Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel increasingly alienated by Tory voters?

358 replies

BarmyBrunhilde · 10/08/2022 14:11

I am in despair as to where our country is at. With the cost of living crisis looming (and already beginning), this winter is going to be brutal and likely life ending for so many in the UK, and the current aspiring leadership of the Tory party seem to be more interested in litigating culture wars and appeasing NIMBY pensioners in the Home countries than actually addressing any of the serious problems in the UK.

I've never been a Tory voter, but I've always been able to get along with people who have different views (provided they aren't racist/homophobic etc). But how anyone could see all the misery and deprivation on the horizon, look at the prospective leaders and frontbenchers with their complete lack of sultions, and continue with supporting them is genuinely beyond me. I find myself slowly being consumed by bitterness and rage against people for their views, and it frightens me. Am I alone in this?

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 10/08/2022 19:19

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 19:13

quincey I was looking at this chart re inflation, which seems to have reputable sources

Cheers midnight. Will take a look.

Quincythequince · 10/08/2022 19:18

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 18:56

I don't think that the Dutch prices have risen by more than 70% though, have they? My point was that our prices have gone up by more than 200 % [to date] whereas in the rest of Europe prices have not risen by as much, though I grant you that they may have been higher to start with.

I think Because we had massive discounts due to the sheer number of supplier and market competition here to begin with, we paid A LOT less. Hence why so many companies went tits up because they didn’t hedge properly and thought we’d always have cheap cheap gas!

We have paid much less than other countries for much longer. I have a large multi-bedroom detached house and my dual fuel bills were <£150 per month. Insane! Not realistic to continue really is it.

Should have been managed better for sure many moons ago (not strictly a Tory problem), but it wasn’t. The increases are awful, but the absolute household costs aren’t worse.
We get <5% our gas from Russia, Germany circa 50%.

In many ways it has been managed better than other places in terms of non-reliance on Russia, but not in terms of the last year.

It’s bad I agree and people will suffer, which is sickening and I am genuinely thinking about ways so can help those less fortunate than me, because I am in a better position. But don’t tell me it wouldn’t be any different under Labour.

And what do you think immediate taxation (if they were to even implement it) on the energy companies is actually going to do for the man on the street right now!

Nothing.

Labour blowing hot air because it’s easy to do so from the other side.

We have a shite government, and a shite opposition and like so many, I am politically homeless because there are no good choices.

Smellywellyhoo · 10/08/2022 19:14

The Tories hate the working class and below. It's that simple. They always will. People vote for them because they don't care about that.

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 19:13

quincey I was looking at this chart re inflation, which seems to have reputable sources

To feel increasingly alienated by Tory voters?
Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 19:09

Festoonlights · 10/08/2022 19:05

This is classic!
So do you think Labour would have found other more ethical contractors? And somehow they would do so without any favour ( even forgetting the huge fight globally for PPE) You are living in cloud cuckkoo land.

Have you actually seen Starmers very long list of sports tickets and ‘gifts’?

A response wins 'classic' status very easily these days.
Yes - I do think Labour would have found more ethical contractors because I think they would have employed people who actually had experience in the field.
I don't think we would have seen headlines like this:
www.ft.com/content/740aa990-9bed-4cd3-b75b-0a5ce50b55c8

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 19:05

Boybandfacedfannyfart · 10/08/2022 18:59

Ok, maybe the table was difficult to understand:

August 21 - €1497
august 22 - €5178

Shall I do the maths for you too?

OK - stand corrected. Didn't read properly.

Festoonlights · 10/08/2022 19:05

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 19:01

Well I think that the hope was that by longer down sooner and harder, we actually wouldn't be locking down for so long, which wasn't a stupid idea at the time, I don't think. But the reason really that I think we'd have been better off under Labour with regard to the pandemic is that the Tories gave so many PPE contracts and Test and Trace contracts to people who should never have had them, and that cost billions. Not wasting those billions would have put us in a better state, I think.
I also don't agree that it minimises the issue. I can see that it's annoying, because I find it irritating when people say things like 'Can you imagine how much worse it would be under Labour?' But I think it's right that the ruling party should be held to account for how it performed, and I think it performed abysmally really. I also think that the EU offering to delay the full implementation of Brexit because of the pandemic was an opportunity that should have been snatched, so that we wouldn't have been facing all these hits at once.

This is classic!
So do you think Labour would have found other more ethical contractors? And somehow they would do so without any favour ( even forgetting the huge fight globally for PPE) You are living in cloud cuckkoo land.

Have you actually seen Starmers very long list of sports tickets and ‘gifts’?

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 19:01

Quincythequince · 10/08/2022 18:53

And I agree we are in for troubled times, but it’s incredibly simplistic to suggest that we wouldn’t be here if we had a Labour Government.

It’s actually annoying to read this, and playing party politics with a global problem is minimising the issue.

Labour wanted to lockdown faster and for longer apparently and do the exact opposite of the the Tories, not to mention his non-view on Brexit. Please tell me how this would have put us in a better state than we are now.

Well I think that the hope was that by longer down sooner and harder, we actually wouldn't be locking down for so long, which wasn't a stupid idea at the time, I don't think. But the reason really that I think we'd have been better off under Labour with regard to the pandemic is that the Tories gave so many PPE contracts and Test and Trace contracts to people who should never have had them, and that cost billions. Not wasting those billions would have put us in a better state, I think.
I also don't agree that it minimises the issue. I can see that it's annoying, because I find it irritating when people say things like 'Can you imagine how much worse it would be under Labour?' But I think it's right that the ruling party should be held to account for how it performed, and I think it performed abysmally really. I also think that the EU offering to delay the full implementation of Brexit because of the pandemic was an opportunity that should have been snatched, so that we wouldn't have been facing all these hits at once.

Festoonlights · 10/08/2022 18:59

I couldn’t get past the drama lama first line…. Life ending?? Its going to be tough in the short term, but medium to long term looks fine. Fuel prices will start to come down shortly. You can make your point without being so overly dramatic. We don’t live in Siberia!

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 18:59

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 18:53

I've said far more than two things on this thread. We will just have to disagree about whether 60% is unacceptable. You were the one who said that people earning six figure salaries were leaving and were unable to provide any evidence of this, despite several posters asking you to do so. I don't think that I did imply that I paid 60% tax at all - my point was rather that it is possible to earn six figures and NOT pay 60% tax. I am a case in point. I'm glad that's all that is you have to say though and wish you well as you emigrate.

It’s not, it’s because you barely, literally just scrape in. Don’t worry though anyone over 60% then pays 45% but you wouldn’t know if you’re on 75k or 99k whichever the truth is.

Boybandfacedfannyfart · 10/08/2022 18:59

Ok, maybe the table was difficult to understand:

August 21 - €1497
august 22 - €5178

Shall I do the maths for you too?

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 18:56

Boybandfacedfannyfart · 10/08/2022 18:50

@Midnightblack im afraid your assertion re 70% simply isn’t true. Now, I’m not going to assume you can read Dutch - but scroll down to the bottom table and you should be able to understand 2021 vs 2022.

www.energievergelijk.nl/nieuws/nederlandse-huishoudens-betalen-nu-hoogste-gasprijs-in-europa

(quick and dirty headline translation - Dutch households now paying the highest gas price in Europe)

I don't think that the Dutch prices have risen by more than 70% though, have they? My point was that our prices have gone up by more than 200 % [to date] whereas in the rest of Europe prices have not risen by as much, though I grant you that they may have been higher to start with.

Deguster · 10/08/2022 18:54

@Midnightblack I used to think Lammy was great, but he made a bit of an arse of himself over twaw nonsense, calling women “dinosaurs” then (iirc) tried to redeem himself by making a big play about women’s rights, then got extremely arsey with the BBC when he was quizzed about “issues that constituents don’t care about”…. basically just playing to the choir, not making any attempt to reconcile his apparently conflicting positions.

Thornberry made an absolute arse of herself by tweeting a picture of a white van and St George cross flags as a sneering “omg look at this thick peasant” joke. Pretty punchy for someone elected to the so-called party of the working classes… then she resigned over it.

Both of the above would also put both in my “thick as mince” category, but my post wasn’t really about individuals, just the depressing lack of morality, brains, consistency and decency across the house.

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 18:53

I've said far more than two things on this thread. We will just have to disagree about whether 60% is unacceptable. You were the one who said that people earning six figure salaries were leaving and were unable to provide any evidence of this, despite several posters asking you to do so. I don't think that I did imply that I paid 60% tax at all - my point was rather that it is possible to earn six figures and NOT pay 60% tax. I am a case in point. I'm glad that's all that is you have to say though and wish you well as you emigrate.

Quincythequince · 10/08/2022 18:53

And I agree we are in for troubled times, but it’s incredibly simplistic to suggest that we wouldn’t be here if we had a Labour Government.

It’s actually annoying to read this, and playing party politics with a global problem is minimising the issue.

Labour wanted to lockdown faster and for longer apparently and do the exact opposite of the the Tories, not to mention his non-view on Brexit. Please tell me how this would have put us in a better state than we are now.

Boybandfacedfannyfart · 10/08/2022 18:50

@Midnightblack im afraid your assertion re 70% simply isn’t true. Now, I’m not going to assume you can read Dutch - but scroll down to the bottom table and you should be able to understand 2021 vs 2022.

www.energievergelijk.nl/nieuws/nederlandse-huishoudens-betalen-nu-hoogste-gasprijs-in-europa

(quick and dirty headline translation - Dutch households now paying the highest gas price in Europe)

Quincythequince · 10/08/2022 18:46

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 18:37

I'm interested in why you think this?
It's absolutely true that loads of people are facing huge hikes in Europe for heating too, but those hikes are no more than 70% whereas we are facing over 200% and rising. That's a political choice. The Tories don't want to tax the energy producers, whereas it was Labour's policy to do so.
Our inflation and growth outlook is also worse than other EU countries, though much of that is due to Brexit and Starmer is not very vocal in opposing that. I don't think, however, that he would have cut ties quite so brutally and therefore I don't think the impact would have been as hard.

It’s the wholesalers that are making insane money here, not the suppliers.

E.ON (I think, might have been N power) posted £700million loss compared to last year. I realise that they still make insane money, but this is a massive supply and demand issue. Are people aware of what German are having to do right now to protect themselves against this energy crisis this winter? Install log burning systems where they can, as well as the government trying to look at more economical options like (Nuclear. - perfectly safe option btw) and wind power.

Please show me the figures where it says our inflation outlook is worse? I read the opposite (will find the link) but am genuinely interested in reading other sources and am prepared to be corrected here. Inflation is worse in many other EU countries.

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 18:45

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 18:41

I said I earned six figures, which I do. I also said, and stand by it, that I would pay more tax happily if I saw that it was being fairly and wisely invested. People aren't paying 60% on the whole of their salary - just on the bit that tips them over, and it still leaves plenty. The point I was making was that, had it been a Labour govnmt, taxing at 45% over £80000, that would still have been only about £1000 more, so not a huge ask.

You have actually said two completely different things on this thread. The latter was to try and prove a point that 60% income tax is acceptable and it isn’t causing a talent retention crisis in this country. You massively over exaggerated as you don’t pay 60% tax as you implied. That can be seen in the posts so that’s all I have to say. Your replies re tax are moot at you don’t pay it al those levels.

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 18:41

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 18:35

Because we were talking about the tax burden in this country which is a whopping 60% for those tipping into 6 figures. Which is why many skilled people leave as salaries in tech and engineering specifically are not competitive. You popped into try and dismiss that by saying you earned 6 figures and we’re happy with your tax burden. You misled people to try and make a point. You pay no where near that level of tax.

I said I earned six figures, which I do. I also said, and stand by it, that I would pay more tax happily if I saw that it was being fairly and wisely invested. People aren't paying 60% on the whole of their salary - just on the bit that tips them over, and it still leaves plenty. The point I was making was that, had it been a Labour govnmt, taxing at 45% over £80000, that would still have been only about £1000 more, so not a huge ask.

Quincythequince · 10/08/2022 18:40

BarmyBrunhilde · 10/08/2022 15:51

Well I think that's rather revealing - I'm sure a 'very middle class' retiree (with a triple locked pension) has the luxury on focusing on 'twaw policy' as being some major issue. For most in this country, including hundreds of thousands of working families, we're focused on rather more pressing matters!

How incredibly patronising and generally ill-informed of you.

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 18:37

Quincythequince · 10/08/2022 18:31

I hate the tories, I do.
But so people not realise that so many of the issues we are facing, are global.
EU has overall worse inflation than us for example and many of them are absolutely ducked re their heating this winter too.

I don’t know why you think this would have been better had Labour been in power - because it wouldn’t.

I'm interested in why you think this?
It's absolutely true that loads of people are facing huge hikes in Europe for heating too, but those hikes are no more than 70% whereas we are facing over 200% and rising. That's a political choice. The Tories don't want to tax the energy producers, whereas it was Labour's policy to do so.
Our inflation and growth outlook is also worse than other EU countries, though much of that is due to Brexit and Starmer is not very vocal in opposing that. I don't think, however, that he would have cut ties quite so brutally and therefore I don't think the impact would have been as hard.

Itisasecret · 10/08/2022 18:35

Midnightblack · 10/08/2022 18:29

How is it a complete over-exaggeration? 99280 + 1500 comes to 100780, which is a six figure salary. I never said it was a huge six-figure salary.

Because we were talking about the tax burden in this country which is a whopping 60% for those tipping into 6 figures. Which is why many skilled people leave as salaries in tech and engineering specifically are not competitive. You popped into try and dismiss that by saying you earned 6 figures and we’re happy with your tax burden. You misled people to try and make a point. You pay no where near that level of tax.

MsPincher · 10/08/2022 18:31

WhereAreMyAirpods · 10/08/2022 14:32

Exactly this.

The rhetoric that all conservative voters are evil kitten-murdering bastards who take joy in seeing children starve, and that all labour voters are paragons of virtue who are super caring and compassionate is just such a pile of shite.

Exactly this. Try to be more tolerant of people with different opinions than you have.

Quincythequince · 10/08/2022 18:31

*do people

Quincythequince · 10/08/2022 18:31

I hate the tories, I do.
But so people not realise that so many of the issues we are facing, are global.
EU has overall worse inflation than us for example and many of them are absolutely ducked re their heating this winter too.

I don’t know why you think this would have been better had Labour been in power - because it wouldn’t.