government who I made this post about.

OP posts:
Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 17:16

BarmyBrunhilde · 10/08/2022 17:07

'They have had enough' but the Tories have been in power for 12 years? Labour have only suggested higher tax rates for salaries of 70-80k (and then was when inflation was a lot lower than it is now). So it doesn't track to suggest that people scraping on just over 50k are somehow going to disproportionately suffer under Labour.

You’ve completely ignored all my posts until now. 70k-80k isn’t a high salary when tax burdens are considered. Especially in in demand industries such at tech and engineering. One example I can give is 150k here vs 750k+ abroad. Labour would lose all talent left in this country. We are a low wage, high tax country. The people quoted already pay 25% of all income tax and they are leaving. They won’t be around to tax anymore. The Conservatives are doing a good enough job with losing talent in this country as it is.

It all started with Labour and their crazy state funding and subsidising income from CTC/WTC. It has bred a generation of poor salaries and state reliance on top up. It’s not as simple as the Tories are all bad and some of the posts on these threads are turning into hate territory. We have a govt who are asleep at the wheel and Labour are partly responsible. That’s past decisions and they too are an opposition asleep at the wheel. They have also alienated a lot of their voters. So yeah, they are all to blame, it’s not a Tory thing. It’s an issue across the whole country, their sense of entitlement and poor political parties.

Fluffyboo · 10/08/2022 17:15

But I'm not sure if people are missing the level of crisis that we're headed for? Are people continue supporting a government which won't support people (most of whom will be in work) being able heat their homes and feed their children? This is going to affect many many more people than I think people understand, and even those who broadly consider themselves comfortably off are going to be facing a nasty squeeze and some really tough decisions come 2023. And how long will we put up with it?

Unless I missed it there hasn't been a general election since covid started, the cost of living crisis started escalating and the war in Ukraine began. So it's a bit disingenuous to act like people knew all this would happen when they voted and voted accordingly.

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 17:09

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 17:05

The tax burden is huge and more and more people are now sucked into paying 40% tax. Some of these families are just scraping by and would be better off on benefits. The solution of labour , ops on threads like this and enough is enough? Tax them more to pay for all of this spending. I’m not disagreeing things seemed better a while ago but people have to pay for it. 90% of the tax burden falls on 50% of the tax payers (not even the population as a whole) they have had enough which is why the Tories will keep getting in. Especially as the opposition is totally useless. They should be wiping the floor with the govt.

But Labour is suggesting taxes on the energy companies which could then be used to subsidise ordinary taxpayers.
They are suggesting more taxes on those over £`100000 - they aren't targetting people struggling on 40% tax on £50000.
They are suggesting closing the tax loopholes so that the likes of JRM would pay tax. Of course those with the broadest shoulders should pay more. Most of us would be far better off.
I just don't understand why people keep complaining about the tax burden right now and then continuing to say that we have to keep voting Tory because there are no other ideas. Labour has been asking for windfall taxes for ages now and talking about how they'd tax the very wealthy. That's not extra tax for most of us.

BarmyBrunhilde · 10/08/2022 17:07

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 17:05

The tax burden is huge and more and more people are now sucked into paying 40% tax. Some of these families are just scraping by and would be better off on benefits. The solution of labour , ops on threads like this and enough is enough? Tax them more to pay for all of this spending. I’m not disagreeing things seemed better a while ago but people have to pay for it. 90% of the tax burden falls on 50% of the tax payers (not even the population as a whole) they have had enough which is why the Tories will keep getting in. Especially as the opposition is totally useless. They should be wiping the floor with the govt.

'They have had enough' but the Tories have been in power for 12 years? Labour have only suggested higher tax rates for salaries of 70-80k (and then was when inflation was a lot lower than it is now). So it doesn't track to suggest that people scraping on just over 50k are somehow going to disproportionately suffer under Labour.

OP posts:
BigDayToday · 10/08/2022 17:06

Lindasllama · 10/08/2022 16:58

This corrupt, incompetent shit show is the best you think we've got when no one else has had a chance is TWELVE YEARS ??? My goodness you have a limited imagination !

No, that's not what I said.

I really hope there's something better to vote for by the time the election comes around. Unfortunately Labour, Lib dems and Greens are currently as unacceptable to me as the Conservatives. There are a couple of smaller parties which might be interesting but are they just a 'wasted vote'? I'm not sure.

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 17:05

Squiblet · 10/08/2022 17:02

Whereas I wish they would tax us MORE. Underfunding of public services (especially salaries) in this country is shocking.

I'd agree if the money went to public services as opposed to being squandered.
It's this sort of thing over and over again with this lot:

4-billion-of-unusable-ppe-bought-in-first-year-of-pandemic-will-be-burnt-to-generate-power

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 17:05

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 16:54

But taxes haven't gone down in the last twelve years, have they? [disclaimer - I worked abroad and came back only in 2010, so am prepared to be corrected.] I find the tax burden here pretty huge - income tax plus national insurance plus council tax. And I think what one gets in return is absolutely paltry. At least under Labour there were decent public services. When I compare my sister's experience of hospital when giving birth and my own in a horribly underfunded health system elsewhere I really thought Labour were getting things right. They helped my stepchildren stay in school by giving them a small grant in sixth form to help the family finances, and now they are paying back by working as a nurse and a teacher. There isn't anything like that now.I brought my children back to the UK because I thought they'd be well educated in the state system, and for the first few years they were. Then I had to take them out of school and home-ed them because their experiences were so dreadful.

The tax burden is huge and more and more people are now sucked into paying 40% tax. Some of these families are just scraping by and would be better off on benefits. The solution of labour , ops on threads like this and enough is enough? Tax them more to pay for all of this spending. I’m not disagreeing things seemed better a while ago but people have to pay for it. 90% of the tax burden falls on 50% of the tax payers (not even the population as a whole) they have had enough which is why the Tories will keep getting in. Especially as the opposition is totally useless. They should be wiping the floor with the govt.

Muminabun · 10/08/2022 17:03

UWhatNow · 10/08/2022 16:43

“'Captured handmaid', dear me I didn't realise thinking manufactured culture wars about 'chest feeding' are less important than basic utilities for the UK population would put me in such low esteem!”

The point is when political parties lose grip on the basic existential realities of what it even means to be a woman then how are you going to trust them on basic utilities.

I’m not saying the tories are perfect - the whole country is a shit show - but where is my vote going? To parties who have come out definitively and decidedly to say men are actually women and should have to same treatment? Like labour? Like Lib Dem? Like the Greens? Women locked up in prison with men. Women excluded from rape support centres because the feelings of men are more important. Men in female hospital wards. Young school girls being groomed to not complain about male bodied classmates in their changing rooms and residential trips. Medical interventions on children without informed consent. Etc etc. These things are not insignificant and ‘fringe’.

You tell me who I’m supposed to vote for.

This. Starmer made himself look like a weak, lying, laughing stock when he was unable/refused to define half the electorate.

Squiblet · 10/08/2022 17:02

HotCaterpillar · 10/08/2022 16:26

Yabu. I'm just hoping for some tax cuts. Taxing people at 40 or 50% of income is theft, let people take responsibility for their own lives.

Whereas I wish they would tax us MORE. Underfunding of public services (especially salaries) in this country is shocking.